Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Compassion & media coverage towards Ukraine but not the Middle East/Africa

263 replies

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 18:40

This is something that has been on my mind for a little while so hopefully I'm able to word it correctly.

Since the invasion in Ukraine there has been constant threads about this on MN. This is also something that is constantly spoken about and written about in the media as it rightly should be. This is a major thing that's going on and people should obviously be informed about this.

However, why is this not the case when there's constant wars happening in the Middle East and Africa? Iraq, Palastine, Syria, Sudan, Afghanistan etc the list really does go on. There's still innocent people in these countries that are getting killed for no reason. Now I've personally never seen threads about these countries on MN but as I don't spend too much time I'm on here, I could be wrong. What I am certain about, is these countries BARELY get any media attention from the West, if ever at all. Why is that?!

Is this because Ukraine is a European country and not a third world country where things like these are 'expected to happen?' Do people feel that as the people in these countries are minorities that they don't deserve the same sort of empathy that the Ukrainians are getting? I really am interested to know why there's such a massive difference in terms of media coverage and general compassion.

It's actually interesting because just a few days ago, supermodel Bella Hadid stated that Muslim suffering deserves the same level of outrage as Ukraine and she is absolutely right. And to those who may say I'm exaggerating or this isn't the case, I've linked a Twitter thread below which has clips of the most racist Ukraine coverage on TV and the wording used in each and every clip is very telling. I'd be very interested in hearing people's thoughts.

twitter.com/alanrmacleod/status/1497974245737050120?s=21

OP posts:
RoastedFerret · 07/03/2022 21:47

Unlike many people here, I'm able to care and have empathy for anyone who's going through such horrible tragedy. Regardless of any culture similarities or whether or not these people look like me.

What form does that empathy take? Do you write about it all across the Internet so that everyone knows just how empathetic you are? I mean I hear about things on the news and I thing oh how terrible but I don't broadcast my thoughts everywhere nor do I spend much time dwelling on the things I can't change.
I have troubles that people in Ukraine would probs love to have right now but they still play on my mind more because I have to actively try and figure out how I'm supposed to afford to heat my home, I have to pay an extortionate amount for a second hand car because the market is bonkers, petrol is almost and is in some places 2e a litre, I have to find counseling for my teenager but the health system is in bits and on and on it goes.

What good does me being performatively empathetic about all of the wars around the world, about climate change, about every bloody shit show thing that is happening in the world do? I donate where I can, do my bits for climate change but I'm not standing around weeping for the worlds struggles and I'm sick of all of these posts telling us that we have to care about every single person all over the world all at the same time or we are somehow defective.

JayAlfredPrufrock · 07/03/2022 21:45

Nuclear weapons

Villagewaspbyke · 07/03/2022 21:45

@RobinBlackbird - Russian bots and agents are well capable of using Al Jazera.

Let’s all ask ourselves -is our response to the horrors in Ukraine really to hand wring about whether we helped others equally before helping them. Help them first.

lightisnotwhite · 07/03/2022 21:45

Not RTT sure it’s been said before.
Ukraine is a settled civilised democracy that’s been invaded.

Not a civil war, or some countries military gone bonkers. And the young men of Ukraine are staying to fight it out. I’d take women and children from anywhere if any colour.

VladmirsPoutine · 07/03/2022 21:45

I wonder if it's all this 'similarity' that essentially made the UK vote for Brexit ostensibly distancing themselves from their fellow white Europeans. People can try and dress it up however they like but the difference in treatment is down to racism.

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 21:44

@Cheshirecatwoman

Oh and not everyone in the uk is white and middle class but most of us are westernised and share a moral compass no matter what our colour is.

Why are you trying to make it only about race?

@Cheshirecatwoman Stop tryna make this a race thing man. People on this thread have LITERALLY said there's more empathy/interest/compassion when someone that looks like you is going through something. Many posters have said it may not be right but it's kind of a natural thing. So why you acting like I just started talking about race out of my arse. Seriously have a good evening
OP posts:
PurpleHills · 07/03/2022 21:44

@TeenyQueen

Simply, wars in Syria, Afghanistan and Yemen are quite far away and these conflicts have been going on for years and even decades. I think we have tremendous sympathy when we see people suffering, especially children. If there's a conflict in a distant country with a very different culture and religion, it's hard to think what we can do practically to help. This war is on our continent so we can donate goods, fundraise, offer shelter to refugees, lobby our MPs etc. What can we do practically about Yemen?

If a house on your street was on fire right now, would you pay more attention to it than an old burnt out house on the other side on your hometown?

Last night I saw a video of a Ukrainian girl holding onto her Peppa Pig toy whilst arriving in Poland. My DD loves Peppa Pig so it hit me like a ton of bricks. I'm sure if we had to flee Peppa would be one of the few things I'd let her bring with us. When I see the mums and their children fleeing I see myself and my children.

What could you do to help people in Yemen? You could not vote for a party that provides arms, staff and expertise to their aggressors.
Chonfox · 07/03/2022 21:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

supermoonrising · 07/03/2022 21:42

@Tillsforthrills
It’s possible to know what’s happening in Ukraine is horrific while at the same time noticing how differently this war is being reported to all others in recent memory - the focus on the human cost, and every civilian death a tragedy. Which is how wars should be reported in my opinion. But to question why no other wars in recent memory have been reported like this.

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 21:41

@Cheshirecatwoman

On the one hand you are implying that there is no cultural difference between the Middle East and Africa and Europe.

I haven't said that anywhere?? I am literally asking you what is this cultural similarity that's constantly being mentioned in relation to Ukraine? English culture is not my culture so what is this cultural similarity that is constantly being mentioned by people on this thread?*
*

On the other hand you mention that it would be dangerous for women and children to make the journey to Europe due to the risk of rape and trafficking!

Now you're just putting words into my mouth. That was another poster, not me...

And then you are comparing a situation of civil unrest in historically volatile countries with an unprovoked invasion of a peaceful non-volatile country.

To me, it doesn't matter how they got there. ALL of these countries are facing a war, one country has provoked more compassion/empathy and media attention than the other. Do the situations have to be exactly the same for people to care about innocent people dying?

It's been nice chatting to you but think I'll stop now as you're literally putting words into my mouth

OP posts:
PurpleHills · 07/03/2022 21:41

[quote Villagewaspbyke]@madroid but op and others are trying to move focus away from helping Ukrainians at a time when they really need our help. Basically op is shouting “ALL LIVES MATTER” at a Black Lives Matter protest. Now is the time to help Ukraine. If you have some issue about how Ukrainian refugees are really privileged white people or we only want to help them because they are, save it until at least the worst atrocities are over. Otherwise don’t be surprised if people think you’re a Russian bot.

To be honest I don’t think it’s true that it’s racism anyway- we were utterly disinterested in refugees from the former Yugoslavia despite them being white folks.[/quote]
Not at all. It's a good time for people to reflect on how they feel about refugees in general and why they feel that some are more deserving of compassion and help than others.

I don't think anyone would think "I didn't do anything to support Syrians fleeing civil war so let me ignore the poor Ukrainians as well". The hope is that people will show more compassion to other (non white) refugees as well as to Ukrainians.

"All lives matter" is completely different as it trivialises or denies that people of colour face issues that white people don't. The purpose of saying it is to trivialise the issue

This (thread) just points out the discrepancy between how refugees of different regions are viewed and questions why.

FoxNet · 07/03/2022 21:39

However, why is this not the case when there's constant wars happening in the Middle East and Africa? Iraq, Palastine, Syria, Sudan, Afghanistan etc the list really does go on. There's still innocent people in these countries that are getting killed for no reason. Now I've personally never seen threads about these countries on MN but as I don't spend too much time I'm on here, I could be wrong. What I am certain about, is these countries BARELY get any media attention from the West, if ever at all. Why is that?!

Which media do you consume? Just putting 'Palestine + BBC' or 'Syria + Channel 4' returns countless articles/stories on just these two conflicts including ones from this year. We were involved in two wars that lasted years and were constantly covered by the media. The sudden US final withdrawal from Afghanistan was a massive, long running news story last year covered by all major channels.

TeenyQueen · 07/03/2022 21:37

Simply, wars in Syria, Afghanistan and Yemen are quite far away and these conflicts have been going on for years and even decades. I think we have tremendous sympathy when we see people suffering, especially children. If there's a conflict in a distant country with a very different culture and religion, it's hard to think what we can do practically to help. This war is on our continent so we can donate goods, fundraise, offer shelter to refugees, lobby our MPs etc. What can we do practically about Yemen?

If a house on your street was on fire right now, would you pay more attention to it than an old burnt out house on the other side on your hometown?

Last night I saw a video of a Ukrainian girl holding onto her Peppa Pig toy whilst arriving in Poland. My DD loves Peppa Pig so it hit me like a ton of bricks. I'm sure if we had to flee Peppa would be one of the few things I'd let her bring with us. When I see the mums and their children fleeing I see myself and my children.

SnowdropsInSpring · 07/03/2022 21:36

[quote Villagewaspbyke]@madroid but op and others are trying to move focus away from helping Ukrainians at a time when they really need our help. Basically op is shouting “ALL LIVES MATTER” at a Black Lives Matter protest. Now is the time to help Ukraine. If you have some issue about how Ukrainian refugees are really privileged white people or we only want to help them because they are, save it until at least the worst atrocities are over. Otherwise don’t be surprised if people think you’re a Russian bot.

To be honest I don’t think it’s true that it’s racism anyway- we were utterly disinterested in refugees from the former Yugoslavia despite them being white folks.[/quote]
This

RobinBlackbird · 07/03/2022 21:34

[quote Villagewaspbyke]@madroid - maybe this thread shows how easy it is for bots to manipulate the foolish including the foolish guardian reader types.[/quote]
The Twitter link in OP indicates where it's coming from.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 07/03/2022 21:34

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll but what on Earth makes you think he is 'happy' to flee his country and leave his family behind?! I think this conversation is pointless because you clearly don't know any migrants and it shows

OK, 'happy' wasn't the best word for me to use as clearly, nobody is being jolly and lighthearted about anything. The point I was trying to make was that these men - making dangerous and harrowing decisions and journeys - are coming for economic reasons.

As I (I believed) clearly said, I do not personally blame them at all: they aren't reasonably well-off and looking for riches; they have nothing and they are wanting a little something - security and a basic standard of living without fear - for themselves and their families; and why ever wouldn't they want that? Good luck to them, I say.

All I was saying is that, ultimately (and the way many people see it, albeit in a grossly exaggerated manner), their plight is economic rather than great risk of imminent violent death.

If your children were going without food, shivering, wearing far-outgrown clothes and unable to do the very basic things that their friends took for granted, would you gladly leave them at home (with their other parent or another responsible adult) and go to work to earn money to elevate the whole family's standard of living? I'm guessing the answer would be Yes.

If, however, your house was on fire, would you still willingly leave them at home and go out to your job? I doubt it.

PurpleHills · 07/03/2022 21:32

@Whelmed

There was a great outpour of support for refugees from Afghanistan last year. It's all very short lived as it will very likely be for Ukrainian refugees as well.
Yes, there was but nothing compared to the outpouring of empathy people are showing now.
Villagewaspbyke · 07/03/2022 21:30

@madroid - maybe this thread shows how easy it is for bots to manipulate the foolish including the foolish guardian reader types.

Chonfox · 07/03/2022 21:29

I find this "whataboutism" so tedious. Of course people will care more about something closer to home that impacts on people who they can relate to more. It's really not complicated. Journalism schools teach about newsworthiness and one of the factors that determines if a story is considered "newsworthy" or not is proximity. Ukraine is in Europe, it is culturally and geographically closer to us in Western Europe than say Burkina Faso.

Proximity and cultural similarity makes it more "real" and therefore has a greater impact. Stop wringing your hands over what is essentially human nature.

Tillsforthrills · 07/03/2022 21:28

@Cheshirecatwoman

I’m not white but find the timing of this thread thread really distasteful.

The UK had helped my Mother and millions of others from all around the world, taken them in and given them a better life.

Villagewaspbyke · 07/03/2022 21:28

@madroid but op and others are trying to move focus away from helping Ukrainians at a time when they really need our help. Basically op is shouting “ALL LIVES MATTER” at a Black Lives Matter protest. Now is the time to help Ukraine. If you have some issue about how Ukrainian refugees are really privileged white people or we only want to help them because they are, save it until at least the worst atrocities are over. Otherwise don’t be surprised if people think you’re a Russian bot.

To be honest I don’t think it’s true that it’s racism anyway- we were utterly disinterested in refugees from the former Yugoslavia despite them being white folks.

Fordian · 07/03/2022 21:26

@madroid

This thread shows how so many people just cannot think for themselves. They are led by the media and do not recognise their own bigotry and racism.

Or, as humans, we recognise 'macro' and 'micro'. We cannot care the same for everyone on the planet. You'd have to be 12 to think so.

We care far more for the micro. It's human nature, it's what keeps us and our family/local communities alive, basically.

As an aside, I wonder how many of you are 60? Who recall the USSR? The Cold War? That affected the western world? That spectre has re-arisen 'in the east'. Let's not forget some aspects of history.

And this time around, the aggressor is threatening nukes. It feels rather more personal.

Knittingchamp · 07/03/2022 21:25

[quote babyhaha]This is something that has been on my mind for a little while so hopefully I'm able to word it correctly.

Since the invasion in Ukraine there has been constant threads about this on MN. This is also something that is constantly spoken about and written about in the media as it rightly should be. This is a major thing that's going on and people should obviously be informed about this.

However, why is this not the case when there's constant wars happening in the Middle East and Africa? Iraq, Palastine, Syria, Sudan, Afghanistan etc the list really does go on. There's still innocent people in these countries that are getting killed for no reason. Now I've personally never seen threads about these countries on MN but as I don't spend too much time I'm on here, I could be wrong. What I am certain about, is these countries BARELY get any media attention from the West, if ever at all. Why is that?!

Is this because Ukraine is a European country and not a third world country where things like these are 'expected to happen?' Do people feel that as the people in these countries are minorities that they don't deserve the same sort of empathy that the Ukrainians are getting? I really am interested to know why there's such a massive difference in terms of media coverage and general compassion.

It's actually interesting because just a few days ago, supermodel Bella Hadid stated that Muslim suffering deserves the same level of outrage as Ukraine and she is absolutely right. And to those who may say I'm exaggerating or this isn't the case, I've linked a Twitter thread below which has clips of the most racist Ukraine coverage on TV and the wording used in each and every clip is very telling. I'd be very interested in hearing people's thoughts.

twitter.com/alanrmacleod/status/1497974245737050120?s=21[/quote]
People are saying the same as you, constantly. And we've heard years of coverage of other terrible wars. What can we do about them? It's horrible, all of it. A lot of us do a lot to try and help various conflicts or charities but don't shout about it on social media. Doesn't mean it isn't happening.

When other mums and their kids are being shelled and killed right now in the Ukraine, we need to at least be humane enough to stop the 'but what about' comments, don't we?

Plus this could lead to WWIII of course, and go nuclear, hence the interest, and it's much geographically closer than any other recent major conflict.

Cheshirecatwoman · 07/03/2022 21:25

Oh and not everyone in the uk is white and middle class but most of us are westernised and share a moral compass no matter what our colour is.

Why are you trying to make it only about race?

flowerycurtain · 07/03/2022 21:24

Because will have a huge impact on our food prices. Head of Yara on the news today saying this

Ukraine war 'catastrophic for global food' www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-60623941

Swipe left for the next trending thread