Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Social media mums - making poor mum's feel like shit since the dawn of the internet

213 replies

Fysal · 05/03/2022 19:37

Just been scrolling through TikTok and came across a mum/baby account, the mum is youngish in her 20's and the baby about 7 months.

There was really sweet 'a day in the life' content showing what they do with their day, what they eat, fun activities. Lots of themed sensory activities and messy play in those Tuff tray things, making a farm yard out of pasta and coco pops for example. Things that take ages to set up and she does it with a smile. Baby ends up in a total mess which is fine because she gets bathed every night before bed as part of their routine.

The occasional well deserved night out with the girls, cocktails and nice food.

I could go on but you get the gist. She just seemed like the perfect mum.

No cute nightly bath routine for us, it's every 2nd or third day and it's always a nightmare - not the tranquil experience I'm seeing on the internet with other people's kids.

The tiktok babies bedroom was stunning. Lovely furniture, she showed inside her babies wardrobe which was full of neatly hung, well ironed pretty clothes. The whites were bright crisp white.

I haven't managed to keep my kids white clothes white for more than a month. I haven't seen an iron in years. If something is going to need ironing regularly I tend not to buy it. I'm not very domestic to be honest. The flat is clean but never stays tidy.

No beautifully arranged wardrobes for the kids here, just folded away into cheap plastic drawers.

She showed herself freezing ozs and ozs of breast milk, she'd managed to exclusively BF for 7 months now her daughter is doing baby led weaning.

I failed to establish BF and only managed to express for a few weeks.

All of the TikTok babies meals were lovingly prepared and beautifully presented, exciting and experimental recipes from a glossy BLW cook book. Baby ate from those cute bamboo bowls shaped like bunnies. Picturesque.

My eldest lives on chicken nuggets. He won't eat a thing else because of his ARIFD and autism.

The TikTok mum goes to lots of baby groups. My anxiety wouldn't get me past the front door if I decided I wanted to do something like that.

Don't get me wrong my children are loved but we don't have a particularly great life, not compared to families like that anyway.

AIBU to think social media makes poor / depressed people feel even more shit?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Chakraleaf · 10/03/2022 16:48

Anyone that has to validate every action/thought/trip online is not happy

Queeniepies · 10/03/2022 16:43

I know a couple of women who seem to live Insta-perfect lives (both are trying to be influencers and have followers at around the 10k mark) and the common denominator both have is money!

One of them is in her mid twenties and has married a wealthy man in his forties and has two children with him. They have a massive house with a pool, so perfect for Instagram pictures. She cooks amazing meals in her lovely kitchen using her expensive thermomix and can easily afford good ingredients. She and her kids are always picture perfect as they can afford nice clothes, and she has regular beauty treatments, hair appointments etc. She also works out every day in their home gym. She has no worries about money and no need to work so has plenty of time to make pasta farmyards or the equivalent. I think she is quite a driven woman; some might say marrying the wealthy older man was strategic and was a 'driven' decision too.

birdglasspen · 09/03/2022 18:50

Maintaining the wardrobe alone would be a full time job. You fold your kids clothes, I just throw them all in a drawer, everything except socks they are generally to be found in the odd sock basket 😂 kids don’t care. I’m sorry your bathtimes aren’t more fun I like ours although the pile of wet yucky toys all over bathroom means I don’t enjoy using bath myself! I think you should stop following such people!

Quincythequince · 09/03/2022 18:44

@Bhud

She has no explicit responsibility to anyone else at all. Why on earth would you say that?

Because I have a different opinion to yours about social responsibility?

So please stop swearing, and implying that those of us who don’t/didn’t struggle are either lying, irresponsible or some kind of mutant parent.

This is a total derail of the thread onto me, my sweariness, and your interpretation of my opinion, none of which seem to be particularly relevant or helpful to the OP’s question which was AIBU to think social media makes poor / depressed people feel even more shit?

I don’t think the OP was U. Especially with a child with AFRID, Autism, a teething baby and other difficulties.

You said someone who makes money on the gram has sold their conscience for some nursery paint.

Dramatic and insanely judgemental much.

Quincythequince · 09/03/2022 18:42

@Bhud

She has no explicit responsibility to anyone else at all. Why on earth would you say that?

Because I have a different opinion to yours about social responsibility?

So please stop swearing, and implying that those of us who don’t/didn’t struggle are either lying, irresponsible or some kind of mutant parent.

This is a total derail of the thread onto me, my sweariness, and your interpretation of my opinion, none of which seem to be particularly relevant or helpful to the OP’s question which was AIBU to think social media makes poor / depressed people feel even more shit?

I don’t think the OP was U. Especially with a child with AFRID, Autism, a teething baby and other difficulties.

So thin people shouldn’t ever model? Pretty people shouldn’t ever model?

In case someone fat or plain feels bad about themselves??

Great cooks shouldn’t show off their skills?

It’s crazy.

If people feel small, unless someone else is actively targeting it towards them, they should look inwards and work on themselves where they can. Not hold other people response for their own feelings of inadequacy.

OfstedOffred · 09/03/2022 15:27

But also OP - I know this is hard but you have to try and tell yourself... the bad luck you have in some things (Arfid etc).... that's not your fault. Its not anything attributable to you as a parent, and the fact that it has happened in your life not theirs is not something that should make you feel worse about yourself. Iyswim.

OfstedOffred · 09/03/2022 15:23

It's like a snapshot of anything.

My DD is cute as a button from a distance/for 10 seconds. She specialises in charming elderly ladies in supermarkets who think she's adorable.

If they had her for 10 minutes at bedtime/when it's time to turn off coco melon the reality would horrify them Grin

Bhud · 09/03/2022 14:58

She has no explicit responsibility to anyone else at all. Why on earth would you say that?

Because I have a different opinion to yours about social responsibility?

So please stop swearing, and implying that those of us who don’t/didn’t struggle are either lying, irresponsible or some kind of mutant parent.

This is a total derail of the thread onto me, my sweariness, and your interpretation of my opinion, none of which seem to be particularly relevant or helpful to the OP’s question which was AIBU to think social media makes poor / depressed people feel even more shit?

I don’t think the OP was U. Especially with a child with AFRID, Autism, a teething baby and other difficulties.

Quincythequince · 09/03/2022 13:57

@Bhud

And she isn’t nailing it because as a social fucking influencer she has a social fucking responsibility not to present a pseudo-reality of a fucking sterilised fake life that could be achievable by all women if they just tried hard enough. Where is her social conscious- has she sold it for some paint for her beautiful nursery
She has no explicit responsibility to anyone else at all. Why on earth would you say that?

I found parenting with small ones fairly easy! I didn’t choose white as a colour for them to wear (3 boys 🤣no chance) but other than being on the go constantly, I didn’t find it hard.

Clean, well-mannered kids, freshly prepared foods, many nice day trips and activities.

So sue me 🤷🏼‍♀️

I had more time as a parent than I ever had at work!

Now my boys are all waaaaaay older, it’s not so easy, I freely admit that. I am tired a lot with teenagers.

So please stop swearing, and implying that those of us who don’t/didn’t struggle are either lying, irresponsible or some kind of mutant parent.

She may be doing this as a paid role, but in life generally with everything, some people can’t! Some can! And some just do it better.

IBelieveInAThingCalledScience · 08/03/2022 17:34

Disclaimer: I'm not an Instagram/TikTok person and have actually never even posted anything on social media about our DC

Having said that, I find it such a lazy argument when people trot out the whole "bet her life isn't really like that" or "she's probably miserable" etc.

Some people prioritise different things and have different sets of circumstances to yours or even sheer luck. Some people have charmed lives and are deliriously happy.

You have to come to terms with that and stop comparing your life to others'
Because you're comparing apples with oranges.

Telling yourself that other woman is secretly shit won't change your circumstances. So change what you'd like to change and address what you can

My advice is water your grass so you stop looking at how green your neighbour's is.

And let's not put other women down because they prioritise other things.

PeeAche · 08/03/2022 17:27

@plominoagain

*I have a subscription to country homes and interiors. A Christmas presents from my mum . I always say it’s what I want my house to look like when I grow up. I’m 50. It’s always a house owned by Nigel ( who works in finance ) and Geraldine Hartley-Farquhar who used to be a hedge fund manager but gave it all up when she discovered a talent for gardening /painting/running a yoga studio . It’s almost always painted in some Farrow and ball shade beige , and with artfully curated objet that they sourced from their frequent trips to the Lower Transvaal . No B and M shiny Buddhas for them . And every month I read it with an inner commentary and notice that no one ever seems to watch telly. Or actually use their bathroom/spa annexe .

None of it is real . It’s a gigantic aspirational con , to make you want a life that NO ONE ( except possibly Tamara Ecclestone) leads . And even she got burgled.*

Do you write opinion pieces for the Guardian on Sunday? If you don't, you should. Grin

grlwhowrites · 08/03/2022 16:25

Social media is SO hard. I get very jealous of people's lovely big houses - mine is a two up, two down that took nearly a decade to save up for, but it's all a highlight reel online. Don't believe everything you see, it's very easy to edit a few clips together and make it look like it's one day. It could be a bunch of clips from a period of days/weeks edited together to look perfect. It's a highlight reel.

Please try and find some time for yourself to have a breather and feel a little more content in yourself. You'll feel less bothered by this if you can have a little "you" time - a bath, a walk, read a few pages of a good book etc. It's so easy to put all your focus on the kids and then you forget yourself in the process. You're doing amazing, your children are well cared for and happy and that's all that matters. "Comparison is the thief of joy". Stay strong, OP.

KeepYaHeadUp · 08/03/2022 15:14

@DdraigGoch

I bet that baby is no happier than yours
This
Lloki · 08/03/2022 15:10

I was once a big follower of the cleaning accounts, generally cos they gave me ideas and motivation, but most of them have turned into posts of their fabulous holidays (paid for by advertiser's), their perfect husbands and perfect kids, mounds of freebies, no one can keep up with that. I now only follow a few accounts that have stayed genuine to helping people with getting motivated and share the everyday (not cleaning an already clean sink!)
I feel quite sorry for these influencers, it must be exhausting trying to portray perfection all the time, and it must take so much time to get the right content worthy to post. Don't get me started on how miserable it must actually be for the children, I think its quite wrong to be displaying their whole life to thousands of strangers, will they have issues when they are teenagers, who know's

Bhud · 08/03/2022 14:31

in 1995 Coolio sang: “Too much television watching got me chasing dreams” television being the social media of the day.

Even rappers from Compton weren’t impervious to the social media influences peddled to them - even when they knew the life of a gang member wasn’t genuinely glamorous or desirable (as he says, “I’m 23 now, but will I live to see 24?”)

JellyfishandShells · 08/03/2022 13:33

Why do you watch such things if you know they are going to make you feel unhappy or dissatisfied ?? They are entitled to post boastful and tone deaf views of their life, however vulgar, but it’s entirely optional for you to scroll on past.

Steelesauce · 08/03/2022 13:28

I posted 'insta-perfect' pics when I was in the depths of deep depression and wanting to kill myself. It made it look on the outside like I was coping just fine when reality was very, very different. Now I'm well, I rarely post because I'm too busy living my life.

Someone I know posts the family walk pictures, all in matching puddle suits with their 2 little sausage dogs. Reality for her is her husband is on high doses of antidepressants because she was shagging the neighbour. Her kids deal with raging arguments weekly and the sausage dogs shit all over the floor constantly.

Its not real, people who are genuinely happy with life do not feel the need to share it constantly.

gogohm · 08/03/2022 13:26

It's staged, please don't assume that is their real life let alone the reality for most.

Start with stopping looking at these and instead concentrate on you and your kids. Set aims of what you want to achieve eg go to a baby group in a church hall once a fortnight rather than lots of expensive activities. Also remember much of it a fad - baby led weaning is the latest thing. I shovelled food into my kids mouths and they grew up ok. Dd1 went through the nit eating, only eating chicken nuggets and chips stage (autistic) she now lives on dal and rice her choice she's an adult.

ManicPixie · 08/03/2022 13:09

At this point social media's been around long enough that if you go on it and get green with envy you only have yourself to blame. It's always been like that and always will be. Release yourself.

LBOCS2 · 08/03/2022 13:06

This is literally her job. Even if she's not being paid to do product placements or ads right now, she's showcasing a lifestyle to advertisers to demonstrate that she 'aligns with their values' and therefore they should employ her.

We all have moments we could put on social media, of course we do. But they're snippets of real life; not the whole day - and they're the bits you want to remember. My 9yo DD1 came leaping down the stairs this morning to tell me she loves me - it was really heart warming, and I'd definitely put that on SM. Probably wouldn't include the absolute battle with her from yesterday morning about brushing her teeth in which I took away pretty much every privilege she has, plus half her pocket money, made her cry, and she still didn't brush her fucking teeth.

They're muddling through as much as the rest of us are.

PeeAche · 08/03/2022 12:57

I try to not take offence at anything I read on Mumsnet, because otherwise you'd end up offended at everything you read on Mumsnet... but...

My mother is totally obsessed with my nephew (my brother's son) and, by proxy with his mum (my SIL too)

SIL is a major "mumfluencer" and my mother bangs on day after day about what a "natural mother" she is. And how she's "naturally" better than me. 😅 My silly narcissistic mother is very easily convinced by sepia toned photographs of walks in the park and assumes, (because I'm on no social media whatsoever?) that I'm doing is a far worse job.

I get by. But I think this term "natural parents" is a little damaging. We're all natural parents.

Even if you adopted.
Even if you had IVF.
Even if you have lost a child.
Even if you couldn't breastfeed.
Even if you didn't want to breastfeed.
Even if you miscarried.
Even if you had a C-section.
Even if you were under general anaesthetic when they did it.
Even if you're a single parent.
Even if you're a step parent.
Even if you're same sex parents.
Even if you work 50 hours a week.
Even if you claim benefits.
Even if you have to choose between eating and heating.
Even if they only wear second hand.
Even if they only wear Mini Boden.
Even if they are going through that "naked phase"... for 2 years.
Even if it took you 15 years to conceive.
Even if they have screamed "I hate you" into your face because you confiscated their mobile phone.
Even if you have had a visit from social services.
Even if you only get to see them EOW and half of the holidays.
Even if your 3yo isn't anywhere near potty trained.
Even if they sometimes eat nothing but Ella's kitchen for a week.
Even if you still give them bed time breast milk at 4yo.
Even if you don't buy the special kid's version of Bonjela.
Even if you let them on their iPads too much.
Even if you don't own a copy of Little People Big World David Attenborough Edition.
Even if you co sleep.
Even if you sleep train.
Even if you bathe them in the kitchen sink.
Even if you have a disability.
Even if they're SEN.
Even if the nursery keep taking you aside for "little chats" every day.
Even if someone on Mumsnet has called you "mad" "a helicopter" or "awful"

In fact, especially all of the above. Being a parent is fucking hard and there's no training. We're all natural parents because that's just the nature of the beast.

Mum, if you're reading this, yes I'm absolutely positive that camping won't kill my kids. And no, I don't think it matters that my high chair is from Freecycle.

Bhud · 08/03/2022 11:13

[quote LittleGwyneth]@bhud Why are you so unwilling to believe that some people find parenting easy? They do. Just like some people find high powered careers or being thin really easy. It doesn't mean that anyone who doesn't is less valid, or less of a good parent, just that some people find things easier than others.

I find this desperate desire to claim that all social media is fake almost as harmful as social media in general. Someone else being good at something shouldn't make you feel bad about yourself. There will always be people who are more natural parents, who get it right more of the time. Allowing that to make you feel bad about yourself is the real problem here.[/quote]
What makes you think the TikTok mother mentioned in the OP “finds parenting easy?”

What is a “more natural parent?”

How do you know that the TikTok parent in the OP is good at anything other than posing for photographs?

LittleGwyneth · 08/03/2022 11:05

@bhud Why are you so unwilling to believe that some people find parenting easy? They do. Just like some people find high powered careers or being thin really easy. It doesn't mean that anyone who doesn't is less valid, or less of a good parent, just that some people find things easier than others.

I find this desperate desire to claim that all social media is fake almost as harmful as social media in general. Someone else being good at something shouldn't make you feel bad about yourself. There will always be people who are more natural parents, who get it right more of the time. Allowing that to make you feel bad about yourself is the real problem here.

Motherdare · 06/03/2022 14:41

Why do you look at this rubbish? It’s entirely your own fault.

Bhud · 06/03/2022 14:21

The damnable reality:
In the UK, half of all mothers develop a mental health problem before or after birth, according to the National Childbirth Trust (NCT). And 10% to 15% experience postnatal depression; many researchers believe the prevalence is even higher. Around 30% of domestic abuse begins in pregnancy. Suicide is the leading cause of death for mothers during their baby’s first year. Research commissioned by the Red Cross and the Co-op in 2016 found that nearly half of mothers under 30 feel lonely often or all the time; 82% feel lonely some of the time. Fewer than 7% of couples, according to a 2019 study from University College London, split the domestic load – let alone the mental load – equally. Most mothers work part time, where pay is lower and prospects for promotion are reduced by more than half. By the time a woman’s first child is 12, she is paid, on average, 33% less than a man, according to the Institute for Fiscal Studies. Becoming a father gives men’s earnings a boost.

from here