Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Compassion & media coverage towards Ukraine but not the Middle East/Africa

263 replies

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 18:40

This is something that has been on my mind for a little while so hopefully I'm able to word it correctly.

Since the invasion in Ukraine there has been constant threads about this on MN. This is also something that is constantly spoken about and written about in the media as it rightly should be. This is a major thing that's going on and people should obviously be informed about this.

However, why is this not the case when there's constant wars happening in the Middle East and Africa? Iraq, Palastine, Syria, Sudan, Afghanistan etc the list really does go on. There's still innocent people in these countries that are getting killed for no reason. Now I've personally never seen threads about these countries on MN but as I don't spend too much time I'm on here, I could be wrong. What I am certain about, is these countries BARELY get any media attention from the West, if ever at all. Why is that?!

Is this because Ukraine is a European country and not a third world country where things like these are 'expected to happen?' Do people feel that as the people in these countries are minorities that they don't deserve the same sort of empathy that the Ukrainians are getting? I really am interested to know why there's such a massive difference in terms of media coverage and general compassion.

It's actually interesting because just a few days ago, supermodel Bella Hadid stated that Muslim suffering deserves the same level of outrage as Ukraine and she is absolutely right. And to those who may say I'm exaggerating or this isn't the case, I've linked a Twitter thread below which has clips of the most racist Ukraine coverage on TV and the wording used in each and every clip is very telling. I'd be very interested in hearing people's thoughts.

twitter.com/alanrmacleod/status/1497974245737050120?s=21

OP posts:
Elissax · 07/03/2022 20:30

I've had countless debates with my afghan in laws about the compassion of British people.

But this Ukraine disaster has really proved me wrong.

The journalist openly saying things like "yes they drop these bombs in Afghanistan BUT it's stomach churning for it to be happening in Ukraine" proved everything.

And Afghanistan despite what people think isn't full of a bunch of hillbillys living in huts.
My in-laws whom live in Afghanistan live in beautiful homes, far better and hygiene is taken more serious than most homes in the uk.
Most people I think would be shocked to see how actual middle class afghans are living over there.

But it's okay, if a afghan nursery gets bombed because it's only brown children.

I feel disgusted at any war and I feel sorry for the people of Ukraine but for this posts sake, I completely agree with you OP and I think we all know the real reason.

It's quite concerning how bombs were dropped every few minutes on Middle Eastern countries but Obama was never blasted? Sanctions aren't put on America every time they try and occupy somewhere. So what's the fuss with Putin? Why is Putin the devil and Biden isn't?

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 20:30

[quote ReadtheFT]@emuloc, not sure if you know about the trip those refugees have to make to arrive to a safe country, but sade to say it is not a journey I would do taking my wife and young children and elderly parents with me. It is not so hard to understand that the man would take the dangerous journey woth the hope of having the family join them in a easier way later? Or those refugees are all monsters that hate women, that the way ment posters seem to think.
And lets finish already with the narrative of the "heroic" ukranian men staying back to fight, they are forced to stay.
Not to mention that when other men in other countries stay and fight they are called terrorist.
No, people dont care about refugees from Africa and middle east because they are a different colour and different religion. So many contorsions to try and explain it otherwise, but thats all there is.
A bit more empathy for something happening nearer, sure. But not this level of disgusting double standards and blatant racism , including by reporters.[/quote]
It is not so hard to understand that the man would take the dangerous journey woth the hope of having the family join them in a easier way later? Or those refugees are all monsters that hate women, that the way ment posters seem to think.

@ReadtheFT thank you!! I even said, what if it was a family decision for the man to leave their family behind in hopes to send money back to them! Yet they're being painted as the monsters because they're just coming here for a 'better life.'

And lets finish already with the narrative of the "heroic" ukranian men staying back to fight, they are forced to stay.

Exactly!!

Not to mention that when other men in other countries stay and fight they are called terrorist.

Right again!!

A bit more empathy for something happening nearer, sure. But not this level of disgusting double standards and blatant racism , including by reporters.

Double standards, that's exactly what it is. When I see the comments about caring more because English people can relate to these people more because of the cultural aspect. It's like okay that's great and I can understand that. But if you ONLY care because these people look like you then that's a problem no? The reporters have just been disgusting with it. Not even trying to hide their views

OP posts:
CBFA · 07/03/2022 20:27

I mean the media and news and politics is always depressing. Usually, it's focused on issues at home and then major international issues that affect us. But to expect that we must always be wailing and handwringing and immobilised with pity at every single conflict and cause if refugees in the world is a peculiarly UK-centric, naval-gazing view that we should care about absolutely everything absolutely equally. Of course that would be ideal, but we are but human and we do kinda get to pick and choose events that affect our little universe most, as does every single country on this planet in turn, rather than feeling particularly responsible to feel wretched about it during our daily lives

emuloc · 07/03/2022 20:27

@ReadtheFT Exactly. The amount of posters so quick to criticize male refugees from other countries, and conveniently overlook the fact that the men in Ukraine have no choice but to stay and fight.

ReadtheFT · 07/03/2022 20:26

@Bubblesandsqueak1

Tbh all the other wars are mainly conflict within the country itself and they have been going on for so many years it has became the norm this new was is 1 sick prat killing for no reason he also has nukes and if any country helps they are screwed, and whats to say he won't move onto another country after
Easy example, Israel invading Palestine is not a conflict within one country. Look at the difference in narrative!? Those ukranians heroes making molotov are the same that would be pointed at as terrorist and the reason why they are being bombed, many, many times over. But even if a war was qithin a country, it doesnt change anything for the innocent civilians. I dont see how the worry of the war spilling into europe and the rest brings more empathy towards white refugees. They are two different things
RocketPanda · 07/03/2022 20:24

I think the reality of living in a place where there's war doesn't affect many people in the UK. NI was somewhat removed from people's minds because it wasn't happening on their island. Its difficult for a lot of people to identify with refugees so they seek to find a connection, be it colour, religion, culture. It may not be consciously racist but just lack of experience and education of war.
A lot of Irish people have marched with Palestinians and identify with what is happening in Palestine. We also identify with Ukrainians. It seems to echo across most countries who have suffered under a regime. It's not because we are better but because unfortunately we identify with the invasion and displacement of war and do not need to find another connection.

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 20:22

*I'm afraid to say that primarily I think it's due to the colour of the refugees.
They're white.

I think sometimes that people in England don't realise that refugees are people no matter which race they are.

It's an unfortunate reality that it's human nature to empathise with people who seem similar to you or share the same race/religion/culture.

It's unconscious bias. As humans we tend to feel more empathy for those who look/feel/seem like us. It's not right but it's a fact.

There have been news reporters and politicians saying these aren’t “the usual” refugees- their whiteness affords them compassion where there is fury and contempt for those from the global south.

Many people care about Syria for example, but most dont see a reflection of themselves there on TV. I think they easily see that looking at Ukraine.*

@Cheshirecatwoman these are only a few comments made because I can't be bothered to copy and paste all when it's in the thread. These are all about race. Again, what agenda?

OP posts:
Bubblesandsqueak1 · 07/03/2022 20:22

Tbh all the other wars are mainly conflict within the country itself and they have been going on for so many years it has became the norm this new was is 1 sick prat killing for no reason he also has nukes and if any country helps they are screwed, and whats to say he won't move onto another country after

kerstina · 07/03/2022 20:22

I don't know . I guess it has a lot to do with what the media decides to focus their reporting on ?
I have been dismayed for years over Israel's oppression and occupation of Palestinian Territories . And people wonder why suicide bombers existed there . Feel the helplessness and powerlessness that the Ukrainian people are facing now .

smsd33 · 07/03/2022 20:21

[quote ReadtheFT]@emuloc, not sure if you know about the trip those refugees have to make to arrive to a safe country, but sade to say it is not a journey I would do taking my wife and young children and elderly parents with me. It is not so hard to understand that the man would take the dangerous journey woth the hope of having the family join them in a easier way later? Or those refugees are all monsters that hate women, that the way ment posters seem to think.
And lets finish already with the narrative of the "heroic" ukranian men staying back to fight, they are forced to stay.
Not to mention that when other men in other countries stay and fight they are called terrorist.
No, people dont care about refugees from Africa and middle east because they are a different colour and different religion. So many contorsions to try and explain it otherwise, but thats all there is.
A bit more empathy for something happening nearer, sure. But not this level of disgusting double standards and blatant racism , including by reporters.[/quote]
This!

ReadtheFT · 07/03/2022 20:17

@emuloc, not sure if you know about the trip those refugees have to make to arrive to a safe country, but sade to say it is not a journey I would do taking my wife and young children and elderly parents with me. It is not so hard to understand that the man would take the dangerous journey woth the hope of having the family join them in a easier way later? Or those refugees are all monsters that hate women, that the way ment posters seem to think.
And lets finish already with the narrative of the "heroic" ukranian men staying back to fight, they are forced to stay.
Not to mention that when other men in other countries stay and fight they are called terrorist.
No, people dont care about refugees from Africa and middle east because they are a different colour and different religion. So many contorsions to try and explain it otherwise, but thats all there is.
A bit more empathy for something happening nearer, sure. But not this level of disgusting double standards and blatant racism , including by reporters.

hattie43 · 07/03/2022 20:17

For me it's very simple, familiarity . I can relate more to near Europeans than I can other cultures and creeds .

Also the Middle East has been fractious and at war since forever so it's like wallpaper now but the Ukraine crisis is recent and new and raw .
Having said that I have given to charities raising funds for all recent wars and disasters because although some are so far away I can empathise with anyone suffering.

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 20:15

@Cheshirecatwoman

“ But it's interesting to see people admitting this is about race and caring more”

@babyhaha

I haven’t seen anyone admit it is about race. Culture yes but race no.

You are putting forward your own agenda again.

Do you honestly, hand on heart have equal compassion for everyone and everything? I find that almost impossible to believe and feel that you are being a bit goady tbh.

@Cheshirecatwoman what agenda? From the start of the thread people have literally said it's easier to feel empathy for those that look like them. Is that not race? And what culture is this that makes you feel sudden empathy that you can't feel for the Middle East/Africa?
OP posts:
NumberTheory · 07/03/2022 20:15

I don’t think it’s quite as simple as it being skin colour, though I don’t doubt that adds to it. I think the fact Ukraine was forging closer ties with the EU and NATO and becoming “one of us” is the clincher. If it’s Ukraine today, will it be us tomorrow?

People can see themselves as Ukrainians, where as they can’t really see themselves as, say, Syrians, or Yemenese.

What Russia is doing to Ukraine is not really different to what the UK and USA did to Iraq. Our compassion is bound up in the sharing of values and a similar world view, as much as it is in the colour of people’s skin.

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 20:13

@Livelovebehappy

Different, in that a lot of the refugees in boats are not fleeing war torn countries, but want a better life, whereby the Ukraine’s are clearly trying to escape war. There’s a difference. We can’t accommodate economic migrants here, because we already have insufficient housing, schooling and nhs facilities. Obviously the ukrainian situation is different. They want to remain in their homeland, but circumstances mean they have no choice. They have nowhere to go so we want to help them.
@Livelovebehappy how do you know these people aren't fleeing war torn countries though? Why do you get the impression that they're just here for a better life?
OP posts:
Boxowine · 07/03/2022 20:10

Why do you think “nothing’s felt for the people of Middle East/Africa” ? I think that a great deal has been felt by a great many people over many years concerning the Middle East and Africa. I keep seeing people bring up the West’s response to the current war in Ukraine, but I don’t see them analyzing China or India’s response. Are those two countries providing assistance to refugees? Are their media outlets providing non stop coverage? If that’s not happening, is it because Chinese and Indian people are racist? Are we going to analyze which countries in Africa and the Middle East provided assistance to refugees from those areas? Why or why not?

Tigofigo · 07/03/2022 20:10

When I say "similar looking lives" I mean western style lives, living in cities / blocks of flats, relative wealth, enjoying the same hobbies, experiences, culture Brits might enjoy. Sadly race probably does come into it as well.

Cheshirecatwoman · 07/03/2022 20:08

“ But it's interesting to see people admitting this is about race and caring more”

@babyhaha

I haven’t seen anyone admit it is about race. Culture yes but race no.

You are putting forward your own agenda again.

Do you honestly, hand on heart have equal compassion for everyone and everything? I find that almost impossible to believe and feel that you are being a bit goady tbh.

Tigofigo · 07/03/2022 20:07

I get where you're coming from and it has crossed my mind too, but as has been said people tend to empathise more with those they can relate to. And those in Europe living similar looking lives to us means we can empathise more easily.

Evolutionarily, we're not designed to take on 7 billion people's woes, we are designed to live in tribes of 1-200 people, so our compassion has to have some limits (or we become easily overwhelmed as I'm sure many people have experienced when they feel deep empathy with ALL displaced people and every injustice).

That's why cancer and animal charities get many times over more money than malaria ones, which are literally capable of saving thousands of children's lives easily and cheaply in e.g. Africa.

Livelovebehappy · 07/03/2022 20:06

Different, in that a lot of the refugees in boats are not fleeing war torn countries, but want a better life, whereby the Ukraine’s are clearly trying to escape war. There’s a difference. We can’t accommodate economic migrants here, because we already have insufficient housing, schooling and nhs facilities. Obviously the ukrainian situation is different. They want to remain in their homeland, but circumstances mean they have no choice. They have nowhere to go so we want to help them.

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 20:06

I wonder what these so called cultural similarities are, that you speak off.

I've been thinking the exact same thing but I don't think I have the energy to get into it!

OP posts:
emuloc · 07/03/2022 20:05

[quote MurmuratingStarling]@Cheshirecatwoman

I cannot relate in the same way to young healthy for men who ditch their families and travel alone. That may be unfair of me but that is how I feel. Also these men often have a different attitude towards women than us in Europe. I have seen and experienced this first hand through my job so do feel I have some understanding.

This. ^ There's a startling difference between the Ukrainian men and the men that came from Syria/the middle east/Afghanistan...The Ukrainian men are staying to fight for their country, and have sent their women and children to safety. In the Middle East/Syria/Afghanistan etc, the men (mostly younger ones) seem to flee to safety and leave the women and children (and older generations) behind.

I wonder why that is?[/quote]
The Ukrainian men of a certain age are not being allowed to leave. They have to stay, if they want to or not.

emuloc · 07/03/2022 20:03

@Ohmnomnom

Racism is definitely the main reason. Journalists have been absolutely shocking and many aren't even trying to hide it.

Additional reasons as pp have said are proximity, threat of nuclear war, possible start of ww3, and global hatred of Putin and his dictatorship. On another thread, someone pointed out that all of the refugees coming from Ukraine are women and children. I wonder if the West would be more sympathetic to African and Middle Eastern refugees if they were all women and children and the men stayed behind.

Somehow I doubt it.
babyhaha · 07/03/2022 20:02

*Also, in case you haven't noticed, the UK has done virtually fuck-all to help the Ukrainians anyway!

Lots of media coverage is just lip service. Less than FIFTY refugees have come into the UK from Ukraine thus far! So the UK is hardly 'favouring' them over people from the middle east and Africa. *

Yes when I was looking into it, I'd seen the UK haven't actually done much and Priti Patel has just been waffling as usual.

Nowhere have I said the UK is favouring them but if all the UK has done is media coverage. They've done a hell of a lot more for Ukraine than other countries. As a pp has said, it's probably because what's happening in these countries has been going on for so long, it's no longer deemed as 'news.' Another point I hadn't actually considered

OP posts:
emuloc · 07/03/2022 20:02

@Cheshirecatwoman

I’m not sure why you’ve asked the question op *@babyhaha* when you have already decided you know what the answer is.

I’ll answer honestly how I feel.

I have massive sympathy wherever the conflict is when I see reports and videos of injured and frightened children (black or white- colour is irrelevant in this instance).

In General though, I probably feel more upset about the conflict in Ukraine because the whole thing seems so unfair and completely unprovoked. It feels with the media coverage that we have ring side seats and it is horrific. I can relate to these people as we are culturally more similar. They are trying to evacuate their women and children and their elderly relatives.

I cannot relate in the same way to young healthy for men who ditch their families and travel alone. That may be unfair of me but that is how I feel. Also these men often have a different attitude towards women than us in Europe. I have seen and experienced this first hand through my job so do feel I have some understanding.

Your whole post sounds judgemental and frankly unfair. You use the word "ditch" to talk about men, who could have very good reason for travelling alone. Who are you to judge them? Your post is very them and us, which is the whole problem. I wonder what these so called cultural similarities are, that you speak off.