Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Social media mums - making poor mum's feel like shit since the dawn of the internet

213 replies

Fysal · 05/03/2022 19:37

Just been scrolling through TikTok and came across a mum/baby account, the mum is youngish in her 20's and the baby about 7 months.

There was really sweet 'a day in the life' content showing what they do with their day, what they eat, fun activities. Lots of themed sensory activities and messy play in those Tuff tray things, making a farm yard out of pasta and coco pops for example. Things that take ages to set up and she does it with a smile. Baby ends up in a total mess which is fine because she gets bathed every night before bed as part of their routine.

The occasional well deserved night out with the girls, cocktails and nice food.

I could go on but you get the gist. She just seemed like the perfect mum.

No cute nightly bath routine for us, it's every 2nd or third day and it's always a nightmare - not the tranquil experience I'm seeing on the internet with other people's kids.

The tiktok babies bedroom was stunning. Lovely furniture, she showed inside her babies wardrobe which was full of neatly hung, well ironed pretty clothes. The whites were bright crisp white.

I haven't managed to keep my kids white clothes white for more than a month. I haven't seen an iron in years. If something is going to need ironing regularly I tend not to buy it. I'm not very domestic to be honest. The flat is clean but never stays tidy.

No beautifully arranged wardrobes for the kids here, just folded away into cheap plastic drawers.

She showed herself freezing ozs and ozs of breast milk, she'd managed to exclusively BF for 7 months now her daughter is doing baby led weaning.

I failed to establish BF and only managed to express for a few weeks.

All of the TikTok babies meals were lovingly prepared and beautifully presented, exciting and experimental recipes from a glossy BLW cook book. Baby ate from those cute bamboo bowls shaped like bunnies. Picturesque.

My eldest lives on chicken nuggets. He won't eat a thing else because of his ARIFD and autism.

The TikTok mum goes to lots of baby groups. My anxiety wouldn't get me past the front door if I decided I wanted to do something like that.

Don't get me wrong my children are loved but we don't have a particularly great life, not compared to families like that anyway.

AIBU to think social media makes poor / depressed people feel even more shit?

OP posts:
Ozanj · 06/03/2022 14:16

@Fysal

Just been scrolling through TikTok and came across a mum/baby account, the mum is youngish in her 20's and the baby about 7 months.

There was really sweet 'a day in the life' content showing what they do with their day, what they eat, fun activities. Lots of themed sensory activities and messy play in those Tuff tray things, making a farm yard out of pasta and coco pops for example. Things that take ages to set up and she does it with a smile. Baby ends up in a total mess which is fine because she gets bathed every night before bed as part of their routine.

The occasional well deserved night out with the girls, cocktails and nice food.

I could go on but you get the gist. She just seemed like the perfect mum.

No cute nightly bath routine for us, it's every 2nd or third day and it's always a nightmare - not the tranquil experience I'm seeing on the internet with other people's kids.

The tiktok babies bedroom was stunning. Lovely furniture, she showed inside her babies wardrobe which was full of neatly hung, well ironed pretty clothes. The whites were bright crisp white.

I haven't managed to keep my kids white clothes white for more than a month. I haven't seen an iron in years. If something is going to need ironing regularly I tend not to buy it. I'm not very domestic to be honest. The flat is clean but never stays tidy.

No beautifully arranged wardrobes for the kids here, just folded away into cheap plastic drawers.

She showed herself freezing ozs and ozs of breast milk, she'd managed to exclusively BF for 7 months now her daughter is doing baby led weaning.

I failed to establish BF and only managed to express for a few weeks.

All of the TikTok babies meals were lovingly prepared and beautifully presented, exciting and experimental recipes from a glossy BLW cook book. Baby ate from those cute bamboo bowls shaped like bunnies. Picturesque.

My eldest lives on chicken nuggets. He won't eat a thing else because of his ARIFD and autism.

The TikTok mum goes to lots of baby groups. My anxiety wouldn't get me past the front door if I decided I wanted to do something like that.

Don't get me wrong my children are loved but we don't have a particularly great life, not compared to families like that anyway.

AIBU to think social media makes poor / depressed people feel even more shit?

There was an ‘Insta mum’ who basically got famous back in the day for making ‘quick’ recipes for things like oat bars. Until an incredibly famous Indian chef (with a massive legal team) came after her for stealing her recipes. The idiot thought she wouldn’t get caught because the chef was from India. The chef has passed away now but now a lot of her recipes westerners might like are written in Hindi using hard to translate (India specific) methods of cooking.
CantStandMeCow · 06/03/2022 14:11

No one’s saying that some people don’t find parenting relatively easy. We’re saying the ones that do are self-assured enough not to need to splash it all over social media.

Bhud · 06/03/2022 14:04

And she isn’t nailing it because as a social fucking influencer she has a social fucking responsibility not to present a pseudo-reality of a fucking sterilised fake life that could be achievable by all women if they just tried hard enough. Where is her social conscious- has she sold it for some paint for her beautiful nursery

Bhud · 06/03/2022 14:01

If this woman is patient and great with kids and didn't want a career outside of the home then it's perfectly possible that she is nailing it right now.

Maybe in an alternate universe this woman is “nailing it right now” the sterilised Insta life presented isn’t “nailing it” - emotional support, stability, consistency and positive role models are a few of the primary needs of children. Clean white clothes, beautiful nursery, cocktails, idyllic bath time, a freezer full of breast milk isn’t nailing it, they are fucking photographs.

Symbols of a sterilised, false happy, clean, un-messy un-emotive living. Is she responsive to her child’s needs, is her home secure, does she provide a good role model to her child, is she a consistent parent, gives me the rage. The very un-Insta rage.

Joinedforthis22 · 06/03/2022 13:54

It’s always a house owned by Nigel ( who works in finance ) and Geraldine Hartley-Farquhar who used to be a hedge fund manager but gave it all up when she discovered a talent for gardening /painting/running a yoga studio

You forgot to mention that Geraldine is also the great-granddaughter of the youngest son of the Earl of Whatsitface and inherited a shit ton of money Wink

LittleGwyneth · 06/03/2022 13:51

I don't buy this 'none of it is real' bollocks. It's a highlights reel, and you're seeing the best bits, but for some people parenting is easier than it is for others.

If this woman is patient and great with kids and didn't want a career outside of the home then it's perfectly possible that she is nailing it right now. There will be times in the future where she doesn't.

Block her account and stop watching if it makes you feel inferior, but the people of mumsnet pretending that there aren't women who find parenting generally easy aren't helping you.

There will always be someone who is better at everything than you are. That shouldn't erode your sense of worth.

StacySandhu · 06/03/2022 13:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

RiverFlowers · 06/03/2022 13:39

None of it is true, they only show you want they want you to see. It's why I rarely use social media, most of it is fake and just makes you feel like crap.

notthemum · 06/03/2022 12:43

OP.
I am sorry if this Social Media nonsense has made you feel bad. As most other posters have pointed out it is mostly rubbish. The young lady concerned appears to be loving every minute, but as pps have said you do not see the juggling that she has to go through to get these shots.
Meanwhile back in the real world things rarely run that smoothly.
A while ago I was a bit down and a good friend sent me the following. So this is for you and for all the other mums who are maybe not feeling at their best for whatever reason.
"Sometimes you just need to hear it.
You are a phenomenal woman.
A beautiful person doing an extraordinary job, making things happen for those you love and although you might not always feel it, you are loved and appreciated.
It ends by asking recipient to send on to 7 women who deserve to be noticed, and then simply says Love you.
Remember ladies sometimes real life is shit. But You , all of you, with whatever battle scars you have and whatever you are dealing with You are bloody awesome. 💐🍫🍷

BodgertheJogger · 06/03/2022 10:59

Social media is terrible for things like this.
Imagine why this person feels she has to make a video for thousands of people she doesn't know. She probably does it because she feels insecure and unworthy. Maybe she's lonely. Maybe she feels she has something to prove to the world.
That's a huge amount of Social media.
Imagine the cut parts of the video.
I assume the video isn't the length of a whole day (12 hours)... so think about what and why she has cut.
If I was a mum these Social media tik toks would drive me crazy because I'm easily influenced, so I get it.

plominoagain · 06/03/2022 10:57

I’ve recently had several conversations with my 16 yo dd about the total bullshit on the ‘gram . We’re relatively comfortable but not minted by any stretch of the imagination. Yet she could easily spin our life to look so much wealthier than it actually is . Yes , we’ve got horses . All that have been rescues and have taken a shit ton of actual blood and tears to sort out . Yes we have a very photogenic Dalmatian. Another rescue who came to us as a psycho with a food guarding problem that almost got her put down . Yes we have a big house . Another rescue job that we bought in a universally loathed by mumsnet area of east anglia ,stretched ourselves to the limit to buy , and have then spent the next 17 years fixing in bit parts as and when we can afford to. At the moment, it’s rained for the last week , so the whole house is full of fucking mud , we lost 3 willows in the last storm , and because DH has one day off a week, we’ve not finished clearing them yet , so they’re still laying on the field .

But , come the spring , when the mud has dried , the trees are cleared , the dog is white and the horses have their summer coats , you could easily take pictures of us having lunch in our field surrounded by white hawthorn blossom and artisanally hand thrown pork pies , and think that we did it every day .

I have a subscription to country homes and interiors. A Christmas presents from my mum . I always say it’s what I want my house to look like when I grow up. I’m 50. It’s always a house owned by Nigel ( who works in finance ) and Geraldine Hartley-Farquhar who used to be a hedge fund manager but gave it all up when she discovered a talent for gardening /painting/running a yoga studio . It’s almost always painted in some Farrow and ball shade beige , and with artfully curated objet that they sourced from their frequent trips to the Lower Transvaal . No B and M shiny Buddhas for them . And every month I read it with an inner commentary and notice that no one ever seems to watch telly. Or actually use their bathroom/spa annexe .

None of it is real . It’s a gigantic aspirational con , to make you want a life that NO ONE ( except possibly Tamara Ecclestone) leads . And even she got burgled.

Sceptre86 · 06/03/2022 10:50

If it makes you feel like shit watching her account then don't follow her and step away. I watched something similar and the mum has a baby a little older than mine. She looked great compared to me, I'm overweight she wasn't but not quite back to her normal self. She was giving an insight into her life as a single mum with lots of family support. I have a husband and three kids. My life is in no way similar to hers. I'm on my own journey. I watched one video I won't watch more because I don't feel our lives are similar in any way.

As long as you're doing your best who cares what anyone is up to. x

LondonQueen · 06/03/2022 10:47

You mustn't fall into the trap of believing everything you see/read on the internet. It will have been carefully staged and retaken many times until it looks perfect, real life just isn't like that.

MummyGummy · 06/03/2022 10:44

Sorry I haven’t rtft so not sure if someone has already mentioned this. What stood out to me was your anxiety, and as your son is diagnosed autistic have you considered that you might be as well?

I agree with all the other comments about social media not being real/not holding yourself up to unrealistic standards. And this applies 10 fold if you are neurodiverse. You need to live & raise your family in a way that makes YOU happy, and not care what anyone else is doing.

Your children will thank you for it as well, as it will likely be much more in line with what they need to feel secure, regulated & supported.

Northernsoullover · 06/03/2022 10:43

You need to follow Shitmumsclub on tiktok if you need an alternative reality. Katie is definitely more my type of mum.

FlasherMcGruff · 06/03/2022 10:41

You realise she posts all this because she wants others to think she’s a good mum, which means she needs external validation that she’s a good mum. The mums I know are too busy for this shit!

ohfook · 06/03/2022 10:09

@DetailMouse

My eldest was born in 2001 and whilst I think SM existed, I wasn't an early adopter Grin However, the mums from my ante natal group still managed to make me feel shit. Women have been doing this to each other since forever Sad
Have women being doing it to each other or are we doing it to ourselves?
MzHz · 06/03/2022 09:23

@DdraigGoch

I bet that baby is no happier than yours
I bet that baby will grow up with a LOT less positive interaction and involvement from its parents than your dc.

Think about it. What kind of person is so desperate to present themselves to the world like this all the time? Seeking approval, making themselves feel better? Popular? Important?

I look at these people and pity them! It’s sad! They’re Far too busy for the gram to stop and enjoy life itself. I’d far rather know someone like you @Fysal!

PeeAche · 06/03/2022 09:20

My SIL is a mumfluencer. Her feed is overflowing with bamboo this and mustard yellow that. According to her insta, she hand knits everything and feeds him only the purest quality BLW finger foods. All of his clothes, shoes and toys are stored on adorable wooden shelves which are labelled.

In reality, I think she's terribly depressed. Her son has been glued to a screen since the very first day that I met him when he was 10 days old. Just watching singing fruit and Octonauts going around and around. The house is a tip, there's cat shit everywhere and piles and piles of dirty clothes everywhere. None of them hand knitted.

When I go around, he's restrained in a bouncy chair that he's outgrown, watching telly and eating Wotsits. She's on her phone.

I don't judge her, because being a mum is hard and, like I say, I think she's depressed. But I do know that she's her own worst critic and the insta thing isn't good for any of them!

ImJustNotMeAnymore · 06/03/2022 09:11

@Chakraleaf

Tattle calls most of the fakeness out. Its all lies :-)
Tattle is a breath of fresh air. I'd recommend to anyone in a similar boat to the op.
FalloutShelter · 06/03/2022 09:10

Well.

When my youngest was a baby, I posted a few pictures and little videos of him enjoying a paddling pool, digging his fingers into his lunch, falling asleep etc. He is my DHs only bio child and his family live halfway across the world and asked to see some daily activity posted. I think they wanted to share/brag with their friends without doing the OTT thing of emailing them the videos. I didn't do anything like it with my older two, their grandparents and extended family saw them grow up. Anyway, after a week or two of this, a few of the mums from school said "oh, you have such a tidy home and such a lovely routine with your little one." And I was like 😳

Because no I don't and not really I didn't. There was no way I was filming all the clutter and swirling tornado of laundry and toys and dishes and muddy dog prints behind me. No way was I going to say stuff like "We're having early bath time and I am gritting my teeth and counting down the seconds until this little teething monster is in bed, because I can't wait to drink some wine and watch shit TV"

AngelinaFibres · 06/03/2022 09:08

Mine were young years before even Facebook came along.This thread made me ponder on which of the people at my mother and baby group would have done the Instagram type thing. There was one young woman, who I am still in contact with today, who I think would have very much lived that life . Not because she wanted to but because her husband was a very , very vain, image obsessed man. It was in the 90s . The Next directory used to arrive in the post twice a year. Centre parcs had just arrived in the UK and it was the place to go. Her husband used to insist that the children (2) had completely new wardrobes of clothes each season. All from the bible that was the Next directory. He and my friend were to have new clothes too. He would decide what everyone wore. They were all to be immaculate at all times. If you had seen them cycling about at Centre Parcs in their perfect outfits, her with perfect hair and make up, just like a Boden catalogue before Boden even existed, you would have thought 'Wow ,what a perfect family'. It was all absolute bollocks. He had multiple affairs. She was utterly crushed and miserable.She spent hours at the gym because he had told her that if she got fat he would leave her. We all went line dancing for a while. She invited the woman he was sleeping with at the time to join us. She said "Well if she is with me, at least I can be sure she isnt with him" After one 'perfect' holiday trip she returned home to find that her marriage was effectively over as he had got their 16 year old babysitter pregnant. He left her. It's very often all smoke and mirrors Op. There is very little to wish for.

HAF1119 · 06/03/2022 09:00

I'd rather be me and parent without my phone glued to my hand making sure everything is rosy and perfect then editing it to within an inch of its life

To each their own, but no thank you

kagerou · 06/03/2022 08:58

My daily routine sounds more like the tiktok mum's (except for the beautiful nursery as baby is still in my room) but that doesn't mean things are easy.

Yes I go to groups most days, but my baby's dad hasn't even met her yet

Yes she's breastfed, but her sleep is awful and I'm exhausted most of the time (plus i have a chronic health condition that adds to the fun!)

Yes we do lots of play and I try to set things up for her, but I'm on statuary maternity pay (which is about to run out) with no financial support from DP

Yes we do baby led weaning with a cute bamboo plate, but that doesn't mean i don't feel inadequate or depressed

Yes I could probably make things look perfect on social media if I used it but they're not. Everyone just tries to do the best with what they have.

If the tiktok mum you saw is truly as happy as she makes out then good for her but if that's the case she is the exception.

All we can aim for is to be the best mum we can be with what we are given and if that's what you're doing then you should be just as proud as she is.

UniversalAunt · 06/03/2022 08:57

‘ a well timed wet wipe can clean the folds of baby's neck (when they sleep)’. That’s a useful tip for both adults & children.

@Fysal you sound like a tip-top lovely mum, never mind that TikTok bollox.