Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel distressed and heartbroken re Ukraine’s increasingly desperate pleas for help?

363 replies

UltraLightfly · 06/03/2022 20:30

You can hear the desperation in their president’s (and former presidents) voices now. They are BEGGING for physical help. Begging for a no-fly zone to be implemented.

I KNOW we can’t do anything as it’ll cause WW3, but tonight, listening to a former presidents and the current presidents desperate pleas is actually quite distressing. Heartbreaking. Those poor people being left to their fate with the Russians Sad

OP posts:
cornflakedreams · 06/03/2022 21:45

@Applesonthelawn

I wonder how much appetite there is in the west to cut off the gas supplies from Russia? If we meant it, we could agree to sell Germany some of ours, to share the available non-Russian gas resources for a while. I'd be willing to endure power cuts etc. if it means a quicker strangulation of the Russian war machine.
It's more complicated than that. It could push the price up even more which would mean it would make no difference to the funds he had available since he would still be making sales to other countries but at a higher price.

I suspect it is the direction of travel though.

colouringindoors · 06/03/2022 21:44

It's horrific.

I've just seen a photo taken by A New York Times journalist of a family, two parents, two children, murdered by a Russian shell as they fled their hometown.

CPL593H · 06/03/2022 21:42

We can't impose a no fly zone. We just can't. It would be a disaster.

I know it's frustrating, frightening and depressing that we're at this pass but take some heart from the fact that the rest of the world response has been much more united and decisive than I for one could have ever imagined it would be.

Just for once, we seem to be seeing things clearly and pulling together. Putin will know this and if he is beyond caring, the people around him won't be.

TellMeMoreHellebore · 06/03/2022 21:42

@ChardonnaysPetDragon

stop what? contributing my opinion to a thread? not a chance, not a chance!

You call that contributing? Shameless scaremongering is why it is. Wind it in.

no
JulesRimetStillGleaming · 06/03/2022 21:42

It's awful but I just hope that there are things going on behind the scenes. He needs to be overthrown from within Russia or persuaded to back down by his friends. Macron and Bennet, the Israeli PM, have been in contact with him. Hopefully someone will get through.

It's so pointless how many people around the world are dying due to male egos.

Fernsinthegarden · 06/03/2022 21:41

[quote youhadmeatjello]@TellMeMoreHellebore that’s interesting about your military family - I have a lot of military family and they don’t think world war 3 is already happening or inevitable yet. I’m genuinely not trying to provoke, just highlighting that even if you’re military it’s still
open to your own interpretation even if it based on your own experience. I’d obviously prefer for my lot to be right but At this point nobody knows.
I do have a family member who works in communications for a government dept that has a lot of knowledge and is involved in planning for this kind of eventuality and she isn’t worried at all. I’ve not been privy to any details from her job of course but my motto is always when she gets worried I’ll get worried.

Although I have been very anxious about this, I’m not going to lie![/quote]
@youhadmeatjello I think you’ve articulated my current experiences better than me! I just feel that it’s important to take a balanced view.

@UltraLightfly please take on board what others have said, pregnancy is a stressful enough time without all of this going on too, so lay your worries down with us for a bit and try not to focus too much on what’s going on (easier said than done I know!)

Gwenhwyfar · 06/03/2022 21:41

@Clarabe1

I am two minds over this. On one hand I think we are at war already whether we like it or not because Putin will not stop at Ukraine. He is going to carry on unless he is stopped. On the other hand I hear all these experts saying a no fly zone will make it worse but is this delaying the inevitable and at some point we will be forced to get involved? Or do we wait until he breaches a NATO land? I have no idea…
Yes, I think we have to wait. He's almost 70, he might have health problems and have to retire in the next few years.
Lockheart · 06/03/2022 21:40

@Copenhagenoffice

Did I read correctly that it's costing him $15 billion per day? That sounds absurd but...I dunno?
I've heard similar figures but we can only guess.

The rockets and ammunition used are very expensive. Missiles can be hundreds of thousands a pop. And it has been observed that Russia seems to be rationing rockets, there is surprise in some quarters that they haven't gone in harder. They're not cheap.

Then think of the equipment lost, the helicopters downed, the tanks and lorries and cars breaking down and being abandoned. The wages for all of the soldiers. Their daily food. Fuel, logistical support, replacement parts.

And remember this is being replicated over many, many fronts in Ukraine. I can believe it's costing billions a day.

neveradullmoment99 · 06/03/2022 21:37

[quote RoseRedRoseBlue]@Pyewhacket that is guaranteed to make a terrible situation worse.[/quote]
Agreed. It will be regarded as retaliation. It will regarded as engaging in the war. Not a good idea.

RoseRedRoseBlue · 06/03/2022 21:37

@Copenhagenoffice me too. No question.

makingmiracles · 06/03/2022 21:34

@TellMeMoreHellebore I completely agree. I’m watching the coverage extensively, both official sources and diy coverage on twitter and TikTok, all the soldiers seem to appear very young and the equipment used old compared to the equipment the Ukrainians are using, I’ve been pondering on it for days wondering if he’s sent the young inexperienced ones out in old equipment to gauge the level of resistance before sending in the big stuff and the more experienced soldiers. Or perhaps to give the Ukrainians a false sense of security/being able to hold them back. It’s very odd.

Everyone feels helpless but the situation needs to be handled extremely carefully given how volatile he is and how untouchable he is(Salisbury). The best that can be done for now to to supply Ukraine with the tools it needs and provide aid assistance, we absolutely shouldn’t get more involved.

Copenhagenoffice · 06/03/2022 21:34

I'd endure power cuts to have this ended definitely

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 06/03/2022 21:33

stop what? contributing my opinion to a thread? not a chance, not a chance!

You call that contributing? Shameless scaremongering is why it is. Wind it in.

Fernsinthegarden · 06/03/2022 21:33

[quote TellMeMoreHellebore]@Fernsinthegarden we are a military family, this is a general view from friends and many many discussions

mumsnet doesn't need any help from me to 'whip up a frenzy' its second nature here[/quote]
Yes, I too am from a military family. I live in a heavily military area. I have heard very different views from many discussions.
You’re right in the second nature of mumsnet though.

Copenhagenoffice · 06/03/2022 21:32

Did I read correctly that it's costing him $15 billion per day? That sounds absurd but...I dunno?

Applesonthelawn · 06/03/2022 21:32

I wonder how much appetite there is in the west to cut off the gas supplies from Russia? If we meant it, we could agree to sell Germany some of ours, to share the available non-Russian gas resources for a while. I'd be willing to endure power cuts etc. if it means a quicker strangulation of the Russian war machine.

youhadmeatjello · 06/03/2022 21:32

@TellMeMoreHellebore that’s interesting about your military family - I have a lot of military family and they don’t think world war 3 is already happening or inevitable yet. I’m genuinely not trying to provoke, just highlighting that even if you’re military it’s still
open to your own interpretation even if it based on your own experience. I’d obviously prefer for my lot to be right but At this point nobody knows.
I do have a family member who works in communications for a government dept that has a lot of knowledge and is involved in planning for this kind of eventuality and she isn’t worried at all. I’ve not been privy to any details from her job of course but my motto is always when she gets worried I’ll get worried.

Although I have been very anxious about this, I’m not going to lie!

redglobox · 06/03/2022 21:31

Yes you're right of course Lockheart but it feels like nothing because we're not physically there defending those people who are being so brave despite their situation seeming so hopeless.

Of course it's one thing to take territory and quite another to hold it. I'm sure the Ukrainians will out up fierce resistance

EddyF · 06/03/2022 21:31

The west knew that Ukraine cannot win this war so I am unsure why they keep pumping them up with ammunition and then standing back. It would have made sense for Ukraine president to have stepped down right from the beginning. Civilians are being killed in a war that cannot be won . The west have egged this situation to a no return point. A no fly zone literally means no more us. Putin has everybody in a corner and there is no point the Ukraine government asking for something that they know would cause the world to cease. They could have given Putin what he wants whilst working in the background to take him out. The west is not clean in this and I suspect the Ukrainian government have been had.

I sympathise with the people but I feel their government has made it worse for them with the half stepping from the west.

Applesonthelawn · 06/03/2022 21:30

He may destroy us all even without us imposing a no fly zone, although it seems less likely. No-one knows what he'll do. Terrifying, but I hope the people making decisions are keeping cool heads and working on as many fronts as possible to rid us of that monster.

MurmuratingStarling · 06/03/2022 21:29

@noblegiraffe

Why are people saying we are standing by and doing nothing? The economic sanctions are incredibly harsh, the Russian economy has tanked, their money is basically worthless.

How long can he keep on funding this invasion with massive problems at home?

I agree with this. ^
CrikeyPeg · 06/03/2022 21:29

@Clarabe1

I am two minds over this. On one hand I think we are at war already whether we like it or not because Putin will not stop at Ukraine. He is going to carry on unless he is stopped. On the other hand I hear all these experts saying a no fly zone will make it worse but is this delaying the inevitable and at some point we will be forced to get involved? Or do we wait until he breaches a NATO land? I have no idea…
I feel the same way @Clarabe1. He is holding the world to ransom with his talk/threats of nuclear. Unless he is somehow stopped, he won't stop, but how do you stop a madman with his finger poised above the bomb button?
LittleBearPad · 06/03/2022 21:28

@Tigersonvaseline

We totally out number him in terms of everything expect nuclear war.

I wonder if the nfz is.also to buy time? To get everything to NATO borders?

Confused
RoseRedRoseBlue · 06/03/2022 21:27

@redglobox it’s just not true to say nothing is happening. You have a responsibility to educate yourself about this.

redglobox · 06/03/2022 21:26

That said, the alternative seems fraught with danger too. We're between a rock and a hard place. And all the while the Ukrainians suffer. It is gut-wrenching.

Our best hope is probably the combination of sanctions and businesses withdrawing from Russia. But who really knows. I'm glad I'm not making these decisions. I hope those who are know what they're doing.