Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’m definitely reasonable…. I think!

184 replies

GracieLouFreeebush · 07/03/2022 20:06

I went out on Saturday, it was for someone’s birthday and was split over two venues meaning we needed taxis halfway through the day. Me and my partner are skint at the moment so he offered to come pick me up, ferry a car full in between then walk the dog at the other side for a couple of hours before driving me home.

I only actually know the person who’s birthday it was. There is a group chat though, it was such a good day we decided to keep it going so we can arrange meet ups in future. Some people had to still get taxis across because there was 19 of us and only 4 fit in my car, including me.

The next morning in the group chat the person who had booked the taxis (Ubers) put her bank details in for everyone to transfer their share - including me. It worked out at £14 each, everyone but me sent the money and she chased me up for it, I replied saying oh I didn’t get a taxi because DP came and drove. She replied saying “to make it fair it’s been divided equally between all that attended so that some don’t have to pay more”…. But I am paying more, because I also paid in petrol and DP paid in time. I’ve refused to pay (I don’t even have the money until I get paid Friday).

Since then I’ve been removed from the group chat, when I asked my friend she explained the others are upset that I would be so selfish and make them pay more, but I see it as we would have needed to pay for an extra taxi so I saved everyone money.

OP posts:
burnthur5t · 08/03/2022 07:22

I would be happy to not be part of the group, this is bizarre

Certainly don't pay (for a taxi you didn't use!)

LouLou198 · 08/03/2022 07:11

@goeasyonmee

Say you're happy to pay as long as the 3 that came in your car reimburse you for the fuel. Send your bank details and wait.
I was thinking exactly this! This is the reason I avoid large meet ups where your only know 1 or 2 people. You always end up out of pocket, when usually the one who eats/drinks the most wants to split the bill.
BarbaraofSeville · 08/03/2022 06:31

^Money is finite. If you spend what you have you run out. Let’s say OP had £50 spare and the activity was £30 and brunch was £20. Once she paid for both she would have no spare money for the taxi.

This seems basic logic to me but my BIL doesn’t get it either. He thinks because we send out DCs to private school and go on holidays that means we also have enough to pay for the whole extended family to do nice things every time we see them. Sadly it doesn’t work that way— we have enough for school and holidays because we spend modestly on everything else.

Also, when someone says they “can’t afford” something like the taxi in the OP it doesn’t necessarily mean they literally could not come up with the money. It means they have prioritized other things. OP’s partner sacrificed his afternoon because he knew the activity was as much as she was comfortable spending without the cost of the taxi^

Exactly, so bloody obvious yet so many people can't seem to see it.

The OP has budgeted for the activity and the meal and identified that paying for the taxi will leave her short, so found a cheaper solution. If she'd have paid for a taxi she would probably then be short of food money, bus fare or some other essential between now and pay day and would look like the kind of stupid person who spent all her money on having a good time at the weekend and is now unable to buy food and would then probably try guilting other people into chipping in for, like her so called friends are doing to her.

cstx89 · 08/03/2022 03:44

Omg this is awful how they are treating you. Do not pay as u did not use the taxi.
Also - why would u want to be friends with ppl like that? Not nice at all!!

Ur well rid of them. Chin up OP!

tinderswindler · 08/03/2022 02:43

Another one to say you are definitely not being unreasonable! They are deluded and mean to kick you out of the group chat.

Rickrollme · 08/03/2022 02:36

@Nat94

Yeah i don't know how they can chase you up for money when you didn't get the taxi. So unless you agreed to use the taxi beforehand and they had already counted on you paying towards it then they are being very unreasonable.

The only thing that doesn't make sense to me which i know is none of my business is how you can afford to go out all day with these girls but claim you cannot afford the £14 taxi fare.

Money is finite. If you spend what you have you run out. Let’s say OP had £50 spare and the activity was £30 and brunch was £20. Once she paid for both she would have no spare money for the taxi.

This seems basic logic to me but my BIL doesn’t get it either. He thinks because we send out DCs to private school and go on holidays that means we also have enough to pay for the whole extended family to do nice things every time we see them. Sadly it doesn’t work that way— we have enough for school and holidays because we spend modestly on everything else.

Also, when someone says they “can’t afford” something like the taxi in the OP it doesn’t necessarily mean they literally could not come up with the money. It means they have prioritized other things. OP’s partner sacrificed his afternoon because he knew the activity was as much as she was comfortable spending without the cost of the taxi.

Lemonweightloss · 08/03/2022 02:17

@GracieLouFreeebush, I voted YABU because I thought it was all pre planned ( Clouded by my own personal experience) I've seen that it wasn't so I will change to YANBU !!

Allsorts1 · 08/03/2022 01:44

The normal way to do this would have been to have your passengers pay the share of taxis, as as you say that was just luck, and for you to be left out of it as your contribution was already made when you reduced the average taxi spend by giving people a free lift!!

Weatherwax13 · 08/03/2022 01:33

They're batshit. Probably a CF queen bee and everyone else following like sheep for fear of being ostracised.
That's a weird mix of animal metaphors Hmm
But you get my drift.
You don't need this level of crazy

Niahm · 08/03/2022 01:21

What weirdos! I HATE it when large groups of people all seem to agree on something that’s obviously ridiculous. It makes you doubt yourself no matter how preposterous their reasoning is doesn’t it!

They’d have had to pay nearly £18 if you hadn’t saved them the fifth taxi. They should be grateful to you if anything the knobs!

NorthSouthcatlady · 08/03/2022 00:20

They sound batshit and CF’s. Avoid!

TheUnexpectedPickle · 08/03/2022 00:16

Not RTFT but no, you’re not in the wrong.

Nothing stopping others arranging their own lifts or driving themselves. Not your problem or your responsibility.

Honestly, don’t worry about being excluded from further days/nights out- it’ll all be similar CF activity. You don’t need that!!

Nat94 · 08/03/2022 00:14

Yeah i don't know how they can chase you up for money when you didn't get the taxi. So unless you agreed to use the taxi beforehand and they had already counted on you paying towards it then they are being very unreasonable.

The only thing that doesn't make sense to me which i know is none of my business is how you can afford to go out all day with these girls but claim you cannot afford the £14 taxi fare.

EeeICouldRipATissue · 08/03/2022 00:07

I've just noticed your username, OP. Gotta love Gracie Lou from New Jersey! 😆

Missed that, love it Grin
'' She's beauty and she's grace, she's Miss United States.... '' lol

Rickrollme · 07/03/2022 23:57

In real life people just explain themselves but on MN for some reason things get so complicated. From what you’ve presented OP it is very clear-cut and I can’t believe even one of them would expect you to pay. It goes beyond being cheeky, it doesn’t even make sense. Either you’ve had a lovely day with 18 women who are all very very thick and have zero basic social experience OR there’s been a misunderstanding. Did you explain this to the birthday girl? What about the woman who took you off the chat and (if they are not the same person) the one to whom you were meant to give the £14? If you had fun with the group and you were looking forward to seeing them again I would reach out and explain because chances are they don’t have their facts straight.

VanGoghsDog · 07/03/2022 23:56

@GracieLouFreeebush

But surely if your DH hadn't picked you up an extra taxi would have cost everyone much more?

YEP! Each taxi cost between £60-£70 so it would have been that on top.

HOW MUCH!!??
EeeICouldRipATissue · 07/03/2022 23:47

You what?!
You're expected to shell out 14 quid for a taxi you didn't even get just so they got a subsidised ride?!
Get to fuck lol
(In case you need telling you absolutely are not being unreasonable, they on the other hand definitely are!)

KatherineofGaunt · 07/03/2022 23:39

I've just noticed your username, OP. Gotta love Gracie Lou from New Jersey! 😆

Hawkins001 · 07/03/2022 23:36

@GracieLouFreeebush

*seem to disagree with me
What if someone in the group runs the maths to.prove you correct .? Just because they think your wrong, does not automatically mean they are correct in their analysis
theresAtablet4thatNow · 07/03/2022 23:29

Why are (some? most?) people so shitty? They're being ridiculous.

This is why I honestly don't bother with people outside my family. Too many of them aren't worth the work.

OliveOyl321 · 07/03/2022 23:26

@MischievousBiscuits

CFs. It's like being asked to contribute to the cost of the wine when you haven't drank any at a dinner out!
^^ My thoughts exactly. We have two friends in our gang who don’t drink. We always take the alcohol off the bill before splitting if we’re out for a meal. They offer but no way could we expect them to pay for something they didn’t have (especially when it’s expensive!) It’s a pity you’re not still in the group chat just to defend yourself but as they’re not people you’ll see again then try and forget it. Pity they ruined what was a nice day for you. Fair play to your DP for being so accommodating, and for you making the effort to go to something for your friend when money was tight.
Gladioli23 · 07/03/2022 23:07

Luckily for you, you've got the money and they've got your sympathy.

Don't transfer any money. If relevant point out that e.g. 20 miles @ 0.45 per mile X2 because he had to come out as well was £18 so you have already contributed more than your share, but definitely do not transfer anything.

Thewindwhispers · 07/03/2022 23:06

Yanbu!

What selfish petty people. Sorry this happened to you butnsounds like you’re better off not knowing them!!

CookieMunch · 07/03/2022 23:05

Did you see other people actually comment saying they thought you were being selfish? Or did your friend just tell you that everyone agrees with her and disagrees with you? I bet ‘everyone’ is just your friend and the admin for the group

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 07/03/2022 23:04

I think they must have known that you were in the right and that they had no case at all. Otherwise, they wouldn't have been so hasty to remove you - they would have left you to squirm and try to justify your way out of your unreasonableness before they properly gainsaid you, had you actually been unreasonable.