Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Confronted mother about her numerous affairs…….

84 replies

ChamberPotOfSecrets · 06/03/2022 20:45

Which is why my father left her. I found this out at age 45! She now wants nothing to do with me.

WIBU to be angry and confront her about it?

OP posts:
WalkingOnTheCracks · 22/03/2022 13:23

Do we have to tell our kids every minute detail of our lives?

No, but they have a right to ask. Especially in the circumstance where they've been affected.

The question isn't whether the mother has the right not to tell her. It's whether the daughter has the right to bring it up.

speakout · 22/03/2022 11:07

Yes but it's weird that a loving mother wouldn't want to clear something up or explain the reasons, if asked about it by their own grown-up child. I just can't imagine being asked such a question by my own child and both refusing to discuss it and cutting them off.

There are lots of things parents may not discuss with their children.
Affairs, financial problems, their sex life, intimate health, traumatic past events.
It's not about keeping a secret, it's just about not disclosing.
I have tons of stuff that my adult children don't know about me- and many of these things I wouldn't discuss with friends either.

My adult kids remain my children - they are not my friends.

Would you really disclose everything to your adult children?

The fact you ( for example- I am not giving anything away about myself) were assaulted/raped/ had a teen abortion/ have genital herpes/ caught syphilis/ used to be a swinger/sex worker/

Do we have to tell our kids every minute detail of our lives?

Turningpurple · 22/03/2022 10:04

I guarantee it would be ' The sleazy disgrace deserves to be NC with you ' , and 'Oh your poor DM'

That would be awful advice to give.

Op is pulled into the issue of her parents marriage breakdown.

Op (and most of mumsnet) are adults and should know one person's side is often not the whole truth.

Anyone who suggests ending a relationship with a parent in these circumstances, especially, without speaking to them really needs to sort themselves out. It's awful advice.

HoneyBeeHappy · 22/03/2022 10:01

I’ll quote this next time someone here posts about their husband having an affair, and point out that their poor husband may have felt trapped and wanted affection. I’m sure that’ll go down well. and it’s entirely possible that even women who come on here to talk about their dh’s affairs that there were issues in the marriage which led to those affairs.

Obviously no-one is going to say that to a woman who has come here for advice re her husband’s affair, but life is rarely black and white. And while some of those affairs will have been as a result of the cheating party just wanting to have their cake and eat it, there will undoubtedly be some who come to the relationships board whose husband’s affair just wasn’t that simple.

yogafairy · 22/03/2022 10:01

@twominutesmore that's not the only reason for not discussing it at all. How can any of us know what her mothers reasons are?

twominutesmore · 22/03/2022 09:58

@yogafairy

My ex husband said that I had, and I quote, 'numerous affairs'. I have never had an affair. He however did and that's why I told him to leave. That's not the story he likes to tell though.

Maybe she did or maybe she didn't. It's her life and she made the choices and she has to live with them. It's not for you to confront her about it anymore than your life choices are up for her to debate surely.

But it's not the same. Your ex told a lie about you. If op has been told a lie, her mum could say so.

The only reason for not wanting to discuss something is because you know that discussing it will make you look even worse than refusing to do so.

twominutesmore · 22/03/2022 09:55

"You can't force another human being to discuss anything they don't want to.
Even people accused of criminal charges have the right to remain silent."

Yes but it's weird that a loving mother wouldn't want to clear something up or explain the reasons, if asked about it by their own grown-up child. I just can't imagine being asked such a question by my own child and both refusing to discuss it and cutting them off.

TabithaTittlemouse · 22/03/2022 09:09

Your title says that you confronted her but your question is should you confront her.

What would confronting her achieve?

yogafairy · 22/03/2022 09:02

So what if there are double standards? Women have to put up with double standards from men every single bastard day. So why would we put up with it but when it's against men we aren't allowed? Yeah thats a big fat NOPE from me.

Bostromani · 22/03/2022 08:28

Exactly.

No way would the great and good of Mumsnet be defending a father that had numerous affairs , and had been confronted.

I guarantee it would be ' The sleazy disgrace deserves to be NC with you ' , and 'Oh your poor DM' .

yogafairy · 22/03/2022 08:18

My ex husband said that I had, and I quote, 'numerous affairs'. I have never had an affair. He however did and that's why I told him to leave. That's not the story he likes to tell though.

Maybe she did or maybe she didn't. It's her life and she made the choices and she has to live with them. It's not for you to confront her about it anymore than your life choices are up for her to debate surely.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 22/03/2022 08:15

Jesus the double standards on here are astounding

Yeah, it’s jaw-dropping.

The most pernicious part is the ‘well, we need to know more about the marriage before we judge’ attitude.

As opposed to ‘say not a word more, we’ve heard enough, he’s a lowlife bastard.’

SleeplessInEngland · 22/03/2022 08:12

Of course it’s the child’s business: they were directly affected.

Whether the mum will actually talk about it is another matter.

speakout · 22/03/2022 08:10

*I find it odd that people are saying you have no right to speak to your mum about serial cheating.

It's not surprising that this has upset OP and, of course, she has the right to discuss how her mum's actions have impacted her.*

I'm sorry but I don't agree.

You can't force another human being to discuss anything they don't want to.
Even people accused of criminal charges have the right to remain silent.

gannett · 22/03/2022 08:10

Surprising amount of affair apologism in this thread.

I do actually think relationships and infidelity are complex, no one knows what goes on behind closed doors etc etc, if I was a family friend I'd keep my beak out. But these are OP's parents, of course infidelity in their marriage will have affected her (and will continue to do so). You'd be furious on behalf of the one being cheated on, for starters. She's perfectly justified to confront her mum about this (though probably shouldn't expect proper answers or a decent response)

donquixotedelamancha · 22/03/2022 08:03

I find it odd that people are saying you have no right to speak to your mum about serial cheating.

It's not surprising that this has upset OP and, of course, she has the right to discuss how her mum's actions have impacted her.

Sunshineandflipflops · 22/03/2022 07:51

This is what worries me. My exh had an affair which ended our marriage. Our dc were 10 and 11 at the time and I didn't want to tell them the gory details as they were too young and too distraught to understand (how could they understand when I didn't), so we told them we weren't making each other happy anymore.

I have said to my ex though that as they get older, if they ever ask questions about why we separated then I won't lie to them.

I don't know if they will ever ask but that's something my ex has to be prepared for if they do.

I think having a conversation with your mum about it is ok but obviously you can't change the past and you might hear things that make you upset/uncomfortable about your parents marriage.

speakout · 22/03/2022 07:32

I would very much like to know the details of my sister becoming engaged and leaving home at 14. My mother then had a nervous breakdown and my father became terminally ill - I effectively then became a carer.
I was 8 and although I was witness to the conflict I was too young to understand the situation completely.
I have tried to raise the topic so I can better understand my upbringing but she makes it clear the events are not up for discussion.
I have tried to piece things together, but without her help I can't.

I have to accept that not discussing certain topics is my mother's right- even though they affected me.

twominutesmore · 22/03/2022 07:31

"But the parent has the right not to discuss her private business."

Yes but can't be surprised if they've maintained a different reason for the marriage ending for many years.

twominutesmore · 22/03/2022 07:28

@BottleBrushTree

So your dad says everything is your mums fault, she had affairs and Everything Wrong in the World is Her Fault, and he was Mr Perfect Husband, Father Human Being et al. It’s really hard to believe you didn’t notice him wearing his angel halo all through your childhood.

Come on OP, you say you’re 45 not 5, you must know by this stage in your life that’s not how relationships work. Nothing is that black and white and one person’s truth is another one’s lie. Don’t behave like a child.

How do you know her dad told her? It could be anyone in the family who knew about the affair.

I think he would have told her a long time before now if he wanted to cause trouble.

Why didn't her mum attempt to explain I wonder. Even 'I did but there's a lot more to it than that' would be more reasonable than cutting off a child for asking the question.

speakout · 22/03/2022 07:26

As an adult you can talk to a parent about anything you wish.

But the parent has the right not to discuss her private business.

Yellownightmare · 22/03/2022 07:24

@Sarahcoggles

YANBU OP. 2 minutes on the relationship board here will show how devastating infidelity is for children. You have every right to be angry. Some posters are conveniently forgetting this, and making it all about your mother as some victim who was in an abusive relationship and just wanted affection.
Absolutely. And she has the opportunity to state her case. Doesn't mean she has to go into all the details. To refuse to talk about it makes it doubly bad. I'm not surprised you feel upset OP. I'm sorry if it hurt your childhood OP.

Many people on MN are either projecting their own issues or are obsessed with the idea it's ALWAYS best to 'let sleeping dogs lie'. It very often isn't and causes a lot more pain in the long term.

Walkingalot · 22/03/2022 07:21

I think it depends on what sort of childhood you had and if she gave you a different narrative, i.e. that he had affairs or treated her badly etc.
At the end of the day, parents split for many reasons. Maybe she tried to make things work for your sake rather than leave after the first affair.
Is there a back story to all this? Usually other people's private business is just that - not up for anyone else's scrutiny.

Sarahcoggles · 22/03/2022 07:16

@LakieLady

Other than the 2 parties to a marriage, no-one else really knows what goes on within that marriage. And the 2 people in it will often see things very differently.

No-one has affairs in a happy marriage, and there can be 1001 reasons why people feel unable to leave an unhappy one.

And I think that as an adult, you need to cut your mum some slack.

Another affair-apologist post that’ll go down a treat on the next “my husband is having an affair” post in Relationships.

Give me strength!

Sarahcoggles · 22/03/2022 07:13

YANBU OP.
2 minutes on the relationship board here will show how devastating infidelity is for children. You have every right to be angry. Some posters are conveniently forgetting this, and making it all about your mother as some victim who was in an abusive relationship and just wanted affection.