Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think Snapchat and pink news should not be promoting "top surgery" to vulnerable teenage girls?

69 replies

2fallsfromSSA · 05/03/2022 22:00

I am really shocked by this. Pink News and Snapchat are trying to paint "top surgery" for "trans youth" (ie, the removal of young women's breasts) as an aspirational and beautiful thing.

Girls who have dysphoria are often girls who have experienced trauma, are ASD or have internalised homophobia.

The targeting of vulnerable children is sinister and dangerous - where is the safeguarding, accountability, responsibility? Children would not be targeted with any other kind of cosmetic surgery or medical procedures, why is this any different? Why is nobody scrutinising this? Snapchat is probably the most important social networking platform for teens.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JessHopeThinks · 26/03/2022 17:33

Now Ben Cohen has been tweeting about Pink News winning an award for the Queer Catchup on Snapchat . According to the video 50 million kids have watched it.

twitter.com/benjamincohen/status/1507324087399587850?s=21&t=C_GdwDw05JLMYCi0BI2hjA

2fallsfromSSA · 09/03/2022 11:11

So at least 9 people who voted think I am being unreasonable. They think it's perfectly reasonable to promote extreme and irreversible cosmetic surgery to teenage girls. I am not sure I know what to say to that.

OP posts:
Datun · 09/03/2022 10:26

@Leafstamp

Yes, *@YouSetTheTone* its very offensive and upsetting.

I have seen TikTok videos of girls/young women who are miffed/cross/jealous that their mothers are going to get their breasts removed before them (because their mothers have breast cancer).

It's disgusting.

Dear God. It's a total indoctrination.
babyjellyfish · 09/03/2022 10:10

@Leafstamp

Yes, *@YouSetTheTone* its very offensive and upsetting.

I have seen TikTok videos of girls/young women who are miffed/cross/jealous that their mothers are going to get their breasts removed before them (because their mothers have breast cancer).

It's disgusting.

Gosh.

Can you imagine how heartbroken those mothers must feel about what their daughters want to do to themselves?

Leafstamp · 08/03/2022 20:18

Yes, @YouSetTheTone its very offensive and upsetting.

I have seen TikTok videos of girls/young women who are miffed/cross/jealous that their mothers are going to get their breasts removed before them (because their mothers have breast cancer).

It's disgusting.

YouSetTheTone · 08/03/2022 12:00

Another thing to consider is how offensive and upsetting the agenda that Pink News are pushing is for women who’ve had a double-mastectomy due to cancer, surely?

Are they to be considered less of a woman because of their surgery? Obviously that’s utterly insane - of course they’re not. But pushing ‘top surgery’ onto teenagers and telling them it DOES make them less of a woman… well how do you square that circle?

Leafstamp · 08/03/2022 07:50

@DoubleTweenQueen

3% consider OP to BU. Ghouls, whoever they are.
Frightening that there’s even that small proportion of people who think this is ok. On a parenting site.
DoubleTweenQueen · 08/03/2022 07:04

3% consider OP to BU.
Ghouls, whoever they are.

babyjellyfish · 07/03/2022 21:34

She butchers children for money.

Dr Franken-Sidhbh.

YouSetTheTone · 07/03/2022 18:25

@babyjellyfish

Just seen that *@YouSetTheTone* linked to the same blog post yesterday.
Yes, sorry I don’t think I made it very clear there was an article linked at the top of my post!

It’s a difficult read, isn’t it. Sad

abeanbaked · 07/03/2022 15:46

Yanbu

porschecayenne · 07/03/2022 11:37

There seems to be no safeguarding around kids who may be questioning their identity, especially when pubity hits. Freddy McConnell, who clearly has identity issues himself, and uses his public platform to aggressively target biological women, has a children's book and cbbc program coming out soon. It's not just Snapchat unquestionably promoting these ideas, it's the BBC and Penguin publishing as well!

babyjellyfish · 07/03/2022 11:03

Just seen that @YouSetTheTone linked to the same blog post yesterday.

FrancescaContini · 07/03/2022 10:56

@babyjellyfish

lilymaynard.com/wielding-the-sidhbh-gallagher/

Blog post about Sidhbh Gallagher, an Irish surgeon who performs "gender affirmation" surgeries in the US.

Terrifying stuff.

The link here deserves a post all of its own so as many people as possible view it.
FrancescaContini · 07/03/2022 10:54

@LizzieSiddal

Disgraceful grooming and the phrase “top surgery” should be banned. Its a mastectomy.
Totally agree. It’s horrifying.
Rainbowshit · 07/03/2022 10:48

@MangyInseam

I think that in reality a lot of the kids calling themselves non-binary are not looking to be neutral so much as revert to the pre-pubescent body they were comfortable in.
this is so true!
teawamutu · 07/03/2022 10:40

@babyjellyfish

lilymaynard.com/wielding-the-sidhbh-gallagher/

Blog post about Sidhbh Gallagher, an Irish surgeon who performs "gender affirmation" surgeries in the US.

Terrifying stuff.

I couldn't finish that piece. Simultaneously apoplectic with rage and genuinely sickened.
babyjellyfish · 07/03/2022 10:09

lilymaynard.com/wielding-the-sidhbh-gallagher/

Blog post about Sidhbh Gallagher, an Irish surgeon who performs "gender affirmation" surgeries in the US.

Terrifying stuff.

Whatwouldscullydo · 07/03/2022 10:06

Yes it does appear that many believe safeguarding is transphobic. I wonder whose interests the removal of safeguarding serves? It's not kids that's for sure

Personally I.find the notion that trans kids and adults aren't entitled to the same level of safeguarding as everyone else or that they aren't capable of following safeguarding protocols and need to be able to not follow them , the real.transphobia.

Datun · 07/03/2022 09:27

Jesus Christ, are there no laws governing this? The promotion of adult surgery on a platform that targets kids. From aged 13.

The cynicism is un fucking believable.

And yes, look at the poster transman, Freddie McConnell, who was an adult in their 20s, making a bloody documentary about their overwhelming desire to transition. Who, two kids later in their 30s, is desperately upset that they can't fucking breastfeed. And yes, blames the medical profession! They went through that, and still didn't know that you can't breastfeed without breasts and nipples??

I wonder if Freddie McConnell would support pink News now.

And that picture. Romanticising radical, irreversible surgery to children is just the lowest of the bloody low.

God I hope these people get their comeuppance.

Leafstamp · 06/03/2022 21:36

@MangyInseam

I think that in reality a lot of the kids calling themselves non-binary are not looking to be neutral so much as revert to the pre-pubescent body they were comfortable in.
Yes. Or, to just not sign up for stereotypes - which is actually included within what feminists and ‘gender critical’ people want - to get rid of outdated stereotypes.
MangyInseam · 06/03/2022 21:29

I think that in reality a lot of the kids calling themselves non-binary are not looking to be neutral so much as revert to the pre-pubescent body they were comfortable in.

2fallsfromSSA · 06/03/2022 21:24

Yes it does appear that many believe safeguarding is transphobic. I wonder whose interests the removal of safeguarding serves? It's not kids that's for sure.

OP posts:
Leafstamp · 06/03/2022 21:15

I’m struggling to link to the tweet, but Benjamin
Cohen has now called the people expressing concern at this ‘transphobes’.

This is the real danger of anything related to transgenderism - it’s supporters seem to think that basic safeguarding doesn’t apply.

Terfydactyl · 06/03/2022 20:56

@Echobelly

I actually am all for trans rights and surgery when it will help and when someone is competent to decide, but I do have a bit of a problem with teenagers seeing this - I'm not convinced they're 'aiming it at teenagers' per se, but obviously it's likely they'll see it.

Top surgery can be the right decision for a small number adults who have had time to reflect and made an informed decision. But I do think anyone who can't legally be living on their own can't be in a position to make that decision.

My oldest is identifying as non binary and I do worry a little about all these 'Yay, Top Surgery was the answer to all my problems and I am happy now stories' and have explained to them that they will see lots of affirming stories about interventions but to bear in mind that's not the whole picture or necessarily the answer to one's own problems. That said fortunately my teen seems happy with their body, not dysphoric or wanting to bind breasts etc. But I can see that kids with more problems in their life, or who are experiencing dysmorphia (or think they 'should' have dysmorphia) finding this idea very appealing.

In America a certain dr is happy that shes doing 4 "top" surgeries a day. She has a tiktok account and has her own strapline "yeet the teets" Not even kidding.

There is pushback here and in the USA but itll be far too late for many many girls.

Swipe left for the next trending thread