Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel distressed and heartbroken re Ukraine’s increasingly desperate pleas for help?

363 replies

UltraLightfly · 06/03/2022 20:30

You can hear the desperation in their president’s (and former presidents) voices now. They are BEGGING for physical help. Begging for a no-fly zone to be implemented.

I KNOW we can’t do anything as it’ll cause WW3, but tonight, listening to a former presidents and the current presidents desperate pleas is actually quite distressing. Heartbreaking. Those poor people being left to their fate with the Russians Sad

OP posts:
alltheapples · 07/03/2022 01:05

@Willyoujustbequiet there have been two negotiated ceasefires to allow time for women and children trapped in basements with no or little food and water, to leave. Both times soldiers have continued shooting and shelling in spite of the negotiated ceasefire.
Putin has no interest in sticking to negotiated agreements.

Putin might agree if Ukraine surrender he will not take revenge. Then he would do it anyway. What are the west going to do? They have already shown they will not attack Russia or intervene directly in Ukraine. He would have nothing to lose given that Russias conduct in Ukraine is already being investigated for a number of war crimes. What would one more be?

So sorry but I think you are being very naive to think Putin will adhere to any agreed ceasefire unless there is military might externally to enforce it.

And if you have been following this you will know Zelensky has been desperately trying to get a ceasefire agreement, drafting in people like Isreals President to mediate. But Putin will not agree to anything.

So what you are asking for is not a negotiated agreement, that is being tried and Putin has not been interested. But a total surrender by Ukraine. It would be a bloodbath. And the Ukranians will know that.

Booklover3 · 07/03/2022 00:59

Oh for goodness sake. Ukraine can’t surrender… and the rest of the world can’t be held hostage by the threats of one mad man who will then go on to destroy more countries because we did nothing and let him.

If we allow that then what’s the point?!

Besides that there’s lots of people saying that Ukraine can’t win… why can’t they? The Russians in their substandard equipment don’t seem to be doing a very organised job of it so they? They seem very, very inexperienced in combat… and outdated in technology.

I wouldn’t write Ukraine off just yet.

Furries · 07/03/2022 00:57

[quote Willyoujustbequiet]@JulesRimetStillGleaming

If we were invaded by Putin I'd say the same thing. Surrender to save lives, prevent a nuclear holocaust and wait it out until the bastard is dead.[/quote]
Great idea, everything I’ve read make living in an occupied country sound positively quaint.

Am guessing you’re female? Maybe do a couple of quick searches on how women tend to fare in occupied countries.

Then think again about why the Ukrainians do not want to give up their country.

Willyoujustbequiet · 07/03/2022 00:57

@alltheapples

I'm not that naive. There would need to be a negotiated settlement of some sort. But I still think surrender will save many more lives than the path we are on at the moment.

alltheapples · 07/03/2022 00:55

And if I was Ukrainian I would rather die trying to win against Putin, than surrender and be murdered.

alltheapples · 07/03/2022 00:54

@Willyoujustbequiet

Ukraine needs to surrender. He is a madman and will destroy the world. Millions will die.

Let Putin think he's won. Play the long game. He's ill and in his 70s. Surrender will save lives until such time his evil has died.

I think there would be a massacre of civilians of Ukraine surrendered. You seem to think they can surrender and there will be no retaliation. I do not think that will happen. Putin will want revenge against every Ukrainian who fought against his army in any small way. Thousands of people will be murdered.
Willyoujustbequiet · 07/03/2022 00:48

@JulesRimetStillGleaming

If we were invaded by Putin I'd say the same thing. Surrender to save lives, prevent a nuclear holocaust and wait it out until the bastard is dead.

Furries · 07/03/2022 00:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Furries · 07/03/2022 00:42

@nothingbutsnow

I was wondering earlier today, whether there would be wars at all if the main pattern for the world was feminine and if so, what would they look like

Like MN Grin

Just a touch of levity to lighten the mood.

Sorry, but this made me laugh.

Some idiot has plonked his tank on my drive, shall I block him in and have a glass of wine? I’ll do a diagram in a minute.

CPL593H · 07/03/2022 00:35

@Iflyaway

It’s so bizarre as in a civilised country we have never had to think like this at all before ever

As CPL593H says, you were obviously not around in the 80's of the last century.

We had the "cold war" between Russia and USA. I grew up with it.

Never thought it would be a feature of 2022. Absolutely terrifying.

To the PP who is pregnant, try to limit your exposure to the news. I was pregnant when the Balkan war was going on. I just couldn't watch it.

Yes, we did grow up with it. Also, my husband (older than me) narrowly avoided being machine gunned by a Stuka in his pram on a quiet street in an East Anglian coastal town, in 1945. This stuff is sadly endless.

I think those of us who lived through the Cold War feel a certain outrage that it is happening again (with knobs on) and much sympathy for those younger who are experiencing it for the first time. We have to think most of the people of Ukraine though, because our imaginings are currently their reality.

WomblingWilma · 07/03/2022 00:32

I feel sick to my stomach seeing those latest pictures in the news tonight of families dead on the pavement obviously killed while in the act of fleeing with their suitcases and their cat they were trying to save in a carrier beside them, while the world looks on scared to intervene by the threats of a deranged psychopath.

A horrific indictment on humanity.

Furries · 07/03/2022 00:32

[quote TellMeMoreHellebore]@WulyJmpr

well yes, i agree...but mumsnettrs dont like hearing that![/quote]
More like SOME people on MN don’t hold much truck with SOME people on MN whipping up hysteria with pointless posts.

To anyone feeling anxious (probably most of us), try limiting your news intake - allow yourself to watch, say, the 6pm news each day. Donate money to appropriate charities. Email your MO with regards to the refugee system. The rest of the time, try to keep your life as “normal” as possible.

In the climate of SM, it’s very tempting to air/vent your worries on sites like this - but just try to remember that you’re doing so to a complete bunch of strangers and you have no clue as to the motives behind their replies.

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 07/03/2022 00:31

All those saying that Ukraine should surrender, how would you feel if someone invaded the UK and everyone said we should surrender for the good of Europe and the rest of the world and be occupied by a tyrannical force? We'd fight for our country, just like the Ukrainians are.

Willyoujustbequiet · 07/03/2022 00:25

Ukraine needs to surrender. He is a madman and will destroy the world. Millions will die.

Let Putin think he's won. Play the long game. He's ill and in his 70s. Surrender will save lives until such time his evil has died.

nothingbutsnow · 07/03/2022 00:24

colossal fucking bold fail there!

nothingbutsnow · 07/03/2022 00:23

Western exceptionalism: "How can this happen in a civilised society, in 2022?"

Rest of world: "It never stopped".

Sad
TiddyTidTwo · 07/03/2022 00:21

Everyone on this thread needs to understand that the dead children that we see lying in the street on the news every night are NOT less important than your children. Their parents didn't love them any less, they are no less worthy of protecting than your own children.

Amen

Iflyaway · 07/03/2022 00:16

It’s so bizarre as in a civilised country we have never had to think like this at all before ever

As CPL593H says, you were obviously not around in the 80's of the last century.

We had the "cold war" between Russia and USA. I grew up with it.

Never thought it would be a feature of 2022. Absolutely terrifying.

To the PP who is pregnant, try to limit your exposure to the news. I was pregnant when the Balkan war was going on. I just couldn't watch it.

DdraigGoch · 07/03/2022 00:16

[quote TellMeMoreHellebore]@LittleBearPad cos the ones used so far are ancient! is that really the best they have got?[/quote]
@TellMeMoreHellebore most Russian equipment is left over from the USSR. Apart from a brief period during the gas boom, Russia couldn't afford to replace its old equipment. They're still operating 42 Tu-95s - those things are older than my parents!

They haven't even bothered maintaining their equipment. Basic stuff like turning wheels once a month to stop the tyres going brittle.

foxlover47 · 07/03/2022 00:09

So really with him threatening nuclear action , he has a huge hold over us all , so why would he stop at Ukraine ?
And I agree the Ukrainian children are every bit as important , how can you watch the news and not want to try and do something to help ,
The animals there too matter ,
Why cant one of his own "take him out" for being the absolute scum that he is

shreddednips · 07/03/2022 00:09

@nothingbutsnow

I was wondering earlier today, whether there would be wars at all if the main pattern for the world was feminine and if so, what would they look like

Like MN Grin

Just a touch of levity to lighten the mood.

Grin
DdraigGoch · 07/03/2022 00:09

@MissAmbrosia

These things have gone on for years and years and years - Syria, Iraq, the Balkans, Yemen, Palestine etc etc. We did some of it ourselves or sold the weapons being used. It is dreadful, of course it is, but it's hard to understand now why it is only now that anyone cares (that doesn't have a racist interpretation) There are millions of refugees displaced from their homes due to war in the last 10 years alone.
Why is it hard to understand why people appear to care a lot more about this war than others?

For a start, it has the potential to escalate into WWIII. That's a massive worry.

nothingbutsnow · 07/03/2022 00:08

I was wondering earlier today, whether there would be wars at all if the main pattern for the world was feminine and if so, what would they look like

Like MN Grin

Just a touch of levity to lighten the mood.

TellMeMoreHellebore · 07/03/2022 00:08

@Furries ah well, we've all got something to say....'help' or otherwise

CatAndHisKit · 07/03/2022 00:07

@RenegadeMasterx

Isn't it absolutely crazy, and utterly terrifying, that the entire world is scared shitless of one crazy little Russian. 😩😩 so much power.
He's bloody loving it, after years of being 'dismissed and disrespected' as he puts it. Ego revenge on the biggest scale possible.
Swipe left for the next trending thread