Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to find DH's dinner behaviour unacceptably rude?

113 replies

ThatsOuchy · 05/03/2022 20:28

Am I being unreasonably picky, or can you please help me explain why I find this behaviour so annoying? I'm fully prepared to be told IABU, possibly I'm hormonal right now, I admit.

DH comes into kitchen whilst I am cooking (fish already in the oven, making batches of chips) and announces "I don't think I'll have any dinner tonight, I'm not hungry". So at first I am surprised (haha, husband never turns down food unless unwell!) so I ask did he have a big lunch whilst I was out or did he eat late? He says yes maybe I did eat late for lunch. I raised an eyebrow, 'cause this alone makes me a bit grumpy, based on my expectation that we normally stick to three meals a day and set an example to the kids that they have to come for dinner whether they like it or not. Don't have to eat if not hungry, just turn up to dinner as is expected.

I then proceeded to make only enough chips for me and the two kids and serve up for three of us. After we have sat down to eat, DH saunters into the kitchen and says "I think I will just have a bit of dinner after all". We had at this point barely sat down and it was less than twenty minutes since his last pronouncement. I came out with some "You can't just chop and change... there's not enough chips now" grumpiness, and then proceeded to carry on eating with the kids. He left us to it, but I know full well he will be back in the kitchen in half an hour eating the single leftover fish with his fingers, standing up, and this makes me sad and a bit cross. Why couldn't he just eat as much/little as he wanted, from a plate, with his family?

Was I wrong to be unaccommodating about it (YABU), and if not how would you explain that you feel this is a crappy way to behave?

OP posts:
gamerchick · 05/03/2022 23:35

@PeacefulPrune

It would piss me right off. I'm a bit surprised by these responses.
I'm not. Of late I'm convinced people really need to get laid more Hmm

If this is an often thing, tell him you're not cooking for him anymore and he can sort himself out. No pandering.

bellac11 · 05/03/2022 23:35

[quote SquirrelFan]**@bellac* mealtime should* be relaxing, but often with kids it's not. That's why some parents opt out, rather than trying to create a happy, relaxed atmosphere, by sitting and chatting and sharing an experience.[/quote]
Perhaps you didnt mean to but you sounded extremely rigid, military and cold about how dinner times should be. Another poster said it better than me 'stifling'.

SquirrelFan · 05/03/2022 23:32

@bellac mealtime should be relaxing, but often with kids it's not. That's why some parents opt out, rather than trying to create a happy, relaxed atmosphere, by sitting and chatting and sharing an experience.

SquirrelFan · 05/03/2022 23:28

@LuckySantangelo35

I didn't say anything about disordered eating--you may be confusing me with someone else..?

I just think he's left the OP to do all the parenting--which does include, in many households, and from her OP, in hers, sitting down to dinner with the kids. As PPs have said, he didn't have to eat with them, but rather to share family time. It's particularly annoying, however that he did want to eat, just not with them, so he waited until dinner was over and snacked on the leftovers.

Bunty55 · 05/03/2022 23:28

This reminded me of what my husband used to do all of the time.
I was a mum of three children, worked full time and did everything in the house and sometimes I was too tired to be bothered with cooking another meal so we would get a chinese or fish and chips.

My husband would always say he did not like whatever it was and not to bother with him, he would make something for himself.

I would bring the food home. We would serve it out on the plates and he would appear in the kitchen and butter himself two slices of bread. Then he would lean over the children's plates and help himself to anything without asking.
They would get very upset and I would say to him, why didn't you ask and I would have brought something. Take it from my plate.
Then there would be a hug row and he would say he wore the trousers in this house.
Every damn time.
I am so glad he is not in our lives anymore, for lots of reasons but this reminded me what an inconsiderate twat he really is/was.

bellac11 · 05/03/2022 23:27

'shoulder the burden of monitoring table behaviour'

That sounds a lovely relaxing family atmosphere!!!!

HudsonRiver · 05/03/2022 23:24

@Thegoodandbadlife

Some people thinking it’s ok - I’m confused as to why. Yes it’s very annoying what he’s done and would make me pissed off too in the moment. Of course if he pronounced he wasn’t hungry then you wouldn’t waste more food at the time making it. To then change his mind once it was all ready and expect food is annoying and would piss me off too but I would get over it. Moving forwards you might need to treat him as a child with two questions if he does it again - would you like me to make a smaller portion for you to eat with us or will you reheat when you’re hungry but still join us for family meal as that’s our thing? If it’s a one off I’d let it blow over but prepare how you want to deal with it incase it happens again. My Dad is like this saying he doesn’t want anything for lunch as he doesn’t eat lunch and then snacks all afternoon on biscuits and chocolate bars a abs hungry in the afternoon.
Because Im not in charge of my DH or what he eats. I would have asked if he wanted me to put his aside for later. Yes/No No anger/ fury needed. I cant get over someone being this angry that her DH ate a bit late , its so controlling.
FeloniusGru · 05/03/2022 23:22

Sorry OP but I’m giggling at you being a bit cross with DH eating fish with his fingers standing up Grin

I get it though, I get a bit cross when my husband thinks chicken breasts are snacks and boils eggs at 10pm because he’s hungry again. I can’t explain why, but I do.

Thegoodandbadlife · 05/03/2022 23:18

Some people thinking it’s ok - I’m confused as to why. Yes it’s very annoying what he’s done and would make me pissed off too in the moment. Of course if he pronounced he wasn’t hungry then you wouldn’t waste more food at the time making it. To then change his mind once it was all ready and expect food is annoying and would piss me off too but I would get over it. Moving forwards you might need to treat him as a child with two questions if he does it again - would you like me to make a smaller portion for you to eat with us or will you reheat when you’re hungry but still join us for family meal as that’s our thing? If it’s a one off I’d let it blow over but prepare how you want to deal with it incase it happens again. My Dad is like this saying he doesn’t want anything for lunch as he doesn’t eat lunch and then snacks all afternoon on biscuits and chocolate bars a abs hungry in the afternoon.

LuckySantangelo35 · 05/03/2022 23:18

@SquirrelFan

He is an adult and surely has a choice of whether and when he wants to eat.

Except he's an adult in a household where they have made a commitment to having a family dinner. Where he is implicitly responsible for helping model correct behaviour for the kids. I agree with previous posters-even if not hungry, he could have sat with the family, chatted about the day, helped model good table manners/conversation. Instead OP is left to not only cook dinner but shoulder the burden of monitoring table behaviour, only to find DH pleasing himself by noshing on a fish fillet after the family had finished. I would be sad and cross that my husband didn't want to share that family dinner time too!

@SquirrelFan Urgh “made a commitment to having a family dinner”. It sounds so stifling! Every once in a while you’re not hungry for lunch at the usual time so you have something when you are hungry and then you might want your dinner a bit later than usual as well. Big deal! When you talk about modelling healthy behaviour in re to food for your teens I don’t know what you’re on about! That kind of behaviour from your husband is not going to given them an unhealthy relationship with food and a disordered eating pattern you know! Unclench a bit and stop being so regimented
TheresSomebodyAtTheDoorNeil · 05/03/2022 23:17

Bit dramatic.

My dp virtuously announced he wasn't having any pancakes on pancake day so I made sure I used all the batter so I wouldn't be guilted into making him any and he sat sulking after he inevitably changed his mind Grin

Im extremely childish tho. If he doesn't want dinner that's fine, he's not a toddler who will be up and hungry.

If he changes his mind then he's lucked out, should have taken your time eating giving a commentary on how tasty it was....he can make himself toast or something

greef · 05/03/2022 22:53

God I’d not be comfortable with this level of controlling behaviour round food op.,he’s hungry, he’s not he changed his mind, for you that’s one form for big deal right,,the question is why?

@Ipadflowers your post makes no sense whatsoever

Whydoesthecatalwaysdothat · 05/03/2022 22:47

As a one off, I wouldn't get upset about it but it's not a one off, is it?

Does he ever plan what you're going to eat, shop and cook at all? If the answer is no then perhaps he needs to start taking some responsibility to help focus his mind.

If DH was messing me about every night I'd tell him he'd need to sort out his own dinner. I don't run a cafe so don't expect people to treat me like I am.

PeacefulPrune · 05/03/2022 22:45

It would piss me right off. I'm a bit surprised by these responses.

Luredbyapomegranate · 05/03/2022 22:41

Why are you bothered? It’s a one off.

trackerby · 05/03/2022 22:35

I'm surprised there was any fish left for him to eat.

I'd have shared out his piece amongst those eating.

SquirrelFan · 05/03/2022 22:34

He is an adult and surely has a choice of whether and when he wants to eat.

Except he's an adult in a household where they have made a commitment to having a family dinner. Where he is implicitly responsible for helping model correct behaviour for the kids. I agree with previous posters-even if not hungry, he could have sat with the family, chatted about the day, helped model good table manners/conversation. Instead OP is left to not only cook dinner but shoulder the burden of monitoring table behaviour, only to find DH pleasing himself by noshing on a fish fillet after the family had finished. I would be sad and cross that my husband didn't want to share that family dinner time too!

bellac11 · 05/03/2022 22:34

@loadofcrap10

Why are there so many controlling women on mumsnet?? And how come their partners are still with them? If it was the other way around the husband would be accused of abuse and all sorts. He is an adult and surely has a choice of whether and when he wants to eat.
There seems to be lots of projection in many of these threads, its almost like men cant be flawed or make mistakes, or forget something or express their needs because if they do, they are controlling/abusive/selfish/twats or dicks or whatever name. If women do the same behaviours its perfectly reasonable, their husbands should be on hand to understand/care/prioritise etc etc.
HudsonRiver · 05/03/2022 22:29

@loadofcrap10

Why are there so many controlling women on mumsnet?? And how come their partners are still with them? If it was the other way around the husband would be accused of abuse and all sorts. He is an adult and surely has a choice of whether and when he wants to eat.
Totally. Op is scolding him as if he is a child for having a late lunch. I would have shrugged and said ok would you like some left for later? If not he can get something later himself.
Londoncallingtothefarawaytowns · 05/03/2022 22:24

The only thing that would piss me off is : the waste of food or him putting the oven on again and wasting energy

loadofcrap10 · 05/03/2022 22:17

Why are there so many controlling women on mumsnet?? And how come their partners are still with them?
If it was the other way around the husband would be accused of abuse and all sorts.
He is an adult and surely has a choice of whether and when he wants to eat.

Suzi888 · 05/03/2022 22:16

But voting is 60% YANBUHmm
To be honest I think he should sit down too, he doesn’t have to eat, just engage in conversation.

grapewines · 05/03/2022 22:15

raised an eyebrow, 'cause this alone makes me a bit grumpy, based on my expectation that we normally stick to three meals a day and set an example to the kids

You're grumpy because he had a late lunch? He's a grown adult and should be able to decide when to eat or not. And whether to have a snack besides the three meals a day.

I just can't understand getting sad and cross about stuff like this. It must make life unnecessarily difficult.

Midlifemusings · 05/03/2022 22:15

She put some fish and chips in the oven - she wasn't slaving away all day over his favorite dishes.

She would have put fish and chips in the oven for herself and the kids even if DH had told her earlier.

bellac11 · 05/03/2022 22:12

All this talk is now making me think about having a sneaky cheese roll, having not eaten as much earlier as I might have and though I wasnt hungry but I sort of was.

I find as I get older, I prefer to snack more and eat less 'proper' meals. Not good for weight loss.