Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have found the 2 best diets ever that WORK?

110 replies

Ambushedbycakeinmydreams · 07/03/2022 10:52

That's it. I now have the formula for successful and doable weight loss. Here they are, there are 2 methods that I can say absolutely work. But please don't tell me that "they don't work because people often put all the weight back on" - it's not the fault of the diet; diets will only work if you stick with them.

  1. Fast 800 Keto After 7 days - 2" lost from my waist; down by a dress size; suddenly regained a lot of formerly worn clothes. Pros - fast results, very motivating Has science behind it so has integrity (Dr Mosley and his GP wife) The food recipes are easy to prepare and the food is gorgeous - I'm so enjoying the food.

Cons - the first phase is hard as though the food is excellent, the portions are small (but you do get used to it after the first week or so).

  1. Slimming World Pros - allows you to eat a diet where no foods are excluded, so you can tailor it to personal requirements eg incorporate a bit of alcohol, chocolate, etc you get my drift. Easy to follow - no need to count calories.

Cons - weight loss is invariably slower eg average loss for me a few years ago was 1 - 2 lbs a week.

I did SW a few years ago, lost nearly 2 stone and then Covid hit so no meetings or weigh ins to help keep me on track. And then I did all the Covid stuff too eg lots of baking and bread making (and put over half of the weight back on).

Currently now on Fast 800 Keto to shift the aforementioned weight gain.

OP posts:
McPie · 07/03/2022 15:22

Unless you can provide non biased research papers then the fast 800 is not backed by science no matter who wrote it!

Googlecanthelpme · 07/03/2022 15:10

Meh - in both examples you’re eating under your required calories so yeah you’ll lose weight.

You haven’t discovered anything, you could eat 3 mars bars a day and still lose weight as long as you’re under your maintenance calorie level.

Both of your examples are methods of controlling calorie intake - ths science is the same regardless. They all work on cals in / cals out.

If they work for you OP that’s all that matters. The method is personal, the science is fact.

Fairislefandango · 07/03/2022 15:05

YABU. Almost any diet will work if you can stick to it. The problem is that people can't. That's why the vast majority of diets fail, it's not that there's anything particular wrong with most of the diets. It's just that anything that requires permanent willpower strong enough to fight against appetite, temptation, convenience and social expectations is pretty much doomed to failure.

SarahBellam · 07/03/2022 15:03

All diets work. Pretty much every single diet you have ever read will work, for the simple reason that one way or another, you are taking in fewer calories than you are using. It’s when you stop the diet that the problems start Grin

theyhavenothingbuttheaudacity · 07/03/2022 15:01

800 calories a day god how miserable

LittleGwyneth · 07/03/2022 15:00

Obviously any diet you stick to will work. There's no magic diet that works any better than others. If you consume fewer calories than you use, you will lose weight.

Dixiechickonhols · 07/03/2022 14:51

Slimmingworld gets slated on here from people who have never done it or not done it recently. It doesn’t say eat buckets of pasta, muller lights and mug shots. It’s the plan the nhs recommend, in some areas you get 12 weeks free on nhs if bmi 30 plus. It doesn’t exclude food groups. Basic concept is minimum 1/3 plate veg each meal which is helpful as you fill up on lower calorie food. Their recommended portions eg 40g oats or a wholemeal roll are in line with bupa healthy eating guidelines. Encourages cooking from scratch.
I lost 5 stone in 8 months to a healthy bmi. I maintain a healthy weight. It’s not faddy, it’s sustainable long term. I’ve had oats, skyr and berries for breakfast. Veg chilli & baked potato lunch. Tonight I’ll have homemade cottage pie and green veg.

picklemewalnuts · 07/03/2022 14:26

Unlimited pasta etc AFTER you've eaten a third of a plate of low cal vegetables and a third of a plate of protein.

So first eat your fibre and calcium allocation, then protein and low density food likes green beans, kale, leeks, peppers, cucumber...

Then whatever pasta you need to feel full.

A jacket potato and baked beans, or a bowl of pasta and cheese- that's not following slimming world.

BritishDesiGirl · 07/03/2022 14:19

@ShirleyPhallus

Lol at slimming world. A “diet” which allows unlimited pasta / potatoes / sugary yoghurts isn’t really encouraging healthy eating.
Yes, its unlimited but no where does it say that you have to eat unlimited, everyone has their own threshold. I can't eat more than a small bowl of pasta and more than one yogurt even though ita unlimited. Each person can judge for themselves unlimited means to them.
NavigatingAdolescence · 07/03/2022 14:16

Not routinely, no. I weigh it up before making the decision. Non-functional food makes me feel tired and lethargic, so it’s not worth it to me. It’s food marketing that makes us think food = reward/celebration. I had 2 days “off” at Xmas and enjoyed the foods I wanted. (I don’t often make roast dinners so thoroughly enjoyed a fancy one.). That didn’t include mince pies this time. The world didn’t end.

I had a little bit of birthday cake at my toddler nephew’s party a couple of weeks ago. I didn’t really enjoy it and needed a nap when I could really have done with doing something else.

I was at a xmas party last week and stuck to plan food wise but had a few gin and slimline tonics. Thoroughly enjoyed and no hangover. I could have stuck to water but decided I wouldn’t.

I can have anything I want. I choose not to eat the things that make me feel less than 100% the vast majority of the time. I have brain clarity, better sleep (for less tie), more energy, less inflammation. The crap food just isn’t worth the effects, for me. It’s total food freedom and once you have it you don’t want to let go of it!

pitstoppop · 07/03/2022 14:03

@NavigatingAdolescence I get it but do you not have anything "bad" I personally don't drink alcohol or coffee because I don't like it, so what do you celebrate with? Carrot sticks ? It's so ingrained in popular culture to have a drink to celebrate or go for a coffee or a birthday cake . Of course once it a while isn't maybe an issue, but I celebrate the little things too often with biscuits.

NavigatingAdolescence · 07/03/2022 13:43

I don’t calorie count, but I also don’t view sweets or crap chocolate, cakes, biscuits etc as treats anymore. Generally speaking they are used to replace an emotional or other need. Dealing with that loses them their power.

I wouldn’t put shit fuel in a Ferrari so I no longer put shit fuel in me either. And I don’t miss it one bit.

pitstoppop · 07/03/2022 13:32

How does anyone eat just 800 kcal a day? I look at food and I've consumed that.

I used to restrict calories and replace with nice treats like haribo or cookies. It's just not a recipe for health to be fasting so much so I see the appeal of no restrictions.

I am only slightly overweight, but I struggle to restrict as I've got into the habit of treat foods daily and thinking cake and cookies are treats. It's tough as I had a very restricted diet as a child due to my parents control issues. I therefore seem to rebel against controlling myself.

NandorTheRelentlessCleaner · 07/03/2022 13:06

It’s great it works for you 💪

You’ll also need a plan of sensible eating for life, and it’s all good 👍

What will you do long term?

Proudboomer · 07/03/2022 12:56

I couldn’t sustain Keto as it was to restrictive and I was looking afor a life style long term change not a diet as I am diabetic and will be now for ever even if I can get it into remission.
I have found low carb is sustainable for me. I eat 50g of carb or less a day. I don’t eat bread, pasta , rice or anything that comes in a box or packet. I eat lean meat, green leaf veg, eggs, salad stuff and fruit with a low GI like berries.
Everyone in the world will lose weight on a restricted carb diet even those on insulin which is a weight gain drug. We don’t need to eat carbs at all they supply nothing that your body cannot get from protein, fats and fibre yet it is still the staple of the western diet mainly because it is used as a cheap filler in foods.

Accountsdept · 07/03/2022 12:52

@WouldIBeATwat

I did the fast 800 3 times for 12 weeks each. Absolutely DESTROYED my metabolism.

It’s taken me 3 years to recover it.

This is what I would be worried about, di you get to the point where anything you ate made you gain weight?
NavigatingAdolescence · 07/03/2022 12:42

I don't understand what you think "Eat healthily for fuelling your body and see where you get with that" is if not a 'diet' in everything but name?

If you use the meaning of “diet”, yes.

Eg the lion’s diet is…….. a cow’s diet is…….

We don’t use the word diet correctly in relation to humans. The “western diet” is absolutely as unhealthy as it’s possible to get for humans and we see it in all the ill health around us. How many people developed type 2 diabetes 40 years ago.

I’ve been on a journey to learn what to eat over the last 8 months. By focusing on what is good for the body (rather than what food manufacturers want me to eat) I’ve lost over 3 stone without trying, my allergies are mostly gone and I’m fitter than ever (without exercise). It’s absolutely a diet - the diet humans should be eating (although I don’t eat meat). Not a temporary fix focussed solely on the scales.

Ambushedbycakeinmydreams · 07/03/2022 12:39

@Whiskyinajar

SW has a lot of myths around it. ….not least because they push that aspect. Unlimited pasta, potatoes, rice etc is not actually correct despite what they say. They also say a third of the plate should be non starchy vegetables. By the time you’ve done that and added protein you have naturally reduced the portion size of your carb . This seems to be poorly understood even by consultants.

I attend a SW group and am 46lbs down, however I am diabetic and so I always weigh and measure my starchy carbs.

I follow the SW third of a plate non starchy veg rule and my carbs work out almost exactly the portion which is suggested by my diabetic team.

I don’t however count syns (made up nonsense) and I count calories …I attend the group purely because I like the people who also attend and to get a weekly accurate weight. Diabetes now in remission and stating that way.

Well done for your brilliant progress to date and I'm so glad you've made these really good points about SW.

The trouble is that I think a lot of people are in denial or not very bright and think that once they've lost the weight, that's the end of it. Then they blame the weight loss method for putting it all back on again (moans of "it doesn't work, all diets are a con just out to make money" etc) rather than accepting they are solely responsible for managing their own eating.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 07/03/2022 12:39

How long have you maintained the loss for?

They all work if you stick to them, but you need something you can realistically keep going for the rest of your life.

BobHadBitchTits · 07/03/2022 12:38

I'm really struggling to lose weight. I'm thinking of trying Noom. Anyone tried it?

babyjellyfish · 07/03/2022 12:38

The only diet that actually works is maintaining a calorie deficit of 500-800 calories per day until you have reached your target weight and then eating however many calories you need to maintain your weight for the rest of your life.

WouldIBeATwat · 07/03/2022 12:38

I did the fast 800 3 times for 12 weeks each.
Absolutely DESTROYED my metabolism.

It’s taken me 3 years to recover it.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 07/03/2022 12:38

@Looneytune253

Come on, can't you see how the post sounds? Yes you'll lose weight on any diet but it always comes back unless you eat that way forever. Eat healthily for fueling your body and see where you get with that. No more yo yo dieting.
There's always comments like this on diet threads.

I don't understand what you think "Eat healthily for fuelling your body and see where you get with that" is if not a 'diet' in everything but name? If you've got fat, you're clearly not doing that in the first place so anything you DO do is going to be a) different and b) something you need to adopt into your lifestyle Confused. If we're specifically saying highly restrictive short-term diets don't work in the long term then say that.

Moody123 · 07/03/2022 12:35

They obviously don't work if you need to be on them to 'loose weight'
Eat healthy and keep fit , it's simple maths ... kcals going in should be less than kcals going out to loose weight ... and to maintain it needs to balance

FromageRay · 07/03/2022 12:35

@ShirleyPhallus

Lol at slimming world. A “diet” which allows unlimited pasta / potatoes / sugary yoghurts isn’t really encouraging healthy eating.
Lol at people who think this is how it works 🤷🏻‍♀️