Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refugees

84 replies

Rinatinabina · 06/03/2022 10:47

Do you think people generally would be more open to receiving refugees if they were primarily women and children?

For example if there were mainly women in tents in Calais do you think Britain generally would be happier accepting them than they are men?

YABU: it wouldn’t make a difference
YANBU: people would be more welcoming to women

OP posts:
AnneElliott · 06/03/2022 16:28

Yes I do think the reaction would be different if it was women and children in Calais.

But I worked in immigration previously and I saw a great number of 'child migrants' who were men older than me - and I was mid 20s at the time. I wouldn't have a strange man in my house - doesn't matter if he was British or a refugee. Statistically they are much more of a risk than a woman with children.

ADHDWoman · 06/03/2022 16:25

If it was up to me there would be no wars, and I do think that a lot of other women and mothers would agree with that because it's impossible to not empathise with those other mums seeing their boys go off to be soldiers, or coming home in body bags. If you can't see it it's because you have found a way to justify them dying and not your own dying by othering them and not seeing them as just like you and yours.

ADHDWoman · 06/03/2022 16:22

My very unpolished and uneducated opinion I'm sure!

ADHDWoman · 06/03/2022 16:22

I hate the low value we put on human life in general. I hate how easily we right people off because they have been traumatised, are homeless, elderly, have health issues, are mentally ill. I hate how much suffering and war there is. I hate the idea of all those young men being used as cannon fodder for rich men's wars. I hate it all. It is hard as the mother of boys and a girl to not feel that they have the same value as one another. But then on the titanic we would probably have been third class and locked in to drown, so maybe the titanic was a bad example.

Sometimes this place is hard work! I'm not going to do academic research just to answer a post, I'm just sharing my opinion.

EezyOozy · 06/03/2022 16:04

.

blodbav · 06/03/2022 15:53

[quote Wintersbone]@blodbav That's the same as the "not all men" argument. It's true but it's not relevant. If you want to offer shelter to a man from the Middle East and take that risk while working out his cultural ideas then be my guest. Most women wouldn't. [/quote]
I'm just asking what culture doesn't value women, I'm not sure where you got that from. If you're going to generalise, at least put who you're referring to.

NAMALT is the go to shit down on this site. No, this is nothing to do with that. It's like saying "not all black people are criminals" is like NAMALT. Lazy comparison, just address which culture disregards women because many people have risked their lives to save women in the Middle East.

woodhill · 06/03/2022 15:36

@SpiderVersed

I don't think it would make any difference at all - bigots will be bigots.

Our track record as a nation is absolutely disgusting. We take far fewer than our share and bleat about it endlessly. We're a disgrace.

We're a small island and last time I looked we have a multi cultural society
Wintersbone · 06/03/2022 15:24

@blodbav That's the same as the "not all men" argument. It's true but it's not relevant. If you want to offer shelter to a man from the Middle East and take that risk while working out his cultural ideas then be my guest. Most women wouldn't.

blodbav · 06/03/2022 13:58

@Wintersbone

Of course they are more open to women and children. Women and children are far safer. It's not debatable. Men are a far greater risk. Men from a culture that doesn't value women or sees them as object are an even greater risk. It has bugger all to do with othering it has to do with common sense.

What culture is this, because a lot of Afghan men and women have been killed fighting for women's rights for example. Like hunted down and executed in their own homes, even publicly. You can't generalise all, why specific people are we talking about here?

LacasadeBernadaAlba · 06/03/2022 13:34

I dislike the whole idea that somehow women and children are more "deserving" of support. What they're doing in Ukraine is incredibly sexist, letting women leave but making men stay to fight. I thought the world was beyond this now, women should be seen as having the same capability as men

So you would be happy to put your child on a bus and wave him/her off? You would prefer to leave children to take their chances in an active war zone?

Someone needs to be caring for the children. If it comes to hand to hand combat, presumably the average man is going to do a better job, even if marginally, than the average woman.

Wintersbone · 06/03/2022 13:29

Of course they are more open to women and children. Women and children are far safer. It's not debatable. Men are a far greater risk. Men from a culture that doesn't value women or sees them as object are an even greater risk. It has bugger all to do with othering it has to do with common sense.

SpiderVersed · 06/03/2022 12:54

I don't think it would make any difference at all - bigots will be bigots.

Our track record as a nation is absolutely disgusting. We take far fewer than our share and bleat about it endlessly. We're a disgrace.

CaptSkippy · 06/03/2022 12:51

@ADHDWoman

I hate so much the low value we put on men's lives. It's like we as a species have not progressed beyond the lifeboats on the titanic. Women and children first, as well as handful of men so long as they are 'first class' and everyone else can drown or die.
On the Titanic more men from first class were saved than children from third class. So this "women and children first" got applied very selectively. Also, apart from the BIrkenhead, the Titanic is the only ship where this ever happened.

Do you still consider it sexist that men are most often the victims of the violence caused by other men, such as in wars? If it were up to women we'd have far fewer wars, if any. No female leader has ever started a war.

WorraLiberty · 06/03/2022 12:36

Of course it's not hard to understand @NuffSaidSam

Given the amount of MNetters against unisex toilets and those who won't answer their phone or open the door to people they don't know, they're hardly likely to want strange men they know nothing about, living in their homes.

NuffSaidSam · 06/03/2022 12:26

@LizDoingTheCanCan

You don't know why people fear strangers more than there own husband/son. Really? I would have thought it was quite obvious.

Yet most abuse is perpetrated by people already known to the victim's family. Not refugees, not strangers, but fathers, uncles, mum's partner...

Well, yes, but someone knows whether they're being abused by their husband or son don't they? And if they're not i.e. they know those people to be safe, it makes 100% sense that they would fear a stranger more than their own DH/son. It then follows, that wouldn't feel comfortable having an unknown man live in their home but would perhaps feel comfortable welcoming a woman and/or young children.

I really don't think it's that's hard to understand tbh.

AlexaShutUp · 06/03/2022 12:25

@Kendodd

And both are at great risk of sexual exploitation I'm sorry but I disagree with you here. I think females the world over are at much greater risk of sexual exploitation and violence than males.
At a statistical level, that's probably true, but sadly the majority of unaccompanied teenage boys that I worked with had been sexually exploited along their journey. They are certainly very vulnerable to this.
Svara · 06/03/2022 12:24

I'd be comfortable with a teenage lad, I wouldn't have when DS was younger but now he is man sized I would. I wouldn't be comfortable with a man in my house as a single woman.

Kendodd · 06/03/2022 12:22

The above isn't to say we shouldn't value mens lives, we absolutely should.

Kendodd · 06/03/2022 12:21

I hate so much the low value we put on men's lives
Not true. There are more than 100 million women missing. Females don't even get to be born.

HELLITHURT · 06/03/2022 12:19

@ADHDWoman

I hate so much the low value we put on men's lives. It's like we as a species have not progressed beyond the lifeboats on the titanic. Women and children first, as well as handful of men so long as they are 'first class' and everyone else can drown or die.
I totally agree!
LizDoingTheCanCan · 06/03/2022 12:16

You don't know why people fear strangers more than there own husband/son. Really? I would have thought it was quite obvious.

Yet most abuse is perpetrated by people already known to the victim's family. Not refugees, not strangers, but fathers, uncles, mum's partner...

NuffSaidSam · 06/03/2022 12:09

@ThinWomansBrain

From another recent thread on here about offering refuge in your own home, there were quite a few "women and children only" responses. Quite why posters assume that refugee males are more likely to be paedophiles that their own husbands or sons, not quite sure.
That's an odd one.

You don't know why people fear strangers more than there own husband/son. Really? I would have thought it was quite obvious.

ADHDWoman · 06/03/2022 12:09

@Kendodd

And both are at great risk of sexual exploitation I'm sorry but I disagree with you here. I think females the world over are at much greater risk of sexual exploitation and violence than males.
I didn't say that young males are more at risk just that they are at great risk. Which they are
SushiGo · 06/03/2022 12:06

@AlexaShutUp

I used to work with unaccompanied minors, ie children. They were treated like shit by the asylum system, and they faced a huge amount of racism in the local community. I found it hard to believe that people could be so cold about kids who had been through the most unimaginable trauma. I guess their faces didn't fit.

So no, I don't think it would make a huge amount of difference.

I think people pretend it would make a difference to make them feel better about their internalised racism towards displaced people.
Kendodd · 06/03/2022 12:04

And both are at great risk of sexual exploitation
I'm sorry but I disagree with you here. I think females the world over are at much greater risk of sexual exploitation and violence than males.