Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Electric cars

93 replies

veevee04 · 07/03/2022 12:38

With the price of petrol going up I've been looking at upgrading to an electric car I only have a 1 litre engine so very cheap to run compared to some. I can't get over the cost !! Even basic ones with an ok range are very very expensive. I'm now looking at hybrid cars which seem to be a bit cheaper than EVs I'm wondering what will happen when production of petrol/diesel cars are banned will everyone eventually have to lease a car ? Many lower paid jobs rely on having access to transport, nurses for example.

OP posts:
Blueuggboots · 10/03/2022 13:35

Both me and my partner use it. We've done 15,000 miles since we bought it. I reckon it's saved us at least £600/month on fuel.

Blueuggboots · 10/03/2022 13:35

I've got a Hyundai ioniq. It does about 125 miles to a charge in the winter (climbs to about 155 in the summer) and it costs me £4.50 to charge it from about 40% to full overnight on a cheaper tariff.
To charge it at a street fast charger is about £8.00.

Doublechocolatetiffin · 10/03/2022 13:19

Cost of charging from empty is the battery size in kwh x unit price of electricity. So my Tesla with a 75kwh battery (which does around 200 miles) will cost 75 x 28p to charge from empty to full so £18.75.

SpecialDay · 10/03/2022 13:14

@twinsetandpearl

I'm in need of a second car - for those that have EV how much is the cost to charge it at home say particularly given the current cost of electricity?

Ours would be for short local journeys only really - school / childcare runs etc

@twinsetandpearl it really depends on your night time tariff, how much you charge, the kw available at your home and of course the EV model and battery size etc etc. there are some online calculators which estimate (try ZapMap).

As a guide - when I used my parents driveway to charge our Renault Zoe overnight we calculated it cost around £5 to top the car up to about 50%. But it is sloooow.

Most people don't tend to charge up to 100% at home as that would take hours, but just keep it topped up enough for their commute or school run. Presumably your school run is pretty close so you wouldn't be needing a full capacity each morning (in our case roughly 230 miles). The faster or rapid chargers you get out in the street or at garages, service stations and shops can be up to 150 times faster so often that's far easier. Eg I have a shopping centre I visit where the rapid charger takes 90 minutes to give me a full battery if I am down to below 10%. Also a favourite pub car park where we go for Sunday lunch and top up to full while we are there!

We don't have a driveway but we get free charging out and about through our car lease service so we don't pay to charge. Have a look at ONTO if you are interested.

DuchessofAnkh22 · 10/03/2022 13:02

@twinsetandpearl

I'm in need of a second car - for those that have EV how much is the cost to charge it at home say particularly given the current cost of electricity?

Ours would be for short local journeys only really - school / childcare runs etc

If you have something like an older Nissan Leaf it has a 24 or 30 KWh battery. Take electricity cost and multiply, remember that is for a FULL charge (0 to 100%). Mostly it'll be (say) 25p * 20kwh = £5.00 which will get you about 80-100 miles.
DuchessofAnkh22 · 10/03/2022 12:59

@Pedallleur

prices will come down but dont believe it will cheap motoring. Insurance on eg tesla is high apparently and one the Govt revenue on petrol starts falling electric cars will be charged (see what I did there?) accordingly. Road pricing is the dream option but a tax/additional charge on the electricity could be an option
Insurance on a Tesla is no different to any other car - it was cheaper than my existing Ford.

And you have to remember EV owners are saving now so no road tax, no company car tax (it's 1% vs 25-37%), no congestion charge, no ULEZ charges etc etc. yes things will change in the future but it's mighty cheap now...

Pedallleur · 10/03/2022 11:12

prices will come down but dont believe it will cheap motoring. Insurance on eg tesla is high apparently and one the Govt revenue on petrol starts falling electric cars will be charged (see what I did there?) accordingly. Road pricing is the dream option but a tax/additional charge on the electricity could be an option

twinsetandpearl · 10/03/2022 11:06

I'm in need of a second car - for those that have EV how much is the cost to charge it at home say particularly given the current cost of electricity?

Ours would be for short local journeys only really - school / childcare runs etc

etulosba · 10/03/2022 10:52

Aye but it's software so is a separate issue to comparing the ICE with an electric motor.

Some issues may be software, but not all. Tesla, in particular, has had issues with hardware. More established motor manufacturers seem to suffer less.

They are reporting and comparing faults in EV's that are resolved with a quick reboot (you know like a phone or pc or any other electronic equipment!) with a full garage visit for a petrol vehicle.

That may be true, but owners still lost the use of the car for an average five days a year compared to three for petrol vehicles.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 10/03/2022 10:17

Of course they will change. But changes haven't previously affected already bought cars. Like in the example I gave in my previous post.
Yes they have, the 2003 changes were retrospectively applied to vehicles previously registered from 2001 onwards. That made many vehicles almost unsaleable overnight.
The current consultation (and previous ones) have suggested retrospectively applied changes. You really can't trust government/treasury not to do this.

Lunar27 · 10/03/2022 10:09

@Kazzyhoward.

The negative points you raise are really quite common and repeated by so many people on various forums. I've no doubt that the government will eventually look to recoup taxes but not whilst the number of ICE cars far outweigh the number of EV's (I think EV's account for less than 5% of cars on UK roads). The amount of people dragging their heels or making up reasons for not buying or hating EV's is only going to keep numbers low, which will keep running costs low for the foreseeable future.

But let's assume that costs will suddenly rise in two years time. How does that negate the savings already made by all those who have taken the plunge? I've owned an EV for three years and have saved a small fortune. Some have owned EVs for ten years. Even someone getting a company car will save a fortune on BIK so don't think they'll be too bothered about costs going back up in the future.

DuchessofAnkh22 · 10/03/2022 10:07

[quote etulosba]EVs are far more reliable than fossil fuel cars. Less likely to go wrong.

Believe me, there is plenty to go wrong and, according to a Which study, less reliable than fossil fuel cars. Tesla being the worst.

www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/cars/article-10569557/Electric-cars-reliable-petrol-diesel-says-Which.html[/quote]
The Which report - Complete load of rubbish - I have lost faith in Which after I read that. They are reporting and comparing faults in EV's that are resolved with a quick reboot (you know like a phone or pc or any other electronic equipment!) with a full garage visit for a petrol vehicle.

Doublechocolatetiffin · 10/03/2022 10:04

[quote etulosba]EVs are far more reliable than fossil fuel cars. Less likely to go wrong.

Believe me, there is plenty to go wrong and, according to a Which study, less reliable than fossil fuel cars. Tesla being the worst.

www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/cars/article-10569557/Electric-cars-reliable-petrol-diesel-says-Which.html[/quote]
I've definitely had far more problems with my Tesla than any other car that I've owned in my life until this point combined. Still I love electric and think that Tesla has got lots right with its cars. I wouldn't say reliability is one of them though. For me the pros of electric outweigh the cons and I wouldn't want to go back to petrol or diesel now, they just feel so slow and I cba with having to go somewhere to fill it up when I can charge at home. They are expensive though and sadly out of reach for a large chunk of people which I hope changes soon.

Lunar27 · 10/03/2022 09:57

@etulosba

Aye but it's software so is a separate issue to comparing the ICE with an electric motor. I don't quite understand why software isn't quite up to scratch with EV's as they're much simpler than all the control necessary for an ICE but is definitely solvable.

As a method of propulsion however, EV's are streaks ahead in almost every measurable way.

etulosba · 10/03/2022 09:38

EVs are far more reliable than fossil fuel cars. Less likely to go wrong.

Believe me, there is plenty to go wrong and, according to a Which study, less reliable than fossil fuel cars. Tesla being the worst.

www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/cars/article-10569557/Electric-cars-reliable-petrol-diesel-says-Which.html

fruitpastille · 10/03/2022 09:23

We lease a zoe. If you look at the total costs over 3 years (v. low running costs) then it's not bad. And dh loves it. We use it for his daily commute and have a larger ICE car for family trips. It's charged a couple of times a week either at home overnight or in a supermarket car park while we shop.

Aniita · 10/03/2022 08:41

[quote Kazzyhoward]@Aniita

Vehicle excise duty (AKA road tax) can be changed at any time, and has been in the past. There was a pretty major shift a few years ago from a flat rate to it being based on emissions. The underlying scales can be changed at any time. There's no rule/law preventing any changes being made nor the method of charging being changed.

If your VED charges have remained the same for the past few years, then that is because, and only because, the Chancellor hasn't changed it for that banding. He could if he wanted to, but obviously chose not to.

In a few years time when the hundreds of billions of tax revenue raised from VED, fuel taxes, etc etc disappears, then it will have to be made up elsewhere, which will basically and inevitably be finding ways of taxing electric car driving. That could be excise duty increases, congestion charges, mileage related taxes, or a mix of all three. But, it WILL happen as the loss in tax revenues from petrol/diesel cars will have to be recouped from electric cars.[/quote]
Of course they will change. But changes haven't previously affected already bought cars. Like in the example I gave in my previous post.

Kazzyhoward · 10/03/2022 08:36

@Aniita

Vehicle excise duty (AKA road tax) can be changed at any time, and has been in the past. There was a pretty major shift a few years ago from a flat rate to it being based on emissions. The underlying scales can be changed at any time. There's no rule/law preventing any changes being made nor the method of charging being changed.

If your VED charges have remained the same for the past few years, then that is because, and only because, the Chancellor hasn't changed it for that banding. He could if he wanted to, but obviously chose not to.

In a few years time when the hundreds of billions of tax revenue raised from VED, fuel taxes, etc etc disappears, then it will have to be made up elsewhere, which will basically and inevitably be finding ways of taxing electric car driving. That could be excise duty increases, congestion charges, mileage related taxes, or a mix of all three. But, it WILL happen as the loss in tax revenues from petrol/diesel cars will have to be recouped from electric cars.

567and · 10/03/2022 08:25

We've had 3 electric cars and love them. I've driven over 300 miles to Cornwall with 2 stops and charging
didn't take any longer than we took to get a drink/ meal and use the facilities. It's true that if you have a tesla it's much easier to find charge points and something we are thinking about for our next car, but once you've had to charge away from home it's no more stressful than stopping for petrol. There are apps to help you find available charge points and some places are free on a slow charger.

They are great if your usual journeys are relatively short and we've saved so much money on fuel costs. DH used to use around £300 a month and I used around £200 a month on fuel and even with the price increases for electricity we still won't be paying as much as we used to. And that's charging a car each night. Plus the fact that they are so easy to drive compared to a manual car, and even an automatic ICE car.

grinbear · 10/03/2022 08:05

Our second hand Tesla will almost certainly end up the same way. They are built really badly and has cost us a small fortune in repairs.

DuchessofAnkh22 · 10/03/2022 08:00

@Fcuk38

The average person needs to wait for the electric car to have gone through the company car life cycle to hit the second hand market. They are then still too expensive at the moment and currently I wouldn’t buy electric. I don’t see why we have to “pay” extra to be green when the car itself is no better performance wise than a petrol/diesel.
You may need to do your own sums on this but it has been slightly cheaper to buy and run my brand new Kia e-niro than it was to run my 11 year old Ford. And I included all costs in that, fuel, purchase and sale prices, servicing, repairs, tax etc.
CatDogMonkeyPOW · 10/03/2022 07:58

We have an electric car through a work lease scheme.

We live rurally so had to install a charger at home, which was £500. Something to factor in your purchase costs etc.

DH does long distances with work, and it's bollocks to say only the Tesla is good for long distances, sorry. His is the ipace and it can do around 230 miles on a full charge.

The charging infrastructure does vary across the country though. Stopping at a service station to discover that only two chargers are working and they are both in use can be really frustrating. A LOT of work needs to be undertaken before EVs can become much more widespread.

Fcuk38 · 10/03/2022 07:50

The average person needs to wait for the electric car to have gone through the company car life cycle to hit the second hand market. They are then still too expensive at the moment and currently I wouldn’t buy electric. I don’t see why we have to “pay” extra to be green when the car itself is no better performance wise than a petrol/diesel.

Fishlegs · 10/03/2022 07:47

Agree with @Kazzyhoward’s post.
We have a second hand Nissan Leaf. I love it. We’ve travelled between the Manchester and Cornwall several times, despite the range being around 100 miles, there’s plenty of charging points to charge at, Na you soon get wise to the companies which are quick and reliable and those that aren’t (gridserve I’m looking at you). Lidl and Booths are leading the way for quick charging points in their car parks.

And the charge at my local garage for a car service has halved, as there’s just less that needs doing when you take the combustion engine away.

Aniita · 10/03/2022 07:47

[quote Kazzyhoward]@RabbitsNapping

There's no road tax, no congestion charge

Not yet, but there will be![/quote]
But road tax isn't retrospective. So if you buy now without road tax, you'll never pay road tax on that car.

My old car was a big dirty diesel, bought when there was incentives to buy diesel.£30 car tax per year, even after they changed the tax system. And the person who owns it now still pays £30 py

Swipe left for the next trending thread