Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have found the 2 best diets ever that WORK?

110 replies

Ambushedbycakeinmydreams · 07/03/2022 10:52

That's it. I now have the formula for successful and doable weight loss. Here they are, there are 2 methods that I can say absolutely work. But please don't tell me that "they don't work because people often put all the weight back on" - it's not the fault of the diet; diets will only work if you stick with them.

  1. Fast 800 Keto After 7 days - 2" lost from my waist; down by a dress size; suddenly regained a lot of formerly worn clothes. Pros - fast results, very motivating Has science behind it so has integrity (Dr Mosley and his GP wife) The food recipes are easy to prepare and the food is gorgeous - I'm so enjoying the food.

Cons - the first phase is hard as though the food is excellent, the portions are small (but you do get used to it after the first week or so).

  1. Slimming World Pros - allows you to eat a diet where no foods are excluded, so you can tailor it to personal requirements eg incorporate a bit of alcohol, chocolate, etc you get my drift. Easy to follow - no need to count calories.

Cons - weight loss is invariably slower eg average loss for me a few years ago was 1 - 2 lbs a week.

I did SW a few years ago, lost nearly 2 stone and then Covid hit so no meetings or weigh ins to help keep me on track. And then I did all the Covid stuff too eg lots of baking and bread making (and put over half of the weight back on).

Currently now on Fast 800 Keto to shift the aforementioned weight gain.

OP posts:
MurmuratingStarling · 07/03/2022 12:30

[quote Ambushedbycakeinmydreams]@MurmuratingStarling

I think the 5:2 is a relative of the Fast 800, Dr Mosley methods? Thanks for sharing your experience of this, it's fab to hear of people successfully maintaining weight loss and showing that it can be done.

I think within any media about Fast 800 Keto, Dr Mosley does back this up with credible evidence that following the first phase, the weight losses are sustainable long-term with people currently doing this. Dr Mosley himself is the poster-boy example as he initially was told to lose weight to prevent diabetes, and since then he has kept it off.[/quote]
@Ambushedbycakeinmydreams

I think the 5:2 is a relative of the Fast 800, Dr Mosley methods?

Oh, I didn't realise this! Yes I guess it is. Thanks for that. Smile

Thanks for sharing your experience of this. Smile

And you're welcome. Smile Hope some people can take some tips or inspiration from this thread. Trying to lose weight is so hard, and keeping it off is even harder!

Whiskyinajar · 07/03/2022 12:24

SW has a lot of myths around it. ….not least because they push that aspect. Unlimited pasta, potatoes, rice etc is not actually correct despite what they say. They also say a third of the plate should be non starchy vegetables. By the time you’ve done that and added protein you have naturally reduced the portion size of your carb . This seems to be poorly understood even by consultants.

I attend a SW group and am 46lbs down, however I am diabetic and so I always weigh and measure my starchy carbs.

I follow the SW third of a plate non starchy veg rule and my carbs work out almost exactly the portion which is suggested by my diabetic team.

I don’t however count syns (made up nonsense) and I count calories …I attend the group purely because I like the people who also attend and to get a weekly accurate weight. Diabetes now in remission and stating that way.

Zilla1 · 07/03/2022 12:16

as @SatinHeart says, YABU to think these or any restrictive diet 'works' and are suitable for everyone or indeed most people.

Ambushedbycakeinmydreams · 07/03/2022 12:12

@MurmuratingStarling

I think the 5:2 is a relative of the Fast 800, Dr Mosley methods? Thanks for sharing your experience of this, it's fab to hear of people successfully maintaining weight loss and showing that it can be done.

I think within any media about Fast 800 Keto, Dr Mosley does back this up with credible evidence that following the first phase, the weight losses are sustainable long-term with people currently doing this. Dr Mosley himself is the poster-boy example as he initially was told to lose weight to prevent diabetes, and since then he has kept it off.

OP posts:
MurmuratingStarling · 07/03/2022 12:05

Sorry @Ambushedbycakeinmydreams I have tried Slimming World, and found it very cliquey and almost like a cult. I hated it! I am glad you found it good and helpful though. Never tried keto.

The best way I found to lose weight - and keep it off - is intermittent fasting. I started off with the 5-2 diet, (where you eat fairly normally for 5 days of the week, and have roughly 800 calories on the other 2 days. The 800 calorie days were Monday and Thursday.)

I then changed it to 4-3 when I reached a plateau. (Lost 19 pounds and then stalled.) I found the 4-3 too much though, and felt a bit light-headed, and was more hungry. So I settled on 1 day on, (on 800 calories,) 2 days off, (eating 'normally,') 1 day on, 2 days off, 1 day on, 2 days off, and so on...........

With this eating plan, I found myself eating less on the days 'off,' where I was eating 'normally.' Eating healthily and eating enough, but not snacking on crap. And I eventually started to lose weight again (after a few more weeks.)

This way of eating is the only 'diet' I have ever been on that has actually worked. I lost almost 3 stone (40 pounds,) in 2017, and have not regained it. I still stick to the 5-2, although on the 2 days 'on' (Monday and Thursday,) I tend to have 1000-1100 calories, rather than 800.

I go swimming and walking too, and also cycling. (I go swimming twice a week, and walk 2 or 3 miles 3 times a week, and cycle 2 or 3 miles 3 times a week.) Not a massive amount, but it works for me.

Rory1234 · 07/03/2022 12:05

(Should add, I find 800 calories a day easy to do because my work means I can’t snack during the day and I rarely drink alcohol. Can completely understand why others may find it intolerable!)

Rory1234 · 07/03/2022 12:02

I lost a lot of weight (3.5 stones) doing 12 weeks of 800 calories a day (on the advice of my GP as I was pre diabetic) and have maintained it by doing 5:2 (so eating relatively healthily 5 days a week and 800 calories 2 days a week).

I think the key thing is that this works for me and my lifestyle, there is definitely no one size fits all.

TabithaTittlemouse · 07/03/2022 12:02

It’s great that you have found something that works for you.

Peoniesandcream · 07/03/2022 12:02

Well done @BusinessMindThoughts

luckylavender · 07/03/2022 11:59

@Ambushedbycakeinmydreams - you post as though no one has ever heard of these diets.

SatinHeart · 07/03/2022 11:58

Congratulations OP, but since you posted in AIBU, then YABU for not saying that you have found what works FOR YOU,

You say yourself that "diets will only work if you stick with them" - for different people that will be different diets, depending on their medical history and what works with the other things going on in their life. It really isn't one size fits all.

NoSquirrels · 07/03/2022 11:57

But if you’re talking just about the process of losing weight i.e. a weight-loss plan then yes, YABU to say you’ve definitively found the two diets that work…they ALL work. If you follow them.

What you’re really saying is “I’ve found two particular diets easy to follow”. Which is subtly different.

PurpleHollyhocks · 07/03/2022 11:48

What worked for me was eating somewhere around 600 - 800 calories for 2 days and 800-1200 calories 3 days and then never going over 1700 the other 2 days (weekend)

I can’t deny that I was often hungry but I lost a lot of weight quickly. I kept it off with a version of the 5:2 and intermittent fasting

Ambushedbycakeinmydreams · 07/03/2022 11:44

@NoSquirrels

Every weight-loss diet works if you follow it to the letter.

It’s whether long-term it’s a sustainable way of eating that allows you to keep the weight off that counts.

It’s an odd post so I can’t say YABU, but really - your thinking is a bit odd on this.

I'm talking here about just the process of losing weight - sustaining it will be a subject for a future thread.

With SW, I kept the weight fully off for 18 months, but as I said ealier, I retreated into comfort baking during Covid so I regained. This is clearly not the fault of SW but it was up to me to keep it sustainable (and obviously I didn't).

With Fast 800 Keto, there is a plan to follow that relies mainly on adopting a mediterranean style diet for life in order to sustain losses. Having started on this, I so love the foods I cannot see that making this lifestyle change will be too hard.

I do wish more people would use their brains before bashing SW though, as per @Fatgalslim: "Surely common sense tells you that you can't eat unlimited amounts of pasta/potatoes/sugary yogurts, they may be 'free' but that doesn't mean unlimited."

OP posts:
AllOfUsAreDead · 07/03/2022 11:40

@ShirleyPhallus

Lol at slimming world. A “diet” which allows unlimited pasta / potatoes / sugary yoghurts isn’t really encouraging healthy eating.
Don't forget the allowed chocolate as long as you syn it. You can literally syn 5 bars a day. Grin
ElephantLover · 07/03/2022 11:39

I came to read this post thinking it would definitely have the magic words 'consistency', 'exercise', 'protein' but instead it's just saying the same old nonsense which works for few days/weeks but never 'really works' for long term sustained weight management and good health. I guess I'll go back to my 3 magic words then.

TellMeMoreHellebore · 07/03/2022 11:35

slimming world doesn't allow unlimited yogurts.....just looked, its all changed

a while back apparently

RonCarlos · 07/03/2022 11:28

Good luck OP.

Portion size is my issue, and snacking between meals. (Especially cheese). Mid-week drinking. More exercise. It's not rocket science. I appreciate a 'plan' helps people feel in control. I am not sure the first one sounds sustainable though.

Softpebbles · 07/03/2022 11:26

Surely you don’t need any of those to help you lose weight. Neither are particularly sustainable - you can’t continue on such low calories for time and slimming world you surely don’t want to be paying someone to weigh you every week forever.

Surely just awareness is the best way - know what calories you need to fuel your body, know what calories are what you are eating in your food. If you are putting on weight you are eating too much and not moving enough?! All diets ultimately work on calories in v’s calories out. Low carb diets will give you a bigger loss to begin with as you won’t be holding on to water.

ShirleyPhallus · 07/03/2022 11:26

Surely common sense tells you that you can't eat unlimited amounts of pasta/potatoes/sugary yogurts, they may be 'free' but that doesn't mean unlimited.

Yes common sense would tell you that, but if these plans are so successful they’d do themselves out of business as everyone would lose weight and keep it off.

BusinessMindThoughts · 07/03/2022 11:24

@Peoniesandcream

Losing weight slowly by increasing exercise and eating a lot healthier is the only way to maintain weight loss. It's a change of lifestyle that works, not a fast restrictive diet.
Yep that's what I've done over the past year. The weight loss has been slow and steady and I'm in danger of going back to old habits but I can keep to it without feeling too controlled/ deprived! Portion size esp carbs was key for me (ate pretty healthy food anyway). I feel really uncomfortable if I overeat now.
Tink1989 · 07/03/2022 11:22

If SW is so successful why the need to go onto keto?

Diets are just money making schemes that can be detrimental to peoples mental health and foster unhealthy relationships around food

NoSquirrels · 07/03/2022 11:21

Every weight-loss diet works if you follow it to the letter.

It’s whether long-term it’s a sustainable way of eating that allows you to keep the weight off that counts.

It’s an odd post so I can’t say YABU, but really - your thinking is a bit odd on this.

Fatgalslim · 07/03/2022 11:20

@ShirleyPhallus

Lol at slimming world. A “diet” which allows unlimited pasta / potatoes / sugary yoghurts isn’t really encouraging healthy eating.
Surely common sense tells you that you can't eat unlimited amounts of pasta/potatoes/sugary yogurts, they may be 'free' but that doesn't mean unlimited.

I do WW, I've lost 5 stone by following what's called the Core Plan and consists of lots of zero point foods which aren't free because they are zero, but should be eaten in moderation

MorrisZapp · 07/03/2022 11:20

800 a day is simply impossible for most working people, I'd have thought.

Of course a severe calorie restriction will produce quick results, but this relies on being able to stick to it.

I don't think I could do one day on 800, never mind weeks of it.