Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think GP’s should encourage breastfeeding?

95 replies

Sofedup2022 · 05/03/2022 22:28

I’m so fed up and furious this evening! I’ve been struggling with anxiety and depression for a few months now and have an 11 month old baby.

I finally worked up the courage to book a doctors appointment - which was a nightmare in itself as it’s impossible to book into our local surgery. I finally got a telephone appointment with a nurse this morning.

I explained how I was feeling and she asked if I was breastfeeding. Once I said yes she said that meant I couldn’t take any drugs and the only option was to refer me to counselling. I politely said I’d been told by the breastfeeding network that there were antidepressants that were safe while breastfeeding, at which point she said she’d speak to the junior doctor and call me back.

She rang me back to tell me that almost all antidepressants aren’t safe while breastfeeding as it passes to the baby so I had two options

  1. Take Amitriptyline which may make the baby sleepy
  2. Stop breastfeeding and take another antidepressant!
I was pretty irritated but decided I would try the Amitriptyline. I have gone to take my first dose this evening and realised I have been prescribed 10mg. I have checked the NICE guidelines and that is the dosage they prescribe for back pain, while they advise at least 50mg for treating depression.

I am so furious. It took a lot for me to make the appointment and they made me feel like a selfish mother for wanting drugs and have essentially made it clear that if I want anything that will actually help me they expect me to stop breastfeeding.

Breastfeeding has been hugely protective for my mental health and has been one area of motherhood that I feel really good about. I have no intention of stopping and luckily know enough to query what she said initially or I’d have ended up stuck on an 18 month long waiting list for counselling! I do have counselling privately which I did explain to her, it’s not that I’m looking for a magic pill to fix everything, but I have taken antidepressants in the past and they were the only thing that was truly effective.

WIBU to complain? Should I book another appointment? Who would I even complain to?!

OP posts:
UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 06/03/2022 00:52

@lochmaree

I started taking a really low dose of sertraline while bf my 18m old. I think its the preferred SSRI for bf mums but citalopram could also be used. I'm also pregnant and there's been no issue with me continuing the sertraline.

@ParalysisByAnalysis OP clearly said that bf helps her mental health, why should she have to stop simply because her HCPs have given incorrect advice? bf past 1 year has benefits for mum and baby, no reason why she can't continue. also worth noting that some mums experience a temporary decline in mental health after weaning from bf due to the hormonal changes, so stopping may make her mental health worse.

Can 100% confirm, as someone currently signed off work for severe depression that really only became unmanageable once I started cutting down on feeds. The hormonal rebalancing is like nothing I’ve ever experienced before. I’m not in the least bit sad, and yet I physically can’t stop crying at various points throughout the day. It is truly the strangest sensation.
NewtoHolland · 06/03/2022 00:48

The specialist pharmacist who writes the breastfeeding network guidance on medication is a great source. In fact all of the BFN guidance is based on reviews of the evidence whether it's around healing sore nipples or best advice on latching. Its the best source we have for breastfeeding information in this country. I hope you can discuss this with a GP who understands OP.

bellac11 · 06/03/2022 00:44

Not connected to breast feeding but a family member has had this, being prescribed a non therapeutic dose of anti depressants and then being startled when challenged about that.

And as you say, impossible to be seen properly, you need face to face appointments for mental health I would say

Tinuviel · 06/03/2022 00:41

@ParalysisByAnalysis

Why are you believing the “breastfeeding network” (whatever that is) over the opinion of two doctors?!

Also, with the best will in the world, your almost-1 year old will benefit much more from you being in good mental health, than your breast milk.

Because Wendy Jones at the Breastfeeding Network did her PhD on Drugs in Breastmilk, so knows considerably more than the majority of GPs?
ralanne · 06/03/2022 00:34

@Jellyfishjean

They're just telling you the scientific facts.They can't change them just because you don't like them.
No, they are misinformed or not up to date on the research. There are SSRI's which are safe to take during breastfeeding as the molecule is too large to pass into the breast milk.
tothemoonandbackbuses · 05/03/2022 23:58

I’ve found the default when bf is to say you can’t have the medication. So far I’ve been denied antibiotics and decent antihistamines. Recently I kicked up a major fuss as they wanted to do a painful medical procedure without any painkillers or sedation because I’m bf. I checked on the bf network (which is the site with all the relevant info) and they did some reading up and said yes you’re right the painkillers and sedatives are safe.
If I hadn’t known where to find the info I would have either had to stop bf or suffered.
Frankly it’s an appalling failure of the nhs.

ItsJustMyFace · 05/03/2022 23:52

My GP prescribed sertraline but only 'as baby is weaning and won't be having as much milk anymore'. They also suggested I completely stop breastfeeding so I could take the medication! I was so upset I spoke to my Health Visitor and some breastfeeding support groups and decided to take the medication and continue breastfeeding on their advice.

I'm so glad I did. A year on I'm still breastfeeding daily and on my medication which has made a real difference to my life.

Nectarines · 05/03/2022 23:42

After GP appointment at four weeks post partum, I had a choice of either paroxetine or sertraline for pnd while breastfeeding. I opted for sertraline with full support of my gp and immediately started to feel better. It took a while to get back to my former self but I got there. And I breastfed my baby until almost two years old.

Blossom64265 · 05/03/2022 23:40

Your GP is giving out inappropriate medical information and you need to file a complaint. The GP needs further training.

There are absolutely antidepressants that are perfectly safe for breastfeeding. If your GP has spent any effort at all the information is easily accessible and the first recommendation is never Amitriptyline.

SickAndTiredAgain · 05/03/2022 23:36

@Thefrenchconnection1

I'd just lie and say I'm not breastfeeding if I had reliable advice elsewhere. Go back and ask for one you know is safe.
So would I. If I was following the NHS guidelines I’d be fine with it.
thingymaboob · 05/03/2022 23:30

Ask to speak to one of the GP partners - they'll be more experienced then the junior GP registrar

Kistam · 05/03/2022 23:26

Maudsley guidelines state:

It is usually inappropriate to stop breastfeeding except when the currently prescribed drug is contraindicated in breastfeeding.

There is a table with excellent summary for each drug.
As stated sertraline and mirtazapine overall best evidence for safety.
Amitripyline has been associated with poor feed in and sedation in the infant.

Also this is keeping my brain going during Mat leave so at least there’s that!

To think GP’s should encourage breastfeeding?
To think GP’s should encourage breastfeeding?
To think GP’s should encourage breastfeeding?
nocoolnamesleft · 05/03/2022 23:23

Surprised they didn't go with sertraline. That usually seems to be the favourite for pregnant and breastfeeding mums.

Kistam · 05/03/2022 23:17

I’d just add further to my previous comment- have you been counselled about amitripyline side effects?
In real life it’s unlikely to make any difference and especially when presumably your child’s main nurtritional needs are met through food. I can say certainly it not the safest in breastfeeding although the risks are very small.
If you don’t feel confident absolutely complain.
I use choice and medication website as well as maudsley guidelines.

Mulhollandmagoo · 05/03/2022 23:10

Speak with your health visitor? I had a brilliant one who got me the help I needed, I know it's luck of the draw but it's definitely an avenue to explore. My SIL has some severe mental health issues, and is on sertraline and has been breastfeeding my nephew for 10 months now with no problems, so I would agree you have been misinformed. A lot of GPs don't seem to have much knowledge with female specific health issues I've found.

Hottubtimemachine · 05/03/2022 23:07

I am shocked that people are saying you are being unreasonable. You absolutely can take an antidepressant when breastfeeding. Please feedback the learning need and speak to another doctor.

Kistam · 05/03/2022 23:06

I’m a psychiatrist and although obviously this is not individual advice there are definitely medications you can take! Sertraline would be first choice and I have considered starting it myself when breastfeeding for postpartum anxiety.
Passes into milk in minimal amounts, very unlikely to cause any SE for baby and unlikely to impact you when your child is relatively older and you have well established supply.

Unfortunately at least in my area you wouldn’t meet criteria for perinatal mental health team as your child is nearly one.

With respect to other health professionals , it sounds like the problem is that you didn’t speak to a GP! A nurse in a GP practice is not best placed to be giving advice and I can assure you having been one that the junior doctor is definitely not the right person either!
An experienced GP should have been able to give you the correct advice and indeed if they couldn’t they should have found out and come back to you.

I am very surprised by the amitripyline- but the dose itself is fine at least for initiation- Start low and go slow. However I admit I only tend to use it as an adjunct…

Luredbyapomegranate · 05/03/2022 23:05

Ring back up and ask to speak to a senior GP.

Don’t take it too personally. I know lots of ADs are safe while BF, but a lot of docs would take the view that the fewer the better, and would assume that at 11 months you were close to weaning,

You should absolutely advocate for yourself but just insist on GP phoner, and have info to hand.

goeasyonmee · 05/03/2022 23:03

I've been in the same position op. GP told me categorically there was no antidepressant they could prescribe while I was breastfeeding, but referred me to the perinatal mental health team who were happy to prescribe whatever i wanted.

Breastfeeding women aren't included in medical research, which tend to only focus on male bodies and ignore pregnancy, breastfeeding, menstrual cycles etc.

But you are being unreasonable - doctors should encourage whatever is right for that mum & baby. Mode of feeding is not important at all beyond convenience and maternal mental health.

AwkwardPaws27 · 05/03/2022 23:01

@Jellyfishjean

They're just telling you the scientific facts.They can't change them just because you don't like them.
But the "facts" they are giving are incorrect Hmm There are antidepressants that can be and are safely used in pregnancy and while breastfeeding.
Chloemol · 05/03/2022 23:01

I always understood that you start of on a low dose and work up to the required dose

I think you will find taking 10mg will start to help and that it’s better to listen to a doctor than a breastfeeding site

Drs will always do what’s best for the baby with regards to feeding

Try the tablets at the low dosage, then go back if it’s still not right

BurnDownTheDiscoHangTheDJ · 05/03/2022 23:01

I breastfed both of mine until they were at least 2.5yrs (the eldest was keener to continue than her sister- she would probably still be going now if i hadn’t gotten pregnant again and the milk dried up) and medical professionals treated me like I had two heads. I’ve got lupus and some other medical issues and kept being told by various GPs that it was dangerous to continue bfing (it wasn’t, I had talked with my consultant before I even gave birth) and once each of my daughters turned one GPs that I was seeing for very much non-bf reasons would actively encourage me to stop. One said “you’re making your life and your lupus harder” which I really wasn’t.

My experience was that from day one with my eldest (when a health care assistant tries to force a bottle of formula on my 12hr old baby who wouldn’t stop crying on the postnatal ward) right through NHS professionals were very unsupportive of breast feeding. I only received one encouraging comment once, when I had totally given up feeding and had to attend the breast clinic because of a (thankfully benign) lump. The consultant asked me if I had ever breastfed and I said yes, for around 5yrs total. She was surprised and said “very well done, your daughters will feel the benefit!” Only positive comment I ever got.

The NHS talks the talk about breastfeeding but it’s very different in practice.

Cowardlytiger · 05/03/2022 23:01

@Jellyfishjean they’re wrong though and not giving accurate advice (or appropriate treatment). That’s the problem here.

Bizawit · 05/03/2022 23:00

Your GP is an idiot. I’m breastfeeding and on antidepressants. I was advised to start them when I was pregnant but opted not to and wait until after I had given birth. Make a complaint and ask to speak to another GP xx

Futurequ · 05/03/2022 22:56

GPs are encouraged to promote breastfeeding but unfortunately there isn’t much teaching around it in the training programme (there is a lot to fit in in 3 years). I have also seen it the other way where mothers who are in need of support feel pressurised to continue breast feeding, again because it isn’t really taught well. I don’t have an answer as how to fix it but it is sad that so many are misinformed with regards to breast feeding and medication.
The information you were given by the nurse and doctor is wrong. You mentioned junior doctor in your post- that would suggest that it was either a GP in training or even a foundation doctor rather than a qualified GP. The junior doctor is a doctor but may have had even less experience with breast feeding and prescribing. I would request another appointment with another GP to discuss your options- if they are more amenable to prescribing something like sertraline I would then raise the previous consultation and the wrong information given. This will allow them to raise it with the nurse and other doctor. If that doesn’t work then I would write to the practice manager with links to the breast feeding network and the nhs guidance. Lots of GPs do use the breast feeding network guidance when prescribing but unfortunately not all know about it.
Sorry you are having a tough time and hope you get the help you want soon.