Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to find DH's dinner behaviour unacceptably rude?

113 replies

ThatsOuchy · 05/03/2022 20:28

Am I being unreasonably picky, or can you please help me explain why I find this behaviour so annoying? I'm fully prepared to be told IABU, possibly I'm hormonal right now, I admit.

DH comes into kitchen whilst I am cooking (fish already in the oven, making batches of chips) and announces "I don't think I'll have any dinner tonight, I'm not hungry". So at first I am surprised (haha, husband never turns down food unless unwell!) so I ask did he have a big lunch whilst I was out or did he eat late? He says yes maybe I did eat late for lunch. I raised an eyebrow, 'cause this alone makes me a bit grumpy, based on my expectation that we normally stick to three meals a day and set an example to the kids that they have to come for dinner whether they like it or not. Don't have to eat if not hungry, just turn up to dinner as is expected.

I then proceeded to make only enough chips for me and the two kids and serve up for three of us. After we have sat down to eat, DH saunters into the kitchen and says "I think I will just have a bit of dinner after all". We had at this point barely sat down and it was less than twenty minutes since his last pronouncement. I came out with some "You can't just chop and change... there's not enough chips now" grumpiness, and then proceeded to carry on eating with the kids. He left us to it, but I know full well he will be back in the kitchen in half an hour eating the single leftover fish with his fingers, standing up, and this makes me sad and a bit cross. Why couldn't he just eat as much/little as he wanted, from a plate, with his family?

Was I wrong to be unaccommodating about it (YABU), and if not how would you explain that you feel this is a crappy way to behave?

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 05/03/2022 22:09

@NotNowBoris

He wasn't hungry, then he was. It's no big deal. The situation is easily rectified.
I do this quite often, though there's only me to please, I will have lunch later then not feel like any dinner. However I will then feel hungry about 9 so I make sure I keep soup in the fridge.
Fernandina · 05/03/2022 22:08

MN is a funny place sometimes.

Providing family meals day in day out is a thankless drudge, made all the more thankless when another adult in the house waits until you are already cooking and then tells you they don't want it.

I'm with you, OP.

bellac11 · 05/03/2022 22:08

@Feedingthebirds1

so I ask did he have a big lunch whilst I was out or did he eat late? He says yes maybe I did eat late for lunch.

Unless there was a very good reason why he had lunch late (and/or had a big lunch that he's not admitting to) I would expect him to have eaten earlier so that he was ready for his evening meal with the family at family dinner time.

Jesus

'Admitting to'

What is it a crime now to have a later or bigger lunch than you usually do, or to get full up or to eat snacks or overeat sometimes. A grown adult can do what they like.

Feedingthebirds1 · 05/03/2022 22:05

so I ask did he have a big lunch whilst I was out or did he eat late? He says yes maybe I did eat late for lunch.

Unless there was a very good reason why he had lunch late (and/or had a big lunch that he's not admitting to) I would expect him to have eaten earlier so that he was ready for his evening meal with the family at family dinner time.

BigupPemberleyMassive · 05/03/2022 22:01

I think you are upset about something bigger but it is 'safer' to feel angry about dinner.

Imperfectp3rf3ction · 05/03/2022 21:54

Welcome to mumsnet =p where you maybe told to LTB over this or someone may suggest something sinister! To me it sounds like maybe there may be a couple of other little irks he's done and this is the one that's blown the top ! For the record my dp will stand up eating too I have no clue what this is all about Confused

bellac11 · 05/03/2022 21:53

@BadgerStripes

Makes you ‘sad’ OP? Crikey Hmm
I thought she meant she was sad that he would be standing on his own eating when he could have sat with the family and eaten with them, socially like
BadgerStripes · 05/03/2022 21:45

Makes you ‘sad’ OP? Crikey Hmm

miraveile · 05/03/2022 21:44

I take it this is a one off? If so just let it go. Sounds like you go the perspective needed so don't know why some are laying into you.

LifeGoesOn222 · 05/03/2022 21:40

Do you do most of the cooking? I'd just tell him to sort himself out for the next few days as you're taking a break from cooking for him.

I have to admit that we rarely have this problem in our house since I'm such a bad wife that I hardly ever cook for my DH. He sorts himself out mostly, although we do try to sit down together at the table with DS for meals at the weekend.

ChickenStripper · 05/03/2022 21:31

You are just getting caught up in your own ( unconscious) guilt about not providing him with food possibly . Just ignore him and let him eat cereal or whatever.

TwoCoffeesPlease · 05/03/2022 21:29

[quote TravellingFrom]@TwoCoffeesPlease you do polite conversation with your dcs and spouse? And you find that painful?
Really? You don’t enjoy spending time with them and have a chat for half an hour. That’s a shame.[/quote]
We have normally already spoken/caught up throughout the day or spent the day together so “insisting” on sitting together just because it’s dinner time can feel painful if you’re not in the mood to chat.

My parents insisted on it every day and even if we had a TV dinner we all had to watch the same thing and sit together in the living room. Sometimes you just want to sit by yourself 🤷🏼‍♀️

thisplaceisweird · 05/03/2022 21:27

@GiltEdges

Agree with PP.

Do you want to spend your life letting insignificant things wind you up? It really wasn’t a big deal.

I read so many threads like this on here, people just filled with rage over small inconveniences. No way to live your life.

I would have just made all of the chips if you were already making them. Nobody turns down chips.

Haudyourwheesht · 05/03/2022 21:27

It would annoy me. I cook for us all, and I'd expect to have been given a heads up before I started cooking if an adult member of the household didn't feel like eating a substantial meal. We also sit down to eat dinner as a family, unless work or whatever makes it impossible, so I don't want the DC thinking you can just opt out when it suits you and eat snacks later.

betwixtlives · 05/03/2022 21:26

‘Sad and cross’ at the thought of your husband eating fish standing up? Grin

TravellingFrom · 05/03/2022 21:23

@TwoCoffeesPlease you do polite conversation with your dcs and spouse? And you find that painful?
Really? You don’t enjoy spending time with them and have a chat for half an hour. That’s a shame.

TravellingFrom · 05/03/2022 21:21

@Ipadflowers

God I’d not be comfortable with this level of controlling behaviour round food op.,he’s hungry, he’s not he changed his mind, for you that’s one form for big deal right,,the question is why?
Because the OP is putting effort into preparing a meal that he then decides he doesn’t want. Only to then decide again he actually wants it and expects people to bend backwards to accommodate him.

It’s not controlling to want to know how many people are eating when you are cooking dinner.
Nor is it controlling to say that there is no food for him when he has clearly stated he didn’t wan to eat! He could have cooked more fries for himself. No one was stopping him!

NaTTate · 05/03/2022 21:21

Also, I think this kind of entitled & thoughtless behaviour is really poor modelling for the children to see, especially if family meals are a "thing" in your household (I appreciate that not everyone does family mealtimes or feels that they are important, but if you do then it's up to the adults of the house to take the lead on it and be consistent.

TwoCoffeesPlease · 05/03/2022 21:21

Idk I understand the not being hungry/not being hungry thing having just done exactly the same thing to DP who wanted to order a take away. Luckily he knows me and ordered extra chips.

I also get not wanting to sit and watch other people eat? Forced sitting around the table making polite conversation every day is painful enough without not also eating anything.

bellac11 · 05/03/2022 21:16

To be honest I am like this all the time, one minute Im hungry, next Im not, then I want this, then I want that, then Im too hot, then Im too cold, then I want a hot drink then I want a cold drink. I drive myself mad.

I do get annoyed when my OH walks round eating without a plate though.

BOOTS52 · 05/03/2022 21:16

That would annoy me also. You did the right thing not to let him ruin your own dinner, did he expect you to give him half or to start making more chips for him. Let him eat the leftovers or make himself a sandwich. You are not been weird about this as he sounds annoying. Hope you enjoyed your dinner. Hope he cooks for you also and helps you around the house. Frustrating that he keeps changing his mind.

NaTTate · 05/03/2022 21:16

I don't think you are being unreasonable. I think it's a basic courtesy if you are an adult and another person is cooking to make it clear whether you will be joining the meal before the other person has already got dinner underway - and then not to change your mind once dinner has been served. It seems like a very offhand way for him to treat the person who is making family dinner.

PinkSyCo · 05/03/2022 21:12

My DP does this often and it's incredibly frustrating. It's not about whether he's hungry or whether I've cooked enough chips, it's about him having control.
My DP will either deliberately wait until I'm almost dishing up to tell me he's not hungry and so won't be having dinner. Or worse, he'll tell me he doesn't want dinner because he's had a big lunch, then will come home and expect dinner and then moan all night that he's had to have toast for dinner again.

This is nothing like OPs situation. Why do you put up with that shit? I would never cook for this man again if I were you.

Bromse · 05/03/2022 21:11

He could make himself some chips, surely. They don't take that long.

TokenGinger · 05/03/2022 21:11

You're a little too regimented about meal times, to be honest.

Who cares if he goes to eat it later?

I'd find it very controlling if my partner dictated to me how many meals I should have a day, or showed grumpiness at me eating later than usual.

In this situation, when he came in and said he thinks he will after all, my response would have been, "Okay, no problem, but there's only fish available. I didn't put any chips in for you once you said you weren't eating. Maybe have it with a side of bread and butter?"