Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Compassion & media coverage towards Ukraine but not the Middle East/Africa

263 replies

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 18:40

This is something that has been on my mind for a little while so hopefully I'm able to word it correctly.

Since the invasion in Ukraine there has been constant threads about this on MN. This is also something that is constantly spoken about and written about in the media as it rightly should be. This is a major thing that's going on and people should obviously be informed about this.

However, why is this not the case when there's constant wars happening in the Middle East and Africa? Iraq, Palastine, Syria, Sudan, Afghanistan etc the list really does go on. There's still innocent people in these countries that are getting killed for no reason. Now I've personally never seen threads about these countries on MN but as I don't spend too much time I'm on here, I could be wrong. What I am certain about, is these countries BARELY get any media attention from the West, if ever at all. Why is that?!

Is this because Ukraine is a European country and not a third world country where things like these are 'expected to happen?' Do people feel that as the people in these countries are minorities that they don't deserve the same sort of empathy that the Ukrainians are getting? I really am interested to know why there's such a massive difference in terms of media coverage and general compassion.

It's actually interesting because just a few days ago, supermodel Bella Hadid stated that Muslim suffering deserves the same level of outrage as Ukraine and she is absolutely right. And to those who may say I'm exaggerating or this isn't the case, I've linked a Twitter thread below which has clips of the most racist Ukraine coverage on TV and the wording used in each and every clip is very telling. I'd be very interested in hearing people's thoughts.

twitter.com/alanrmacleod/status/1497974245737050120?s=21

OP posts:
Crankley · 08/03/2022 00:23

There is such a thing as compassion fatigue.

Also, I've noticed a very interesting difference between those fleeing from Ukraine and those from other areas. The Ukranians leaving their country are predominantly women and children whereas from many of the areas you mention they are usually young men, hellbent on getting to the UK while the women and children are left behind to face what?Rape? Death?

EeeICouldRipATissue · 07/03/2022 23:30

I've definitely noticed a shift in tone/language used and compassion from the main stream media usual suspects

side eyes DM

YANBU

MacaroniBaloney · 07/03/2022 23:03

Definition of Whataboutery;

Edward Lucas's 2008 Economist article associated the tactic specifically with the Soviet Union, stating "Soviet propagandists during the cold war were trained in a tactic that their western interlocutors nicknamed 'whataboutism'. Any criticism of the Soviet Union (Afghanistan, martial law in Poland, imprisonment of dissidents, censorship) was met with a 'What about...' (apartheid South Africa, jailed trade-unionists, the Contras in Nicaragua, and so forth)." Lucas recommended two methods of properly countering whataboutism: to "use points made by Russian leaders themselves" so that they cannot be applied to the West, and for Western nations to engage in more self-criticism of their own media and government.[4]

Chonfox · 07/03/2022 22:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

JanuaryJones22 · 07/03/2022 22:38

Ah Bella Hadid the great geo-political commentator. She won't remember the Bosnian War...neither do you clearly OP. And is obviously to ignorant to look beyond what has passed recently but not in her own living memory. The Muslim Bosnians were persecuted horrifically and was it not one of the worst cases of ethnic cleansing the in the past 50 years. The coverage was huge, it dominated the news for years and the global outrage and sympathy for the Muslim population there was massive. I can remember so much of the coverage and underatood that it was a section of that cpuntry being persecuted because of their religion and I was barely a teenager.

Also and I think this was prior to Bosnia I remember the horrific wars in Seira Leone and Rawanda and the genocide that took place there and I was even younger then. The coverage on the news was intense and I can fundraising events for the victims of those wars (if you remember tthe genocide and brutality aas staggering) taking place at school.

Looking at more recent times the coverage and of Syria and Afganistan and the war in Gaza has dominated headlines and social media on and off for years. You have to remember as well the war in Syria is 10 years old now and started within the context of the West having recently gotten involved in conflicts in the Middle East and Northern Africa and frankly did more harm than good - rise of Isis, failed states etc. So have tended towards a more hands of approach than I think they would have liked.

Going

Findwen · 07/03/2022 22:24

It's not one thing, it's many reasons:

  1. They are being invaded by what seemed like an unstoppable force by someone who wants to steal their land and liberty (the 'little guy' in the conflict).

  2. The invader is Russia who has been a threat to the UK since 1945 and in the minds of many of the time.. as far back as the Russian revolution.

My parents generation would say they hoped they would see Christmas and not be nuked by Russia. They had this hope year after year... for decades. It's easy to forget or perhaps be unaware if you are say under 40 but Russia has been a threat for all of the formative years of the older generations.

  1. If Ukraine falls, it is feared the Russian threat will not stop there and edge closer to us.

  2. They refugees are women and children. Read many, many threads on here and there is a near universal opinion that men are always seen as a threat when compared to women. cross-reference the sex assaults at German new years parties after they let a huge number of male asylum seekers in just a few years ago.
    en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015–16_New_Year%27s_Eve_sexual_assaults_in_Germany

  3. They are close enough for anyone of us to drive to with supplies and support through countries that we would have no fear crossing their borders.

  4. The invasion is by a foreign power. You do not see the same sympathy for Russians fleeing Russia right now even though they have the same threats as you mentioned earlier (being drafted into the armed forces). I guess there is a feeling that by running away from conflict within your own country you are leaving others to deal with the mess.

Not sure the similar culture and whiteness argument is really convincing, on any other day anti-eastern european comments are abound.

Cheshirecatwoman · 07/03/2022 22:17

“@ Cheshirecatwoman
Stop tryna make this a race thing man. People on this thread have LITERALLY said there's more empathy/interest/compassion when someone that looks like you is going through something. Many posters have said it may not be right but it's kind of a natural thing. So why you acting like I just started talking about race out of my arse. Seriously have a good evening”

Apologies if I’ve misinterpreted the point of your original post but I thought you were implying that the difference in reporting and empathy etc was most likely down to race?

I was disagreeing that it was mainly down to race, but other factors already mentioned.

I do appreciate the question though and enjoy hearing other peoples opinions and views and debating them. I’m not saying I’m right but just trying to be honest with my views.

Villagewaspbyke · 07/03/2022 22:14

@babyhaha you said you didn’t start talking about refugees- clearly as I said that’s not true as you started a thread on mumsnet about it.

You are trying to stop people helping Ukrainian refugees,whether due to external influence or personal prejudice who knows. Of course I will not be dissuaded from helping others but clearly your intention is to dissuade others which could have real consequences to very vulnerable people.

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 22:08

I appreciate all the comments especially the ones that highlighted the threat of nukes and Ukraine being so close to us that it makes it more scary. When things happen so far away it feels like it's happening on another planet and there's not much that we can do. It also seems that it's easier or a natural human response to feel immediate empathy/interest when things are happening to someone that looks like you/lives like you. I can't say I agree with that myself but interesting to know that this is how so many think.
I'll continue to keep spreading awareness for the Middle East/Africa as well as Ukraine so thanks again for all the comments.
Definitely been an eye opener

OP posts:
stuckdownahole · 07/03/2022 22:05

I remember the fall of the Berlin wall as the first major political event of my life. I was a young teenager and had been interested in the 1987 general election but that was basically a non-event, the government got back in and nothing changed.

When I saw the wall being torn down I knew that the world was in a different place - crazy to think now that one of Europe's great capitals was a divided city, split down the middle ... then the Soviet Union broke up and we began a new phase in European history, leading to Eastern and Western Europe coming together under the EU umbrella.

Now Russia has invaded a peaceful neighbour with the apparent intention of annexing lands they consider historically "Russian" which has very strong echoes of Hitler in 1938. It feels like the Cold War is back and World War II is back.

Ever since I can remember, the Middle East has been at war. While the wall was coming down, Lebanon had been at war for over a decade. Before that, Oman. In current times, Yemen. Long, multi-faceted, insoluble conflicts. 15 or so years ago, Britain helped to topple a bloody dictator in Iraq and it turned out, awful as he was, he was stopping war from breaking out. Syria is similar. No conflict in this region feels unexpected. The war in Ukraine does; it has genuinely shaken me.

Villagewaspbyke · 07/03/2022 22:05

@PurpleHills - why when Ukrainians desperately need help is this a good time to think about how we have helped others less rather than focus on helping them? Black Lives Matter protests are to protest black victims of police brutality not to start highlighting victims of other races.

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 22:03

[quote Villagewaspbyke]@babyhaha this thread makes me uncomfortable as it is trying to take away assistance from those who desperately need it.[/quote]
@Villagewaspbyke it's not taking away from anything. This is the Internet, if something makes you uncomfortable then just close the tab and enjoy your evening. This thread is not stopping you from doing anything you're able to do to support Ukrainian victims

OP posts:
babyhaha · 07/03/2022 22:01

[quote Villagewaspbyke]@babyhaha No you definitely did start talking about Ukrainian refugees- you started a thread on mumsnet about it.

If you really do want to help them you will stop attacking those who want to help them.[/quote]
@Villagewaspbyke maybe read my OP again? I speak about innocent people getting killed in all of these places so why is there more media outrage for one and not all. That was my point, there were no mention about refugees

OP posts:
Villagewaspbyke · 07/03/2022 21:59

@babyhaha this thread makes me uncomfortable as it is trying to take away assistance from those who desperately need it.

Sharnydubs · 07/03/2022 21:58

Many people crossing the Channel turned out to be economic migrants. Ukrainians are escaping war. Whatever the motives for coming to the UK, this is a small overcrowded island with finite resources. If we were more strict initially about who we took in, we may have had more resources for those fleeing persecution and war.

lonelyapple · 07/03/2022 21:58

how do you know these people aren't fleeing war torn countries though? Why do you get the impression that they're just here for a better life?

Because France isn't a war torn country.

Villagewaspbyke · 07/03/2022 21:58

@babyhaha No you definitely did start talking about Ukrainian refugees- you started a thread on mumsnet about it.

If you really do want to help them you will stop attacking those who want to help them.

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 21:57

The thread made me uncomfortable too as it felt as though it was pitching us all against each other when despite being racially diverse in the uk, we all (mostly!) share the same values.

Ha what UK is this you speak of?

OP posts:
babyhaha · 07/03/2022 21:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post

twilightermummy · 07/03/2022 21:53

I’ll just add that I have been very moved by what is going on. It’s extremely sad. My point is that I’ve also cared greatly about other similar situations and I can see the stark contrast in the reporting and people’s reactions.

Villagewaspbyke · 07/03/2022 21:53

@VladmirsPoutine - what explains the difference with the refugees from the former Yugoslavia then?

Anyway I think it’s pointless to engage with those who have no compassion. Please everyone help refugees including Ukrainians who are currently in desperate need.

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 21:53

[quote supermoonrising]@Tillsforthrills
It’s possible to know what’s happening in Ukraine is horrific while at the same time noticing how differently this war is being reported to all others in recent memory - the focus on the human cost, and every civilian death a tragedy. Which is how wars should be reported in my opinion. But to question why no other wars in recent memory have been reported like this.[/quote]
Thank you this has been worded much better than what I've tried to do. This is essentially it!

OP posts:
twilightermummy · 07/03/2022 21:49

I’ve felt the same as you op about the Ukrainian refugee situation; it does seem so unfair. When I went to see Encanto at the cinema, I cried when they were essentially migrants at the beginning, as all I could think about were the lives lost in the channel. I also think the way we left people to the hands of the Taliban in Afghanistan is a complete stain on the West.

However, people have raised good points. We fear Putin and his nukes; we also fear some Muslims coming over as they can be associatied with terrorism. We fear this is the beginning of world war 3 against somebody who is actually a massive threat to us. It’s all encroaching upon our doorstep. I do agree with the women and children comments but understand that some journeys are too dangerous for women to make. However, it does get to me just seeing the men. I guess a more cynical person may question their motives.

However, have I personally felt any deeper emotion for Ukrainian children than children from around the world? Not in the slightest. In fact, I feel less concerned for them as a lot of help is going their way, as opposed to the migrants stuck being raped in appalling conditions in the camps just over yonder.

Cheshirecatwoman · 07/03/2022 21:49

[quote Tillsforthrills]@Cheshirecatwoman

I’m not white but find the timing of this thread thread really distasteful.

The UK had helped my Mother and millions of others from all around the world, taken them in and given them a better life.[/quote]
@Tillsforthrills

I’m glad to hear that.

The thread made me uncomfortable too as it felt as though it was pitching us all against each other when despite being racially diverse in the uk, we all (mostly!) share the same values.

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 21:49

[quote Villagewaspbyke]@madroid but op and others are trying to move focus away from helping Ukrainians at a time when they really need our help. Basically op is shouting “ALL LIVES MATTER” at a Black Lives Matter protest. Now is the time to help Ukraine. If you have some issue about how Ukrainian refugees are really privileged white people or we only want to help them because they are, save it until at least the worst atrocities are over. Otherwise don’t be surprised if people think you’re a Russian bot.

To be honest I don’t think it’s true that it’s racism anyway- we were utterly disinterested in refugees from the former Yugoslavia despite them being white folks.[/quote]
@Villagewaspbyke seeing as I'm black that definitely isn't the case. I've done and will continue doing what I can to help victims in Ukraine, I don't need to shout it from the rooftops. That doesn't mean I can't say 'okay I can see this is happening but why aren't people feeling the same way about the same thing happening here??'

The funny thing is I never even started talking about refugees, I've only done it in response to other people but fair enough

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread