Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Times article - awful description

35 replies

Bakingdiva · 06/03/2022 15:56

I saw this Times article today.

Peter Dundas on surrogacy: ‘People think, oh, same-sex couples — they buy a baby’

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/78526d60-9944-11ec-84fe-a2a0efa555d1?shareToken=5501606db6ab581c591892c53d3e9365

AIBU to find this specific phrase just appalling (screenshot). How can someone GIVE a surrogate - the surrogate is another human being?

Times article - awful description
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/03/2022 18:03

Sounds like the words a slaver would use.

It's not that far a leap for there to be contracts where women out of desperation sign over their reproductive and sexual behaviour for x years in case the rich person wants a sibling born in exactly the same circumstances/biological conditions - and then being able to sell on those rights to others.

Baaaa · 12/03/2022 17:35

The mother isn't a thing to give jeez

SweetPeaGirl · 12/03/2022 17:33

The whole surrogacy thing makes me really, really uncomfortable. I can see how it's possible to do it well and for women to be genuinely happy about it (though I can't relate myself), but it seems like it's now an 'industry' and is mostly exploitative.

I've seen a few stories about parents being super happy and relieved to get their surrogate-born babies out of Ukraine and brought here just in time. I had no idea it was such a big thing there. The articles hardly ever mention how the mothers are - it's like they barely exist at all except as an incubator. Fucking heartless.

And as with surrogates in India, it seems like something desperate women do for money and that makes the 'choice' not real to me. They're not forced into it, but it's very close to that.

MurmuratingStarling · 12/03/2022 17:24

@Tiddlesthecat

I have enormous sympathy for couples who have turn to surrogacy as a way of becoming parents. I have little sympathy when they decide to suddenly do this when they have turned 50 and spent years partying/pursuing careers etc and then suddenly decide to have a baby because it now feels more convenient. The genders of the parents don't bother me, it's the selfishness of anyone who suddenly decided that they want a baby that makes it feel like it's a commodity.
I agree with all this, except for the age. It's people closer to 36-40 rather than people who have passed 50. To be honest, I think very few people will try to conceive/acquire a baby in their 50s. (In fact I have never known any personally!)

I do agree with everything else you say though @Tiddlesthecat

MurmuratingStarling · 12/03/2022 17:20

@Enough4me

Women, we are vessels, time to step back in line.
Shock Grin
Times article - awful description
Enough4me · 12/03/2022 17:14

Women, we are vessels, time to step back in line.

Tiddlesthecat · 12/03/2022 17:07

I have enormous sympathy for couples who have turn to surrogacy as a way of becoming parents. I have little sympathy when they decide to suddenly do this when they have turned 50 and spent years partying/pursuing careers etc and then suddenly decide to have a baby because it now feels more convenient. The genders of the parents don't bother me, it's the selfishness of anyone who suddenly decided that they want a baby that makes it feel like it's a commodity.

lljkk · 12/03/2022 16:59

I wondered if it was a garbled comment like "tried to give us the name of her surrogate"

Um, given the ways people otherwise commodify their bodies, intellect and effort - I've no moral principle against surrogacy for money in principle. Can't muster opinions beyond that about this situation / Slebs I never heard of least of all.

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 12/03/2022 16:48

No surprise that they have turned comments off of that article.

MurmuratingStarling · 12/03/2022 16:31

Urgh! Shock Awful yes.

Reminds me a little of when I worked 4 afternoons a week (midday to 6pm) for a couple of years, when my DC were at primary school, and I took them to school (at 8.30am,) and DH got them. (He was on permanent nights at the time, and woke at 2.30pm to get them at 3pm... )

The next door neighbour - a woman with a little boy (only 4 and not at school yet) worked 5 mornings a week - 8.30am til 12.30pm, at a dental practice, and her MIL looked after her son while she was there. Her MIL lived 2.5 miles away and couldn't drive so my neighbour took her son there around 8.10am every day and then went to work. Picked him up after work.

Aged around 3.5 years, he started nursery at the local school that my DC went to, and was due to go in the morning.. 9.15am til 12.45pm. So she was OK to pick him up but couldn't take him as she started work at 8.30am. Her MIL couldn't do it, as the school was the one 10 minutes walk away from us, in her catchment area, and the MIL would have had to get the bus to our neighbour's house, at 7.45am, and then back again after she had taken the boy to school. EVERY day.

SO when our neighbour told us this, what does my DH say??? He said 'oh no worries, Starling will take him. She has to take our DC, and she doesn't start work til midday. SHE will do it. Just drop him off around 8am, and he can even have breakfast here if you want.'

I was like Hmm Angry I could have punched him to be honest. We went indoors and I said 'How fucking DARE you volunteer me?! Our DC start school at 8.30am and HE doesn't start nursery til 9.15am. WTF am I meant to do for three quarters of an hour? Just hang around outside HIS class, waiting for the door to open? Or walk the ten minute walk back home, hang around for 25 minutes and then walk back?!' Hmm

DH said 'well you've got nothing else to do.' Hmm I was livid. I did 90% of the housework, and all the shopping and house admin, as I 'only' worked 24 hours a week, and I was always busy in the mornings after I had dropped our DC off at school.

I said 'tell you what.. you come in off nights at 6.30am. YOU stay up and YOU do this lad's breakfast, and look after him and YOU take him to school for 9am.' He said 'don't be ridiculous. I go to bed at 7am, as I have to be up at 2.30pm to go and get OUR DC. And I work full time and my job's far more important as I earn more money.' Hmm

Long story short, I went next door and told our neighbour I wouldn't be able to do it, and she laughed and said 'I would NEVER expect this of you. I am going to try and get him in the afternoon nursery, and oh my GOD your face when your husband volunteered you!' Shock

I said 'I could have killed him. So rude to assume I would - or COULD - do it. The fact that your DC starts nursery 45 minutes after mine start school is a bit of an issue.'

SHE was fine about it, and DID get him into the afternoon nursery, starting 1.15pm, but I was so angry with my DH for WEEKS! To add insult to injury, he could not see, for a fleeting second, anything wrong with what he had said, and thought I was the unreasonable one!

As many posters have said, some people just assume women are commodities, and there to be used. He would never have done this to a man, and HE would have gone mad if anyone had done this to him.

He tried similar things a few more times, and I said NO every time. But he hasn't tried anything for 18-20+ years. He eventually realised I won't be taken for a fool, I won't be bullied into anything I don't want to do, and I won't back down.

Liz1tummypain · 12/03/2022 16:02

Well science is moving so fast. You could wonder how a woman can produce a baby and hand it over to a stranger for money as well. People have all kinds of motivations. I couldn't give a child away for any reason. But that's probably been happening for a long time.

HRTQueen · 12/03/2022 15:54

Kim was wonderful and tried to give us her surrogate

Well that line sums up absolutely everything wrong about surrogacy. How can you claim that people make unfair judgements when a friend feels she can rent out another woman’s body

Totally self absorbed I want so I shall have as I have money attitude that becuasee they are gay couple is overlooked and celebrated

Theluggage15 · 12/03/2022 15:53

The Times is massively pro surrogacy. That awful Sophie Beresiner column, the only comments allowed were fan girl stunning and brave, love you hun comments, then it seemed weekly articles on various Times employees who’d used surrogacy made me cancel my subscription.

nothingcomestonothing · 12/03/2022 15:29

Buying the use of a woman's body, for any purpose, should be illegal. Similarly, buying humans of any age should be illegal. Because that is what we're talking about.

Mistlewoeandwhine · 12/03/2022 15:24

Vile

MidCenturyClegs · 12/03/2022 14:36

@Loopytiles

Yes, Times coverage on women’s issues is all over the place!
I am trying to piece together a timeline of how the Times used to be ok for discussing women's rights (Janice Turner et al) yet recently on all articles they've been turning comments off. #nodebate I only know much about women fighting against self-ID. If you've any other info could you please pop stuff here? Or DM me. Thanks.
Hoardasurass · 06/03/2022 18:10

All surrogacy should be illegal

Clymene · 06/03/2022 18:05

@NorthSouthcatlady

Grim. Totally grim

I also doubt it was a gruelling 4 year battle. All they did was throw cash around and have a wank. My 4 year battle to conceive has been way harder and unsuccessful as yet

Yeah really gruelling. Casting around for a woman who met their exacting standards to sell them her eggs.
Lesperance · 06/03/2022 17:03

That is really awful. The women just becomes a commodity.

Kangaruby · 06/03/2022 17:00

The times despite being mostly good on women's rights is shockingly pro surrogacy (especially the style section, possibly due to their writer who had a column about her surrogacy for what felt like a decade), comments turned off shows they know fine well what the readers think but they continue to push it

NorthSouthcatlady · 06/03/2022 16:56

Grim. Totally grim

I also doubt it was a gruelling 4 year battle. All they did was throw cash around and have a wank. My 4 year battle to conceive has been way harder and unsuccessful as yet

Loopytiles · 06/03/2022 16:52

Yes, Times coverage on women’s issues is all over the place!

DTW33 · 06/03/2022 16:41

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ThatsNotMyGolem · 06/03/2022 16:28

Proper Handmaid's Tale stuff. Dystopian.

DoobryWhatsit · 06/03/2022 16:26

I'm a science tutor. One mum I worked for told me very excitedly one week that she was going to "gift" me to her niece for the next six weeks before her exams. I was very young, and I convinced myself that I was being unreasonable to be upset (because it was the same one hour of the week I would have been teaching for the original woman, and it was no further to travel) but honestly, I died a bit inside.

This here is some next level awful, dehumanising language.

Swipe left for the next trending thread