Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Compassion & media coverage towards Ukraine but not the Middle East/Africa

263 replies

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 18:40

This is something that has been on my mind for a little while so hopefully I'm able to word it correctly.

Since the invasion in Ukraine there has been constant threads about this on MN. This is also something that is constantly spoken about and written about in the media as it rightly should be. This is a major thing that's going on and people should obviously be informed about this.

However, why is this not the case when there's constant wars happening in the Middle East and Africa? Iraq, Palastine, Syria, Sudan, Afghanistan etc the list really does go on. There's still innocent people in these countries that are getting killed for no reason. Now I've personally never seen threads about these countries on MN but as I don't spend too much time I'm on here, I could be wrong. What I am certain about, is these countries BARELY get any media attention from the West, if ever at all. Why is that?!

Is this because Ukraine is a European country and not a third world country where things like these are 'expected to happen?' Do people feel that as the people in these countries are minorities that they don't deserve the same sort of empathy that the Ukrainians are getting? I really am interested to know why there's such a massive difference in terms of media coverage and general compassion.

It's actually interesting because just a few days ago, supermodel Bella Hadid stated that Muslim suffering deserves the same level of outrage as Ukraine and she is absolutely right. And to those who may say I'm exaggerating or this isn't the case, I've linked a Twitter thread below which has clips of the most racist Ukraine coverage on TV and the wording used in each and every clip is very telling. I'd be very interested in hearing people's thoughts.

twitter.com/alanrmacleod/status/1497974245737050120?s=21

OP posts:
deragod · 08/03/2022 13:23

It's funny how you are talking about islamophobia while both Ukraine and Poland have established Muslim communities longer than Britain has.
Where were you when Chechnyan refugees were fleeing?
Are they not proper muslim or they are victims of Russia so not good victims?

JasperHale · 08/03/2022 12:20

@AledsiPad

Sick to death of hearing this. There has been just as much compassion for refugees from Syria/Afghanistan/Whatever.

The difference is quite clear - the threat of NATO Vs Russia to the wider world. If people can't get their head round that then what's the point in arguing.

There is such desperation to find racism where it isn't. Must be fucking exhausting tbh.

What is the difference refusing to play football against Israel by Algeria, and against Russia by Poland? Difference is Algeria got banned for 10 years, Poland was branded heroes. It's just a small example, Scotland I believe was closest to home to be penalised for the "wrong" support Hmm
Brainwave89 · 08/03/2022 10:27

As a person of colour I can see the perspective that some of the commentary (notably from US correspondents) does seem to regard Ukraine as a more important conflict as those impacted are white. However, generally most refugees stay close to home, so they flee to next door countries. Which is exactly what you see happening in Ukraine. My family is Tamil by origin and during the Tamil conflict most displaced people went to India, with quite some numbers coming to the UK and the USA. In practice the UK does take quite large numbers of refugees, and did from the war in Sri Lanka and it is reasonable that it takes more from a European conflict than from a Middle Eastern or African conflict. It is closer geographically and culturally to the UK. it also took quite large numbers of Kosovan refugees during the war in this region and Bosnian refugees as well.

AledsiPad · 08/03/2022 10:22

Sick to death of hearing this. There has been just as much compassion for refugees from Syria/Afghanistan/Whatever.

The difference is quite clear - the threat of NATO Vs Russia to the wider world. If people can't get their head round that then what's the point in arguing.

There is such desperation to find racism where it isn't. Must be fucking exhausting tbh.

lonelyapple · 08/03/2022 10:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

stuckdownahole · 08/03/2022 09:50

@emuloc

The Islamophobia being displayed on this thread is disgraceful.
I've worked and lived in Islamic countries, in various regions. I am non-religious. I prefer any country where the state religion has less of an impact on me, so that would be liberal multi-faith (Asian) Islamic countries or Western Christian countries. I am less keen on conservative Islamic countries, which describes most of the Middle East except Lebanon. I feel less kinship with people from those countries because their way of life is different to mine.

Is that wrong?

JasperHale · 08/03/2022 09:50

Also, nobody seems to care that Ukrainian president is very pro Israel, but doesn't like the same being done to his country. He said in the past that no matter if Israel is right or wrong, Ukraine supports it, and only day or two ago, that Ukraine is like Israel, defends it's own country. So it's ok if Muslims are being murdered in Palestine, but not ok for Ukraine to be invaded by Russia.

Before anyone says anything, I am not Muslim, and none of it is ok, but some deaths are more ok than some others Hmm

KnotKnot · 08/03/2022 09:35

I've not read any of the posts on this thread, and can only reflect on my own perspective. But there is a huge difference in the level of coverage and detail on the Ukraine war compared to what was happening in Syria or Iraq for example. All the coverage I'm exposed to is Putin/Russia=Bad and Ukraine=Good (that would also be my personal point of view too).

For Iraq we were initially fed a consistent message in the press of Iraq=Bad and US/UK=Mostly Good ... that changed over time.

This is classic imperialism. Whatever about what happens in the short term, it looks like Russian/Putin is out to destroy Ukraine as a state and Russify the area. In the past for Russia, it has meant removing/killing the local population and moving in pro-Russian forces and citizens on a large scale.

This is what happen to the ethnic Germans in Eastern Europe after WW2, they were eliminated (of course the Germans planned to do the same to Slavs if they had won the war).

It is exactly we (I'm English) have tried to do in the past in South Africa, Australia, Ireland, etc. I think it is better media coverage today!

emuloc · 08/03/2022 09:21

The Islamophobia being displayed on this thread is disgraceful.

Joinedforthis22 · 08/03/2022 09:14

Since 9/11 we've been fed the idea that Islam is problematic and impossible to coexist with western ideals, despite the face that there are millions of peaceful Muslims just getting in with their lives. It serves those in power well to distract us with this and weakens are sympathy for Muslim countries. I keep thinking about the Iraqi war where we were Russia in the equation, freeing the country from a corrupt government and extremists which is the same reason Russia is giving when realy it was about oil, personal vendetta on Bush part and the fact they wanted to be seen as doing something after 9/11.

OvaHere · 08/03/2022 08:54

I think some of it is about who Putin is too, or what he represents. Unlike leaders from distant continents that many people first hear of when a conflict starts we are very familiar with him.

He's been in power for 22 years and is sort of 'one of us'. By that I mean a western leader who we are used to seeing at global stuff along with all the other familiar leaders of their day.

Even though he has escalated a lot in recent years and has always been the 'dodgy uncle' of the family we should have seen it coming. I think there was a feeling that European leaders who rub shoulders with Merkel, Macron, our own PM etc...just don't do things like invade sovereign countries next door and threaten to start WW3.

The commonalities with the rise of Nazi Germany are there, not saying it's exactly the same but enough so that it feels like something most of us learnt about as history could happen again. I think most of us naively thought something like that would be impossible on our doorstep again.

Sorry if that's not expressed very well, I'm a bit sleep deprived this morning. I just think there are a few factors that have particularly grabbed our attention and shook us out of a complacency that was there before.

BettyBag · 08/03/2022 08:48

@JasperHale

I haven't read all comments, so apologies if anyone has mentioned it before, what about displaying support for other countries in sport? Many teams and players got penalised for showing support to Palestine for example. Now suddenly it's ok, even encouraged to display support for Ukraine. Algeria got banned for 10 years for refusing to play Israel, Poles are heroes to do the same to Russia. Very double standards.
Shit like this drives me mad. I don't give a fuck if people call it whataboutary because asking "what about X?" Is fair enough.
emuloc · 08/03/2022 08:48

[quote ReadtheFT]@emuloc, not sure if you know about the trip those refugees have to make to arrive to a safe country, but sade to say it is not a journey I would do taking my wife and young children and elderly parents with me. It is not so hard to understand that the man would take the dangerous journey woth the hope of having the family join them in a easier way later? Or those refugees are all monsters that hate women, that the way ment posters seem to think.
And lets finish already with the narrative of the "heroic" ukranian men staying back to fight, they are forced to stay.
Not to mention that when other men in other countries stay and fight they are called terrorist.
No, people dont care about refugees from Africa and middle east because they are a different colour and different religion. So many contorsions to try and explain it otherwise, but thats all there is.
A bit more empathy for something happening nearer, sure. But not this level of disgusting double standards and blatant racism , including by reporters.[/quote]
For those posters, who seem unable, or unwilling for whatever reason, to see why some men will be travelling alone. It really is not that hard to understand.

BettyBag · 08/03/2022 08:44

It doesn't sit right with me either op. The boycott thing in particular drives me mad with the hypocrisy, the shit that corporations get up to, particularly in SA and Africa are just gut wrenching yet apparently selling their products in Moscow is a step too far.

Fuck that shit.

Trainbear · 08/03/2022 08:40

Despite all the words and newsprint Britain is only accepting a tiny number of refugee Ukrainians. The channel is still open and very very few of the migrants/asylum seekers/economic migrants etc are being returned.
No evidence of pro Whiteness in access to the UK.

Cheshirecatwoman · 08/03/2022 08:37

@lookforthesun

The people feeling Ukraine are predominantly women, children and the elderly. They are leaving a very active war zone and the men are staying to fight and defend it.

The people arriving on boats from FRANCE are overwhelmingly male, who have left their women and children behind in war zones and are fleeing...well... France.

They are economic migrants and I'm not saying they don't deserve any sympathy but it is a lot less sympathy in most people's minds when you're trying to leave France than when you're trying to leave Ukraine. Especially when they're mainly men and their culture has women so low down the pecking order that they didn't bother to try and bring the women to safety too.

Boat loads of young fit men, leaving women behind to be raped and die in their country or origin.

It's totally different.

Yes that’s exactly how I feel too.

I just don’t feel their situation has the same level of urgency and cannot understand why, if the situation they are leaving is that bad, they would choose to leave their children and wives behind to put up with it. Especially when it could take years to bring them over. And many destroy their passports and documents. Not to mention paying ££s to illegal traffickers, It’s a completely different situation and there is no comparison.

They may be better doing a shorter journey to a neighbouring country instead with their family members and applying for sssylum using the proper channels. People would then probably have more sympathy.

lookforthesun · 08/03/2022 07:21

The people feeling Ukraine are predominantly women, children and the elderly. They are leaving a very active war zone and the men are staying to fight and defend it.

The people arriving on boats from FRANCE are overwhelmingly male, who have left their women and children behind in war zones and are fleeing...well... France.

They are economic migrants and I'm not saying they don't deserve any sympathy but it is a lot less sympathy in most people's minds when you're trying to leave France than when you're trying to leave Ukraine. Especially when they're mainly men and their culture has women so low down the pecking order that they didn't bother to try and bring the women to safety too.

Boat loads of young fit men, leaving women behind to be raped and die in their country or origin.

It's totally different.

bappymonday · 08/03/2022 07:20

@JasperHale

I haven't read all comments, so apologies if anyone has mentioned it before, what about displaying support for other countries in sport? Many teams and players got penalised for showing support to Palestine for example. Now suddenly it's ok, even encouraged to display support for Ukraine. Algeria got banned for 10 years for refusing to play Israel, Poles are heroes to do the same to Russia. Very double standards.

This is an interesting point

Obira · 08/03/2022 07:18

Um because the fighting in Ukraine is literally on the borders of Europe and could easily spill into western countries. Russia is already threatening to fire nukes at us. Of course I’m more concerned when it might affect my own life in my own country. Fighting in the Middle East etc doesn’t affect my everyday life, apart from news reports I don’t even know it’s happening.

Bumpitybumper · 08/03/2022 07:14

I hate the implication of threads like this, that any difference in how we treat people must be due to racism and any arguments to the contrary are seen as pathetic attempts to disguise obvious racism. Racism is a problem, not many will deny that but making everything about race and dismissing other factors is as dangerous as ignoring race.

The UK and Ukraine are both European countries. It makes absolute sense that those countries on the same continent as you would take a greater interest in any conflict and want to help more. In many senses they have a greater obligation to get involved as they are the most obvious sources of support and help and also if the conflict was to grow further then neighbouring countries and those in the same continent are likely to be greatly impacted.

Finally, it generally makes sense that refugees who plan on returning to their own country would like to stay somewhere safe, close to their home country and somewhere that is culturally similar to what they know. That is certainly what I would want if the UK was at war and I had to seek refuge elsewhere. Europe obviously represents this for Ukrainians, but less so for people from other parts of the world where other countries would seem to be a more obvious place of refuge.

thewhatsit · 08/03/2022 07:01

I’m racking my brain trying to think up any other recent conflict that has been so clear cut in terms of Good vs Bad (and not to say Russians are bad but Putin and the ones who orchestrated this are). Everyone rallied around Aung San Suu Kyi because that seemed clear cut.. but then her recent actions suggest otherwise.

thewhatsit · 08/03/2022 06:40

I don’t think it makes you a bad person for being more aware because it is closer to home, in our own continent. I’ve known countless Russian and some Ukrainian people. I hear Russian spoken about five times a day.. it feels very relevant and very here. The Cold War effected all of Europe a lot. So many of my friends are from ex soviet countries and have so much to say about Russia even if they don’t know much about Ukraine.

I also think Zelensky is a HUGE part of why we care so much. If it were one of the previous prime ministers - more corrupt, less pleasant back story - it wouldn’t be so clear who was the good guy vs bad guy. It’s the Russian premise for the invasion - “denatizification” - that makes the whole thing so clearly good vs bad because it’s so clearly bullshit. That and the troops now imposing martial law in Russia, going through people’s phones to see if they’ve discussed Ukraine …

If we look at Syria - we hated ISIS but Assad was also terrible so what did we want? What was the good outcome? I know there were some pro democracy smaller factions but there was no realistic chance of them winning. What we wanted to happen was a pipe dream and would have involved huge western interference in a country (also bad in the eyes of many / most) and might have been misguided anyway.

Afghanistan - again, I am appalled by the actions of the Taliban but the previous government didn’t have enough support of the people and there was a lot of corruption. It was only upheld by US forces anyway. Again.. it’s a disaster and it makes me sad but there is no clear answer there.

JasperHale · 08/03/2022 06:33

I haven't read all comments, so apologies if anyone has mentioned it before, what about displaying support for other countries in sport? Many teams and players got penalised for showing support to Palestine for example. Now suddenly it's ok, even encouraged to display support for Ukraine. Algeria got banned for 10 years for refusing to play Israel, Poles are heroes to do the same to Russia. Very double standards.

Aishah231 · 08/03/2022 06:19

I think the difference OP is that our government's and/or our allies are the ones bombing or invading countries in the middles east etc. Plus clearly a racial element. Plus geopolitics. To hear US politicians who were behind the invasion of Iraq criticise Putin for invading a sovereign country is mind blowing. Do they not have any powers of self reflection .

Ladylornax12 · 08/03/2022 06:11

It’s relating to the people and their way of life it’s not about skin color. I remember the thread where people were aghast at people selling their daughters to survive for example. It’s unthinkable in our culture and so far removed from our way of life that it’s hard to see ourselves in these people. The whole culture is so different.It’s not right and everyone deserves compassion but it’s human nature to put ourselves in the position and have sympathy for those we can see could be us.

Swipe left for the next trending thread