Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel distressed and heartbroken re Ukraine’s increasingly desperate pleas for help?

363 replies

UltraLightfly · 06/03/2022 20:30

You can hear the desperation in their president’s (and former presidents) voices now. They are BEGGING for physical help. Begging for a no-fly zone to be implemented.

I KNOW we can’t do anything as it’ll cause WW3, but tonight, listening to a former presidents and the current presidents desperate pleas is actually quite distressing. Heartbreaking. Those poor people being left to their fate with the Russians Sad

OP posts:
shreddednips · 07/03/2022 00:06

@Sarah13xx

I can’t stop thinking about all of them. Also can’t stop thinking of the animals left behind and worrying that many will be locked in houses without food dying a slow death as people would be too afraid to leave them on the street. At least outside they might have had a fighting chance of someone helping though 😢 It’s like the situation just can’t get anymore sad then you hear something else. This is literally happening right this second ☹️ There were stories of people being trapped under buildings etc. The video on sky news of them coming for the reporters car and them having to abandon it and run is completely terrifying! Makes it way more real 😞

I feel like no one can even make a prediction on Putin’s next move anymore. I do think about it all day though that he it metaphorically just hovering over the big red button with the power to end my life any time he likes. It’s so bizarre as in a civilised country we have never had to think like this at all before ever 😕 I’m genuinely sitting mapping a way out for us wondering if moving to Australia would be the best bet 🤦🏼‍♀️

This anxiety is understandable, but remember that he isn't sitting there twiddling the red button between his fingers like a set of car keys. We have been here before, during the Cold War and the Cuban missile crisis. This nuclear sabre rattling is terrifying, but brinkmanship has been used before to try and intimidate the other side into backing down. Giving the impression of being crazy can make the effect even more intimidating, but that doesn't mean he really IS crazy, beyond being an absolute evil bastard.

Even if he was actually totally bananas and felt like going out with a bang, he would need the cooperation of others to do it. And they probably don't feel like being blown up just to let him do so.

I genuinely think the sabre rattling is a tactic to try and get the west to back off and test to see if it has the balls to stand firm, to see what he can get away with. It's meant to scare us so that we lose faith in the plan to sanction him and supply arms to Ukraine.

Furries · 07/03/2022 00:05

@TellMeMoreHellebore

to be honest we are just delaying it

ww3 is inevitable. it will happen because it wont stop at ukraine.

herding the whole of ukraine into other countries....feels like he's rounding us all up. also feels like we[ve not yet met the might of the Russian forces. he's sent out kids in antiquated tanks. wheres the bigger, better tanks?

These kinds of posts are completely baseless and are no “help” whatsoever.
ClaudineClare · 06/03/2022 23:59

I am worried that the narrative is beginning to turn in favour of escalation. Some elements of the media and social media (including MN) are beginning to push a pro-war agenda and accusing those who are anti-war of being pro-Russian. Escalation of this conflict is not the answer.

CPL593H · 06/03/2022 23:58

@Sarah13xx

I can’t stop thinking about all of them. Also can’t stop thinking of the animals left behind and worrying that many will be locked in houses without food dying a slow death as people would be too afraid to leave them on the street. At least outside they might have had a fighting chance of someone helping though 😢 It’s like the situation just can’t get anymore sad then you hear something else. This is literally happening right this second ☹️ There were stories of people being trapped under buildings etc. The video on sky news of them coming for the reporters car and them having to abandon it and run is completely terrifying! Makes it way more real 😞

I feel like no one can even make a prediction on Putin’s next move anymore. I do think about it all day though that he it metaphorically just hovering over the big red button with the power to end my life any time he likes. It’s so bizarre as in a civilised country we have never had to think like this at all before ever 😕 I’m genuinely sitting mapping a way out for us wondering if moving to Australia would be the best bet 🤦🏼‍♀️

We have had to think like this before . WW2 and the Cuban Missile Crisis for starters. It was OK then and I really believe that there is every hope it will be OK now.

There is no big red button, there are as far as anyone knows layers of military he would have to go through to implement a nuclear strike and I would put good money on all of them being more grounded than him.

It is pointless telling you not to worry but please try not to worry too much Flowers

shreddednips · 06/03/2022 23:58

@LizzieMacQueen

Oh I know it's hardly a solution but I'm think out loud about what would result in the fewest deaths & casualties. It's a cowards way faced with a bully but I'd rather be a live coward than a dead hero!

As for, well Putin won't stop there - maybe - but who's to say he will?

Isn't trying to de escalate a better option than escalating? (NFZ).

You're right about deescalation being the ideal goal. But not at the expense of Ukraine's sovereignty. That would show that he can take whatever he likes with impunity. A success would embolden him, it might 'solve' the immediate problem but if he decided to set his sights on further expansion, the same problem exists and Ukraine has lost its sovereignty to boot.

I don't think he would have stopped at Ukraine, I do think the plan was originally to retake more countries subsequently. I do sincerely hope that he has lost enough credibility with his own people and enough money that it will curtail his plans, it would be great if he just dropped dead.

I agree that deescalation with an 'off ramp' so that he can claim some kind of victory at home would be the best outcome, but that off ramp can't be to just allow him to take Ukraine.

Clarabe1 · 06/03/2022 23:53

@LizzieMacQueen there are worse things than death. Living under the rule of a Putin for one, I would fight to the death for my rights and for those of future generations. I don’t think you can begin to comprehend a life without freedom. Why do you think the Ukrainians are fighting so hard?

Sarah13xx · 06/03/2022 23:51

I can’t stop thinking about all of them. Also can’t stop thinking of the animals left behind and worrying that many will be locked in houses without food dying a slow death as people would be too afraid to leave them on the street. At least outside they might have had a fighting chance of someone helping though 😢 It’s like the situation just can’t get anymore sad then you hear something else. This is literally happening right this second ☹️ There were stories of people being trapped under buildings etc. The video on sky news of them coming for the reporters car and them having to abandon it and run is completely terrifying! Makes it way more real 😞

I feel like no one can even make a prediction on Putin’s next move anymore. I do think about it all day though that he it metaphorically just hovering over the big red button with the power to end my life any time he likes. It’s so bizarre as in a civilised country we have never had to think like this at all before ever 😕 I’m genuinely sitting mapping a way out for us wondering if moving to Australia would be the best bet 🤦🏼‍♀️

CPL593H · 06/03/2022 23:50

Sorry, old habits die hard, Ukraine. I am learning better ways.

CPL593H · 06/03/2022 23:49

@LizzieMacQueen

There is a solution. Let him take Ukraine without further fighting on the understanding of two things,

Those who don't want to live under his rule are allowed a safe exit.

Any 'western' country is allowed to join NATO asap so they have that protection going forward.

This is never going to happen, truly it isn't. However, he's trying to recreate the old Soviet/Imperial Russian borders and (thankfully, due to brave people) he has bitten off rather too much with the Ukraine.

We (very big we) might need to find a face saving compromise in the shorter term, but Putin is finished, one way or another, in the longer.

LizzieMacQueen · 06/03/2022 23:48

Oh I know it's hardly a solution but I'm think out loud about what would result in the fewest deaths & casualties. It's a cowards way faced with a bully but I'd rather be a live coward than a dead hero!

As for, well Putin won't stop there - maybe - but who's to say he will?

Isn't trying to de escalate a better option than escalating? (NFZ).

Rhannion · 06/03/2022 23:46

@LizzieMacQueen

There is a solution. Let him take Ukraine without further fighting on the understanding of two things,

Those who don't want to live under his rule are allowed a safe exit.

Any 'western' country is allowed to join NATO asap so they have that protection going forward.

Why the hell should people have to abandon their country to a fucking nut job like Putin? Would you seriously just let that happen? I’m damn sure I would not. Women in Scotland are fighting our government about our rights and I’m sure we would fight to save our country too for all it’s faults now if we were invaded by a nut job’s army.
shreddednips · 06/03/2022 23:44

@LizzieMacQueen

There is a solution. Let him take Ukraine without further fighting on the understanding of two things,

Those who don't want to live under his rule are allowed a safe exit.

Any 'western' country is allowed to join NATO asap so they have that protection going forward.

I don't agree, Ukraine is not 'ours' to bargain with. Why should Ukrainians accept someone taking their country from them? It is up to nobody but Ukraine.

When it comes to whether Putin would invade other countries, I'm on the fence about this. I expect he would ideally want to, but whether he CAN is a different matter entirely. First, he's shown the world that the Russian military isn't what we believed it to be and he's spent a colossal amount of money in the process, and Russia's economy is tremendously damaged. Also, I suspect that invading Ukraine would not have been the red line for the people around him to seriously challenge his ability to rule, but invading a NATO country may will be.

Sadly, I do agree that NATO cannot impose a no-fly zone. I don't think it's a matter of anyone's children being more important than anyone else's- if a major conflict were to break out, no one's children would be safe. The children who have sought refuge in other European countries deserve to be safe in them; it doesn't help them to risk the conflict spilling over.

Clarabe1 · 06/03/2022 23:42

@LizzieMacQueen that is not a solution! You cannot sacrifice Ukraine and think everything will be ok. He is going for the ex soviet countries, who are you willing to sacrifice next? Moldova, Latvia? He is not going to stop. Same as Hitler after taking Czechoslovakia. He guaranteed he would not annex another country, a year later he invaded Poland. You cannot appease a madman. Appeasement is NEVER a solution. I would hope somebody wouldn’t give the UK away to save their own skin. Wouldn’t you?

oakleaffy · 06/03/2022 23:40

@LizzieMacQueen

There is a solution. Let him take Ukraine without further fighting on the understanding of two things,

Those who don't want to live under his rule are allowed a safe exit.

Any 'western' country is allowed to join NATO asap so they have that protection going forward.

People will argue with the logic of this and say ''But Putin will take Paris next''.
LizzieSiddal · 06/03/2022 23:39

TellMeMoreHellebore

@LizzieSiddal just the UK? us alone?

Of course not, which is why I said the UK much “join in”.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 06/03/2022 23:39

@oakleaffy - there's been plently of posters saying - and I paraphrase - 'we shouldn't do anything to escalate the situation that might put MY children in danger' as though that's OK. I can only assume that those posters didn't watch the news tonight and see the dead children lying in the street. Or the fathers having to say goodbye to their families as they put them on trains to safety. Or all the fear and the crying and the fucking death. But, yeah, as long as your kids are OK. Fucking hell. You have to be an arsehole to write something like that.

RantyAunty · 06/03/2022 23:38

It's damned if you do, damned if you don't.

Intervene and it may end up WWIII

Don't intervene and he may be encouraged to go further as he believed no one will risk doing anything.

CPL593H · 06/03/2022 23:37

[quote TellMeMoreHellebore]@uneven which country are you posting from?[/quote]
Good question. I am wary of anyone who makes the current horrible situation entirely about the awfulness of Britain, because it really isn't.

LizzieMacQueen · 06/03/2022 23:35

There is a solution. Let him take Ukraine without further fighting on the understanding of two things,

Those who don't want to live under his rule are allowed a safe exit.

Any 'western' country is allowed to join NATO asap so they have that protection going forward.

SecretKeeper1 · 06/03/2022 23:35

Soy shush now @uneven. I don’t know which magical and perfect country you come from, but ordinary Britons are doing what they can by donating items, money and time to try to help Ukrainians. The generosity of the ordinary public is absolutely amazing so knock it off with the “all Britons are heartless” stance, it makes you sounds thick as shit.

oakleaffy · 06/03/2022 23:31

@StepAwayFromGoogling

Everyone on this thread needs to understand that the dead children that we see lying in the street on the news every night are NOT less important than your children. Their parents didn't love them any less, they are no less worthy of protecting than your own children.
Nobody is saying this? What people are saying is that if WW3 breaks out {No Fly Zone} there will be millions more killed. It's a ghastly situation , and could indeed happen to us if things escalate. Truly lucky are those in NZ or Australia, far, far away from European madness.
TheKeatingFive · 06/03/2022 23:27

I'm not saying I have any answers, but if people think Putin's happy to take Ukraine, then tootle off leaving everyone else alone, then they're deluded.

Where will he stop? Who the fuck knows.

TellMeMoreHellebore · 06/03/2022 23:26

@uneven which country are you posting from?

TellMeMoreHellebore · 06/03/2022 23:26

@LizzieSiddal just the UK? us alone?

StepAwayFromGoogling · 06/03/2022 23:25

You might know that, @TellMeMoreHellebore but a shit load of people on here don't seem to.