Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have found the 2 best diets ever that WORK?

110 replies

Ambushedbycakeinmydreams · 07/03/2022 10:52

That's it. I now have the formula for successful and doable weight loss. Here they are, there are 2 methods that I can say absolutely work. But please don't tell me that "they don't work because people often put all the weight back on" - it's not the fault of the diet; diets will only work if you stick with them.

  1. Fast 800 Keto After 7 days - 2" lost from my waist; down by a dress size; suddenly regained a lot of formerly worn clothes. Pros - fast results, very motivating Has science behind it so has integrity (Dr Mosley and his GP wife) The food recipes are easy to prepare and the food is gorgeous - I'm so enjoying the food.

Cons - the first phase is hard as though the food is excellent, the portions are small (but you do get used to it after the first week or so).

  1. Slimming World Pros - allows you to eat a diet where no foods are excluded, so you can tailor it to personal requirements eg incorporate a bit of alcohol, chocolate, etc you get my drift. Easy to follow - no need to count calories.

Cons - weight loss is invariably slower eg average loss for me a few years ago was 1 - 2 lbs a week.

I did SW a few years ago, lost nearly 2 stone and then Covid hit so no meetings or weigh ins to help keep me on track. And then I did all the Covid stuff too eg lots of baking and bread making (and put over half of the weight back on).

Currently now on Fast 800 Keto to shift the aforementioned weight gain.

OP posts:
Luredbyapomegranate · 07/03/2022 22:09

Pretty much any diet works if you follow it 🤷‍♀️

They go in fashions - if we were in 1992, you’d be worshipping at the alter of Rosemary Conley

Eims88 · 07/03/2022 21:53

Can I ask, those who do 800 calories diets - do you exercise as well? I'm contemplating giving it all a go but not sure what to do regards exercising, will it just make me feel more hungry and need more calories?

SkinnyChaiLatte · 07/03/2022 21:50

@AllOfUsAreDead You're talking bollocks. You can't eat 5 chocolate bars a day and syn them. Most people can have 5-15 syns a day and a chocolate bar would have around 10 syns in it.

SartresSoul · 07/03/2022 21:41

@Fairislefandango

At 5 years following weight loss around 95% of people will have regained all the weight to within a pound or two.

Exactly. At that percentage, it's ridiculous and futile to say that people who fail to lose weight are just weak. On that basis pretty much everybody is weak. It's not weakness, it's just the way humans are. Your brain/body/survival system doesn't want to be in a calorie deficit. Not enough food equals less energy, less nutrients, lower ability to survive. We haven't evolved past the urgent drive to access high calorie food, even though it's all too easy to get hold of now. If you try and fight that innate drive, you sooner or later almost inevitably fail - it's as simple as that.

So by this thinking we’re all destined to be overweight and shouldn’t try to prevent that? Makes sense.
SartresSoul · 07/03/2022 21:39

I lost 7 stone in a year a few years ago just eating healthily, cutting my portion sizes and exercising a lot. I worked really fucking hard. My overweight friend tried to berate me one day when I’d lost all of the weight for eating a banana because it’s ‘ssooo many calories’ while she tucked into a 50 calorie ‘diet’ bar with Christ knows what chemicals inside it. She never did lose the weight fwiw, she’s used SW on and off for years.

I gained some back when I had 2 DC in under 2 years so finally tackling it this year. Lost 24 lbs since January 3rd again just exercising hard and eating well. No need for faddy diets.

Fairislefandango · 07/03/2022 21:26

At 5 years following weight loss around 95% of people will have regained all the weight to within a pound or two.

Exactly. At that percentage, it's ridiculous and futile to say that people who fail to lose weight are just weak. On that basis pretty much everybody is weak. It's not weakness, it's just the way humans are. Your brain/body/survival system doesn't want to be in a calorie deficit. Not enough food equals less energy, less nutrients, lower ability to survive. We haven't evolved past the urgent drive to access high calorie food, even though it's all too easy to get hold of now. If you try and fight that innate drive, you sooner or later almost inevitably fail - it's as simple as that.

PinotPony · 07/03/2022 20:15

@Looneytune253 Ok, you got me! It might not be as high as 100!

But the point still stands that muscle does burn more calories than fat.

Looneytune253 · 07/03/2022 19:57

@PinotPony

I'll never understand the obsession with losing weight. Your bathroom scales literally show the gravity you are exerting on the planet! Yes, it's a useful indicator of progress but should only be part of the calculation.

Each pound of muscle on your body burns 100 calories a day. Each pound of fat on your body burns 10 calories a day. If you drastically reduce your calorie input, your body will start shedding the high calorie burning muscle before it loses fat. Yes, the scales show you are losing "weight" but you're losing all the good stuff. Your metabolism slows down and you become a skinny fat person!

At age 20 I weighed 8 stone and was a dress size 10. Twenty five years later, having learnt about nutrition and training, and recovered from being overweight in my 30s, I weigh 9 stone and am a dress size 8. My wedding dress fits me better today even though I weigh a stone more! I eats loads of healthy food to fuel my strong body.

That's why WW and SW are a load of tosh. If I lost 3lb of fat and gained 4lb of muscle, some sanctimonious cow bag would tut at the scales and tell me I'd failed that week.

Is that too but true? Cos I have110lb of muscle (genuinely, I know that's weird) so I would burn 11000 cals a day and I'm still fat haha. That can't be accurate
Lesperance · 07/03/2022 18:42

Of course it was aimed at you, @Ambushedbycakeinmydreams . You have just confirmed what I said. I think you don't really understand about food at all. You can have tons of good stuff in your diet, but if you eat all the rubbish too, then it's a poor diet. You obviously got in some kind of food rut, which is why you're getting excited about the meals you are eating, and my point is, that's not a feature of a diet, those are not at all unusual foods, and not a sign that it is a good diet, it's a sign that you were in a food rut. It's not a sign that the diet itself is amazing. Any diet where you eat so few calories is going to make you lose weight. Did you mean to posted AIBU?

ShirleyPhallus · 07/03/2022 18:14

@PinotPony

I'll never understand the obsession with losing weight. Your bathroom scales literally show the gravity you are exerting on the planet! Yes, it's a useful indicator of progress but should only be part of the calculation.

Each pound of muscle on your body burns 100 calories a day. Each pound of fat on your body burns 10 calories a day. If you drastically reduce your calorie input, your body will start shedding the high calorie burning muscle before it loses fat. Yes, the scales show you are losing "weight" but you're losing all the good stuff. Your metabolism slows down and you become a skinny fat person!

At age 20 I weighed 8 stone and was a dress size 10. Twenty five years later, having learnt about nutrition and training, and recovered from being overweight in my 30s, I weigh 9 stone and am a dress size 8. My wedding dress fits me better today even though I weigh a stone more! I eats loads of healthy food to fuel my strong body.

That's why WW and SW are a load of tosh. If I lost 3lb of fat and gained 4lb of muscle, some sanctimonious cow bag would tut at the scales and tell me I'd failed that week.

THIS IN SPADES ^^

People who crash diet and lose 5lbs in their first week, it’s all water and muscle. Much much better to work on exercise, protein, consistency

Whiskyinajar · 07/03/2022 18:06

If you look at research around commercial diets you will find that the five year results are pretty appalling. At 5 years following weight loss around 95% of people will have regained all the weight to within a pound or two. There’s even an increasing body of evidence showing that a high minority….around 40% will have gained more on top. As a treatment for obesity it has appalling outcomes, would we accept this of treatment for any other issue?

Fact is that slimming clubs rely upon repeat custom. The only club which acknowledged this (once) was WW.

Most of them are not sustainable long term and there are good biological reasons for this.

Have a read about set point weight theory which is fascinating.

Meanwhile…I’ve lost a huge amount of weight but being diabetic is turning out to be a pretty powerful motivator to keeping me going. I will never again not weigh myself weekly for example.

I’ve had to find my own way though. I do it with SW (although I don’t follow their plan) and use it as a vehicle for weighing accurately once a week. I look at carbs, I look at protein and I look at calories. I don’t care about fat….when I do note it I see I am eating pretty low fat on the whole.

PinotPony · 07/03/2022 18:01

I'll never understand the obsession with losing weight. Your bathroom scales literally show the gravity you are exerting on the planet! Yes, it's a useful indicator of progress but should only be part of the calculation.

Each pound of muscle on your body burns 100 calories a day. Each pound of fat on your body burns 10 calories a day. If you drastically reduce your calorie input, your body will start shedding the high calorie burning muscle before it loses fat. Yes, the scales show you are losing "weight" but you're losing all the good stuff. Your metabolism slows down and you become a skinny fat person!

At age 20 I weighed 8 stone and was a dress size 10. Twenty five years later, having learnt about nutrition and training, and recovered from being overweight in my 30s, I weigh 9 stone and am a dress size 8. My wedding dress fits me better today even though I weigh a stone more! I eats loads of healthy food to fuel my strong body.

That's why WW and SW are a load of tosh. If I lost 3lb of fat and gained 4lb of muscle, some sanctimonious cow bag would tut at the scales and tell me I'd failed that week.

Whiskyinajar · 07/03/2022 17:58

@bluepeacock

You're basically saying fat people are weak and just don't try hard enough. Do you really think that's the case?

Well, that's a brutal way to put it but...yes, I guess so.

We all make a choice what we put in our mouths don't we? No one is force feeding us?

There is a psychology behind why people overeat, of course (in my case I think it was the fact that food was in short supply when I was growing up). But what you weigh comes down to how many calories you consume. If you want to blame the "science" go ahead, but if you can't find a way to control what you eat you will unfortunately stay fat.

You know NOTHING and I do mean NOTHING about obesity or why it occurs. Not a thing.
Moon22 · 07/03/2022 16:50

I highly, highly recommend weight loss resources for weight loss and maintenence. It's basically calorie counting- and moving more!- really good format, links to your fitbit and just works!
Not knocking SW as I know loads of people have been successful on it, but it left me with a weird relationship with food.- and the ONLY way you will lose weight, on any diet, is by being in a calorie defecit.
I have a friend code for 7 days free on WLR if anyone wants it.

pitstoppop · 07/03/2022 16:36

The thing is to drop weight you have to eat less energy than you need a day ( over over a course week) and so is that is hard, to maintain you can relax a little, you don't need that deficit, but it's only a little and that is where it goes wrong for people. They relax into bad habits.

I'm fine at maintenance now my weight is the same every week, even with cheeky treats here and there, but I want to loose weight and dropping down that low makes me feel weak and down.

Ambushedbycakeinmydreams · 07/03/2022 16:36

@Lesperance

YABU. You clearly had a poor and unvaried diet. You are loving the food, the very ordinary, normal food, that you describe in your last message. It's not the diet, you just needed to learn how to cook nice stuff.
Is this aimed at me by any chance? There was nothing wrong with my previous diet - meat, fish, home-made bread; lots of fruit and vegetables; all meals cooked from scratch - hardly ever do takeaways.

The problem I had was I like cakes, puddings, bread too much. And I'd eat too much of them (my own home-made seeded bread, my own home-made crumbles and eves pudding).

But the difference with my recent way of eating is that I'm adding more things in such as omelettes, unusual soups, courgettes and cauliflower as pasta and rice; and going back to cooking with extra virgin oil (rather than a low-fat spray).

OP posts:
bluepeacock · 07/03/2022 16:36

You're basically saying fat people are weak and just don't try hard enough. Do you really think that's the case?

Well, that's a brutal way to put it but...yes, I guess so.

We all make a choice what we put in our mouths don't we? No one is force feeding us?

There is a psychology behind why people overeat, of course (in my case I think it was the fact that food was in short supply when I was growing up). But what you weigh comes down to how many calories you consume. If you want to blame the "science" go ahead, but if you can't find a way to control what you eat you will unfortunately stay fat.

Tigofigo · 07/03/2022 16:21

It basically comes down to how tough you are mentally and how much you want to stay slim I guess?

I guess you don't understand the science and psychology behind willpower and overeating.

You're basically saying fat people are weak and just don't try hard enough. Do you really think that's the case?

Also some plans are generally easier to stick to longer term than others, which in my view makes them "better" diets.

bluepeacock · 07/03/2022 16:12

That's why so many people at Slimming World etc are repeat customers. I know people who are on their third or fourth time round. 'But it works!' they cry. Clearly not.

You're missing the point - it DOES work. It just stops "working" if you go back to eating crap or too much food.

Whether you want to call it a diet or a lifestyle change - it works as long as you keep following the plan.

SW is based on eating 3 healthy meals a day and having low-cal snacks. If you can't live this way (ie. Don't have the willpower) of course you will put the weight back on. That's down to the individual giving up on that particular way of eating - not the diet itself not working.

Eating healthily and drastically cutting back on stuff that's bad for you requires a lot of willpower. It basically comes down to how tough you are mentally and how much you want to stay slim I guess?

Lesperance · 07/03/2022 16:05

YABU. You clearly had a poor and unvaried diet. You are loving the food, the very ordinary, normal food, that you describe in your last message. It's not the diet, you just needed to learn how to cook nice stuff.

Doggydreaming · 07/03/2022 15:53

I tried the fast 800 and I was so exhausted, that I couldn't even think. Plus headachy, weak and grumpy. I only lost a pound a week on it (I do have subclinical hypothyroidism though and a busy life). Definitely did not work for me.

Paradoxically, slimming world doesn't cut calories enough for me to lose weight, even with extra excercise. I seem to be in a no-mans land where I either eat enough to not feel terrible and remain fat, or go on an extremely low calorie diet and feel massively I'll the whole time.

Fingers crossed my TSH will cross that magical no. 10 with my next blood test and my GP will cough up the levothyroxin 😕

Ambushedbycakeinmydreams · 07/03/2022 15:45

@theyhavenothingbuttheaudacity

800 calories a day god how miserable
Not at all!

I am loving the food - so much variety, textures and easy to prepare. Eg today's menu:

pancakes with raspberries and greek yoghurt;
Pea and mint soup with feta crumbs and small can of tuna wrapped in cabbage leaves;
Courgette lasagne with ricotta and spinach.

I'm eating a much wider range of foods than I did pre-diet and will be more than happy to carry on eating similarly post-diet (obvs with more quantity). The menus have given me a boot up the backside regarding expanding my cooking repetoire.

And I'm already losing weight, in 7 days 2" off my waist and down a dress size. Now I'm over the adjusting to keto hump I feel really good and energised, especially knowing that everyday I wake up I am losing weight.

OP posts:
BusinessMindThoughts · 07/03/2022 15:37

@Peoniesandcream

Well done *@BusinessMindThoughts*
aw thanks! I don't really bang on about it as it's a bunch of small changes that I don't always stick to but I feel loads better for it and have found exercise that I actually enjoy!

My biggest problem is that I cook my meals and usually enjoy all my recipes so to only have a small portion that doesn't take long to eat makes me feel a little hard done by...

Hugasauras · 07/03/2022 15:27

@SarahBellam

All diets work. Pretty much every single diet you have ever read will work, for the simple reason that one way or another, you are taking in fewer calories than you are using. It’s when you stop the diet that the problems start Grin
Yep!

The best 'diets' are sustainable lifestyle changes that change how you approach food and eating, because most of the buzzword diets are not sustainable for the long term. That's why so many people at Slimming World etc are repeat customers. I know people who are on their third or fourth time round. 'But it works!' they cry. Clearly not.

bluepeacock · 07/03/2022 15:23

Lol at slimming world. A “diet” which allows unlimited pasta / potatoes / sugary yoghurts isn’t really encouraging healthy eating.

This is a myth though, peddled by haters of SW. (although FYI pasta and potatoes can absolutely form part of a healthy diet). Anyone who thinks you can eat "unlimited" amounts of these things though and still lose weight is of course deluded.

I lost weight following SW and have managed to keep it off, more or less. I stopped going to group about ,3 years ago because I found the "image therapy" sessions after weigh-in deathly boring. Some people love the sessions and find them integral to maintaining their weight loss.

I've continued to follow the plan - and guess what? The weight has stayed off. If I go off-plan (ie. eat whatever I like and as much as I like) I start putting weight back on and have to reign it back in.

Any "diet" works, be it Keto, fast800 whatever so long as you follow it - but if you start eating lots of takeouts/chocolate/fatty foods again you will obviously revert back to your previous weight.

But if you can treat it as a long-term lifestyle change and not a diet it will continue to work for you.

It's not rocket science is it? Any diet is basically calories in v. calories out. They are all just framed in slightly different ways.