Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nursery attendance / absence. Is this the norm?

91 replies

Pollysforever · 07/03/2022 21:56

My 3 year old and 2 year old go to a small nursery, both receive the 15 hours free funding so go for two full days each week.

As you'd expect with toddlers they're no strangers to picking up all sorts so have had some time off here and there on account of things like D&V, temperatures and coughs throughout the pandemic, awaiting test results etc. Nursery wouldn't accept them in with anything that could be covid understandably.

The nursery also has a policy of: snotty nose = stay at home (which is fine by me)

So a few weeks ago before half term it was my son's 3rd birthday and we booked to take him to shreks adventure. It had to be on a Monday as that's the only day dad was able to come with us. DS needs an adult ratio of 2:1 because he has special needs and trips out need to be planned with military precision. I wasn't going to deprive DD of the trip just to send her to nursery so ofc she came too.

When I told the nursery they wouldn't be in that day as we were taking them to see Shrek for DS birthday I got a bit of a lecture from the nursery manager about booking it on a nursery day and whether I could have chosen another day. I said no.

She mentioned there had been a few absences and we needed to get his attendance up next term.

I was a bit Confused as nursery isn't compulsory but I was caught off guard so said right... ok then.

Since they've come home from nursery today they're clearly coming down with something. DS has puffy eyes and a cough, DD has a temperature of 39 and she's lethargic. I sent a text to let nursery know they won't be in tomorrow and why.

I'm just wondering is it the norm for nurseries to be on at parents about attendance?

DS starts school in September which is a different kettle of fish obviously.

OP posts:
Stars1979 · 07/03/2022 23:17

I have a 4 yr old. Taken my child out of nursery for various reasons over the years, holidays, weekends away,day trips re birthday. I let nursery know and all they say is "thank you for letting us know" thats it. If i was told what you were told, I would very very shocked.

Kite22 · 07/03/2022 23:15

We pay but I don’t expect them to tell me about attendance.. it’s a service as simple as that.

It isn't as simple as that. Not looking at the whole picture - it might be for your family.
Some children - and this is particularly often the case where dc have an additional need - really struggle when they have a big gap between Nursery sessions. They have to 'start again' with the settling in as it can have been a long time since their last session.
OP has pointed out her ds has significant needs and starts school in September. If the school are to stand any chance of getting additional funding to support him in school, the Nursery need to be able to evidence the support they have given and the impact of that support. EVen if that isn't teh case, many, many dc struggle with that big gap. If the 15 hours are spread across the week (5 x 3 mornings or 5 x 3 afternoons) then missing a session here and there has less impact, but when they are in {say} Mon, Tues, then miss the next week, that is a long time for a 4 yr old with significant needs and a 2 year old to cope with in terms of some dc making progress with socialising, and understanding expectations at Nursery and so forth.

Now, obviously I don't know the Nursery and don't know the OP's dc, but that can be quite a common scenario in Nurseries.

MissM2912 · 07/03/2022 23:14

Ok- I am with the nursery manager on this. While not enforceable- it is beneficial for the child to be in a good routine. It disrupts the other children with coming and going, impacts on planning, and some children become unsettled. It isn’t ‘free childcare’- childcare practitioners deserve the same respect as teachers and you wouldn’t take kids in and out of school whenever suited.
And as someone said above- if child as been awarded a two year old place they must have some other potential vulnerability- even if mild.

CookieMunch · 07/03/2022 23:14

Have you checked the details you got about the funded hours. When mine had funded hours a few years ago there was a minimum attendance policy attached to it (by gov not by the nursery). They may be concerned that your funding will be withdrawn if they’ve missed a lot. I’d ask them if this is the concern. It makes sense if you think about it. Otherwise nursery’s could claim funding for kids who regularly don’t attend and it is taxpayer money after all.

BulletTrain · 07/03/2022 23:08

Nope, not normal. DS is 3. We can have 2 weeks holiday and not pay. We took him our for a week in December for a holiday and they just said have a lovely time! This is also a private nursery ages 1-4.

Thewindwhispers · 07/03/2022 23:02

That’s odd. My (funded) nyrsery were always very happy if we chose not to come in as they still got paid for looking after less children.

🤷‍♀️

ChocolateMassacre · 07/03/2022 23:00

Isn't one of the joys of having nursery-age children that you can take them out of nursery during term-term for holidays/family stuff Confused?

I would explain to the nursery that your child isn't of an age for compulsory education and that you think one day out of nursery for a family event is perfectly acceptable. All of the rest of the days are due to their policy, not your choices, so involuntary absences on your part. The only way you can get your DC's attendance up, therefore, is for the nursery to change its policy or for your DCs to stop getting ill (which you can't control).

If my DS's nursery had had this policy, there would have been very few children there from October to February. Certainly, my DS had a permanent runny nose for 3-4 months last year.

DockOTheBay · 07/03/2022 22:51

@nearlyspringyay

I can see both sides tbh. You're taking a funded place and then taking them to the cinema.

On the other hand if our nursery had a snotty nose stay away policy dts would literally not have been in nursery.

They still get their funding why would they care.
50DaysAF · 07/03/2022 22:37

I think @Endofdaysarehere is thinking of the second part of this guidance:

“Your 2-year-old can get free childcare if you live in England and get one of the following benefits:

Income Support
income-based Jobseeker’s Allowance (JSA)
income-related Employment and Support Allowance (ESA)
Universal Credit, and your household income is £15,400 a year or less after tax, not including benefit payments
child tax credits, and your household income is £16,190 a year or less before tax
the guaranteed element of Pension Credit
the Working Tax Credit 4-week run on (the payment you get when you stop qualifying for Working Tax Credit)

2-year-olds can also get free childcare if they:
are looked after by a local authority
have a statement of special education needs (SEN) or an education, health and care (EHC) plan
get Disability Living Allowance
have left care under an adoption order, special guardianship order or a child arrangements order”

TokenGinger · 07/03/2022 22:37

@Pollysforever

Oh and also, when speaking to her about the trip I said I was happy to send them in on a different day that week so they did the two full days if they'd prefer that to them just having a day off and was told no.. so it can't all be about funding?
It's not. They still get the funding. Their funding is based on their census, which is the number of children on roll entitled to the 15 hours. I'm not sure why so many people are assuming the nursery won't get paid. They do.
Pollysforever · 07/03/2022 22:30

Oh and also, when speaking to her about the trip I said I was happy to send them in on a different day that week so they did the two full days if they'd prefer that to them just having a day off and was told no.. so it can't all be about funding?

OP posts:
Pollysforever · 07/03/2022 22:28

They haven't told me that, though.

When she was speaking to be about the attendance she mentioned it being important to get kids into a routine before school. Nothing about funding.

Are people absolutely certain it's a funding issue?

OP posts:
Looubylou · 07/03/2022 22:20

It's be a use it is not "a free place" the government is paying. The nursery won't get the funding, if the children's attendance isn't high enough.

Pollysforever · 07/03/2022 22:19

@Endofdaysarehere

Your dd has 2yr old funding because the government has judged that the safest and best place for her to be is in nursery, so yes, you will need to take them to nursery as often as you can (illness aside). Any nursery would be the same. As PP have said, if you book holidays for any reason while they should be in nursery you are breaking the terms of the agreement you have made. The nursery could lose money,
Safest place for her to be?

Sorry I might be misunderstanding where you're coming from but there are no safeguarding concerns.

She goes for the socialization because I thought it would be nice for her, nobody else has suggested she needs to be there.

OP posts:
TokenGinger · 07/03/2022 22:16

Also, just to add to my last comment, the FFT data our schools receive also show that the figures for nursery places being undersubscribed is common across the national picture.

The admittance of children below compulsory school age has taken a drastic decline since Covid and it's becoming increasingly more common for parents to not send children to school until the term after their fifth birthday.

NuffSaidSam · 07/03/2022 22:15

The 'taking up a space' argument is ridiculous. She's not denying some other child a pre-school education because her children have had one day off for a special treat.

If the nursery have got a policy of sending them home for every minor illness/snotty nose then attendance is going to be low.

FTEngineerM · 07/03/2022 22:15

We pay but I don’t expect them to tell me about attendance.. it’s a service as simple as that.

If ours wouldn’t allow snotty noses literally wouldn’t be there.

Endofdaysarehere · 07/03/2022 22:14

Your dd has 2yr old funding because the government has judged that the safest and best place for her to be is in nursery, so yes, you will need to take them to nursery as often as you can (illness aside).

Any nursery would be the same.
As PP have said, if you book holidays for any reason while they should be in nursery you are breaking the terms of the agreement you have made. The nursery could lose money,

TokenGinger · 07/03/2022 22:14

@Readyforspring

Its the fact there's not enough pre school places some are waiting till the sept after they're 3, ie instead of starting jan or easter. Because theres no spaces. Dd pre school has 18m waiting list. My youngest is on the list since last july 2021 and have been told I'd be very lucky to get in this sept 2022
The list your daughter on is out of the norm. I work in eduction, and every single nursery across the whole of our borough is undersubscribed. Schools are changing their nursery admissions policies to allow for rising 2s and 3s, and reception places are also sorely undersubscribed, to the point that it's having an impact on staffing as there are too many teachers, not enough pupils, and therefore not enough funding to pay them.

I think people are missing the point here that this is one day that OP has taken her children out of non-compulsory education for her DS's birthday, who has additional needs and may well find it too overwhelming to go in busier periods (ie the weekend). All of absences have been due to the nursery's rules.

They're out of order, OP. The nursery still received the funding for the days that the children are on roll. I'd be a bit Hmm too.

DuggeeHugPlease · 07/03/2022 22:14

This is news to me. I took mine out for holidays and day trips whenever I wanted to. Surely everyone makes the most of being able to do things like that in term time when it's quieter/cheaper before they start school and you're limited to school hols.

Abouttimemum · 07/03/2022 22:13

I think you can’t help it when they’re ill and they won’t take them - that’s their policy. I’ve never heard of nurseries being so strict. But as pp said it might be to do with the funded place.

Mind I’ll take mine to the door no matter what state they’re in - if they want to send him home they’ll have to turn him away at the door!!

Pollysforever · 07/03/2022 22:12

They're not running at full capacity. There is space.

OP posts:
CowsAreNotGreen · 07/03/2022 22:12

@Pollysforever

It's not a pre school, as in not attatched to a school. It's privately run and accepts children from age 2 - 5.

They're not at full capacity either

In that case as long as they are getting paid I don't see what the issue is. You've explained each absence so it's not like they have to worry about why they aren't there.
AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 07/03/2022 22:10

@Merryoldgoat

15 hours is available to ALL children over 3 so she’s not taking a place from anyone.

My children have both been ill nearly all the time during nursery and no one has mentioned it to me.

That would be true if there were an unlimited number of places but there aren't everywhere. Funding available to all does not equal places available for all.
Pollysforever · 07/03/2022 22:09

There is space for others. I'm not taking up space on a long waiting list.

OP posts: