Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think Snapchat and pink news should not be promoting "top surgery" to vulnerable teenage girls?

69 replies

2fallsfromSSA · 05/03/2022 22:00

I am really shocked by this. Pink News and Snapchat are trying to paint "top surgery" for "trans youth" (ie, the removal of young women's breasts) as an aspirational and beautiful thing.

Girls who have dysphoria are often girls who have experienced trauma, are ASD or have internalised homophobia.

The targeting of vulnerable children is sinister and dangerous - where is the safeguarding, accountability, responsibility? Children would not be targeted with any other kind of cosmetic surgery or medical procedures, why is this any different? Why is nobody scrutinising this? Snapchat is probably the most important social networking platform for teens.

OP posts:
Davros · 06/03/2022 20:50

I had a single mastectomy two years ago just before my 60th birthday. I don't think I was fully aware of what to expect. I wanted it off as "it's done its job", no reconstruction, just as little surgery as possible. Then I regretted my haste and felt I should have given much more Consideration to reconstruction as I have one massive boob and nothing on the other side. It's so unbalanced although I don't care about how it looks and whether people can tell I'm one-titted , it's just uncomfortable because I either go without any "padding" or use the full prosthetic. Then a close relative had a mastectomy and reconstruction recently and I felt I should have done what she did and felt some regret, except it was really hard going, she had infections and other issues and then I was very glad I didn't have the reconstruction. I have been offered another mastectomy just to balance me up. I don't think I want that surgery unless essential, it's fairly horrible. How can some young, idealistic, optimist make that decision? I feel I made a bit of a bollix if it and I'm over 60, I've had plenty of surgery of other sorts, I know what it's like to be in hospital etc. at least I can say my decision, however it could have been, kept me alive

DoubleYouOhEmAyEn · 06/03/2022 20:48

It's truly horrific. Poor, poor girls being groomed to think they're better off removing their breasts.

DdraigGoch · 06/03/2022 20:45

@VaddaABeetch

It’s a radical mastectomy not top surgery. All surgery carries a risk, let’s call it what it is.

I’m also interested why non binary people get mastectomies. Why is the default male?

Surely to be truly neither male, nor female, non-binaries should have a single mastectomy.
ScreamingBeans · 06/03/2022 20:44

It's horrific what they're grooming young girls to believe and do to their bodies.

The detransitioners' stories are heartbreaking. And there will be so many more of them in future.

2fallsfromSSA · 06/03/2022 20:41

[quote JessHopeThinks]All of this let me to quite a lot of Google searches. I think that a lot of us have missed how big PinkNews is on Snapchat
www.journalism.co.uk/news/pinknews-ceo-ignore-snapchat-at-your-peril-/s2/a879114/[/quote]
Thanks for sharing this, I hadn't realised quite how connected pink news and snap chat had become

OP posts:
keeptalkinghappytalk · 06/03/2022 20:31

Pink News promoting mutilation … to young girls… and selling it as a fun route to trans…and worse, there are therapists and medics who collude with this! It’s a public health catastrophe that will end in billions of dollars of lawsuits that will do little to compensate these ruined lives

NotBadConsidering · 06/03/2022 20:12

@Duchessfloofy

They are disgusting, misogynist groomers.
Absolutely 100%
YouSetTheTone · 06/03/2022 18:29

lilymaynard.com/wielding-the-sidhbh-gallagher/

I read this article the other day - about an Irish surgeon who works in America and specialises in double mastectomies and other ‘gender reassignment surgery’. She talks about ‘yeeting the teets’ (cutting off breasts) and the photos are significantly more disturbing than the one Penis News glamorises. The article spells out just how much these surgeries are marketed at adolescents - lots of cutesy language peppered with emoticons. Largely done via tweets and social media. There appears to be a disturbing lack of rigorous assessment done before these surgeries.
There will undoubtedly be women waking up from being swept up in a social contagion in a few years, with mutilated bodies, unable to experience full sexual pleasure or to breastfeed their babies. These girls and women are being let down on a massive scale.

WarriorN · 06/03/2022 17:42

Daisy - @ DMchandra, on twitter, is a detransitioned woman.

She's currently pregnant and dealing with the fact she'll never be able to breastfeed.

PenisCentringNews is publishing and glamorising mastectomies when women are policed online and in real life for daring to breastfeed.

Preventing a woman from breastfeeding is classed as sexual abuse.

Misogyny.

Goatsaregreat · 06/03/2022 17:32

For balance, here's one of the episodes from the Nolan Podcasts (on BBC sounds) with Dr David Bell who used to work at the Gender Identity Clinic at the Tavistock speaking clearly about the appalling harm being done to teenagers / young people where their "gender identity" is prioritised rather than all the other mental health challenges this vulnerable cohort face. It's well worth listening to:

www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/p09yk7dh

JessHopeThinks · 06/03/2022 12:24

All of this let me to quite a lot of Google searches. I think that a lot of us have missed how big PinkNews is on Snapchat
www.journalism.co.uk/news/pinknews-ceo-ignore-snapchat-at-your-peril-/s2/a879114/

Whatwouldscullydo · 06/03/2022 11:51

They wouldn't. And presumably some of the parents a not coughing up..hence the crowd funders

CourtRand · 06/03/2022 11:50

How would teens even afford plastic surgery?

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 06/03/2022 10:51

oops just noticed the link above takes me there in a couple of hops. My google fu is not good !

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 06/03/2022 10:50

For context, could someone link the promotion of top surgery by pink news ? Just want to understand how it’s being promoted.

JessHopeThinks · 06/03/2022 10:23

PinkNews has more than 3 million followers for its main channel on Snapchat and 17 shows on there including one called the Queer Catch up. twitter.com/benjamincohen/status/1500090243021783040?s=21

Whatwouldscullydo · 06/03/2022 10:15

Deformed. Not defined

Autocorrect..

Whatwouldscullydo · 06/03/2022 10:14

Oh god the photo on thr twitter feed us awful. The chest looks defined as the scar tissue must be pretty tight as it doesn't stretch and its almost bunching the chest up

How can this be what they want for kids. It's a sure fire what to inhibit them from sports or exercise and ti am extent even sone jobs if they can't breathe or raise their arms properly.

If they truly believed in it they wouldn't need to recruit this way

TheWeeDonkey · 06/03/2022 09:59

It's always about the breasts.

This obsession is not new but it seems all consuming now. They're no longer treated as an organ with a function but a pair of "fun bags" that need to be removed or enlarged/exposed in order to gain "validation"

PN are no better than Pornhub in promoting the idea that women's bodies are here for public/male consumption.

Leafstamp · 06/03/2022 09:44

This is very alarming. Apparently Benjamin Cohen’s husband, a GP, is an ex-Mermaids Trustees.

mobile.twitter.com/simonjedge/status/1500216493614804999

Duchessfloofy · 06/03/2022 09:31

They are disgusting, misogynist groomers.

Helleofabore · 06/03/2022 09:26

Isn’t the default to have no sexual characteristics at all?

No breast tissue. No genitals at all. The ‘smooth’ genital op where everything is removed just a urination hole left. (Of course, a prostate is most likely left so males can still have some sexual activity, whereas females… meh, someone will come and remind us they are the exception and ‘they’ enjoy anal sex.)

Or there is the option of both a penis AND a vagina where one of those is artificially fashioned and added.

Either way, these are significant life changing cosmetic surgeries and I am not convinced that those having them are properly informed or assessed for mental health.

The number of female detransitioners reporting that they were told to not discuss any negative outcomes or face ostracizing from groups is growing. I’d like someone to explain the benefits of keeping future patients in the dark about the realities of living with these operations.

VaddaABeetch · 06/03/2022 09:06

It’s a radical mastectomy not top surgery. All surgery carries a risk, let’s call it what it is.

I’m also interested why non binary people get mastectomies. Why is the default male?

Helleofabore · 06/03/2022 08:17

Yes. How did a university graduate not do their own research into a brutal operation of getting both breasts removed for cosmetic purposes?

But then how did that same university graduate calm the dissonance of getting a GRC saying they would live as the opposite sex, male, for life and then quickly seek medical assistance to get pregnant?

Living the queered science dream of trying to force open the prove and established science of sex categories because you changed the ‘labels’. Not the material reality, just the labels but trying to force society to adhere to the relabeling for your own personal and political reasons.

To be fair, Freddy doesn’t make a good spokesperson for the movement (if any of these high profile cases ever do) because Freddy really comes across as having significant ‘issues’.

Including having any no empathy at all for mothers who have lost their babies. As proven when Freddy bullied (although FM claimed hypocritically that the women were the bullies) women who were telling Sands they needed the word ‘mother’ to not be removed from their group’s communications and description and of course, the wider world.

I won’t say anything more because I don’t want this thread deleted. or my posts.

Here is a current thread on their antics.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4493300-YogabirthUK-cancel-event-after-Freddy-McConnell-flounce

And this about when Sands dropped the word ‘mother’ from their tweet and FM’s reaction to the women simply saying ‘no, please don’t dehumanise us’.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4059473-sands-sorry-if-upsetting

There are other threads around this individual.

Whitefire · 06/03/2022 08:09

@Theeyeballsinthesky

Top surgery is a mastectomy- so sick of the twee euphemism “top surgery”
Yes me too. Top Surgery makes it sound so innocent, when it is everything but.
Swipe left for the next trending thread