Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel distressed and heartbroken re Ukraine’s increasingly desperate pleas for help?

363 replies

UltraLightfly · 06/03/2022 20:30

You can hear the desperation in their president’s (and former presidents) voices now. They are BEGGING for physical help. Begging for a no-fly zone to be implemented.

I KNOW we can’t do anything as it’ll cause WW3, but tonight, listening to a former presidents and the current presidents desperate pleas is actually quite distressing. Heartbreaking. Those poor people being left to their fate with the Russians Sad

OP posts:
Strawberryjellyicecream · 07/03/2022 11:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Furries · 07/03/2022 11:10

Blimey, didn’t realise I’d been offensive enough to get a number of posts deleted!

MiniCooper15 · 07/03/2022 11:03

@TiddyTidTwo

Everyone on this thread needs to understand that the dead children that we see lying in the street on the news every night are NOT less important than your children. Their parents didn't love them any less, they are no less worthy of protecting than your own children.

Amen

How about the children (especially girls) in Afghanistan?
MiniCooper15 · 07/03/2022 10:59

@userxx

So we have to stand by and watch. How can this be happening in 2022.
The same way it happens in places like Syria Afghanistan and Rwanda just the people are white so Europeans care more. None of the people suffer worse and what they have in common is that it's usually middle aged men who start wars young men pay with their lives women and children suffer poverty and often are sexually abused or raped.
MafaldaHopkirk · 07/03/2022 10:30

I am totally against a no-fly zone. I don't think it would stop the atrocities anyway because most of the bombing is not from planes, so it would be pointless.
What I worry a NFZ would do, is give Putin a massive excuse to escalate. I think it would also galvanise the Russian public against the West due to shooting down Russian planes being seen as an act of war. The major thing I then worry is that it would give China a legitimate excuse to step in to help Russia against 'Western aggression'. China have massive resources and it will be a very long and bloody battle if it's Russia and China vs NATO (assuming everyone is too scared to nuke).
Heartbreaking as it might be, we have to let Ukraine fight for herself, use up Russian army resources and hope the people come to realise that they're being lied to by their government. It won't mean that they can overthrow him, but it might stop them wanting to take up arms and fight the West.

What the West, and specifically the UK need to do is impose proper sanctions. The UK are worrying about imposing sanctions legally so are giving notice which allows wealth to be moved out of the country (probably to China?) whereas they just need to seize it and worry about consequences later. Unfortunately, I'd guess there are some politicians so entangled with Russian money that they are holding up the proper imposition of sanctions.

Sunnierdays · 07/03/2022 10:18

To think the nuclear weapon was supposed to be a deterrent and now it’s being used as the highest form of blackmail!! It should never have been invented, how can we live our lives normally with this constant level of stress looming over us ??? I just can’t imagine how scared the poor people of Ukraine are, so upset seeing that poor family massacred Sad

Strawberryjellyicecream · 07/03/2022 09:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Woollystockings · 07/03/2022 09:47

@JulesRimetStillGleaming

Going back to the surrender point, a similar situation would be if GB suddenly got a mad dictator and decided to annexe Ireland by force. And as if people in the rest of the world said ah well, just surrender Ireland as we don't fancy a world war; that'll be best for everyone. (Obviously the analogy doesn't quite hold true because of the EU and NATO but there are political parallels).
Well, GB - or England, to be precise - did annexe Ireland by force…
User121212121212121212 · 07/03/2022 09:43

Some people think that putin operates in realms of logic. He does not. He doesn't need a reason to launch a nuke if he wants to. He clearly didn't need a reason to invade Ukraine. All of his excuses are just this - excuses. That's why it's vital that he's stopped now. Feeding the monster helps for a moment, but the beast is growing stronger and more powerful.

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 07/03/2022 09:21

Going back to the surrender point, a similar situation would be if GB suddenly got a mad dictator and decided to annexe Ireland by force. And as if people in the rest of the world said ah well, just surrender Ireland as we don't fancy a world war; that'll be best for everyone. (Obviously the analogy doesn't quite hold true because of the EU and NATO but there are political parallels).

Strawberryjellyicecream · 07/03/2022 08:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Cam77 · 07/03/2022 07:49

Our media has for once not pulled any punches in showing the horrific consequences of bombs and the invasion in general on normal citizens. Horrifying. I do hope they will do the same for all future wars, and conflicts which are in more far off places and do not involve white people. Military intervention should only ever be the very last resort to an existential threat or a genocide that cannot be dealt with my any diplomatic means.

Sunnierdays · 07/03/2022 07:45

@Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase please don’t worry too much about NATO, the Admiral of defence was being interviewed on TV yesterday, watch the interview. Remember these are highly trained military personnel who do not buckle under public opinion . He even stated that emotions must not take over and a calm level headed attitude is required!

TheGreatATuin · 07/03/2022 07:43

I don't think Putin is going to be taken down from the West. His position at home will become untenable very quickly. It's clear that he was expecting a quick win in Ukraine.
Instead, he's got a war that ordinary Russians don't want, sanctions that are going to do serious damage and an army consisting of a lot of young and inexperienced recruits who don't want to be there.
I'm not sure how this is going to end, but his position at home has already been hugely weakened by his own tactics, and the longer he keeps going, the harder it's going to be for even someone like him to cling to power. I think he has made a fundamental error.
I suspect that as he begins to panic and his position becomes weaker, he will hit out harder and harder. The only question is how much damage he is going to do on the way down.

noblegiraffe · 07/03/2022 07:40

I cannot understand why the UN hasn't got involved.

Russia held the presidency of the UN Security Council as it invaded Ukraine. It was a joke, Russia calling emergency UN meetings to discuss the situation in Ukraine.

Sunnierdays · 07/03/2022 07:32

Totally heartbreaking situation , under normal circumstances a bully meets his match but a mad power mad man with nuclear weapons at his control is another story !! A no fly zone would certainly escalate this situation in to something a lot worse for everyone. If a nuclear war starts it affects the whole world not just the countries attacked !! I think the only hope now is non nato countries to try and talk the mad man down , hoping China can help to de escalate this problem ! If the world unites without actual military force hopefully Putin’s advisors will say enough is enough !! (Praying this will happen ) more peace demonstrations everywhere required ?? I just don’t know !!

Willyoujustbequiet · 07/03/2022 06:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 07/03/2022 06:29

one solution put forward was for Zelenskyy to keep half of Ukraine

but what could would that do?
Putin and his army would surely come back?

UniversalAunt · 07/03/2022 05:51

The Falklands Islands have been British territory since 1833. The Argentinians invaded in April 1982, the UK forces fought the Falklands War to liberate the islands.

Thatcher did not have many women (i.e. Baroness Young) in her cabinet, just ‘the vegetables’, but at the time there were few Tory women MPs available to serve as Ministers in the Cabinet.

FarangGirl · 07/03/2022 05:29

@crowsfeet57

I cannot understand why the UN hasn't got involved. Their function is to maintain International Peace and Security. Russia was massing troops on the border for months, the UN had ample time to deploy peacekeeping troops yet did nothing.

Then last week they unanimously voted to 'deplore' the invasion. They have done absolutely nothing as this terrible situation has unfolded. Just sat on their backsides in New York and deplored it. They are useless and toothless,

The UN can't do anything without a resolution from the Security Council. Guess who has veto power?

The problem here is the security council and its make-up. That's what needs to be reformed. Ridiculous that Russia has veto power. Ridiculous too that Britian and France occupy two permanent seats while Africa has none and India is not represented.

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 07/03/2022 05:09

@L0stinCyberspace

At the moment, Putin is saying that enforcing a no fly zone will essentially result in WW3, while breaking cease-fires, massacring civilians and bombing Ukraine to bits. What will you say when (I suspect he will say soon) that supplying weapons or imposing economic sanctions is an act of war and he ups the stakes? He will not stop at Ukraine.
He has already said that….
Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 07/03/2022 04:53

@lemmein

Russia isn't the only country with nuclear capacity. If he nukes us, Russia will be no more within minutes too. He might survive in his bunker but he'll be the leader of fuck-all when he emerges.

The threat of nuclear war is just an excuse for us to do nothing - will nuclear bombs hurt less if he goes into a nato country and we have no choice to act?

What about our promises to Ukraine? Would this even be happening if they kept their nuclear weapons?

Nobody wants war, especially nuclear, but desperately trying to appease a mad man rarely brings peace. We're in a ridiculous position where Putin is deciding what constitutes an act of war from nato whilst simultaneously bombing the shit out of a neighbouring country - ultimate CF! Hmm

It would be suicide to implement and enforce a no fly zone over Ukraine. I genuinely think he would press the button if nothing but to save face. This man doesn’t care about the value of human life. He’s demonstrated that to all of us now. He’s old and I think he’s trying to recreate the former Soviet Union as his lasting legacy. I’ve even read reports that he’s terminally I’ll with stomach cancer. If he fails I believe he would be intent on destroying the whole world. It’s utterly terrifying.
Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 07/03/2022 04:41

It’s sad but I’m more worried that nato will buckle under the pressure and change their minds and that ww3 will them ensue. I listen to LBC and the number of callers that ring in and say the government is not doing enough - do they not understand the risk it would pose for many more millions of people including the Ukraine? I’m feeling very upset about the whole thing. I think Putin has lost the plot and poses a danger to the whole world. I look at my children and I’m scared for them. We have to get as many people out of that country and give them safe refuge.

lemmein · 07/03/2022 04:36

Russia isn't the only country with nuclear capacity. If he nukes us, Russia will be no more within minutes too. He might survive in his bunker but he'll be the leader of fuck-all when he emerges.

The threat of nuclear war is just an excuse for us to do nothing - will nuclear bombs hurt less if he goes into a nato country and we have no choice to act?

What about our promises to Ukraine? Would this even be happening if they kept their nuclear weapons?

Nobody wants war, especially nuclear, but desperately trying to appease a mad man rarely brings peace. We're in a ridiculous position where Putin is deciding what constitutes an act of war from nato whilst simultaneously bombing the shit out of a neighbouring country - ultimate CF! Hmm

LunaTheCat · 07/03/2022 03:59

@userxx

Surely we could take the fucker out ?
Absolutely! That is what I am constantly saying. Where is 007 when you need him!
Swipe left for the next trending thread