Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you don't say this to a child!

494 replies

UndertheCedartree · 07/03/2022 17:20

I spoke to the doctor this afternoon about my DD who has Long Covid. He wants to do a blood test to rule out any other causes of the symptoms.

I am separated from her dad but he was over at my house after picking her up from school. I spoke to DD alone about the blood test. She burst into tears but I explained they can put numbing cream on your skin so it shouldn't be too painful and promised her a muffin from the cafe. Along with a cuddle she calmed down. We came downstairs and I told her dad she needed a blood test. His response was 'Oh, I bet you're not looking forward to that!' at which point she burst into tears again! I don't understand why he can't think before he speaks!!

OP posts:
mummykel16 · 07/03/2022 20:27

@BuyDirt

Instead he was left downstairs while the conversation took place and then told just as a highly sensitive child was calming down and expected to have the perfect response!

He just needed to say anything which didn’t make it sound like it was something to worry about. Anything! He could have just said ‘ok’ when told about the blood test. But to be honest he should have said something reassuring knowing his daughter struggles with these things.

Her mom made her cry too, how is she any better?
Norgie · 07/03/2022 20:26

You both sound like a pair of drama llamas.
She's having a blood test, not brain surgery.
When my youngest was in and out of hospital as a child and having cannulas stuck in the back of her hand all the time, there wasn't any of this ridiculous drama.

NinaDefoe · 07/03/2022 20:26

Your OP asked if what he said was wrong.
No, not really. Saying something like ‘I bet you’re not looking forward to that!’ is a sympathetic rather than goady comment I think.

Anyway, your following posts have revealed that she is sensitive, with sensitive skin and possibly Autistic.
Maybe you need to inform her Dad of this.

Whinge · 07/03/2022 20:25

Op sorry if i've missed it, but what response would have been acceptable to you?

You bought up that she neede a blood test

He was put on the spot and you didn't like what he said

So what should he have said? Confused

BuyDirt · 07/03/2022 20:25

Do children with anxiety have anxiety because their parents make a huge deal out of every tiny throw away comment and prepare them for "big events" like a blood test? I have had countless blood tests and it's a tiny prick in your arm with "pain" that lasts about 10 seconds if that. It's not something to build up as a massive painful experience. It's almost a non-event

Not in our case, no. We always play everything down. Our first child didn’t worry about anything. Still doesn’t whether that’s medical tests, exams, public speaking, nothing has ever bothered him. It was quite a shock that our second child was/is so different. She’s lovely though, yes she’s sensitive and can get anxious but she is the most caring teenager.

AlternativePerspective · 07/03/2022 20:24

Good god what a load of drama.

By going on about spray and how she will get muffins and cuddles etc you are teaching that a blood test is something to be over sensitive about.

Your child is being so over sensitive because you’re pandering to it. Tears and drama get rewards and cuddles, the more you promise her, the more likely it is she is going to burst into tears at something which is generally completely innocuous.

And if she’s never had one before she doesn’t know if it’s going to hurt, that idea has come from you.

no wonder there are so many anxious children these days.

UndertheCedartree · 07/03/2022 20:23

@ThanksItHasPockets

It was clearly the wrong thing to say to your child but it would have been a perfectly empathetic thing to say to most children. It validates their understandable feelings while using a touch of litotes to to lighten the situation.
That's my point. He should know not to say that to his child.
OP posts:
HeadacheGrey · 07/03/2022 20:23

But it doesn't matter if my responses aren't the most helpful for helping someone else's anxiety! They are helpful for my DD and that's all that matters!

If you believe you are so right and your ex is so wrong, why start this thread? You know 81% on here think YABU, don’t you? 😂

UndertheCedartree · 07/03/2022 20:22

@fallfallfall

“Scared her to death” how melodramatic.
Do you know what - I was told that as a child. My experiences were always invalidated. I've had to have a lot of therapy to deal with that trauma. We don't all feel the same thing. Some of us feel things more.
OP posts:
Springhassprung86 · 07/03/2022 20:22

What do you mean she has sensitive skin and more likely to hurt? Is this an actual medically diagnosed condition?? Confused

kittensinthekitchen · 07/03/2022 20:21

@XelaM

Do children with anxiety have anxiety because their parents make a huge deal out of every tiny throw away comment and prepare them for "big events" like a blood test? I have had countless blood tests and it's a tiny prick in your arm with "pain" that lasts about 10 seconds if that. It's not something to build up as a massive painful experience. It's almost a non-event
🙄🙄
OmgIThinkILikeYou · 07/03/2022 20:21

Why on earth did you calm her down, walk downstairs then bring it all back up again? Really if she was that scared and upset, you wouldn't have announced it again infront of her after coming up with the plan and reassuring her. I think it sounds a bit like you set him up to be a bad guy. You have already said this is the sort of thing he often does/says.

Peraonally I think you ex has just agreed it wasn't the best and he didnt think because he can't be bothered with the over the top back and forth that would inevitably come from disagreeing.

UndertheCedartree · 07/03/2022 20:20

@Prettynails

I don’t tell any of mine until an hour before if even that much and they are older. Seems a slight over reaction to rant on here as it is a typical comment anyone could make who isn’t empathetic might make * insert grandparent etc
He's her dad so should be empathetic to her!
OP posts:
Iamaneggman · 07/03/2022 20:20

There is a lot of evidence that children are very suggestible and that we should not use any negative influencing words around procedures. Rather, let children decide for themselves what the experience is. So instead of saying scratch say you make feel something now. Or tell me what you feel. Or you may get a fizzy sensation. Essentially let children work things out for themselves or offer positive sensations that they can compare to.

Springhassprung86 · 07/03/2022 20:20

Sorry OP but I think YABU. This coupled with your previous threat about your daughter not being sent home from school makes you come across as a bit precious and over sensitive about your daughter. I think you should be helping her build resilience, you have her wrapped in cotton wool and it won’t do her any favours.

XelaM · 07/03/2022 20:19

Do children with anxiety have anxiety because their parents make a huge deal out of every tiny throw away comment and prepare them for "big events" like a blood test? I have had countless blood tests and it's a tiny prick in your arm with "pain" that lasts about 10 seconds if that. It's not something to build up as a massive painful experience. It's almost a non-event

Tee20x · 07/03/2022 20:19

Stating that someone won't enjoy something isn't malicious? Who enjoys blood tests? No one. It's not as if he said "god your arm might fall off so prepare yourself" - simply commenting on the fact that she won't enjoy it is fine.

I think you on the other hand have built it up to be something way more scary - cuddles muffins etc? That's making it seem like the blood test is really traumatic and needs special treatment to get over when that's really not the case.

Like others have said best way to deal with these things is just to be matter of fact about them and not make a song and dance about it.

UndertheCedartree · 07/03/2022 20:19

@Roselilly36

Only certain nurses can perform blood tests on u16’s at my GP practice, my DS had one when he was young, it was absolutely fine, didn’t hurt and was over before you knew it. He was quite interested/fascinated by it at the time tbh. The nurse said are you worried, he said no, I have been looking forward to it 😂 took her by surprise I can tell you.
Ah, bless him!
OP posts:
nitsandwormsdodger · 07/03/2022 20:19

You both made her cry
Nothing too wrong with what he said- what he said in hospital was unforgivable so maybe your still angry / upset from that ?

She needs bit more resilience can I recommend Claire baldings book

Mocara · 07/03/2022 20:18

You gave her the idea that it would be painful !!! What a load of bloody nonsense !!! "pain " 😂 well god help her when she gets a splinter ,bumps her knee or god forbid she breaks a nail , she'll need flamin therapy .

UndertheCedartree · 07/03/2022 20:18

@WorraLiberty

I don't think your partner should have mentioned to her that it was going to hurt so I do think he's unreasonable there.

He didn't, did he?

Apologies if I missed the OP adding that bit.

He didn't specifically say that but that was what it made her think. In hindsight he realised.
OP posts:
BuyDirt · 07/03/2022 20:18

Fascinating…..

I was correcting something in my previous post, I missed the word ‘son’ out.

BuyDirt · 07/03/2022 20:17

OP gave her child the basic facts, and calmed her down with the promise of a nice cake afterwards. The dads comment made his child think it was something she should dread due to the sarcasm used. There’s a world of difference.

UndertheCedartree · 07/03/2022 20:16

@willithappen

As someone who was/is terrified of getting blood taken I don't think you should have told her so far in advance to 'prepare' her. The longer you know about it the longer you have to overthink and work yourself up about it. Over thinking it all is what causes me an anxiety attack over it where I pretty much faint and it's purely because of thinking too much beforehand and expecting the worst.

I don't think your partner should have mentioned to her that it was going to hurt so I do think he's unreasonable there. Not a good reaction from dad. Probably something like 'it will be okay'

However I do think BOTH of your responds to her were unreasonable and telling her it will hurt. For all you know it may not hurt her at all. Just because you find them painful doesn't mean she will. You can try prepare her all you like but until you know how she handles it I don't think you can prepare for it to hurt, just prepare her of what will actually happen.

She has sensitive skin so more likely to hurt. I did just say it might hurt a little. She needs the time to process it as it takes her time to get her head round something. If I told her tomorrow morning she would have panicked and it would have been very unlikely I would have got her to the hospital.
OP posts:
HoneyItIsntGoodLuck · 07/03/2022 20:16

@BuyDirt

my son would have been fine
Fascinating…..
Swipe left for the next trending thread