Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leaving odd seats empty on planes

211 replies

FawnFrenchieMum · 07/03/2022 10:00

I actually didn’t think it allowed you to do this (leave a single window seat of the middle seat of three)
Am I being unreasonable to this leaving single seats like this all over the plane shouldn't be allowed?

Leaving odd seats empty on planes
OP posts:
Scianel · 07/03/2022 13:28

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing that must have been an extremely comfortable and satisfying flight Smile

As I said in a pp we don't do the aisle and window thing any more, I think probably just did it once or twice years ago, just to avoid any awkwardness or skirmishes over the aisle seat! Would definitely never talk over some poor stranger either.

Rosehugger · 07/03/2022 13:28

Quite interesting this summer. Flew out on cough Ryanair and we were none of us sitting together which was fine as we didn't want to pay the extra. I swapped with a boy of about nine so he could sit next to his dad but they didn't ask me, I offered when I saw the boy going towards the back and looking a bit sad about it.

Coming back the stewardess actually made sure that children under 12 were sitting with at least one adult who was in charge of them - which are the actual air passenger regulations, I believe, and even asked my daughter who was 12 then and looks older, and was happy to sit with people she doesn't know, how old she was and if she was ok. Going out I'd just swapped informally and other passengers had too.

Just an observation. Even though it no longer affects us it would be nice if airlines actually complied with the regulations all the time.

Dinoteeth · 07/03/2022 13:27

@AchillesPoirot

There are only certain seats allowed for children due to the oxygen I think. If it has to drop down
Yes completely agree, only one infant per row of three, but it might be only every other row. I also don't think infants are allowed in the aisle seats because of the difficulty in getting out for other passengers
JustLyra · 07/03/2022 13:26

We've just had the exact same with tui, seems really weird. I'm thinking maybe we can negotiate a swap with whoever is in the aisle when we get on the plane

It’s a pain with them. I had this last time we travelled, but it was my DS who was in the aisle seat. He’s only 10 so I didn’t want him in at the window, but the couple with the toddler really wanted to be on the aisle. It didn’t help anyone not being able to pick the seats they wanted originally.

Scianel · 07/03/2022 13:25

@Lou98 god no I'd be far too conscious of being inconsiderate, I'd just be quietly reading my kindle. I'd feel bad for you and not want to make your trip worse.

Tbh I don't think we've done that for years anyway - for long haul we'd probably book the two in a row seats at the back or something and short haul just book an aisle and a middle.

gogohm · 07/03/2022 13:24

Looks normal to me, I always book an aisle seat

MayMorris · 07/03/2022 13:24

Depends on destination. If it’s a major city and therefore high business travel this is absolutely normal. Some single travellers prefer window and some aisle. Aisle always got booked up more on long haul so people didn’t need to scramble over some stranger asleep especially if you’re a woman. Aisle seats more popular on shorter flights.
No business traveller in their right mind would book a middle seat voluntarily

AchillesPoirot · 07/03/2022 13:24

There are only certain seats allowed for children due to the oxygen I think. If it has to drop down

notimagain · 07/03/2022 13:23

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

Getting off a plane quickly can make a big difference to how long you're queuing for immigration, taxis, etc.

I guess it depends on the airport - I used to fly once a week from EMA to DUB - it made almost zero difference whether I rushed or didn't - in fact rushing to get off disadvantaged me on the rare occasions we were bussed to the terminal as fist on the bus meant I wasn't first off it. Mostly these "advantages" are just like people who push past you to get on the tube - they are largely illusory.

As you correctly say it depends on the airport..if you are disembarking via a jetty it can make a big difference.
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/03/2022 13:23

@Scianel I’m very claustrophobic too and can’t really fly without an aisle, so again i always book in advance.

I agree that it’s the talking over people that’s the issue, not that a couple might have different needs and want to sit in aisle and window as though not travelling together.

Once I flew with exh who was determined not to hook in advance, it’s a waste of money etc. So I booked my aisle and he left his to chance. On the day I had an empty row of three seats (just by chance) and he was wedged in the worst middle seat of all, right at the back with extra small leg space Grin

AchillesPoirot · 07/03/2022 13:23

I travelled recently and the cabin crew said no one could move seats as the flight wasn’t full and the seats were set for balance and load.

Could it be that?

ShadowPuppets · 07/03/2022 13:23

DH and I are travelling in May with an 18 month old and a 6 week old (yes, we’re insane). We’re not allowed to both have an infant on our laps and be in the same row of 3, so we’ve booked either side of an aisle (also means he’s less likely to drive anyone mad with a wriggly 18mo). I felt really bad when we booked our seats as it meant we were leaving middle seats empty in an otherwise booked row but what can you do, it’s the airlines rule!

nearlyspringyay · 07/03/2022 13:20

@BarbaraGordon if I've paid for my seat why should I negotiate a swap?

nearlyspringyay · 07/03/2022 13:19

You have no idea who has booked what - family group / solo flyers / whatever. If I'm going to pay for my seat I get on asap and book them. For four we take x2 aisle + middle on a 3x3 or we take a middle 4 on a 3x4x3. I don't want to sit in the window, my kids don't and they would definitely piss off anyone on the aisle if we had to clamber over every time they needed the toilet.

If I didn't have to pay I'd take the allocation, if I'm paying I'll pay for what I want.

BarbaraGordon · 07/03/2022 13:17

@FTMworrier

Literally had this argument with TUI this weekend. Family of 3, but LO is 14months so only two seats. Paying to select our seats and it wouldn’t allow us to select an aisle seat and middle seat. We tried to choose this incase LO is being a pain on the fight and we need to walk around with him etc. but the system literally blocked us and wouldn’t allow us to select. So we are having to select window and middle seat and have to pay for them even though we don’t want to sit there 🤷🏻‍♀️
We've just had the exact same with tui, seems really weird. I'm thinking maybe we can negotiate a swap with whoever is in the aisle when we get on the plane
JudgeJ · 07/03/2022 13:17

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

If I was left in the middle seat and people tried to talk across me I’d object to that immediately.

I’d want the man to vacate his aisle seat (it’s always the man in the aisle seat in these sort of couples) so I could have some peace, and that’s the seat I’d have wanted to begin with.

Hopefully the man would tell you where to get off for your arrogance, reserve your seat earlier if you're so picky. We often booked aisle and window but would manage the trip with little communication.
Ted27 · 07/03/2022 13:15

@Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov

that did make me laugh on an otherwise depressingly trivial non issue

Lou98 · 07/03/2022 13:14

@Scianel and that's absolutely fine - as long as you don't then proceed to have conversations over the person in the middle seat and pass food/drink etc.
I booked the middle seat in that flight because I didn't want a window seat, it makes no difference to me if I'm in the aisle or middle but I have anxiety and it makes me panic sitting at the window when I can see out so I wasn't willing to swap with her for the window seat. I do think it's extremely rude to then have a conversation over me with her Partner in the aisle seat. Especially in that case it was a late night flight, I was tired and couldn't relax for them talking and passing eachother things

Dinoteeth · 07/03/2022 13:12

@Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov

Guys. Can we all take a moment to appreciate what is actually happening here? Right now. It's an airlines seat thread. COVID must be over. It's been at least 2 years since I've seen one.
That is a very fair point!
Rosehugger · 07/03/2022 13:10

Personally I think the default should be you book and get your seat(s) allocated then, by default with the people you booked with unless the aeroplane is already full, and you only pay extra if you want to sit right at the front, in an extra leg room seat or have other specifications unless it is as a result of a disability. As with trains. And the further you book in advance, the cheaper it is and easier it is to book seats.

melj1213 · 07/03/2022 13:09

@BoredBoredBoredB

I don’t think two people travelling together should be able to book aisle and window seats leaving a gap between them. It just seems greedy to hope that nobody goes between you.
But how do you know when just looking at the seat allocations that the people are travelling together? It could be solo travellers. Equally there may be different needs within the same group - I'm tall so prefer to pay extra for the extra leg room seats where possible, but some airlines charge £10/15 extra for these seats so whenever I travelled with ExDH and DD they would sit in the regular seats and I would "upgrade" on short haul flights because it wasn't worth the extra £20/30 for us all to sit in the bulkhead seats when they were perfectly comfortable two rows back

I often travel alone, if I'm booking a flight and see a row around my preferred seat area with only one seat booked then I will take the vacant window/aisle seat rather than book a seat in an empty row. I don't take the middle seat as I always think it's weird to specifically choose a seat right next to a stranger when there are options to give everyone a little space.

In my head this leaves the full rows for larger parties and if I'm lucky then nobody books the middle seat and both me and my seat mate get a bit extra room. Sometimes you can also see that a group of 4 has probably booked their seats together and decided to take A-C on one side and D across the aisle, in which case I will take F because I prefer the window seat.

Mychitchatdays · 07/03/2022 13:08

Yes it happens. I always place someone in between them. Then they complain that they want to sit together and don't want someone in between. Teaches them to select practical seats next time.

TrashyPanda · 07/03/2022 13:08

[quote FawnFrenchieMum]@Arabellla, that was my bad punctuation, I meant it to read, that people have made good points re single travelers still wanting a choice of seats but my guess is its a couple hoping no one else sits there so they have three seats. (If I was travelling alone, an empty seat at the side of me would be bliss!), not that its two separate single travelers.

This is a very standard holiday destination flight, highly unlikely to be business travelers IMO.[/quote]
Single people go on holiday too.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 07/03/2022 13:07

Guys. Can we all take a moment to appreciate what is actually happening here? Right now. It's an airlines seat thread. COVID must be over. It's been at least 2 years since I've seen one.

Scianel · 07/03/2022 13:06

@Lou98 no unfortunately not as I have claustrophobia and need the aisle seat which is why I'm pretty obsessive about advance booking.

Swipe left for the next trending thread