Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refugees

84 replies

Rinatinabina · 06/03/2022 10:47

Do you think people generally would be more open to receiving refugees if they were primarily women and children?

For example if there were mainly women in tents in Calais do you think Britain generally would be happier accepting them than they are men?

YABU: it wouldn’t make a difference
YANBU: people would be more welcoming to women

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thereisonlyoneofme · 11/03/2022 10:44

montysma1, if the UK was invaded I assume you wouldnt expect anyone to fight for you then.

montysma1 · 11/03/2022 05:06

Women don't have the same capability as men in war/fighting/physicality.

And they would be in even greater danger than men. History has shown what invading forces do to women. Its actually used as a type of warfare.

That being said, I dont think men should be made to fight if they don't want to.

Suzi888 · 11/03/2022 04:41

@AlexaShutUp

I used to work with unaccompanied minors, ie children. They were treated like shit by the asylum system, and they faced a huge amount of racism in the local community. I found it hard to believe that people could be so cold about kids who had been through the most unimaginable trauma. I guess their faces didn't fit.

So no, I don't think it would make a huge amount of difference.

^ That is awful Sad poor kids.
fallfallfall · 11/03/2022 00:56

Not to forget bank accounts and jobs.

fallfallfall · 11/03/2022 00:43

if they were pale christians that would fit in with the culture maybe. coming from a country with a passport and biometrics so you can ascertain who they are, very very helpful and then there is recognizable education.

Grantanow · 11/03/2022 00:35

Johnson's government talks up helping Ukrainean refugees but erects all sorts of barriers to their actually reaching the UK - lots of forms to fill in, documents to produce, translations required, visa centres far from Calais, etc. Pritti Patel is one the worst Home Secretaries we have ever had, the Home Office has a terrible history with refugees (just think of Windrush) and there needs to be a clear out.

Bromse · 07/03/2022 19:25

I'd never thought of it like that. Certainly parents and children should be treated more sympathetically but I have no problem with welcoming refugees at all. If I had a place where they could stay whilst getting on their feet, I'd offer it.

zafferana · 07/03/2022 19:18

I think the issue people have is the disconnect between the narrative of 'desperate, vulnerable people fleeing war' and the reality of fit, healthy young men who are prepared to cross through multiple safe countries to cherry pick where they end up. The gangs of Muslim men who have been convicted in recent years of sexually abusing and sometimes murdering women in western countries also doesn't help. Large number of young men without their families may be best placed to find work and put down roots, but they are also a threat to the safety and security of their destination countries.

MorrisZapp · 07/03/2022 19:17

@ThinWomansBrain

From another recent thread on here about offering refuge in your own home, there were quite a few "women and children only" responses. Quite why posters assume that refugee males are more likely to be paedophiles that their own husbands or sons, not quite sure.
What a bizarre take. People's husbands and sons are their family. Strangers are strangers.

It's entirely understandable that people would prefer to offer safety to women and children.

Villagewaspbyke · 07/03/2022 19:07

@ThinWomansBrain - I don’t think it’s unreasonable to want only women and children if you are accommodating people in your own home. I am a single mum with 2 dds - I definitely wouldn’t want an adult man I didn’t know in my house. I think it’s natural to find women and children less threatening than men (and statistics bear that out too - vast majority of violent crime is committed by men).

BlackCoffeeInAPoolOfSunshine · 07/03/2022 19:00

Aside from the detail above... I live near Munich and know people who've taken mothers and children, solo women and small children and babies from an orphanage in (in the last case members of the Munich Ukrainian and indeed Russian community who speak relevant languages).

In the mostly male wave of refugees a few years ago this didn't happen though people mobilised to donate money and bikes and medical supplies and clothes and indeed to help access services and all sorts - accommodation was set up in sports halls and containers and there wasn't the grassroots movement to open up spare rooms.

This is completely logical from a purely objective point of view - statistically the risks from women and small children are very different from the risk from post pubescent and adult males and the risk to personal safety statistically completely different. That's not about deserving refuge but about the fact that regardless of whether victims are male or female statistically men commit the vast majority of violent crimes.

CaptSkippy · 07/03/2022 18:46

@Kendodd

I'm just asking what culture doesn't value women I'd say any country or culture where males outnumber females would be a good measure to go by.
There is no country on Earth that truly values women. If there were misogyny would actually be considered hate-speech. There would not be an overhwleming number of derogatory slurs describing women and girls as opposed to boys and men.

In a country where women are truly valued women would make up at least 50% of government leaders and business leaders. Women would not die needlessly from diseases with preventable causes, just because the world of medicine of dominated by men. Etc, etc.

Kendodd · 07/03/2022 08:04

Are you seriously holding up places in the world where people are murdered for defending womens rights as a marker of a place with high value on women? So when Malala Yousafzai (and others) was shot for demanding the right to an education for girls you thought 'they must really value women where she lives'? And can I point out that the women living under these laws and practices are also brown or does that not matter just as long as we don't call out the perpetrators because they also happen to be brown?
No country in the world has completely cracked it when it comes to womens rights but let's not pretend that there aren't better and worse places in the world to be a women.

blodbav · 06/03/2022 21:01

@Kendodd

Tbh I think you know perfectly well that across the ME and north Africa countries are heavily bias towards men. It's even enshrined in some of their laws ffs.
People have died fighting for women's rights. Nice of you to ignore that.

And clearly exceptionally ignorant, pretending like you know what your talking about. There's so many ethnic groups and cultures but they're all brown so they must all be the same, innitHmm

forinborin · 06/03/2022 18:07

I cannot understand these threads that pop up about ukrainian refugees all the time. The UK was crystal clear that no unsponsored Ukrainian refugees will be allowed in, and at the moment only close relatives of settled people can come under a specific temporary visa route.

HELLITHURT · 06/03/2022 17:56

@Kendodd

Tbh I think you know perfectly well that across the ME and north Africa countries are heavily bias towards men. It's even enshrined in some of their laws ffs.
Wtf are you saying here?
Kendodd · 06/03/2022 17:45

Tbh I think you know perfectly well that across the ME and north Africa countries are heavily bias towards men. It's even enshrined in some of their laws ffs.

Kendodd · 06/03/2022 17:34

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_sex_ratio

Kendodd · 06/03/2022 17:34

It's not nearly the trend in countries in the Middle East
It is.
Male babies are highly prized over females and sex selective abortion is not uncommon.

luckylavender · 06/03/2022 17:31

@thereisonlyoneofme

Unfortunately due to the threat of terrorism etc from certain parts of the world, some form of restriction has to be set. People are up in arms when it has turned out in the past criminals/bombers have bypassed the asylum system by illegal entry. re economic migrants If we want to migrate somewhere like Australia etc for work there is a process to be gone through you cant just turn up.

The Ukraine scenario is different, as is the Afghan resettlement
However, homes, education etc have to be found for all these people.
I m aware many will join relatives already here, or may only wish to stay until their homeland is safe again.

Also there is a lot of Tory bashing that no homes are being built. Try saying that in the South East where many thousands of houses are being built, with no infrastructure to go with it.

I live in the South East but this attitude really annoys me. The South East is not the whole of the U.K.
luckylavender · 06/03/2022 17:28

@FairyCakeWings

No, I don't think people would be more accommodating or sympathetic to women and children. They are a much bigger drain to the public purse than men who can work cash in hand.
Nice attitude
blodbav · 06/03/2022 17:27

@Kendodd

I'm just asking what culture doesn't value women I'd say any country or culture where males outnumber females would be a good measure to go by.
I totally get that and it's true in some places - but it doesn't really apply to the places where a lot of refugees come from. I believe it happens/happened in India and China.

It's not nearly the trend in countries in the Middle East where people are actively fighting against repressive regimes (or complying out of blind fear). It's not fair to condemn them all when it's nowhere near as simplistic as that.

Even when IS we're around, people in Raqqa were forced to live there, many civilians couldn't leave. You can't just look at people and say they must hate women.

If you're talking about another group, please specify.

Ted27 · 06/03/2022 17:14

There are many women staying to fight in Ukraine. Someone has to go with children. and the elderly
Systematic rape of women has become established as means of grinding down the civilian population.
There are already reports of rape in Ukraine. I'd take a bet that most men would want their children safe with their mothers

Kendodd · 06/03/2022 17:04

Especially at birth.

Kendodd · 06/03/2022 17:00

I'm just asking what culture doesn't value women
I'd say any country or culture where males outnumber females would be a good measure to go by.

Swipe left for the next trending thread