Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if these people would help if they didn’t have the opportunity to brag about it on social media

65 replies

ButtercupOfFlorin · 05/03/2022 21:28

I’m quite possibly being cynical but I’m seeing A LOT of these kind of posts on local Spotted pages lately

“Yesterday I took a man who collapsed on the street to A&E. I didn’t get his name but on the journey he told me he lives on Crook Street, is 84 in September and has a daughter called Sally. Does anybody know how he’s doing???”

“A lovely lady posted on a for sale page the other day saying she was desperate for food to feed her young family. I contacted her and took a week’s worth of food to her house. I’ve lost her contact details and wanted to see if she was OK”

“A lady tripped and broke her elbow at the shopping mall today, I stayed with her and bought her a coffee as I called the ambulance, but didn’t get her name or any details - I wanted to know if she was OK”

“Today a family were lost looking for the crematorium so I drove them there and dropped them at the door just in time for the funeral. Wanted to check they were ok? Been thinking about them.”

I just look at these posts and think “Yes it’s nice what you did but the desperation for adoring comments is palpable” and I wonder if half these good deeds would happen if they couldn’t then go on social media and humble brag about it. You’d think surely they’d have found another way to contact them if they were THAT desperate - who gets a street address and not a name? And if you call an ambulance presumably you do get a name? AIBU to think it’s just a way to get a pat on the back and people are probably thinking at the time how they’ll have to post on social media later?

OP posts:
foxy3 · 05/03/2022 23:17

Someone on a local fb community page asked where she could buy a badge showing the Ukraine flag and she got told she was virtue signalling a few times!
I keep seeing this phrase but hadn't heard of it before seeing it on mn

Amnotamug · 05/03/2022 23:15

Sorry I disagree..virtue signalling is a MN expression ..have never heard that expression apart from MN ..think it is absolutely trashy.
Agree that people saying they are not sending Christmas Cards and donating to a charity are a PITA but sharing a charity donation etc is good publicity for the charity and increases social awareness !

Theyulelog · 05/03/2022 23:09

The local towns community pages are the worst for this. Every damn day there are people seeking validation for their community good deeds.
One lady had 100 quid shoved in her letterbox for a good deed she did, she posted it on social media and kept updating the post with what she spent the money on ie I spent 20 quid on myself and the rest went on the local food bank.
Can’t help but feel if she was genuine about helping others, she wouldn’t need to broadcast it to the nation for more Facebook brownie points.
Doing good for doing is good is adequate and part of being a decent human being. You don’t need a round of applause.

I’ve had to leave some of the groups created to help Ukrainian refugees. The amount of people who say things for bloody validation.
Tonight people were looking for volunteers to help sort through donations and one woman wrote I would but I live too far away and don’t drive….why comment then!? Angry

FOJN · 05/03/2022 23:03

I was taught that for a good deed to be a good deed you tell no one about it.

Me too. If you can't do a good turn without recognition you are a needy person not decent human being.

EssexLioness · 05/03/2022 22:57

I agree. I read a horrible post on here earlier started by a virtue signalling OP that posted to say she donated to Ukraine and that she knew posting on here and telling people about it would motivate her. She admitted that without the knowledge that she was going to post on her, she probably wouldn’t have donated at all! The OP encourages other people to brag about their donations too. Ridiculous! I can’t believe that she needed to tell people about it in order to donate.

ButtercupOfFlorin · 05/03/2022 22:52

@ShirleyPhallus

Yes, but see also: “I found this credit card on the ground, anyone know a Mrs Elise Westerton-Smith? Ask her to PM me”
  1. Tear up the credit card and chuck it away / send it back to the bank
  2. The woman has a unique name, look her up on FB first!

Also I never get why people share posts from local stuff across the other side of the world. Ie “black dog lost in New Jersey” then you get “shared in Northampton, UK”. Is the dog likely to have made its way across the Atlantic?

🤣🤣one of my most favourite SM ‘wars’ was a cousin who lives in Cumbria who shared a post about a missing woman in Penrith (her nearest town). Until someone pointed out that it was Penrith Australia. Rather than admit it was a (easily made) mistake she argued for about 30 posts that she knew that but she was sharing just in case the woman DID come halfway across the world to hide in a pokey little market town Hmm Grin
OP posts:
Crimeismymiddlename · 05/03/2022 22:26

Often I think these good deeds on sm are made up, the people showing off about them are generally not the sort of people who go out of their way for others.
I was taught that for a good deed to be a good deed you tell no one about it.

WorraLiberty · 05/03/2022 22:23

Also I never get why people share posts from local stuff across the other side of the world. Ie “black dog lost in New Jersey” then you get “shared in Northampton, UK”. Is the dog likely to have made its way across the Atlantic?

And a closer inspection reveals the original post was from 2014 😂

WorraLiberty · 05/03/2022 22:21

@Kendodd

Anyone remember that thread about the psychology around virtue signalling? This thread reminds me of that. It puzzles me more why people feel the need to throw stones at people trying to do a bit of good.
It puzzles me more why people feel the need to throw stones at people trying to do a bit of good.

People doing a bit of good is a completely separate topic.

The OP is talking about the need to broadcast it and to look for praise.

ShirleyPhallus · 05/03/2022 22:18

Yes, but see also:
“I found this credit card on the ground, anyone know a Mrs Elise Westerton-Smith? Ask her to PM me”

  1. Tear up the credit card and chuck it away / send it back to the bank
  2. The woman has a unique name, look her up on FB first!

Also I never get why people share posts from local stuff across the other side of the world. Ie “black dog lost in New Jersey” then you get “shared in Northampton, UK”. Is the dog likely to have made its way across the Atlantic?

Kendodd · 05/03/2022 22:16

Anyone remember that thread about the psychology around virtue signalling?
This thread reminds me of that.
It puzzles me more why people feel the need to throw stones at people trying to do a bit of good.

Sparklingbrook · 05/03/2022 22:12

@WorraLiberty

It's exactly the same on Mumsnet except the excuse to crow about it is normally, "I told a friend and they said I was BU, so now I'm doubting myself?"

Followed by lots of "YANBU, you sound like a lovely person OP", to give them a warm fuzzy glow Grin

Yes as soon as I get to ‘I told a friend’ I am immediately thinking no you didn’t and this never happened.
Hibye23289 · 05/03/2022 22:09

I know what you mean! 😂 Can't be too outing but there was an incident in my village and an overly bubbly mum from down the school set up a go fund me page, she then did a personal status asking for items or what not and somebody commented saying 'local hero' and she replied 'I try 😊' and the original commentor said no try the local heroes page they may be able to help with items 🤣🤣

WorraLiberty · 05/03/2022 22:07

It's exactly the same on Mumsnet except the excuse to crow about it is normally, "I told a friend and they said I was BU, so now I'm doubting myself?"

Followed by lots of "YANBU, you sound like a lovely person OP", to give them a warm fuzzy glow Grin

NETSRIK · 05/03/2022 22:02

Their lives revolve around social media validation. They just seem like very sad individuals who are oblivious that people can see through their desperate attempts for likes.