Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refugees

84 replies

Rinatinabina · 06/03/2022 10:47

Do you think people generally would be more open to receiving refugees if they were primarily women and children?

For example if there were mainly women in tents in Calais do you think Britain generally would be happier accepting them than they are men?

YABU: it wouldn’t make a difference
YANBU: people would be more welcoming to women

OP posts:
BlackCoffeeInAPoolOfSunshine · 06/03/2022 12:04

I have an adult size 14 year old son and am acutely aware of how vulnerable he is at the same time as being aware that he could be intimidating in certain contexts to people who don't know him! That doesn't change the fact that he too is more at risk from men than women!

It's not a value judgement - men and boys can be vulnerable and often are, but men and older boys are also more likely to be the ones who pose risk to others on average (not any one individual but statistically). They're often victims of violence but also perpetrators far more often than women and young children and everyone knows that!

ADHDWoman · 06/03/2022 12:01

That's why I said somewhat different ways, because men and boys are much less likely to be sold or forced into marriages, but are much more likely to be forced into fighting and being cannon fodder. And both are at great risk of sexual exploitation

TheOnlyMrsMac · 06/03/2022 11:59

@ADHDWoman

Oh 100% girls and women are so vulnerable to exploitation as refugees, but boys absolutely are as well. In somewhat different ways.
Boys and vulnerable men - in the same ways.
ADHDWoman · 06/03/2022 11:58

Unfortunately I think that plays out on a larger scale, and that we write off a lot of men and boys who are not abusive in any way and deserve a chance at life the same as anyone else.

ADHDWoman · 06/03/2022 11:55

Yes I wouldn't let a strange man into my house. And by strange man I don't mean anything other than a man that I don't know exceptionally well. Having been the victim of domestic violence, financial abuse, emotional abuse and rape at the hands of my male partner previously, I know that it doesn't matter how well you think you do or do not know men they can turn out to be violent and dangerous, so a man I don't know is too big a gamble for mine and my children's safety. I wouldn't take any man in. I don't think that means I don't care about them, I just know that there is an indisputable risk which I am not willing to take that they could turn out to be violent. Not on account of their refugee status, on account of them being XY's

TheOnlyMrsMac · 06/03/2022 11:55

I recommend the City of Sanctuary UK website for information and links to how to help refugees from around the world including Syria and Afghanistan, and also now from Ukraine.

BlackCoffeeInAPoolOfSunshine · 06/03/2022 11:51

What people are more open to, for understandable reasons of personal safety, is taking women and children into their own homes. This is happening somewhat with Ukrainian refugees in the part of Germany I live in. Taking in unknown men is statistically even riskier in terms of personal safety than unknown women and children. That's not about who's deserving in any way.

thereisonlyoneofme · 06/03/2022 11:51

Unfortunately due to the threat of terrorism etc from certain parts of the world, some form of restriction has to be set. People are up in arms when it has turned out in the past criminals/bombers have bypassed the asylum system by illegal entry. re economic migrants If we want to migrate somewhere like Australia etc for work there is a process to be gone through you cant just turn up.

The Ukraine scenario is different, as is the Afghan resettlement
However, homes, education etc have to be found for all these people.
I m aware many will join relatives already here, or may only wish to stay until their homeland is safe again.

Also there is a lot of Tory bashing that no homes are being built. Try saying that in the South East where many thousands of houses are being built, with no infrastructure to go with it.

ADHDWoman · 06/03/2022 11:47

@AlexaShutUp

Yes I did know some appeals, but on a much smaller level than the Ukrainian appeal.

Kendodd · 06/03/2022 11:47

Our government don't, but I think a lot of citizens are a lot more pro Ukrainian refugees Than Syrian ones. If there were mass collections in the same way for Syria or Afghanistan I must have missed them
I think one factor though is that people can actually drive to Ukraine. Lots of these collections are being coordinated by Polish people who will have done most of that drive themselves.

Inkyblue123 · 06/03/2022 11:46

I think generally people are more welcoming to war refugees then they are economic migrants. Many people see those in Calais as the later - as they have passed through several countries where they could have already claimed asylum but they have chosen to
Push on to the UK for reasons other than seeking refuge.

ADHDWoman · 06/03/2022 11:46

Oh 100% girls and women are so vulnerable to exploitation as refugees, but boys absolutely are as well. In somewhat different ways.

Kendodd · 06/03/2022 11:44

Quite why posters assume that refugee males are more likely to be paedophiles that their own husbands or sons, not quite sure.
I don't think that's the case. I think it's that males in general are more likely to be paedophiles (or present a threat) than females. This is the case the world over as reflected in crime statistics. Male violence is a real thing (which isn't to say females are never violent).

AlexaShutUp · 06/03/2022 11:44

@ADHDWoman

Our government don't, but I think a lot of citizens are a lot more pro Ukrainian refugees Than Syrian ones. If there were mass collections in the same way for Syria or Afghanistan I must have missed them
Actually, there were mass collections for Syrian refugees where I live, coordinated by a local restaurant owner. I believe that the response was very generous. I have not been aware of similar collections for Afghanistan though.
ADHDWoman · 06/03/2022 11:42

Our government don't, but I think a lot of citizens are a lot more pro Ukrainian refugees Than Syrian ones. If there were mass collections in the same way for Syria or Afghanistan I must have missed them

Kendodd · 06/03/2022 11:40

We want the refugees from the Ukraine now right?
Actually we don't. The government is putting every barrier it can possibly get away with to prevent them coming.

AlexaShutUp · 06/03/2022 11:35

In my experience, unaccompanied teenage boys are every bit as vulnerable to exploitation as unaccompanied teenage girls. There are some truly evil people out there.

ThinWomansBrain · 06/03/2022 11:35

From another recent thread on here about offering refuge in your own home, there were quite a few "women and children only" responses.
Quite why posters assume that refugee males are more likely to be paedophiles that their own husbands or sons, not quite sure.

Rinatinabina · 06/03/2022 11:33

@ADHDWoman

I hate so much the low value we put on men's lives. It's like we as a species have not progressed beyond the lifeboats on the titanic. Women and children first, as well as handful of men so long as they are 'first class' and everyone else can drown or die.
Tbf women in many of the places that contribute to refugee numbers are extremely vulnerable, so I guess in afghanistan right now women will find it hard to access work to support their families without male family members or not having the “protection” of a male. There was a report on very young syrian girls being married off in aid camps because a) their parents felt they couldn’t provide for them b) they feared that without a husband for protection their daughters would be trafficked or raped. Also watched a report on nigerian women trafficked into sexual exploitation in Italy. Female refugees do appear to be more vulnerable especially once they are on the move, same for children I imagine.
OP posts:
ADHDWoman · 06/03/2022 11:32

This fear of refugees and asylum seekers is 100% thinly veiled racism and xenophobia, and often times Islamophobia as well. We want the refugees from the Ukraine now right? But didn't want those from Syria?
It's all to do with skin colour and religion and other forms of othering.

ADHDWoman · 06/03/2022 11:29

As regards economic migrants, if I was in my home and could not afford to feed myself or my family, damn straight I would move somewhere where I could afford to do that. I'm not the kind of person who would just wait for death, I am the kind of person who will go through hell for my family. I know the gift that hope can be when you are in a time of despair and darkness. If the choice is to stay and have no hope, or emigrate and have hope, I know I would emigrate. My family were emigrants not so many generations ago for economic reasons, the light skinned kind though so nobody knows to judge me on it.

Kendodd · 06/03/2022 11:24

One instant change I would make would be to let asylum seekers work. Although that would probably open them up to the whip cracking sanction laden benefit system.

MischievousBiscuits · 06/03/2022 11:24

I think people being 'wary' of refugees is thinly veiled racism most of the time.

ADHDWoman · 06/03/2022 11:23

I hate so much the low value we put on men's lives. It's like we as a species have not progressed beyond the lifeboats on the titanic. Women and children first, as well as handful of men so long as they are 'first class' and everyone else can drown or die.

Kendodd · 06/03/2022 11:21

I think it would help if people knew what they were fleeing as we don't really hear about the situation in the countries they are coming from most think they are just economic refugees after our benefits.
What a load of Daily Mail bollocks, "after our benefits"

Imo with regard economic migrants, I'm surprised we don't see loads more of them in the rich world. These people have eyes in the head, they can see how much we have and how little they have. I don't blame they for rocking up and wanting to know where their share of the worlds wealth is.