Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - kids and alcohol free drinks

69 replies

GobblingWeasel · 06/03/2022 10:05

Hi,
I've recently got into drinking 0% Martini Vibrante with tonic. Unfortunately DD10 has also decided she loves it too and would like an occasional drink of her own instead of stealing sips of mine! The idea of giving a child a drink modelled on an alcoholic version makes me feel uneasy even though it is alcohol free, but really does that matter? What do you think wise people, please help me decide!

OP posts:
mrsbyers · 06/03/2022 18:27

@Proudboomer

Never heard of this drink so I just looked it up. It contains both Potassium Sorbate and Sodium Benzoate both of which I try to avoid so I wouldn’t drink it myself or give it to a child. Potassium Sorbate is actually banned for use in EU and Canada.
This isn’t true
NuffSaidSam · 06/03/2022 18:23

Isn't it always shown that in countries where they introduce alcohol early, in a responsible family setting they have much lower rates of binge drinking and alcoholism? Like in France for example.

Is there actually any evidence that drinking at home with your parents younger leads to a worse relationship with alcohol when you get older? I think it's actually the opposite.

AuntFlorence · 06/03/2022 18:23

Whether I prohibit my tween from drinking alcohol free booze or not will not determine whether they go on to be alcoholic. They will be exposed to actual alcohol at some point or not, in our society it is inevitable that they will be offered and heavily peer pressured into drinking. It's everywhere. Keeping an open relationship and having lots of conversations about health and mental Health and alcohol and all those things, will mean that if they do have a struggle round alcohol they will know they have someone to talk to about that.
With my tween it's very much a case of talking about what they want (eg. To drink Coca Cola) and what I want (them not to drink Coca Cola) and giving them all the facts before coming to a middle ground.

LuckySantangelo35 · 06/03/2022 18:19

@UndertheCedartree well 18 is probably optimistic, 14/15 more likely when they will start experimenting with alcohol. I dunno I think you can make it in a ‘forbidden fruit’ a bit too much. Also the candy cigarette sweets that were very popular when I was a kid did not induce me into smoking. There are so many other factors that lead kids to drink/smoke mostly to do with their peers rather than having the odd glass of this or that at home

UndertheCedartree · 06/03/2022 18:07

[quote LuckySantangelo35]@Rewis
A “gateway” thing? It’s not like drugs, most kids will grow into teens who will pretty much inevitably drink alcohol[/quote]
But you don't want them heading that way at 10. 18 ok, 10 no, imo.

UndertheCedartree · 06/03/2022 18:05

@Soontobe60

When I was a child, we used to ‘smoke’ chocolate cigarettes, pretending to be like our parents - until we were old enough to buy the real thing. You can’t buy them now - for good reason. It’s normalising the action of smoking in children. Letting children drink alcohol free versions of alcoholic drinks does just the same thing. It normalises drinking alcohol.
Yep, me and my friends used to do that too!

No, I wouldn't give my DC (14&9) a non-alcoholic drink modelled on alcohol. It would normalise drinking alcoholic drinks which I don't want. I wouldn't have let them try it to be honest, but I appreciate it's more tricky if they've tried and liked it!

Xpologog · 06/03/2022 18:00

@Soontobe60

When I was a child, we used to ‘smoke’ chocolate cigarettes, pretending to be like our parents - until we were old enough to buy the real thing. You can’t buy them now - for good reason. It’s normalising the action of smoking in children. Letting children drink alcohol free versions of alcoholic drinks does just the same thing. It normalises drinking alcohol.
This.
LuckySantangelo35 · 06/03/2022 17:53

@Rewis
A “gateway” thing? It’s not like drugs, most kids will grow into teens who will pretty much inevitably drink alcohol

lookforthesun · 06/03/2022 16:04

I wouldn’t. I’m uncomfortable at giving children drinks marketed as adult drinks or that might encourage them into taking the step to drinking alcohol earlier than they should.

LovelyRita1 · 06/03/2022 15:59

I feel the same op. My dh wanted to let my then 5yo try 0% beer in a restaurant and I asked him not to. I can't figure out why though! I let them have my elderflower cordial and tonic water which looks just like a g&t

NuffSaidSam · 06/03/2022 15:57

What if they grew up to be alcoholics?

I'm assuming no-one wants their child to be an alcoholic.

Is there a link between alcohol-free fruity drinks and alcoholism though?

I think people who turn to alcohol for comfort/a coping mechanism have generally got bigger problems in than drinking alcohol free soft drinks at the odd special occasion/family event when they were a child.

Soontobe60 · 06/03/2022 15:52

@AuntFlorence

The difference is with smoking pretend cigarettes is that I don't want my kids to grow up fo be smokers but if they grow up to be moderate drinkers it wouldn't bother me.
What if they grew up to be alcoholics?
notthemum · 06/03/2022 12:47

@user1471447924

Nope. Those things are not for children.
This
TheSillyMastiff · 06/03/2022 11:32

Personally I'd just give it to her but call it cordial and tonic. Because that's all it is, you've paid like £10 for a bottle of posh squash.

I let DS 7 drink a shandy bass, or a home made shandy occasionally. If I open a bottle of beer he always asks for one so I end up loosing the neck of my bottle to make him a week shandy.

He's also had watered down wine at meals.

It de-mistifies alcohol to them if you introduce it slowly and responsibly. It's why many European cultures don't have the binge drinking issues we have here in the UK. I come from a European family and we were always given watered down wine at family meals and things. I out of my friends am probably now the one who drinks alcohol less. Many of my friends drink a glass of wine after work every day, I can go months without drinking alcohol and it's never an issue.

CourtRand · 06/03/2022 11:30

Under 18s can't buy nonalcoholic beer/spirits. So if they're not allowed to buy them they shouldn't be able to drink them. It gets them used to 'alcohol' flavours.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 06/03/2022 11:26

I think the difference is one is made by removing alcohol (the main ingredient listed is dealcoholised wine) as opposed to there never being alcohol.

NuffSaidSam · 06/03/2022 11:22

@Rewis

But that's also true of coke, lemonade, orange juice etc. all the popular mixers

I was actually thinking about this when I read the ops post. I think for me it comes down to intended purpose. Oj and cokes intended purpose is not to be a replacement for alcohol. Where as non-alcoholic things the purpose is to imitate alcohol.

So in my head a kids cocktail sprite, orangejuice and strawberry syrup is fine and kid friendly. But adding a dash of non-alcoholic gin would make it an adult drink.

I know what you mean, but it doesn't really make any logical sense does it?

It seems different, but it isn't really. If she's drinking it at home with her mum, a child's cocktail made of sweet fruity drinks and an alcohol free sweet, fruity drink is the same? It's just different to us because we're aware of the marketing/branding.

Rewis · 06/03/2022 11:16

But that's also true of coke, lemonade, orange juice etc. all the popular mixers

I was actually thinking about this when I read the ops post. I think for me it comes down to intended purpose. Oj and cokes intended purpose is not to be a replacement for alcohol. Where as non-alcoholic things the purpose is to imitate alcohol.

So in my head a kids cocktail sprite, orangejuice and strawberry syrup is fine and kid friendly. But adding a dash of non-alcoholic gin would make it an adult drink.

FluffyBooBoo · 06/03/2022 11:10

These drinks are often treated the same way as alcohol in a supermarket for good reason. It's marketed to adults as an alternative to alcohol.

Just like vaping is as an alternative to smoking. Would you want your ten year old vaping?

Drywhitefruitycidergin · 06/03/2022 11:09

I wouldn't as they are not completely alcohol free and are chemically.
It's probably not much difference to bass shandy though I guess.

I do let my 10 year old dd have mocktails (juice and lemonade ina cocktail glass) and have a sip of my actual drinks; she likes pear cider

NuffSaidSam · 06/03/2022 11:08

I want to address the point that alcohol free drinks supposedly taste different to the alcohol versions they're modelled on. This isn't really true; you don't get alcohol free vodka, as an example, because it wouldn't be possible to make them taste similar. Drinks companies only make alcohol free versions of drinks that taste very similar to the real thing, and this is particularly easy to do with sweet drinks, the type where you wouldn't really know if there was booze in it or not. The drink being discussed, Martini Vibrante, is fruity and sweet. The fruity sweetness hides the alcohol (or lack of it) - that's why it's a good virgin drink. These are the flavour qualities that also, worryingly, are most appealing to children.

But that's also true of coke, lemonade, orange juice etc. all the popular mixers. But we don't ring our hands about a ten year old having a coke and getting addicted to X and coke down the line, do we?

These non-alcoholic drinks are just the mixers basically, same as coke, lemonade, orange juice, any sweet, syrupy drink. Obviously not ideal for everyday, but also not linked to alcoholism down the line.

DropYourSword · 06/03/2022 11:03

@NewPapaGuinea

Martini Vibrante has less than 0.5% alcohol, so not strictly alchohol free.
To be fair though, grape juice, apple juice and orange juice can all also potentially be around 0.5% ABV! I do t think it's the very low alcohol content that's the issue here. I agree it's almost like the chocolate cigarettes we had as children. It just makes an adult thing more appealing to a young child.
Rewis · 06/03/2022 11:02

It feels weird to me. Can't really explain why. Weirdly it feels like an adult thing even when alcohol free. Like a gateway drink or something. I'm not sure kids that young should have something that is modeled after alcoholic beverage. I feel similarly people drinking non alcoholic beer at work. There is nothing wrong with it but a gp having a can of Heineken 0,0% would be a bit off.

pawpaws2022 · 06/03/2022 11:01

I was allowed to drink from an early age - Pimms was the thing I loved! So my mum would do a tiny measure (like 1/3 of a standard one) and then add the lemonade.
I grew up around alcohol and seeing what it did to people and was more sensible with it than a lot of my friends because I could say "can I have a pimms?" And would get yes/no
Just put a tiny dash in rather than a full measure

If she likes the tonic then just do that, or she might like the more adult fruit sparkling waters as they're not sweet? Like dash or aqua Libra

Eightiesfan · 06/03/2022 10:59

Personally, I wouldn’t, at 10 I’m not sure how much you could explain about alcoholic vs non-alcoholic to her. She’s going to feel very grown up and tell her friends she’s allowed mummy’s martini.

Plus even though it has no alcohol, it does seem a bit like social drinking with a child and might give her the perception it’s okay.

At the end of the day, you know your daughter better than anyone on here, but it’s clear you are unsure as you’re posting on here. If your gut says no, that’s your answer.