Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I go to CSA??

63 replies

kickasssinglemum · 06/03/2022 10:06

Me and my ex-p split when our DS was a few weeks ago. Since DS was 4 months old ex-p started paying me £200 per month for maintenance. This increased to £350 on my request to cover half the childcare costs as we both work full time.

He has our DS overnight 2 nights a week (as he’s still a toddler). DS goes to childcare 3 days per week and I have him at home with me the other 2 days per week, while working a full-time job 5 days a week (I wfm these 2 days). My job is very stressful and demanding but I’m trying to keep the cost of childcare to a minimum.

We both have good jobs and earn well. Ex-p earns significantly more than me however. He is self employed so I don’t know how much exactly. However he owns 3 expensive properties (1 he lives in and 2 he rents out) as well as a mobile holiday home and drives a very nice car.

He has complained previously that he shouldn’t be paying me anything at all as I also have a ‘good job’ and that he only needs to “pay what he can”.

Childcare fees have now increased due to inflation so essentially there will be nothing left over from his current £350 once I pay half of his share of the childcare fees. I have asked him for more and he’s reluctant to increase the monthly payment anymore than £50 a month (so £400).

I pay for everything for DS and ex-p doesn’t pay for anything extra, except supplying what DS needs the 2 nights he stays with ex-p. We also share the driving for when DS stays with ex-p but ex-p doesn’t share the driving to nursery. I do all of that.

Ex-p has a new girlfriend and they frequently go on foreign holidays together and spend a lot of their weekends travelling around the country staying in 5* spa hotels. His girlfriend is much younger than him and wouldn’t be earning much at all to afford such a lifestyle, so I know he pays for everything for her.

I’m thinking I should go to CSA to get them to properly assess what ex-should be paying as I think it should be a lot more. Thoughts?

I don’t know ex-p’s NI number so is it a case that CSA will write to ex-p to ask him to provide details of what he earns?

OP posts:
ChiselandBits · 06/03/2022 19:03

I don't think arguing about if £400 is a lot or not is helpful. For some it more than covers 50% of what they are outlying on a child, for others, it doesn't touch the sides. Its about what is relative to the parents' earning power. A barrister is NOT going to be on a small or average salary.

Mangoberries · 06/03/2022 18:57

OP,
What would you like him to pay per month?
Instead of asking for frequent raises, perhaps ask him for what you think he should pay?

GreMay1 · 06/03/2022 18:40

@hupfpferd

Definitely stop referring to the money as "half of childcare" etc.

You run the risk that he stops paying when your child goes to school.

£400 is not a lot. My ex pays £450 and earns substantially less than £50k

£400 is a lot though and OP gets 2 nights a week. I know there's the whole long debate of it doesn't cut it to raise a child. I absolutely understand and agree.

Realistically though £400/£450 for CM is a lot of money generally speaking on average.

hupfpferd · 06/03/2022 18:24

Definitely stop referring to the money as "half of childcare" etc.

You run the risk that he stops paying when your child goes to school.

£400 is not a lot. My ex pays £450 and earns substantially less than £50k

RandomMess · 06/03/2022 17:08

He is a barrister he will submit annual accounts as he is self-employed.

He will not want to have a legal dispute because he is a barrister, I would look into with not paying CMS risks his licence/registration and no longer being able to work.

His earnings will fluctuate depending on when he is paid for his work so some years you could get more than others.

LittleOwl153 · 06/03/2022 17:04

I'm aware of that sadly. Clearly this bloke is a pass taker when it comes to paying his share.
As I doubt the CMS is going to come up with anything useful for the OP, I was looking for alternatives or ways of phrasing getting a voluntary increase from him.

ChiselandBits · 06/03/2022 17:00

of course he can argue with it - legally, the CMS amount is ALL he can asked for unless something else was included with a separate consent order upon divorce, eg private school fees.

LittleOwl153 · 06/03/2022 16:56

What's half of the full time nursery place? He can't argue with the request to pay that (although I expect he will!)

Is he self employed or does he have his own company... if he has a company his earnings are easier to find... but also easier to legitimately discount!

He should be paying 12% of his income so on £100k he owes £1000 a month. I might ask for £650/700.

If he is over £150k you can apply direct to the court for additional maintenance... I wonder if mentioning that would encourage him to pay more...

ChiselandBits · 06/03/2022 16:34

If he is barrister its going to be rather harder for him to hide his payments than if he was a cash in hand tradesman for instance. Any sniff of illegality and he'd be dis-barred. Ignore those saying you're "lucky" to get what you do. he should be paying the CMS rate as a MINIMUM. The childcare issue has to be done to death on other threads but for what it's worth, IMHO, if both parents are enabled to work by paid childcare then they should be sharing that cost (or whatever is owed after any tax credits are factored in.) on top of any CMS figure which is very loosely defined as "a contribution toward the essentials" - meaning of course than anything beyond the most basic bed and board can't be asked for.

kickasssinglemum · 06/03/2022 16:27

The girlfriend is 12 years his junior. She just finished uni last summer so highly doubt she is contributing much to their social life.
I would love to drop down to a 4 day week but I couldn’t afford to financially.

OP posts:
GreMay1 · 06/03/2022 15:56

I would not rock the boat OP in your case. I would push gently for the extra £50 a month and leave because your ex has your DS 2 nights a week also.

Can you reduce your work days to 4 perhaps? Or use a child minder?

funinthesun19 · 06/03/2022 15:48

I’d check the calculator first. If they assess him and say he has to pay less then he will do that.
Also you don’t truly know his girlfriend’s financial situation even if you might have a rough idea what she earns. She might have money stashed away you know nothing about. She might be paying for more than you think.

kickasssinglemum · 06/03/2022 15:16

It’s not that I want him to pay for childcare necessarily, just more maintenance in general as I don’t think the £350 is currently enough based on what he earns. I know he definitely earns more than £80k, but being able to prove that though CMS is another matter if he’s self employed and can ‘hide’ some of it. I think based on all of the advice I will avoid going though CMS as I don’t think it would be worth the hassle. I will just try and appeal to him reasonably to contribute more. If not monthly then to pay for things on an ad hoc basis. Thanks all

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 06/03/2022 14:20

If he's self employed he can easily avoid CMS at all. Many self employed men pay £7 pw . Given he has him 2 nights every week that will reduce what he's expected to pay. I'd stick with what yo got rather than rock the boat

Thehop · 06/03/2022 14:20

I would think carefully. He’s not obliged to pay towards any childcare at all.

LuaDipa · 06/03/2022 14:16

@justamumseekingadvice

Considering the fact that your child stays several nights a week with your ex - you are VERY unlikely to get anymore of child maintenance service, you will probably end up getting less.

Seriously £350-400 - count yourself lucky and be grateful for that rather than cutting off your nose to spite your face - I get £30 a month for my DD and plenty of single parents on here get absolutely nothing - try living off that!

I’m sorry you get such a small amount, but op should not be grateful that her ex is paying for his child. The system is utterly wrong but that isn’t op’s fault. She she should get what she is entitled to as should every other single parent. What is wrong is that your ex gets away with paying so little.
newbiename · 06/03/2022 11:31

@justamumseekingadvice

Considering the fact that your child stays several nights a week with your ex - you are VERY unlikely to get anymore of child maintenance service, you will probably end up getting less.

Seriously £350-400 - count yourself lucky and be grateful for that rather than cutting off your nose to spite your face - I get £30 a month for my DD and plenty of single parents on here get absolutely nothing - try living off that!

She should be grateful he contributes financially to his child ? She pays for everything.
LacasadeBernadaAlba · 06/03/2022 11:29

Seriously £350-400 - count yourself lucky and be grateful for that rather than cutting off your nose to spite your face

If the ex partner is paying below the minimum that the CMS would calculate, I don't think she needs to be grateful for what she gets. It's a legal minimum at the end of the day. The system is utterly broken - I haven't received a penny for 3 children in 12 years - but we shouldn't be telling people to feel grateful they're getting as much as they do because it's more than we get.

MorningStarling · 06/03/2022 11:25

As a rule only go to the CMS if you're certain that you will get significantly more than you get through any voluntary arrangements. If they award you less, or even the same, it's a lot of hassle and aggravation for nothing.

cadburyegg · 06/03/2022 11:20

As he is self employed and you're getting £350-£400 for one child I don't think it would be worth the hassle of going through the CMS

AHungryCaterpillar · 06/03/2022 11:16

I would try to avoid cms if you can, they are rubbish, my ex didn’t have to pay anything and cms wouldn’t do anything about it.

kickasssinglemum · 06/03/2022 10:53

He’s currently only paying £350. He hasn’t agreed to the £50 increase yet! My worry is that he would try and go for 50/50 custody and as he’s a barrister he would have lots of legal friends who could advise him on what to say.

He doesn’t live wi the his girlfriend but on the 2 nights he does have DS he passes him off to his mum so he would do that if it was on a 50/50 split basis. I would die if he got 50/50 as DS is only 2.

I think I’m probably best asking him to agree to the increase to £400 and as and when big purchases come up maybe help out there too from time to time.

OP posts:
millymolls · 06/03/2022 10:40

Well
Of course he should help more but unfortunately

I). He’s not expected or required to pay towards childcare costs ( over and above cms mo they min)
2) he’s self employed, likely to only pay himself c£12k per year

So you could see it go down based on a cms assessment

kickasssinglemum · 06/03/2022 10:40

Thanks for the advice all. I think he would be really difficult financially if I went to CMS. If the assessment was lower he would start paying the lower amount.

I know he should be paying a lot but if it runs the risk that he earns less then it may not be worth the hassle. I might just try and have to appeal to his reasonable side and hope that he can work with me financially in splitting the cost of childcare and then contributing a bit more to general maintenance also.

OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 06/03/2022 10:34

He is under no legal obligation to actually pay for your childcare anyway just 12% minus his two days

Can you get a cheaper provider?