Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have found the 2 best diets ever that WORK?

110 replies

Ambushedbycakeinmydreams · 07/03/2022 10:52

That's it. I now have the formula for successful and doable weight loss. Here they are, there are 2 methods that I can say absolutely work. But please don't tell me that "they don't work because people often put all the weight back on" - it's not the fault of the diet; diets will only work if you stick with them.

  1. Fast 800 Keto After 7 days - 2" lost from my waist; down by a dress size; suddenly regained a lot of formerly worn clothes. Pros - fast results, very motivating Has science behind it so has integrity (Dr Mosley and his GP wife) The food recipes are easy to prepare and the food is gorgeous - I'm so enjoying the food.

Cons - the first phase is hard as though the food is excellent, the portions are small (but you do get used to it after the first week or so).

  1. Slimming World Pros - allows you to eat a diet where no foods are excluded, so you can tailor it to personal requirements eg incorporate a bit of alcohol, chocolate, etc you get my drift. Easy to follow - no need to count calories.

Cons - weight loss is invariably slower eg average loss for me a few years ago was 1 - 2 lbs a week.

I did SW a few years ago, lost nearly 2 stone and then Covid hit so no meetings or weigh ins to help keep me on track. And then I did all the Covid stuff too eg lots of baking and bread making (and put over half of the weight back on).

Currently now on Fast 800 Keto to shift the aforementioned weight gain.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Comtesse · 11/09/2022 20:34

2 tablespoons of rice as a serving? Haha sure thing. I bet all those people in India and China do that….

Vallmo47 · 11/09/2022 20:08

@JulieBur I went for a yearly check up and all my levels were borderline or downright awful. The GP phoned me for a consultation, very matter of fact, no nonsense and it was what I needed. My mum died of similar issues I was starting to develop so enough was enough. I’ve always been up and down with my weight over the past 40 years, I go through periods of thinking “Life is short, have some cake” and I equally go through periods of “Life is short, be careful so you don’t shorten it even further!”
I’m sure my motivation will go again for one reason or another (usually goes hand in hand with poor mental health- feeling down often means I over eat to compensate). I will say that once you do find that motivation don’t let it go - I find exercise has helped massively with my mental health. All the science tells you this but you know when you have to experience it for yourself before you believe? That’s me. :)

HoneyIShrunkThePizza · 11/09/2022 18:05

Different horses for different courses. They work for you, great.

I don't diet and have been a healthy weight all my life bar immediately after having babies 2 and 3. I got back to my healthy weight by doing what I've always done - lots of fruit and veg, avoiding shit processed food and moving lots. We don't eat meat. I have friends who stay slim by avoiding carbs and eating loads of animal products. One who eats loads but is an ultra runner.

I just think this is an odd post especially from someone who sounds like a yo yo dieter...

JulieBur · 11/09/2022 17:54

Vallmo47 · 11/09/2022 17:14

Congrats on finding something that works for YOU OP. I have also found something that works - healthier eating (everything within proportion) and consistent exercise. :) It’s sustainable because I’ve changed the way I think about both food and exercise.

@Vallmo47 I think this is key - you can sustain it cos you've changed the way you think about food and exercise. Can I ask what changed for you?

Vallmo47 · 11/09/2022 17:14

Congrats on finding something that works for YOU OP. I have also found something that works - healthier eating (everything within proportion) and consistent exercise. :) It’s sustainable because I’ve changed the way I think about both food and exercise.

JulieBur · 11/09/2022 17:07

Agree that diets don't work. I tried keto, slimming world, weight watchers, noom and could not keep the weight off. I yoyo dieted for around 20 years. The conflicting advice out there was so confusing - I would get to "goal" and then go right back to my old habits. I have figured it out now and managed to stay within my healthy BMI for years now. I ended up going to therapy to sort it out and figured out the thoughts and behaviours that were keeping me stuck. Cognitive behavioural therapy for weight loss worked for me. 12 sessions and I have never looked back.

thelittlestrhino · 08/03/2022 23:02

The only way to lose weight and keep it off is a life style change count carbs not calories.

Grin Grin Grin

What absolute rubbish

OwlinaTree · 08/03/2022 22:45

Diets work if you stick to them.

Slimming world is good in the sense you can eat family meals without faffing about trying to work out calories. It's an easy diet to follow especially if you have a lot to lose.

Exercise is great, building muscle is great, but realistically if people are very overweight and unfit it is very hard to chance this through exercise alone. The healthy eating needs to be hand in hand with exercise.

NavigatingAdolescence · 08/03/2022 22:12

Have you done any blood tests to check your inflammation markers?

I ate as you do for years (common amongst vegetarians) but it made me feel horrendous (tired/lethagic) and the weight piled on. I definitely don’t run well on carbs. Fat and protein, different story. I’m not hungry, certainly don’t eat 3 times a day: I generally 16:8 or 18:6. I can do a 3 day water fast without thinking about it (there are amazing health benefits to fasting).

We didn’t evolve to eat grains and potatoes are poisonous to us raw, which tells you they aren’t naturally part of the human diet in its truest sense. We haven’t evolved much biologically since our cave dwelling days.

NandorTheRelentlessCleaner · 08/03/2022 22:03

This kind of advice sounds so counter intuitive to me…

@Proudboomer
The modern diet is what makes people overweight. Practically everything is packed with carbs as carbs are used as cheap fillers. Even so called healthy brown and seeded breads have a high carb content.
Rice and potatoes all used to bulk out meals are just starch which again is carb and just turns into sugar the moment it hits your digestive tract.
Pasta again is just carb and used to bulk out a meal. Pretty much every main food source eaten these days is just to high in carb and the volume we eat it at is just too much.
The body doesn’t need carbs at all. It can get everything it needs from protein, fats and fibre yet even diets like slimming world are still promoting the eating of carbs.
Diet foods and the increase in the labelling of meals as “no added sugar” is just another con to make us think it is better for us as when you read the nutriental value on the labelling it is still packed full of carb and carbs = sugar.
The only way to lose weight and keep it off is a life style change count carbs not calories. A serving of rice should be two tablespoons max not the silver foil container full you get from the takeaway and again with pasta and potatoes or even better yet just don’t eat them.”

I eat lots of carbs , oatmeal or muesli for breakfast, bread with lunch, potatoes or rice or pasta for dinner

We’ve no issues with our weight

I don’t think carbs are necessarily bad Confused

DoucheCanoe · 08/03/2022 22:01

I lost 7st following Slimming World.

I also gained an eating disorder and massive issues with my self-esteem.

Slimming clubs are toxic cults.

NandorTheRelentlessCleaner · 08/03/2022 21:58

@Fairislefandango that’s definitely true for some of my friends

They either undereat ;diet/fast/keto etc or overeat (lots of treats, takeaways, pizza, burgers etc

When they are in the diet bit of the cycle they will tell me that eating bread or rice is “pure sugar” and toxic, then a few weeks later they are back to eating carbs. Not rice or bread but pizza and croissants

I always think it must be exhausting and keep my counsel. But yeah, imo diets mess up People’s mindset about food

I have one friend who goes through the entire diet-feast cycle within a day, every day. Skips breakfast, eats some lettuce for lunch, then by 4pm “cracks” and has a biscuit… followed by the entire pack.

It’s hard to watch. Not sure how those who managed to never diet did it tbh, maybe upbringing? Luck with metabolism?

Fairislefandango · 08/03/2022 18:17

So by this thinking we’re all destined to be overweight and shouldn’t try to prevent that? Makes sense.

No, not at all. Plenty of people don't get overweight in the first place. For whatever reason - genes, upbringing etc they start with and stay with moderate eating habits and so they never get into the yo-yo of dieting.

For many (probably even most) people who do get overweight, 'trrying to prevent that' and mucking about with their metabolism, weight set point, insulin response and relationship with food actually ends up making them more overweight than they were to start with. So yes, it's quite possiy true that if they'd never started trying to diet back in their teens/20s they might well be lighter, or at least no heavier, than they are umpteen diets later at 40 or 50.

lonelyapple · 08/03/2022 15:22

The keto initial weight loss will be water weight as it's diuretic, however, I agree with you that it is the way to go and a very good diet otherwise!

scottishnames · 08/03/2022 13:25

'His ideas for the Fast800 book*, I should say. According to that BBC article.

scottishnames · 08/03/2022 13:24

This is not a criticism of anyone or anything. Just for info:

Mosely did not invent low-carb diets - they've been around for 50, 60 years. Look up Atkins Diet, John Yudkin's work, South Beach Diet, Dukan diet etc etc. Fasting has been around for millenia.

Mosely qualified as a doctor but is no longer registered, at least according to this: www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/showbiz-tv/who-michael-mosley-real-doctor-22864823 He works as a journalist and presenter.

Mosely based his ideas on the work of Dr Roy Taylor of Newcastle, who has worked with Diabetes UK : www.bbcgoodfood.com/howto/guide/what-fast-800-diet
Before writing the Fast 800 book, Mosely also wrote the Fast Diet book with another journalist, Mimi Spencer :
www.waterstones.com/book/the-fast-diet/dr-michael-mosley/mimi-spencer/9781780722375

Tigofigo · 08/03/2022 13:13

Improved muscle tone means better glucose control which is important for preventing and controlling diabetes.

I did not know this!

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/03/2022 12:36

@Proudboomer

The modern diet is what makes people overweight. Practically everything is packed with carbs as carbs are used as cheap fillers. Even so called healthy brown and seeded breads have a high carb content. Rice and potatoes all used to bulk out meals are just starch which again is carb and just turns into sugar the moment it hits your digestive tract. Pasta again is just carb and used to bulk out a meal. Pretty much every main food source eaten these days is just to high in carb and the volume we eat it at is just too much. The body doesn’t need carbs at all. It can get everything it needs from protein, fats and fibre yet even diets like slimming world are still promoting the eating of carbs. Diet foods and the increase in the labelling of meals as “no added sugar” is just another con to make us think it is better for us as when you read the nutriental value on the labelling it is still packed full of carb and carbs = sugar. The only way to lose weight and keep it off is a life style change count carbs not calories. A serving of rice should be two tablespoons max not the silver foil container full you get from the takeaway and again with pasta and potatoes or even better yet just don’t eat them.

[Looks at sushi, prawns, sesame, tomato and cucumber in lunchbox, down at significantly smaller figure compared to 10 months ago and to the online order of another 5kg bag of sushi rice on second monitor]

Only two tablespoons, you say? And no potatoes or other sources of carbs?

Well, I suppose 10 prawns and 10 sticks of cucumber with a pinch of sesame seeds would make me lose weight. But I'm not a fan of EDs. Been there, done it, got the fucked front teeth nto show for it.

Proudboomer · 08/03/2022 08:31

The modern diet is what makes people overweight. Practically everything is packed with carbs as carbs are used as cheap fillers. Even so called healthy brown and seeded breads have a high carb content.
Rice and potatoes all used to bulk out meals are just starch which again is carb and just turns into sugar the moment it hits your digestive tract.
Pasta again is just carb and used to bulk out a meal. Pretty much every main food source eaten these days is just to high in carb and the volume we eat it at is just too much.
The body doesn’t need carbs at all. It can get everything it needs from protein, fats and fibre yet even diets like slimming world are still promoting the eating of carbs.
Diet foods and the increase in the labelling of meals as “no added sugar” is just another con to make us think it is better for us as when you read the nutriental value on the labelling it is still packed full of carb and carbs = sugar.
The only way to lose weight and keep it off is a life style change count carbs not calories. A serving of rice should be two tablespoons max not the silver foil container full you get from the takeaway and again with pasta and potatoes or even better yet just don’t eat them.

Whiskyinajar · 08/03/2022 08:05

@SartresSoul no it’s not a case of not bother to prevent weight gain. It’s a case of pointing out that as a treatment for obesity diets have appalling outcomes within five years.

It would be far better if GPs gave out sports club subscriptions instead. Movement and activity improves everything all round and improved muscle tone means better glucose control which is important for preventing and controlling diabetes. It also has wonderful cardiovascular effects,

There are a lot of people who also have eating disorders …diets are a disaster for them and they’d do better wih proper MH a support to examine why they eat.

Eat less and move more is wonderful for preventing obesity but it has poor results once obesity occurs. Once that’s happened it needs different and multi pronged approaches.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/03/2022 00:16

@GayParis

Is there really no part of you that understands how utterly stupid this post is?

"X,Y & Z worked absolutely perfectly for ME, so of course it would work absolutely perfectly for YOU (a completely separate genetic entity with a completely separate familial history and an entirely different set of life circumstances)"

Umm, I'm not entirely clear on this - are you ripping into me for saying what works for me (and what didn't/wouldn't) or into the OP for saying what works for her?

If it's me, I'm not saying it will work for anybody else at all. But I don't think I'm that special or unique.

TheTeenageYears · 08/03/2022 00:14

They are diets which work for you. Everyone's bodies are different and there is no one size fits all when it comes to diets.

GayParis · 07/03/2022 23:49

Is there really no part of you that understands how utterly stupid this post is?

"X,Y & Z worked absolutely perfectly for ME, so of course it would work absolutely perfectly for YOU (a completely separate genetic entity with a completely separate familial history and an entirely different set of life circumstances)"

NeverDropYourMooncup · 07/03/2022 23:30

Good that they work for you.

Personally, I've found it far more successful to do a bit of exercise for my own mental health/it feels good plus some strength and generally eat things that aren't ultra processed (but not cut them out altogether, as there are still days when only a GF pizza base with chorizo, tomato, cheese, mushrooms, onion and chilli oil will do - or the protein shake in the morning taken purely because I don't do food at 5.15am).

Seeing as I've gone from supermorbidly obese to a kilo off overweight since last May without feeling hungry, uncomfortable, restricted, dizzy, tired, headachey, or in any way unpleasant, I think it's working rather well.

I have (lightheartedly) given it a nickname. It's Eat Better, Move More.

Eating better for me means what I actually want, what looks pretty on a plate, what has multiple vegetables, the protein I fancy, the fat I fancy, however many carbs I feel I need, the flavours I feel I need. It means thinking of how to add one (or two, or three) extra vegetables sometimes. Of how if I feel like I need two huge jacket potatoes, I bloody well have two jacket potatoes with whatever filling I want. And as many olives, red pepper and onion as I want in the tuna mayonnaise because I really like olives, red pepper and onion in it. And how avocado toast tastes so much better with smoked bacon and a fried egg on top at the weekend.

Move more is fairly self explanatory. Not by much, as injuries aren't fun. But any moving is better than no moving. And if it involves a bit of daylight and fresh air, even better.

If I could just manage to chuck in sleeping for more than 5 hours a night, everything would be awesome. Then it would become my ultimate goal lifestyle;

Eat Better. Move More. Sleep Well.

Luredbyapomegranate · 07/03/2022 22:10

[quote SkinnyChaiLatte]@AllOfUsAreDead You're talking bollocks. You can't eat 5 chocolate bars a day and syn them. Most people can have 5-15 syns a day and a chocolate bar would have around 10 syns in it.[/quote]
Syns…. Oh God.

Swipe left for the next trending thread