Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think fcuk all is being done to combat climate change

280 replies

getdown2021 · 06/03/2022 15:48

Most people don't seem to care and I rarely hear of it anymore despite being told months ago of the dire warnings. Aibu to think no action is being taken either by governments or by the average person?

OP posts:
Lilifer · 07/03/2022 14:56

[quote stuntbubbles]@MistOverTheDowns You missed the word “sheeple” from that little tinfoil hat rant.[/quote]

Doubt you ever made it on to the school debating team with that level of intellectual engagement 😏

BiBabbles · 07/03/2022 14:39

We keep electrical products till they break and it's either not possible or not ecomomic to fix - and fair few things don't last 7 years. In fact there's few items we've upgraded that haven't out right failed before being replaced.

I was thinking that for #3 on keeping electronics for 7 years to work, we're going to need #6 in pushing for requirements on electronic products to reasonably last that long and able to be repaired and potentially support for more training and jobs to do repairs that it's not feasible for the average person to do on their own.

For me, that's tricker than 2 & 4 (though for clothes, I tend to not buy anything for years and then need to replace multiple items at once, and as you said, items aren't lasting like they used to).

Daftasabroom · 07/03/2022 14:37

@mummykel16

Electric cars charged on renewable energy have half the CO2e of the equivalent internal combustion engine after 200,000km. Even the standard EU energy mix see’s an improvement.

www.polestar.com/dato-assets/11286/1600176185-20200915polestarlcafinala.pdf

And wind farms are no longer subsidised.

Last year offshore wind supplied energy to meet 39% of UK electricity demand and the installed capacity is due to grow by 400% by the end of the decade.
www.sse.com/media/dotp5quh/delivering-40gw-of-offshore-wind-by-2030.pdf
www.windenergynetwork.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/A1-Map_Issue-57-WEB.pdf
Gas prices here: www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-58650634

Wood isn’t a fossil fuel.

@Stompythedinosaur
I can't foresee a situation where people will agree to their families having a significantly poorer quality of life, really.
By not taking climate change seriously you are directly contributing to doing just that.

@MistOverTheDowns
How do you justify carbon fibre having a carbon footprint 14x steel? LCA’s don’t work in such a way that you can make that statement. Unfortunately, climate change is manmade, in what way is it a con?

@JanisMoplin
The article in the Guardian is very disingenuous as it refers to scope 3 emissions which are not reported as they move the emissions from the emitter to the originator, in this context fossil fuel companies will always be responsible. This would be like blaming BP for the emissions from YOUR boiler.

@Kazzyhoward
Burning wood is not generally considered as a CO2e emission as the tree has already captured the carbon. There is debate around this along with waste to energy. Particulate emissions are a different matter. The 2030 date is challenging but it is doable.

blodbav · 07/03/2022 14:05

What exactly do you want to 'be done'? What sacrifices are you personally prepared to make to combat climate change?

  • mandatory building specifications and green energy systems for all new buildings
  • ban most single use plastics unless necessary
  • shift towards sectors other than retail and mass consumption. More agriculture
  • more/better public transport and mandatory electric cars for drivers
  • urban farming to reduce food miles
  • afforestation
  • carbon capturing tech to advance
blodbav · 07/03/2022 13:59

@Notlabeled

1) What type of climate do you want? 2) At what period in our 4+ billion year history did your preferred climate occur? 3) How do you plan to stabilise your preferred climate? 4) How are you planning to compensate for seasonal changes? 5) How big do you want the Polar ice-caps to be?

As for the 80 year timeframe? Hysterical nonsense.

Resource scarcity? Water scarcity? Desertification? Extinction? No comment on any of these and there's way more.

It's hysterical nonsense but when it starts affecting you it'll be a different story. A very selfish perspective, how can you live on a planet and not give a shit about anything 😑

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 07/03/2022 13:56

@Shehasadiamondinthesky

Why is 4 difficult though, how much do normal people fly if they don't have to for work, we haven't flown anywhere for 20 years, I have taken the ferry to mainland Europe several times.
It depends on the person. In normal years I take a few short haul flights for long weekends away & holidays. A lot of people travel for other reasons than work.
Swimmum78 · 07/03/2022 13:51

I'm not saying lots of people don't live like this. I've hardly bought any new clothes for years. Have 1 car which I will keep until it dies. Cutting down on meat etc. However when I look at influencers, or go into ahops at christmas and see all the tat on display it's clear that most people don't want to live that lifestyle. And unless it's enforced it will make fuck all difference if i live on lentils and weave my own clothes which then makes it all seem pointless.

Calennig · 07/03/2022 13:37

@Swimmum78

It's in the press today. 6 points for us mere mortals to make, rather than waiting for gov/companies.
  1. Eat largely plant based diet, with no waste
  2. Buy no more than 3 new items of clothing per year.
  3. Keep electrical products for at least 7 years.
  4. Take no more than 1 short haul flight per 3 years, or 1 long haul every 8 years.
  5. Get rid of personal motor vehicle or keep existing one for longer
  6. Make at least 1 shift to nudge the system like moving to green energy or insulating your home.

Problem is, I just don't see enough people being willing to make these personal sacrifices.

We're reducing meat in diet anyway.

Clothes are an issue for me - mainly beacuse I've worn bulk of my wardrobee to destrcution and newer stuff hasn't lasted as long as previous stuff so need to replace items. Clothes don't have longvity they once did and can't seem to afford the quality items which are very expenisvbe these days. Do mend what we can and buy second hand as well - and sometime re-purpose fabric.

We keep electrical products till they break and it's either not possible or not ecomomic to fix - and fair few things don't last 7 years. In fact there's few items we've upgraded that haven't out right failed before being replaced.

Haven't been on a plane for over 20 years - though may do this summer. In fact only been on 6 flights overall and 2 of those for work.

We don't have a car and never have - we get around by taxi, bus, train, occaionally bike for DH, and feet.

We have insulated the house as much as we can afford but don't want to change electricty providers yet.

So we're already doing a lot of this were we can. Though we live in a city - it's much harder to go carless in rural locations - and imporved public transport would be a help in many cities.

Blossom64265 · 07/03/2022 13:23

I actually feel quite nostalgic for the days when I used to worry about having had a child who would face a climate crisis. That fear I felt 10 years ago felt so big, but i now know it was nothing compared to today worrying about plague and war.

Blossom64265 · 07/03/2022 13:16

Think about it in more personal terms. When your child is sick, a pipe has burst in your home, and you just lost your job, it’s hard to worry about your retirement years.

People, businesses, and governments are past their limits.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 07/03/2022 13:13

Why is 4 difficult though, how much do normal people fly if they don't have to for work, we haven't flown anywhere for 20 years, I have taken the ferry to mainland Europe several times.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 07/03/2022 13:11

@Swimmum78

It's in the press today. 6 points for us mere mortals to make, rather than waiting for gov/companies.
  1. Eat largely plant based diet, with no waste
  2. Buy no more than 3 new items of clothing per year.
  3. Keep electrical products for at least 7 years.
  4. Take no more than 1 short haul flight per 3 years, or 1 long haul every 8 years.
  5. Get rid of personal motor vehicle or keep existing one for longer
  6. Make at least 1 shift to nudge the system like moving to green energy or insulating your home.

Problem is, I just don't see enough people being willing to make these personal sacrifices.

Well I fulfil all of these and I only have one adult child who isn't having any children himself, him and DiL are in their 40's. We share a house which has been divided into 1/3...2/3rds to keep costs down and because it's not sensible for me to live in a big three bed house on my own. We are all vegetarians/vegans. But I don't want a gold star, we have always lived like this because it makes sense and its much cheaper. The only problem we have is cars, we have to have two cars, DS works from home so doesn't need one but due to the piss poor public transport in Somerset me and DiL have to drive to work as I work in the NHS all over the county and Dil has no bus or train route to the remote place she works. Really if they expect people to give up their cars there must be a viable alternative and there isn't one.
Tulipomania · 07/03/2022 13:03

I saw that list too and thought it was going to be very off-putting for many people.

Especially 2 and 4.

Verysadatwork · 07/03/2022 13:03

Mist, we can all be hypocrites and I get that you might not want to listen to particular people if they are not practising what they preach.

but do you think the science is wrong? or just that a lot of politicians talking about being green are in it for themselves?

MistOverTheDowns · 07/03/2022 12:50

The world leaders and others at the top of this climate change tree are going to find especial difficulty keeping number 4 on your list!

Surely it is a fact universally accepted that in order to attend a conference on climate change one has to first fly many miles to it-often on private planes- and then, once there, travel around in gas guzzlers!

Let's see how sticking to point number 4 works out for them!

mummykel16 · 07/03/2022 12:49

@Swimmum78

It's in the press today. 6 points for us mere mortals to make, rather than waiting for gov/companies.
  1. Eat largely plant based diet, with no waste
  2. Buy no more than 3 new items of clothing per year.
  3. Keep electrical products for at least 7 years.
  4. Take no more than 1 short haul flight per 3 years, or 1 long haul every 8 years.
  5. Get rid of personal motor vehicle or keep existing one for longer
  6. Make at least 1 shift to nudge the system like moving to green energy or insulating your home.

Problem is, I just don't see enough people being willing to make these personal sacrifices.

For many all of that and more is called every day life, not everyone changes their car yearly or has more clothes than Primark not everyone jets off, well at all.

Most of that list just shows a massive lack of understanding about how millions live

Swimmum78 · 07/03/2022 12:43

It's in the press today. 6 points for us mere mortals to make, rather than waiting for gov/companies.

  1. Eat largely plant based diet, with no waste
  2. Buy no more than 3 new items of clothing per year.
  3. Keep electrical products for at least 7 years.
  4. Take no more than 1 short haul flight per 3 years, or 1 long haul every 8 years.
  5. Get rid of personal motor vehicle or keep existing one for longer
  6. Make at least 1 shift to nudge the system like moving to green energy or insulating your home.

Problem is, I just don't see enough people being willing to make these personal sacrifices.

mudgetastic · 07/03/2022 12:31

No I have just followed the logical conclusions of what many say

Too many children is not the problem
It's the lifestyle people want for themselves that is the problem

It's all about deflecting

MistOverTheDowns · 07/03/2022 12:18

I meant, of course, that you have displayed limited comprehension skills!

MistOverTheDowns · 07/03/2022 12:17

@mudgetastic

Your first paragraph shows that you have displayed comprehension skills and immediately jumped to a very dramatic-and incorrect interpretation.

This is a great example of the dramatic and incorrect interpretation spouted by those who have swallowed the Climate Catastrophe Kool Aid. They pick up on one point, misunderstand it and rush to a an extreme conclusion.

Many thanks for demonstrating this so ably.

mudgetastic · 07/03/2022 11:06

Wanting people who want to combat climate change to not have kids so you can carry on regardless? Nice. Go the whole hog , demand sterilisation if anyone concerned about climate change

Children can have low carbon impact - no point getting rid of people who only have a small footprint

So you will simply end up with your children dying young from war, famine and heat

We have had decades of notice during which time money has been pumped into the fossil fuel industry- if it had been pumped into green electricity instead there would be no crisis now. So a few oil companies would be less rich - their wealth doesnt seem to help us though does it ? let's raise NI not claim more tax of those poor oil companies seems to be the government line

Green electricity was already cheaper than oil before this crisis and we need more of it and we need it fast

Tulipomania · 07/03/2022 10:51

Actually green policies are helping to cut costs for everyone.

Large-scale solar and onshore wind are the cheapest ways of generating electricity - they were cheaper than gas even before Putin invaded Ukraine, and are much cheaper than nuclear.

So called Green 'taxes' are used to fund energy efficiency which also helps reduce people's costs.

And many years ago the Stern report pointed out that the long-term economic costs of NOT taking action on climate change would be much higher than the upfront costs of tackling it. Which is now being born out by the impact Ukraine is having on our energy prices here.

Too many people on here are taking the Nigel Farage view of Net Zero as gospel without even questioning it.

mummykel16 · 07/03/2022 10:14

@Whatdidisay

To be concerned about the climate you need to be comfortable financially, until the current cost of living crisis we as a family were very environmental thinking but now as many families we are more concerned with keeping a roof over our heads, keeping the lights on and keeping warm. Green levies /taxes are adding to the crippling prices the average households pay and I bet if there was a referendum in the UK most would vote to axe them until prices stabilise.
Yes
JanisMoplin · 07/03/2022 09:49

I very much hope you are right @MistOverTheDowns .

Guineapigssweak · 07/03/2022 09:38

Humans have survived 2 ice ages. That was without central heating and thermal clothing. Incredible what we can endure. (Obviously climate change then too)