Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Compassion & media coverage towards Ukraine but not the Middle East/Africa

263 replies

babyhaha · 07/03/2022 18:40

This is something that has been on my mind for a little while so hopefully I'm able to word it correctly.

Since the invasion in Ukraine there has been constant threads about this on MN. This is also something that is constantly spoken about and written about in the media as it rightly should be. This is a major thing that's going on and people should obviously be informed about this.

However, why is this not the case when there's constant wars happening in the Middle East and Africa? Iraq, Palastine, Syria, Sudan, Afghanistan etc the list really does go on. There's still innocent people in these countries that are getting killed for no reason. Now I've personally never seen threads about these countries on MN but as I don't spend too much time I'm on here, I could be wrong. What I am certain about, is these countries BARELY get any media attention from the West, if ever at all. Why is that?!

Is this because Ukraine is a European country and not a third world country where things like these are 'expected to happen?' Do people feel that as the people in these countries are minorities that they don't deserve the same sort of empathy that the Ukrainians are getting? I really am interested to know why there's such a massive difference in terms of media coverage and general compassion.

It's actually interesting because just a few days ago, supermodel Bella Hadid stated that Muslim suffering deserves the same level of outrage as Ukraine and she is absolutely right. And to those who may say I'm exaggerating or this isn't the case, I've linked a Twitter thread below which has clips of the most racist Ukraine coverage on TV and the wording used in each and every clip is very telling. I'd be very interested in hearing people's thoughts.

twitter.com/alanrmacleod/status/1497974245737050120?s=21

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fritilleries · 14/03/2022 13:06

[quote Tillsforthrills]@Fritilleries

Did you see that the pregnant lady pictured in the media a few days ago on a stretcher has now died? Screaming in agony and begging “Kill me now” when she realised she was losing her baby. Your comment is crass. Any pregnant woman in those kind of situations regardless of colour garners sympathy.[/quote]
I fear you missed the sarcasm within my initial point. That poor woman and baby, regardless of who they are, should never have died. My point is that the government is clamouring over themselves to 'help" when there are already hundreds and thousands of displaced and lost people who also need help. It's the "optics" that stink. Nobody wins. It is utterly gut wrenching how awful people can be.

Ghostmooncup · 14/03/2022 13:02

There is more to this than the colour of people's skin.

Ukraine is in Europe- demographically close to the UK and central Europe than other war torn countries. If the invasion of Ukraine is successful, then who is next? Poland? Which leads me onto.....

The huge history of ww2. My grandparents were part of that and we learn so much about it in school, celebrate remembrance day. Never again - has happened again.

I will hold my hands up and say my knowledge of the middle East is poor and it has been volatile for as long as my memory serves. I do not know the political history of that area like Europe.

Afghanistan was shocking and I feel for the people there greatly.

The Ukraine invasion feels like the next in a series of destabilising global events with a potential huge knock on effect on the world and the potential to blow up into ww3 with nuclear weapons.

Tillsforthrills · 14/03/2022 11:37

@Fritilleries

Did you see that the pregnant lady pictured in the media a few days ago on a stretcher has now died? Screaming in agony and begging “Kill me now” when she realised she was losing her baby. Your comment is crass. Any pregnant woman in those kind of situations regardless of colour garners sympathy.

Trainbear · 13/03/2022 12:37

A lot of people were sympathetic to the plight of the Syrians. With a dictator president clinging onto power, an apparently varied group of resistance varying from liberals who would like a more western style of governance to Daesh wanting a premedieval theocracy it is easy to feel for the plight. But a large number of those who claimed to be Syrian have been proven to be Iranians, Pakistanis, and from a myriad of African counties pretending to be Syrians or Iraqis to take advantage of western feeling. As the west has a much higher proportion of white people this is racist.
Syria is an ongoing tragedy. We did not get involved partly due to Russian and Chinese government support for Assad, and partly due to the clamour against western intervention in Iraq and Afghanistan, but non intervention in Syria did not stop the critisim from the same people who critisised intervention.

MagnoliaXYZ · 13/03/2022 10:22

I do think the fact that more men (or at least according to the media, I haven't seen the statistics myself) have come over as refugees in the past does garner less sympathy. OP, your comment about maybe the family have decided that they should come over and send money back home - to me, that makes them a migrant wanting to come to the UK for financial reasons, not a refugee or asylum seeker, and there are proper channels for applying to migrate here. Able-bodied young men, particularly those coming from places where women are treated as second-class citizens, should be the ones staying behind, defending their family and their country.

Wars and conflict seem commonplace in Africa and the Middle East. I was 15, I think, when the UK went to war in Afghanistan and the problems there don't seem to have stopped since. An issue that has been going on for 20 years no longer feels like news. But a war happening on European soil is news. It is also far more likely to impact on us, both as a nation and on an individual level, than something which is happening on a different continent.

Geographically, we are much closer to Ukraine than we are to African and Middle Eastern countries. In any conflict, I would expect the nearby countries to have a moral duty and an obligation to take in refugees first, and that would likely amount to a greater interest in the issue.

Fritilleries · 13/03/2022 07:57

Basically.... people are racist. The thought of a white woman and child is more appealing than some lone male that has clung to a dinghy. Basically, the world is going to hell in a handcart and this is the beginning.

Tillsforthrills · 10/03/2022 10:47

@Lovingeveryrainbow @emuloc

Can we have some examples of Islamophobia on this thread? I haven’t read through it all but would like to see exactly what you’re referring to.

Polyanthus2 · 10/03/2022 07:09

Self preservation - you can't be beating yourself up about the tragedies in the world constantly - I'm old - there have ALWAYS been wars, in fact I would say there have always been wars somehwere in the world during my lifetime without a break. So 6 decades. Should I be jumping off the nearest cliff.
Russia has nuclear bombs - other wars didn't - that is focussing minds.

Tillsforthrills · 10/03/2022 06:35

Can we have some examples of Islamophobia on this thread? I haven’t read through it all but would like to see them.

Lovingeveryrainbow · 09/03/2022 16:08

@Sinuhe

Don't forget about the situation in Myanmar... someone is getting away with nass murder at the moment. Or the situation of the Turkish kurds... anyone?

These threads make me so cross. There is one group accusing an other about ignorance. In reality the world is full of conflicts and unless the country or area has a catchy name, valuable resources or harbours so called terrorists nobody gives a damm shit.
Or, just a thought, maybe people on these threads lobby for their own people. Which makes them no better than the ones they accuse of racism and ignorance.

Actually that is what some of us are saying - that all people are deserving of the gushing and empathy that Ukrainians refugees have received. The pain of refugees is universal. But it's clear not many of us feel that way.

For me this isn't a lobbying instance. Anyone who has fled war, lost livelihoods and potentially family members has my full empathy and support.

It's just becoming more and more obvious, that I would not have theirs. Not surprising but sad nonetheless.

Sinuhe · 09/03/2022 11:47

Don't forget about the situation in Myanmar... someone is getting away with nass murder at the moment.

Or the situation of the Turkish kurds... anyone?

These threads make me so cross. There is one group accusing an other about ignorance. In reality the world is full of conflicts and unless the country or area has a catchy name, valuable resources or harbours so called terrorists nobody gives a damm shit.
Or, just a thought, maybe people on these threads lobby for their own people. Which makes them no better than the ones they accuse of racism and ignorance.

FluffyBooBoo · 09/03/2022 10:40

I wonder how much media attention the Middle East and Africa gave to the Falklands war, or the conflict between Ecuador and Peru in the mid 90's.

Lovingeveryrainbow · 09/03/2022 10:29

@emuloc

The Islamophobia being displayed on this thread is disgraceful.
It’s shocking. People are really telling on themselves.
FloBot7 · 08/03/2022 19:42

@lonelyapple

How many Ukrainian refugees are the rich Arab states taking in? What about other rich countries like Japan? The UK has taken tens of thousands if not hundreds of thousands of refugees over the years, mostly from the Middle East and Africa. Compare that to other rich countries that take hardly any and I think you'll find there is a lot of generosity and support from the UK given to people fleeing war in the Middle East/Africa. It's never good enough though is it!
Most Arab states refuse to acknowledge refugee status. I think other countries signed up to a UN charter which most Arab states didn't. The two exceptions I can think of are Jordan and Lebanon. The latter dealing with its own internal conflicts is not the safe haven most refugees are searching for.
botanicalart · 08/03/2022 19:37

Please see the movie The Kashmir FIles.
While it is a movie it is based on true events. It gave me a completely different understanding of some of the things discussed on this thread. I am so confused. Would like to discuss this further if anyone is interested

thecatsthecats · 08/03/2022 19:26

It's not new or clever to observe that we're more likely to respond to events that are closer to us and more likely to affect us directly and to people who are more like us. It's entirely normal behaviour for human beings.

Our minds simply aren't designed to perfectly contextualise and feel the exact "fair" degree of sympathy for all of them.

(for reference, my research specialism is comparative studies of global responses to genocide)

madbadrad · 08/03/2022 19:16

I think it's predominantly three things

They are geographically closer to us and part of Europe. It's human nature to feel more impacted by things that are happening closer to home.

People are able to understand it, it's a war of aggression rather than a complex civil war.

It's primarily women and children.

ReadtheFT · 08/03/2022 19:04

So what about the israel situation, thats not hundreds of years ago. It is ongoing. Condemn by international bodies, human right violations, aphartheid state etc etc.
Yet football players not allowed to side with Gaza, for example. How is this different from the russia/ukraine situation?

Trainbear · 08/03/2022 18:56

@Brainwave89

As a person of colour I can see the perspective that some of the commentary (notably from US correspondents) does seem to regard Ukraine as a more important conflict as those impacted are white. However, generally most refugees stay close to home, so they flee to next door countries. Which is exactly what you see happening in Ukraine. My family is Tamil by origin and during the Tamil conflict most displaced people went to India, with quite some numbers coming to the UK and the USA. In practice the UK does take quite large numbers of refugees, and did from the war in Sri Lanka and it is reasonable that it takes more from a European conflict than from a Middle Eastern or African conflict. It is closer geographically and culturally to the UK. it also took quite large numbers of Kosovan refugees during the war in this region and Bosnian refugees as well.
Absolutely. And the Hong Kong And Vietnamese refugees in the 1970s and HK residents today. Unfortunately there are a number of Grievance Moaners who would love to stir up racism.
Trainbear · 08/03/2022 18:53

@KnotKnot

I've not read any of the posts on this thread, and can only reflect on my own perspective. But there is a huge difference in the level of coverage and detail on the Ukraine war compared to what was happening in Syria or Iraq for example. All the coverage I'm exposed to is Putin/Russia=Bad and Ukraine=Good (that would also be my personal point of view too).

For Iraq we were initially fed a consistent message in the press of Iraq=Bad and US/UK=Mostly Good ... that changed over time.

This is classic imperialism. Whatever about what happens in the short term, it looks like Russian/Putin is out to destroy Ukraine as a state and Russify the area. In the past for Russia, it has meant removing/killing the local population and moving in pro-Russian forces and citizens on a large scale.

This is what happen to the ethnic Germans in Eastern Europe after WW2, they were eliminated (of course the Germans planned to do the same to Slavs if they had won the war).

It is exactly we (I'm English) have tried to do in the past in South Africa, Australia, Ireland, etc. I think it is better media coverage today!

Yes, several hundred years ago. Or is it the sins of the fathers and seven generations onwards?
samyeagar · 08/03/2022 15:30

When it comes to the Middle East and Africa, there is a certain amount of fatigue regarding coverage, and awareness that has nothing to do with race. Those regions are, and have been in a perpetual state of famine and warfare for as long as anyone can remember. Status Quo is generally not news.

MangyInseam · 08/03/2022 14:07

I do kind of which the sport stuff would stop. Either we make international sport above political differences, or not, and in the latter case we should apply it a lot more widely.

MangyInseam · 08/03/2022 14:05

@AledsiPad

Sick to death of hearing this. There has been just as much compassion for refugees from Syria/Afghanistan/Whatever.

The difference is quite clear - the threat of NATO Vs Russia to the wider world. If people can't get their head round that then what's the point in arguing.

There is such desperation to find racism where it isn't. Must be fucking exhausting tbh.

Yeah, I agree with this actually. Overall I saw huge support for Syrian refugees.

There is often less support, or maybe better to say different support, for economic migrants.

And there are reasons for that. There are solid reasons economic migrants are not normally considered refugees, even when people are very sympathetic. There is just no way any western country, even a very wealthy one, is in a position to accept every person who might want to come to seek their fortune. It's not just about whether such people would contribute to society either, it's a lot more to do with material infrastructure, and also the infrastructure of community life. Both of which are required to welcome newcomers.

MangyInseam · 08/03/2022 13:52

I think there are a lot of elements to this.

Part of it is that with some places, there has been political and social breakdown for so long that they are in a constant state of war. And no one really knows what to do about it that would work or be sustainable long term.

People feel badly for those caught up in it and want to help them, But there is no shock or surprise when things are bad in a place where there is already so many problems, be they ongoing warfare, corruption, famine, tribalism, gangs, whatever. We expect war under those circumstances.

It also fits in well to the sense that there is one "side" being bad to another "side" which is blameless.

Ukraine is different in that many people see them as having stable lifestyles they imagine are much like their own. And so they can picture what it would be like to suddenly have to pick up from their regular lives and have to run or fight. I think additionally it is a wake up call or some that the stability they thought Europe had is a lot more tenuous than they realized.

lonelyapple · 08/03/2022 13:33

How many Ukrainian refugees are the rich Arab states taking in? What about other rich countries like Japan? The UK has taken tens of thousands if not hundreds of thousands of refugees over the years, mostly from the Middle East and Africa. Compare that to other rich countries that take hardly any and I think you'll find there is a lot of generosity and support from the UK given to people fleeing war in the Middle East/Africa. It's never good enough though is it!