Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Autism. Friends ignorant comments.

70 replies

KellyB154 · 07/03/2022 21:31

I have a friend of 8 years. She's a nice person in general.

Two years ago my 4yo was diagnosed with autism.

When I told her about the diagnosis she was surprised and said "oh he doesn't look autistic"

I thought it was a bit of a daft thing to say but didn't let it bother me, sometimes people don't know the right thing to say and all that.

So FF to yesterday we were chatting about coronation and I mentioned that I really like Roy, and did she know that his character is based on somebody with autism.

Her response "Oh really, yeah he's always been really strange hasn't he"

I was taken aback and just replied that no he's not strange, he's supposed to be autistic.

That annoyed me and brought the first comment back to mind, and I've got a bee in my bonnet now. I'm sick of the ignorance autistic people have to put up with.

AIB too sensitive?

I'll admit I felt pretty offended

OP posts:
5zeds · 08/03/2022 00:13

@SpidersAreShitheads which has been proven to be unhelpful and inaccurate. has it? By whom and how? I can see if it is used inaccurately to describe how well you pass for neurotypical, then it has limited use but knowing someone who presents as having a low IQ has a high one is fairly key to appropriate support is it not?

x2boys · 08/03/2022 00:12

Autistic*I'm also

x2boys · 08/03/2022 00:10

And some auristic people are unable to function in any way but I can't be borhered to explain that either it's unhelpful .

SpidersAreShitheads · 08/03/2022 00:10

@CheshireChat

I've always felt that the removal of Aspergers complicated the high/ low functioning as you can absolutely have an I IQ over 80 and be fully dependent for example (I know that's exactly the point both PPs were making).

My son will realistically have more in common (needs wise) with a NT person with anxiety than a person with ASD who will be dependent on care for life, non verbal etc

@CheshireChat

Absolutely agree with you completely. I think the removal of the Asperger's label was supposed to be more inclusive but it's left our community without any helpful language to describe a particular type of autistic presentation.

If there's no intellectual disability, it's really hard to describe the needs of an individual in a way that's meaningful yet succinct.

My DD sounds like your child Cheshire, but my DS has much higher care needs, despite being verbal and bright.

CheshireChat · 08/03/2022 00:09

Clear as muck

CheshireChat · 08/03/2022 00:09

Ooh, that graph is a lot better than the one I've seen floating around which was as clear as much even when you knew what it meant and agreed with it.

SpidersAreShitheads · 08/03/2022 00:06

@thehighsandthelows

I love that tweet about "doing an autism" - absolutely cracks me up to this day 😅

My DC like to say to me "mummy, you're so weird" and I say "thank you", and they laugh. It's like a little daft ritual we've had for years ❤️

CheshireChat · 08/03/2022 00:06

I've always felt that the removal of Aspergers complicated the high/ low functioning as you can absolutely have an I
IQ over 80 and be fully dependent for example (I know that's exactly the point both PPs were making).

My son will realistically have more in common (needs wise) with a NT person with anxiety than a person with ASD who will be dependent on care for life, non verbal etc

thehighsandthelows · 08/03/2022 00:06

Here is a handy table for you @5zeds

Autism. Friends ignorant comments.
SpidersAreShitheads · 08/03/2022 00:03

Functioning labels aren't the same as an intellectual disability.

SpidersAreShitheads · 08/03/2022 00:02

@5zeds Autistic people are NOT low or high functioning - that's an extremely out of date way of labelling things which has been proven to be unhelpful and inaccurate.

The functionality of an autistic person can vary due a wide-ranging set of circumstances. This graphic explains it more than I could, but please do google it if you want to understand why low/high functioning is now considered to be such an unhelpful description.

Autism. Friends ignorant comments.
thehighsandthelows · 08/03/2022 00:02

*Also, autistic people are often perceived as strange. I'm autistic. I get on with people really well. I can be vibrant and fun. But also I can be bloody strange. I have absolutely no qualms celebrating my weirdness. My DC are autistic too. We are a house full of people who are wonderfully and unapologetically unique.
*
❤️

Tbh I don't usually think of weird as an insult, just got defensive 😂

Unique is better though!

5zeds · 08/03/2022 00:00

Or you could?

High functioning iq over 80, low functioning iq under. NOTHING to do with “where you are on the spectrum” nor an indication of how well you pass for neurotypical.

thehighsandthelows · 07/03/2022 23:56

@5zeds

Just google it, I'm out of patience

thehighsandthelows · 07/03/2022 23:55

Exactly what came to my mind @SpidersAreShitheads 😁

5zeds · 07/03/2022 23:54

Autistic people are not 'high or low functioning' - it is a spectrum, everyone has a different profile of strengths and challenges.
Of course autistic people are either high or low functioning.

thehighsandthelows · 07/03/2022 23:54

@Ionlydomassiveones I wouldn't expect everyone to be well informed. There are many things I know very little about but I think I can gauge when it is a topic that I might hold back on discussing without learning about it first. It gets to me, the whole 'I don't know better' - show some tact, admit you don't know much about it. That's fine. Just think before you speak.

SpidersAreShitheads · 07/03/2022 23:53

Also, when people talk about a child not looking autistic, I always think of this tweet. The first time I read it I nearly cried with laughter.

Of course people should know not to be so ignorant. But here we are.

Autism. Friends ignorant comments.
SpidersAreShitheads · 07/03/2022 23:49

But Roy's character is a bit strange? That's just a factual observation.

Aside from whether Roy is based on an autistic person or not, his character is quite a long way from a typical bloke, and I think that's deliberate. Doesn't really matter what the reason is.

Also, autistic people are often perceived as strange. I'm autistic. I get on with people really well. I can be vibrant and fun. But also I can be bloody strange. I have absolutely no qualms celebrating my weirdness. My DC are autistic too. We are a house full of people who are wonderfully and unapologetically unique.

Autistic people think differently. We communicate differently. We may speak differently. We may even seek out different types of relationship, or be attracted to unusual interests or subjects.

We also might hide it very well and you'll see none of what's really going on.

We don't share a single personality, but we're more likely to be described as strange because we don't fit the neurotypical profile that people are more used to seeing. Personally speaking, and this is just one autistic person giving her opinion, I don't mind if people think I'm a bit strange. A lot depends on the tone of voice and the way they say it. You can call someone strange and mean it in a spiteful/nasty way, or you could call someone strange in an affectionate/contemplative way and mean absolutely no offence.

I think context is everything.

Actually, just to add, I need to watch it again but I saw a documentary the other night where they were talking about stalkers, and one of them was autistic. And there were such sweeping generalisations about "autistic people" that did feel a bit offensive - as if we all have the propensity to start some crazed stalking at the drop of a hat. That one left me feeling a bit uncomfortable.

thehighsandthelows · 07/03/2022 23:45

Autistic people are not weird.

Autistic people are not 'high or low functioning' - it is a spectrum, everyone has a different profile of strengths and challenges.

There is literally no such thing as looking autistic, unless you are looking inside someone's brain.

There is so so so much information from Autistic adults & advocates. So much information on what it means to be neurodivergent & how we can be inclusive/neurodiversity affirming in our attitudes and in society.

If you don't want to learn about it fair enough but I don't get why people feel the need to share nonsense opinions about topics that are obviously important to a lot of people and their lived experience.

Ionlydomassiveones · 07/03/2022 23:40

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

SalmonEile · 07/03/2022 23:39

Sorry I just realized I didn’t actually offer any advice,
Your friend clearly knows nothing about autism so I guess it comes down to if you have the energy to educate her and if not then ignore her ignorant comments / change the subject / call her out each time

5zeds · 07/03/2022 23:32

I think she phrased things badly but surely just meant she hadn’t observed any autistic behaviour (ie he doesn’t look autistic) and that the character does behave unusually (aka weird or strange). Could you not just tell her it’s upsetting to hear it said like that? She’s your friend help her to be what you need.

I agree with pp that while it’s great to see high functioning verbal can “pass” autistic individuals on tv the vast majority don’t fall into that subset of the community.

SalmonEile · 07/03/2022 23:25

Yes he got drunk and then Tracey lied and told him they’d slept together when they hadn’t and convinced him he was the father of her baby. Horrible storyline which included him attempting suicide and Tracey selling the baby to Roy and Hayley (they named her Patience) then changing her mind and taking her back.

The problem here with your friend was Roy was written as an odd ball or strange because soaps use charictures of people
I remember my mother being particularly upset by an episode where Gail screamed at Roy that he was a word beginning with r and ending with d
I believe Gail apologized afterwards but this was the late 90s / 00s
It’s possible your friend grew up with that view of Roy as “the strange one from corrie”

x2boys · 07/03/2022 23:24

You should watch the early 2000,s Op Tracy and Roy were married very briefly because Tracy convinced him he fathered Amy!
Tbh when Roy first came into Corrie "higher functioning autism " and I know it's all autism now ,wasn't really that well known people of Roy's age just wouldn't have been diagnosed ,so fair play to Corrie they have always portrayed him with traits .