Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Compassion & media coverage towards Ukraine but not the Middle East/Africa

263 replies

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 18:40

This is something that has been on my mind for a little while so hopefully I'm able to word it correctly.

Since the invasion in Ukraine there has been constant threads about this on MN. This is also something that is constantly spoken about and written about in the media as it rightly should be. This is a major thing that's going on and people should obviously be informed about this.

However, why is this not the case when there's constant wars happening in the Middle East and Africa? Iraq, Palastine, Syria, Sudan, Afghanistan etc the list really does go on. There's still innocent people in these countries that are getting killed for no reason. Now I've personally never seen threads about these countries on MN but as I don't spend too much time I'm on here, I could be wrong. What I am certain about, is these countries BARELY get any media attention from the West, if ever at all. Why is that?!

Is this because Ukraine is a European country and not a third world country where things like these are 'expected to happen?' Do people feel that as the people in these countries are minorities that they don't deserve the same sort of empathy that the Ukrainians are getting? I really am interested to know why there's such a massive difference in terms of media coverage and general compassion.

It's actually interesting because just a few days ago, supermodel Bella Hadid stated that Muslim suffering deserves the same level of outrage as Ukraine and she is absolutely right. And to those who may say I'm exaggerating or this isn't the case, I've linked a Twitter thread below which has clips of the most racist Ukraine coverage on TV and the wording used in each and every clip is very telling. I'd be very interested in hearing people's thoughts.

twitter.com/alanrmacleod/status/1497974245737050120?s=21

OP posts:
Ohmnomnom · 07/03/2022 20:01

Racism is definitely the main reason. Journalists have been absolutely shocking and many aren't even trying to hide it.

Additional reasons as pp have said are proximity, threat of nuclear war, possible start of ww3, and global hatred of Putin and his dictatorship. On another thread, someone pointed out that all of the refugees coming from Ukraine are women and children. I wonder if the West would be more sympathetic to African and Middle Eastern refugees if they were all women and children and the men stayed behind.

Cheshirecatwoman · 07/03/2022 20:01

@WeddingHangover

You can't police how people feel. It feels like you are actively discouraging kindness.

As people said… it’s culture, Eastern European ties and the fact it’s woman and children.

Why don’t you direct your outrage at the
UAE? Culturally similar and an abundance of resources yet take next to no refugees.

Here is an example …… you have a limited income and a family member is in financial distress, but there is also a family from down the road in distress. You can only help one -so who are you helping ?

You started this thread to make yourself feel better. To feel like you are doing something and recognising this injustice.

Bella Hadid’s Father is Palestinian so she does a lot for that cause, but I haven’t heard her talking about/helping other war torn nations.

What about the troubles in NI - why weren’t those in the Bahamas doing more for their plight?

Yes well said.
babyhaha · 07/03/2022 19:59

@Ylvamoon

The Ukraine has the infrastructure to document the war via social media channels. We don't rely on journalists on the ground to document the plight of ordinary people... Then there are also the geographical implications and the fact that it is relatively easy to go to Poland to deliver aid = no visas or other travel restrictions.

I very much remember the the reports about families in Afghanistan having toselltheir daughters in order to survive the winter. Or how much women's & girls lives are getting worse.Where are the people from these reports now? Yet there is very little reporting now, because most journalists have left, thanks to the Taliban.

The same is happening in Russia, we will know very little about a possible opposition to Putin or how they are silenced due to media blocks and the journalists exodus.

I think people/ keyboard worriers need to put things into perspective. Saying that the help offered is about race is very simplistic. It is about geography, infrastructure and how & who reports about the suffering and displacements. And then there is politics...

Hmm this is a very interesting take, especially the last paragraph. Very interesting and valid points made that makes way more sense to me
OP posts:
MurmuratingStarling · 07/03/2022 19:58

@Cheshirecatwoman

I cannot relate in the same way to young healthy for men who ditch their families and travel alone. That may be unfair of me but that is how I feel. Also these men often have a different attitude towards women than us in Europe. I have seen and experienced this first hand through my job so do feel I have some understanding.

This. ^ There's a startling difference between the Ukrainian men and the men that came from Syria/the middle east/Afghanistan...The Ukrainian men are staying to fight for their country, and have sent their women and children to safety. In the Middle East/Syria/Afghanistan etc, the men (mostly younger ones) seem to flee to safety and leave the women and children (and older generations) behind.

I wonder why that is?

DingleyDel · 07/03/2022 19:58

I remember the Syrian conflict having similar constant coverage. All the footage from the white helmets, coverage of refugee camps, outrage as the violence escalated and became more and more extreme. I’m sure as time goes on the Ukrainian war won’t be constantly reported on. You can’t blame news outlets for reporting more on a war from their own region. I think there’s something about it being an invasion of an otherwise peaceful region rather than a civil war that really concerns people. Putin and the potential for it to turn nuclear. As for sympathy for refugees, I don’t think Britain is showing much, yet again. Absolutely failing to do our bit. No change there.

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 19:57

@Happylittlethoughts

If you think humans care about everyone and everything equally then you are surely naive. I agree with PPs. We surely seem to care more about issues /people with closer geographical or cultural connections . That is a very broad statement obviously. Many people care about Syria for example, but most dont see a reflection of themselves there on TV. I think they easily see that looking at Ukraine.
That's not what I'm saying at all. But it's interesting to see people admitting this is about race and caring more because there's a sense of familiarity. If you're white and seeing white people on the TV going through a bad situation such as war, you have emotion. If you're seeing people on the TV that aren't white, there's less emotion (if any) simply because they don't look like you. That's insane to me. People have to look a certain way to gain any sort of compassion but it makes sense as it's about race
OP posts:
babyhaha · 07/03/2022 19:54

@MissAmbrosia

I totally understand that this conflict has risks that others did not and people are afraid, for genuine reasons. But it does make me cross all the virtue signalling on here "it's breaking my heart" etc. about Ukraine when no-one gave a shit before. UK has actually been the agressor before and still supplies weapons that have destroyed cities and killed innocent civilians.
Yes this is exactly what I mean tbh. Due to some of the comments I can now see why media coverage may be so frequent as Ukraine is relatively closer to us. People have also mentioned nukes which isn't something I've thought too much about.

However the general emotional that the situation is provoking in people, yet nothing's felt for people in the Middle East/Africa? That's exactly what I mean

OP posts:
WeddingHangover · 07/03/2022 19:54

You can't police how people feel. It feels like you are actively discouraging kindness.

As people said… it’s culture, Eastern European ties and the fact it’s woman and children.

Why don’t you direct your outrage at the
UAE? Culturally similar and an abundance of resources yet take next to no refugees.

Here is an example …… you have a limited income and a family member is in financial distress, but there is also a family from down the road in distress. You can only help one -so who are you helping ?

You started this thread to make yourself feel better. To feel like you are doing something and recognising this injustice.

Bella Hadid’s Father is Palestinian so she does a lot for that cause, but I haven’t heard her talking about/helping other war torn nations.

What about the troubles in NI - why weren’t those in the Bahamas doing more for their plight?

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 19:51

@Lovingeveryrainbow

This. It’s clear as day.

There have been news reporters and politicians saying these aren’t “the usual” refugees- Confusedtheir whiteness affords them compassion where there is fury and contempt for those from the global south.

The same old same old.

My reaction exactly!! The 'usual refugees' what an actual joke
OP posts:
nosyupnorth · 07/03/2022 19:48

I think firstly you are underestimating the coverage those other conflicts got just Ukraine is front and centre as the newest - certainly Syria and Afgahnistan were all over the news in the weeks immediately following with coverage similar to Ukraine and Palestine is often in the news.

But also, most of your examples are civil conficts. Russia invading Ukraine is one sovereign nation invading another with a clear and distinct aggressor and victims so it is easy to take a side and feel sympathy for the innocent victims. Longstanding civil conflicts are less clear cut and harder to distinguish who is right/wrong, where there was provocation and be certain of if would be refugees are victims or fleeing to avoid the consequence of being in an oppresive group etc.

Cheshirecatwoman · 07/03/2022 19:48

I’m not sure why you’ve asked the question op @babyhaha when you have already decided you know what the answer is.

I’ll answer honestly how I feel.

I have massive sympathy wherever the conflict is when I see reports and videos of injured and frightened children (black or white- colour is irrelevant in this instance).

In General though, I probably feel more upset about the conflict in Ukraine because the whole thing seems so unfair and completely unprovoked. It feels with the media coverage that we have ring side seats and it is horrific. I can relate to these people as we are culturally more similar. They are trying to evacuate their women and children and their elderly relatives.

I cannot relate in the same way to young healthy for men who ditch their families and travel alone. That may be unfair of me but that is how I feel. Also these men often have a different attitude towards women than us in Europe. I have seen and experienced this first hand through my job so do feel I have some understanding.

Squashpocket · 07/03/2022 19:44

I think that unconsciously people perceive there to be a hierarchy of responsibility in these situations I.e. countries geographically, culturally and religiously close to the refugees should step up first.

A bit like when deciding who should look after a child. Ideally it should be their parents, but if not, then their family. If not their family, then someone from their community. A family from a different race, religion and culture would be lower down the list. I think this feeling is human nature.

Greyrootszerohoots · 07/03/2022 19:44

A person who has said some very anti-refugee things to me in the past organised a local collection for Ukrainian refugees. I understand that this ‘feels’ closer to home, but I it has highlighted how much of a racist I knew they were.

MurmuratingStarling · 07/03/2022 19:44

@IHateWasps

I don't see how you can say that Syria got little coverage. When war broke out there, it was all over the news and high profile for a few years. Iraq got considerable coverage. Afghanistan got a lot too though.

This. ^ The middle East/Syria crisis got lots of coverage, for MONTHS, and 10s of 1000s of refugees were helped by the UK along with 100s of 1000s being helped/given sanctuary by lots of other 'first world' countries. We have given 100s of 1000s of £ to people from the middle east and Africa who needed it, and housed many 1000s of refugees and asylum seekers. And other western European countries have accepted 10s of 1000s each too.

To say 'the Ukrainians are mostly white, and that's the only reason the west care' (as a previous poster said,) is disgusting, insulting, and wholly incorrect. What a vile thing to say. Hmm

Also, in case you haven't noticed, the UK has done virtually fuck-all to help the Ukrainians anyway!

Lots of media coverage is just lip service. Less than FIFTY refugees have come into the UK from Ukraine thus far! So the UK is hardly 'favouring' them over people from the middle east and Africa. Hmm

@babyhaha YABU!

Ylvamoon · 07/03/2022 19:43

The Ukraine has the infrastructure to document the war via social media channels. We don't rely on journalists on the ground to document the plight of ordinary people...
Then there are also the geographical implications and the fact that it is relatively easy to go to Poland to deliver aid = no visas or other travel restrictions.

I very much remember the the reports about families in Afghanistan having toselltheir daughters in order to survive the winter. Or how much women's & girls lives are getting worse.Where are the people from these reports now? Yet there is very little reporting now, because most journalists have left, thanks to the Taliban.

The same is happening in Russia, we will know very little about a possible opposition to Putin or how they are silenced due to media blocks and the journalists exodus.

I think people/ keyboard worriers need to put things into perspective. Saying that the help offered is about race is very simplistic. It is about geography, infrastructure and how & who reports about the suffering and displacements. And then there is politics...

Happylittlethoughts · 07/03/2022 19:37

If you think humans care about everyone and everything equally then you are surely naive.
I agree with PPs. We surely seem to care more about issues /people with closer geographical or cultural connections . That is a very broad statement obviously. Many people care about Syria for example, but most dont see a reflection of themselves there on TV. I think they easily see that looking at Ukraine.

AlistairCamel · 07/03/2022 19:32

I am always sympathetic to those in war torn regions across the world. But Ukraine is part of Europe, it looks similar to many cities I’ve visited in central and Eastern Europe. I consider myself to be European. I know Ukrainians. There’s a sense of familiarity.

Lovingeveryrainbow · 07/03/2022 19:31

This. It’s clear as day.

There have been news reporters and politicians saying these aren’t “the usual” refugees- Confusedtheir whiteness affords them compassion where there is fury and contempt for those from the global south.

The same old same old.

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 19:28

@TabithaHazel

That's disgusting imo. Cultural differences or not we are all people. You can feel one thing for a group of people but won't feel the same for another group of people going through the exact same thing due to cultural differences? And the fact that there's been a few comments after you saying a similar thing shows that people really do think like this. What a wow

@babyhaha I think you have misunderstood - I was musing on the OP's question of why it might be that people are showing more empathy to this situation to others, not that I agreed with this as you will have seen if you'd read my comment, I even wrote 'all humans no matter where they were born are part of the human race and deserve the same empathy' so not sure why you have picked on my comment for your indignation.

Empathy is a very subjective thing though and people are able to feel it more for people where they can imagine themselves in the other person's place. Not saying that's right or wrong that's just how many humans are wired.

@TabithaHazel no no sorry I got your point and I got that you wasn't saying that's your personal view. I was just responding to the fact that people even thinking like that is disgusting in my eyes. When I was saying 'you' I was just speaking in general terms for the people that think that way.

I agree empathy is subjective but I just think if you only care more about something when you see someone who looks like you/lives similar to you is going through it. Then your empathy really is capped and won't be given to every human simply because they're human. It's sad if anything but is what it is

OP posts:
FloBot7 · 07/03/2022 19:27

I get what you mean. I work with someone from Syria and the stories of what her family are still going through are awful. They're lucky to be relatively well off but there have been weeks when they've had the extended family living in the only central room in the house during air strikes. She's had days where they haven't been in contact. It was very frequently in the news when the worst of it kicked off. I think most of us saw the heartbreaking images of chemical attacks injuring children at that time. It's older news now and not quite as frequent so stories have tapered off. More than anything, the key difference is how very far away "the Middle East" feels compared to Ukraine, especially when they started talking about the Polish border.

ToTestOrNot · 07/03/2022 19:26

It's unconscious bias. As humans we tend to feel more empathy for those who look/feel/seem like us. It's not right but it's a fact.

MissAmbrosia · 07/03/2022 19:26

I totally understand that this conflict has risks that others did not and people are afraid, for genuine reasons. But it does make me cross all the virtue signalling on here "it's breaking my heart" etc. about Ukraine when no-one gave a shit before. UK has actually been the agressor before and still supplies weapons that have destroyed cities and killed innocent civilians.

Riverlee · 07/03/2022 19:24

I had a similar conversation with my dh a few days ago. His response was because ‘the enemy’ is Russia, who are a huge powerful force.

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 19:24

@CouldIhaveaword

The statistics show that the majority of asylum seakers in the UK in 2021 were young men. The refugees coming out of Ukraine seem to be largely women and children. In fact men are pouring into the country to join the resistance.

Could this affect sympathy levels?

@CouldIhaveaword clearly it does! I never considered the fact that more men coming over as asylum seekers would even be a thing. Whether it's women, kids or men why does it even matter? What if they're fleeing a country because the family decided it's in the best interest for the man to go elsewhere and send money back home? Who honestly knows what the reason is but again, this is interesting to know
OP posts:
DamnUserName21 · 07/03/2022 19:24

Interesting (opinion) article on this very topic.

edition.cnn.com/2022/03/07/opinions/europe-refugee-response-ukrainians-syrians-damon/index.html