Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't think all men 18-60 should be forced to fight and not allowed to leave Ukraine. It should be the choice of individual men and women.

157 replies

Jjjayfee · 07/03/2022 22:17

I just saw a young father in tears as he said goodbye to his wife and baby. He is not allowed to leave Ukraine, but has to stay and fight. I think it should be a choice of individual men and women.

OP posts:
BigOlDingleSlinger69 · 08/03/2022 16:01

@MrsTerryPratchett

The point about Mao’s army being that it was made up after the industrial revolution and ideas of women’s equality - and ideas of communism obviously contributed to what your talking about - even if it wasn’t a large number.

BigOlDingleSlinger69 · 08/03/2022 15:57

@MrsTerryPratchett

Mao’s army was post industrial revolution and those were very small numbers in gorilla warfare.

Your point about pre-agricultural society is pure fantasy. There is absolutely no proof of that at all in regards to women having “bad days” gathering as a payback to make men behave and it’s become something of feminist type wishful thinking that pre-history was somehow more equal than agricultural times.
As much as can be known about those small types of societies functioning can be learned from what has been observed from first interactions with tribal peoples in more modern times - and violence still very much ruled the roost. Quite possibly more so with less consequence for using it.

There is zero reason to think women felt any more or less “oppressed” in those times than they did in ancient agricultural or more recent (say Medieval) times. There is plenty of reason however to think that whether women were happy, sad or whatever, the idea of women being “oppressed” into their role didn’t even enter people’s minds until modernisation and the industrial revolution made it so the sexes could do many of the same jobs.

Viviennemary · 08/03/2022 14:39

Conscription is quite usual when a country is at war. And woman in Ukraine are taking up arms.

sairiegamp · 08/03/2022 14:32

@Jjjayfee

If it happened here would it not be fairer if men and women had to stay behind then?
Ignorance at its best here. One man can impregnate many women. One woman can carry one child only. That's why men are more expendable than women in a war. It's got fuck all to do with fairness but everything to do with biological reality and survival of the species
MrsTerryPratchett · 08/03/2022 14:24

No societies put there women on the front lines of battle. Ever.

Actually that's not true. There are other examples but the best is probably Mao. There's a good book, The Long March, worth reading. Women joined up in big numbers and mostly served logistically but many fought on the front lines as well. They were taught to fight silently because if the enemy worked out they were women the obvious would happen. Mao's army was notable for a low incidence of sexual violence but their enemy was not. Interesting considering what a psycho he turned into. No one is 100% evil.

Also, your point that gender roles are 'reverted to' in times of stress... Oppressive gender roles have only existed since fixed agriculture. Before that there were gender roles, but they didn't involve violence to women. Women's gathering supplied most of the calories (in most hunter gatherer societies) and those calories were the most reliable. Hunting was good but patchy.

Be horrible to the women and they would magically have really bad days out gathering and come back with full stomachs and empty baskets. And since that was 60% of the calories and all of the reliable ones... men largely behaved. Fixed agriculture meant grain storage, hoarding, guarding and violence. Physical strength meant controlling resources in a way that couldn't happen in hunter gatherer societies.

The 'natural' state of humanity is fixed gender roles but not the patriarchy.

Chris365 · 08/03/2022 14:17

This is what sex isn't looks like for men
It's frustrating that people will come up with excuses why sexism is ok because women are benefiting if you are at fighting age you should be forced to stay no matter what your gender is
If you have kids you pick between yourselves who will go with the kid and who will stay
Like people said before some women are choosing to stay there's no doubt in my mind they are a benefit to the fire

BigOlDingleSlinger69 · 08/03/2022 13:30

@godmum56

No societies put there women on the front lines of battle. Ever.
You act as though some choice has been made at sometime in the past of whether or not women would fight in wars and it impacted evolution - no, it happened entirely naturally because men are simply better at it and women on the whole wanted to avoid it. It had nothing to do with old societies consciously choosing not to send women to war because they could bear children - there was no choice of this kind ever made, there is no past society that died out because of sending women to war, there is no past society that did it. It’s rooted in our gender differences since before we were even fully “human” in evolutionary terms.

Clarabe1 · 08/03/2022 12:26

@vickyc90 I think you need to defect to Russia. You would do well over there with your Nazi ideas on how some lives are more important than others. How dare you be so cavalier with other people lives! What makes you so special. Disgusting comment

thevassal · 08/03/2022 12:15

@FloraPostePosts

If men and women all stayed behind then child refugees would be on their own. It happened with evacuees in ww2 but it is a bit of pot luck; some were lucky with the families they stayed with and some weren’t. I imagine it would be scary from the children to be separated from both parents unless they absolutely had to.

This is true, but even more pertinent is the fact that the evacuation of children was only possible because we hadn’t yet been invaded, so had control of our own transport system. This isn’t the case in Ukraine, where the Russians are already in the country, disrupting transport and posing danger to civilians. There’s no way it would be remotely safe to send unaccompanied children anywhere there at the moment.

Also most evacuees were still sent within their own country, where their foster families spoke the same language as them, and (because we hadn't been invaded) could return at any point if their parents wanted them to come back.

Not sent to a completely random country with different languages and customs and no way of returning home.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/03/2022 12:15

I suppose the fairest solution would be to say that one parent of either sex can accompany a child/children under 16 but the other parent has to stay but there's no way of practically administrating that.

This wouldn’t be fair though, as an abusive husband could force his way into the carer role when he wouldn’t be suitable. Also see men in general will make better soldiers as they at bigger and stronger and less likely to be raped etc

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/03/2022 12:13

Er, only when it suits us, thanks. Definitely not when it might involve getting shot at, which sounds horrid. So we’ll leave that to the men.

This is such a back to front comment!

The pandemic has shown that whenever childcare is the harder option, eg homeschooling whilst working at the same time, the men happily pass it to women. It’s men who are more likely to change their tune when it comes to war - women will be sticking with the same tune which tends to be doing all the childcare (whether they like it or not most of the time).

Men in general make more successful soldiers so it makes sense to choose the man where there are two parents to fight. Plus it’s interesting to see there’s evidence that women are better at keeping children safe. As above, fleeing with children would hardly be a picnic.

Conscripting women who don’t have children or elderly to care for would be a possibility, as would be exempting lone fathers, but I can see how Ukraine didn’t have time for distinctions like this.

thevassal · 08/03/2022 12:12

@Jjjayfee

I would want to fight in any way I could so think that if men have to stay women should too unless they have children who can be moved to safety. I know the roles for men and women would be different.
But most women do have children. It's not like 20-50 year old women with children under 16 are only a tiny proportion of the population, they are the majority. So what are they supposed to do, just take their babies to Poland and hand them over to random strangers then come back?

I suppose the fairest solution would be to say that one parent of either sex can accompany a child/children under 16 but the other parent has to stay but there's no way of practically administrating that.

LatteToday · 08/03/2022 12:12

@PlanetNormal you should read this unherd.com/2022/03/how-ukrainian-women-will-suffer/
So far, 11 women raped by Russian soldiers, only 5 of these survived.

Pornhub has a new category- Ukrainian girls and war rape videos.
So maybe the women aren’t being shot at- but they’re being raped- and filmed being raped. Possibly so forcibly that it kills them.

Lesperance · 08/03/2022 12:05

I find it odd that you feel entitled to have a view on this with regard to Ukraine, @Jjjayfee. What are you basing it on?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/03/2022 11:53

Plus, I can't speak for the Ukraine but at least here the majority of caring responsibilities are with women. Children and the elderly.

Yes and I can imagine a lot of men in this country suddenly deciding they were equal carers if there was conscription…

andi62 · 08/03/2022 11:40

Men should get in touch with their feminine side, hasn't that been the feminist viewpoint, for decades now, however, now there's a war on.....

Boood · 08/03/2022 11:26

As an able-bodied person who isn’t responsible for any children, I would expect to be involved somehow in defending my country and protecting people who needed it if we were invaded. I don’t think conscientious objection is an option when war has been landed on your doorstep like that. It’s not a choice, it’s survival. You’d do whatever you could.

godmum56 · 08/03/2022 10:33

[quote BigOlDingleSlinger69]@godmum56

That’s an easy justification for modern times - the much simpler and more obvious explanation is that men are both much better at fighting (on the whole) and women are inclined to avoid it.

It’s not like there have been meetings in olden times where sending women to battle has been discussed and decided against because they bear children - it’s much simpler than that, it’s just natural gender instincts playing out.[/quote]
I didn't post it as a justification at all.....as others have said its the way that gender differences played out....you might call it an aspect of evolution.....the societies who put their women in the front line of battle didn't survive because they had no women to repopulate in peace time.

Change123today · 08/03/2022 09:48

It’s not like the elderly, women & children are off for a five star holiday resorts leaving the men to fight! Those women aren’t carrying a gun but they carrying the weight of ensuring their child is safe, without knowing where they will sleep - those little children have gone from a safe warm bed to a mat on the floor in a old supermarket with hundreds of other people. No idea when the next meal may come from. One day you were going to give birth in a clean hospital the next day a dirty floor.

Neither should be happening. It’s not as simple as saying men are fighting send the women and children away - look further into those mothers and children eyes and see the war they are fighting.

GabriellaMontez · 08/03/2022 09:30

Soviet occupation is a living memory in many parts of the world including Ukraine. People know what Russian soldiers do. They remember.

Do you really think the men want the women and children to stay to be "fair". Grow up.

KittyWindbag · 08/03/2022 09:25

What choice do they have?? They have to defend their country or what’s the alternative? War is awful. Disgusting, brutal, cruel. The Ukrainians are in an impossible position and being extraordinarily brave in order to protect their Country.

Butchyrestingface · 08/03/2022 09:12

I have to be honest, I'm in awe of the bravery of these people. But if this happened here, there isn't a hope in hell my husband or oldest son would be staying behind. I don't care how I would get them out. We were talking about it the other night and honestly I'd push them down the stairs, break a leg on each on them, anything, I just couldn't imagine fleeing with 3 kids, our foster daughter and leaving them behind. I had been wondering if some people are exempt eg my husband is a surgeon, so would he be allowed/needed to keep on working? Aware of how much of selfish coward this makes me!

You want to be careful THEY don't shove YOU down the stairs to get rid of the hysterical element so the rest of them can get on with the business of escaping/staying to fight as required.

I suspect in a war situation your surgeon husband would have his hands a bit too full to contemplate high tailing it for the nearest border.

sashh · 08/03/2022 09:08

@Jjjayfee

If it happened here would it not be fairer if men and women had to stay behind then?
No.

If you keep both behind then then what happened to children? Elderly people?

Even in the UK the vast majority of care is done by women, it's a crude measure but it works.

In WWII women who were not married (or possible ones who were not parents, I'm not sure) were conscripted into things like the land army as well as the forces.

Woollystockings · 08/03/2022 08:49

@vickyc90

Honestly I would make it all men and woman who do not have children. I would also make it so those of limited benefit to society go to the front line firsts. So prisoners etc are used first, over a father with a good education and professional job as that who you need left to rebuild.

Interestingly both me and DH come from military families and none of them support national service

Well, if that’s the level of intelligence and morals in the military, God help us all.
Woollystockings · 08/03/2022 08:44

@ChangeNameagain2

I have to be honest, I'm in awe of the bravery of these people. But if this happened here, there isn't a hope in hell my husband or oldest son would be staying behind. I don't care how I would get them out. We were talking about it the other night and honestly I'd push them down the stairs, break a leg on each on them, anything, I just couldn't imagine fleeing with 3 kids, our foster daughter and leaving them behind. I had been wondering if some people are exempt eg my husband is a surgeon, so would he be allowed/needed to keep on working? Aware of how much of selfish coward this makes me!
So your DH and son wouldn’t get any choice in the matter? Perhaps they would want to stay and defend their country.