Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance issue AIBU

118 replies

BeanCart · 07/03/2022 13:18

Married to my husband who has two children aged 9 and 12 and we have one 2 year old together.

My step children live with us 3 nights a week and he pays £300 a month via a private agreement not calculator. This is nearly £150 a month more than the calculator amount although I appreciate those calculations are not typically enough.

Anyway, to my question...

I'm the higher earner, I earn quite a lot more than my husband as I am fortunately pretty successfully self employed however I like to save a lot. Especially due to not having an official pension through an employer.

My husband's ex works part time in the NHS and has told him that she's struggling and is worrying about the increase in bills and things coming up.

Unfortunately he would struggle to give more whilst still contributing fairly to our home (I already pay more toward our home and bills due to the difference in earning).

I'm receiving pressure from my husband via his ex to help with this. He is a little bit spineless when it comes to his ex and often just agrees to things for an easier life.

I really do not want to do this. Our own bills will be increasing substantially as with everyone and it's important to me that I have some spare available to save.

AIBU to say no?

OP posts:
Cantleave · 07/03/2022 16:33

I think he is being very fair as it is. On top of what he is giving her, she will also be getting just over £35 a week in Child Benefit. That on top of the £300 a month he gives her, means she is getting an average of just over £450 extra per month, for having the children one more night a week than your dh looks after them.

Reading your last update, rather than thinking her ex (via you) should up his payments, maybe her own partner could be putting more into the pot?

ToryRussians · 07/03/2022 16:29

Can he earn more money then??

Ellie56 · 07/03/2022 16:24

YANBU OP. It is not for you to subsidise the Ex's household and the new family. Your husband already pays more than the going rate for his children and they live with you for nearly half the week.

Ex and her DP need to sort their own financial problems out. Like PP have said she could increase her working hours.

Quitelikeit · 07/03/2022 16:18

Why is she making her problems your problems? Oh that’s easy because your dp already pays her extra and she knows he might bend.

The fact that she works part time and has three kids means she’ll be getting plenty too ups not to mention maintenance from two different fathers.

She is a chancer.

Marmight · 07/03/2022 16:17

I know that this isn't the main point of your OP but...
You need to save into a pension to take advantages of the tax breaks.
ISA's and other types of savings do not attract tax relief when paying in.
You are literally losing money before you even start.

OfstedOffred · 07/03/2022 16:16

It was her choice to have the 3 year old.if as a result she is struggling to work FT and her family budget is tight it sounds like the 3 yo's father needs to step up.

Tomnooktoldmeto · 07/03/2022 16:08

Presumably she’s working part time because like the op she has a younger child in her family set up and childcare for her new partners child costs too much

However, Thats down to her new partner to financially support not the op’s family who are financially supporting their own third child

BeanCart · 07/03/2022 16:05

@CityHigh

How old is her other child OP? Is that the main reason why she doesn’t work full time? I can understand that it could be harder for her to work young time with a small child but I don’t think you or your DP should be paying more for that choice, especially when he’s already paying double what he has to. If she’s choosing not to work full time because she has a small child with her new DP then I think that’s something he should be contributing more to not your family.
It may well be, they are about 3.

As you say though, not sure how that becomes our problem!

OP posts:
CityHigh · 07/03/2022 16:01

How old is her other child OP? Is that the main reason why she doesn’t work full time? I can understand that it could be harder for her to work young time with a small child but I don’t think you or your DP should be paying more for that choice, especially when he’s already paying double what he has to. If she’s choosing not to work full time because she has a small child with her new DP then I think that’s something he should be contributing more to not your family.

Everafter20 · 07/03/2022 15:59

I didn't state a fact I said 'which could mean'. If I was making it up I would of said they have nice cars.

SparrowLand · 07/03/2022 15:58

@Everafter20 Also missing where I insulted you? Telling you that you sound ridiculous, when you do, is not an insult.

CityHigh · 07/03/2022 15:57

@Everafter20

Actually she didn't say he couldn't afford it she said he couldn't equally contribute to the household out goings of a high earner which could mean they lead a lovely comfortable life and have nice cars, holidays and are able to save. Maybe he should get a better job then by your reasoning Wink
Why should he have to? Who has mentioned nice cars and holidays? You are just making things up.
vampirewellness · 07/03/2022 15:56

Hmm. She definitely needs to at least start considering working more hours.

What dies she plan to do when the kids are out of education and he won't be paying maintenance any more?

SparrowLand · 07/03/2022 15:56

@Everafter20

Sparrow land I don't need to lower myself to insults like you. I have clearly asked people to consider her position without the other issues at play in these circumstances. If it was a male or a female I would be saying the same. It helps to read all the posts as you would of seen I work with single parent families and helping with their income so please don't make this about a male female argument as it is not relevant.
She isn’t a single parent family so that point is completely null. She has a partner who she has another child with.
Neenawneenaw76 · 07/03/2022 15:54

Nope, not your problem.

Everafter20 · 07/03/2022 15:53

Sparrow land I don't need to lower myself to insults like you. I have clearly asked people to consider her position without the other issues at play in these circumstances. If it was a male or a female I would be saying the same. It helps to read all the posts as you would of seen I work with single parent families and helping with their income so please don't make this about a male female argument as it is not relevant.

lanthanum · 07/03/2022 15:50

It obviously depends on distance/logistics, but could you offer to have them a little more but without any more overnights, so that she doesn't feel she's losing her role as the primary carer? It might be that if you could have them after school just until she finishes work, that would enable her to increase her hours.

Inkyblue123 · 07/03/2022 15:50

It’s not your responsibility, but it is his.

SparrowLand · 07/03/2022 15:45

@Everafter20

Oh god ok she is a lazy mare who could be earning a fortune working full time but prefers to plead her case to the ex partner Grin you win Wink
Who said that? Obviously he should be handing all of his money to her then because he’s the man even though he has them four days less a month than 50% and she refuses 50/50 contact (obviously because she would lose the maintenance). He already pays double what he has to, but obviously that’s not enough. You sound ridiculous.
GlitteryGreen · 07/03/2022 15:42

Why should he have to get a better job when he's currently able to pay his share AND pay double child support?! 😩 I just can't understand your reasoning at all.

He just can't afford to increase it to support his ex more.

I'd get it if he was just having the kids every other weekend and she was restricted by that, but it's not the case.

Everafter20 · 07/03/2022 15:41

Oh god ok she is a lazy mare who could be earning a fortune working full time but prefers to plead her case to the ex partner Grin you win Wink

Blossom64265 · 07/03/2022 15:40

If she is working part time because she facilitates more of the children’s lives, school runs, sick days, school breaks, etc, then I do think he has a moral obligation to step up. Could she switch to full time work tomorrow with no need for additional child care or for the father to share more of the burden?

GlitteryGreen · 07/03/2022 15:39

@Everafter20

Actually she didn't say he couldn't afford it she said he couldn't equally contribute to the household out goings of a high earner which could mean they lead a lovely comfortable life and have nice cars, holidays and are able to save. Maybe he should get a better job then by your reasoning Wink
Where have nice holidays and cars come from? OP hasn't mentioned that at all.

She did say he couldn't afford it because he can't afford it whilst still paying his share of the bills. The only way he could afford it is for OP to pay more of his share, when she is already paying more than him.

Why should she have to do that? Especially as OP has now confirmed mum also has a partner to share her bills with too!

SparrowLand · 07/03/2022 15:34

@Everafter20

Oh great idea I hadn't thought of that! Are you not listening she could be worse off working full time even with some days help with childcare. That's the life of a single wage with today's rent/bills. She probably only survives because of tax credits or uc which restrict the hours worked.
If she upped her hours then she wouldn’t need to rely on UC/tax credits. They have restrictions but unless there’s other circumstances listed then you’re always better off working more when you’re on them. Working part time when your youngest is 9 years old and they have an involved Dad who has them almost 50% of the time is a luxury.
Everafter20 · 07/03/2022 15:32

Actually she didn't say he couldn't afford it she said he couldn't equally contribute to the household out goings of a high earner which could mean they lead a lovely comfortable life and have nice cars, holidays and are able to save. Maybe he should get a better job then by your reasoning Wink

Swipe left for the next trending thread