Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

…to take my DM’s credit cards?

32 replies

kanyewestbrom · 05/03/2022 16:11

She’s 67. Very gullible. Twice in the last 3 years she’s been caught out by scammers - once they contacted her on Facebook using cloned accounts from her friends telling her to buy Tesco vouchers then scratch off the codes and send back to them to help on an emergency. She lost £200. Second time they phoned her and told her scary stories about her computer warranty and being at risk and told to buy Amazon vouchers in cash and send the codes. She was at the bank about to withdraw £800 when the bank staff (who know her - she’s lived in the same place for 35 years) asked her casually why she needed such a large amount and she told them the story and they told her it was probably a scam. She phoned me today saying she had a customer service operative on the phone who needed her personal info and a photo of her driving license for security reasons. This is the first time she’s phoned me before the fact.

She lives 200 miles from me and I’m the closest sibling. She’s separated from my dad. I don’t know how to help her. Any ideas? All I can think of is somehow convincing her to not have a bank card and working out a way of getting her a cash allowance. Does anyone have any ideas or experience? She’ll not agree to anything I say.

She’s the perfect mark for scammers. She’s just computer literate enough to have a Facebook account but not enough to be safe.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HELLITHURT · 06/03/2022 06:33

Aren't these scammers utter bastards? They don't just take money, they take peoples independence.

Agree with a note of the bank account.

kanyewestbrom · 05/03/2022 21:39

We’ve tried a bit to discuss POA with her. She sort of doesn’t see the point as she’s still got all her marbles. Will keep chipping away.

OP posts:
Meandthesky · 05/03/2022 20:33

She’s only 67, unless she lacks capacity she should have access to her own money, it’s unreasonable to take away her cards like she’s a child. She needs to take some level of personal responsibility by not giving out details over the phone to people who call her/online or sending money. Genuine companies will understand and be happy to send a letter and/or for her to call them back. Some scammers are very convincing but the ones she’s fallen for are obvious. Nobody who’s not a scammer is ever going to ask her to buy vouchers like that!

But do get a POA in place so that you can gradually do more for her and can take over in the event she does lose capacity (POA must be arranged while she still has capacity).

CMOTDibbler · 05/03/2022 20:29

@kanyewestbrom I'd start with thinking about the different start points - phone call, text, FB message, someone at the door. Then what would someone be trying - there's a problem with someone, she owes money to someone, theres a problem with her stuff, trying to sell her something, they need something, they need information.
Then what should she do: ask for it in writing, say she will go into the bank branch/doctors, call you, say she never buys at the door, no 'her daughter deals with everything'
And a clear reminder at the top - always use the door chain, never give out information on the phone (name, address, bank, birthday...), all her bills are paid and up to date so she'll never need to pay anything on the phone, never do anything from a fb message or text

SofiaAmes · 05/03/2022 20:18

And everyone please remind your parents (and kids) that even smart business people get scammed. Some years ago I stopped my brilliant professor DF and his CEO of a billion dollar pharmaceutical friend from wiring money to a scientist friend of theirs in some African country because he had "lost his wallet." The scientist friend probably was in the far off country, (which the scammers would have known from hacking his email), but he had not lost his wallet and did not need money urgently.

SofiaAmes · 05/03/2022 20:14

A scam that's common here in the USA....someone calls pretending to be the person's grandchild and needing help. In my case, someone called my DM claiming to be my DD and explaining the funny voice by saying that she had a cold. The fake "granddaughter" said that she had been arrested for drunk driving and needed her grandmother (who lives nearby) to bring money to a lawyer for bail. Luckily my mother texted me to check on whether my DD was ok. She was, of course in class and NOT in jail. I pointed out to my DM that DD was (at the time) only 17 and a minor and if she had been arrested they would have called me, her legal guardian, and not let her make a call by herself to organize a lawyer. My DM kept saying that they person calling knew DD's name. I delved a little further into what had been said and it turned out that they had called saying "grandma I need help" and of course my DM responded "xxxx is that you" and gave them DD's name. I also pointed out to my DM that DD calls her Nonna (she's Italian) NOT grandma so that should have been a red flag....
Anyway, I happened to be volunteering with lots of older grandparents when I got the text and they all said that they had gotten dozens of these exact types of calls. So please warn your elderly parents or grandparents about this particular scam.

kanyewestbrom · 05/03/2022 18:51

Sorry pressed send too soon. Can you share with me some points for the flowchart I mightn’t have thought of?

OP posts:
Frazzled50yrold · 05/03/2022 18:35

You can , with her consent, get a call blocker installed on her phone and close down the privacy options on her Facebook. She's only 67 and most of us will still be working full time at that age.

CMOTDibbler · 05/03/2022 18:02

Bless him, my dad ended up with a few flow charts as he got very anxious with age and the pressure to decide anything quickly sent him into a spin. Having things written down let him be calmer and also gave him 'permission' to do or say things, even if that was just to check with me. And a laminated one was apparently more official and calming than a post it note

kanyewestbrom · 05/03/2022 17:52

Thanks everyone lots of good ideas. I have told her time and again to ring me or my sister. To ask for things in writing. To follow up uncharacteristic msgs on FB. The flowchart is a good idea.

OP posts:
SeaToSki · 05/03/2022 17:11

I have my MIL trained to tell everyone that calls or contacts her online to send her the information in a letter so she can show me. That usually puts them off.
It helps that she doesnt feel like she is telling them no, so its easier for her to stick to.... and she also would prefer to see it all written down anyway

1frenchfoodie · 05/03/2022 17:08

Love your flow chart initiative @CMOTDibbler . Scammers are getting so good and spin up such a sense of urgency / protecting you this is a great reality check.

godmum56 · 05/03/2022 17:00

If she won't agree to anything you say then there is nothing you can do.

WeatherwaxOn · 05/03/2022 16:53

If she trusts you sufficiently then you could apply for power of attorney over her finances.

couchparsnip · 05/03/2022 16:49

My dad has been caught by scammers a couple of times. Luckily it wasn't too bad as my mum caught it.
He's 76 and I wouldn't dream of taking his credit cards! That's over the top. Treat your mother like an adult and help her look out for signs of scammers. Don't insult her by suggesting this.

WutheringHeights66 · 05/03/2022 16:41

Can you not explain to her the risk and have her repeat to any request for anything “please contact my daughter, she will help” so you can field the dodgy calls and messages.

70kid · 05/03/2022 16:36

If you have a Lloyds account the debit cards can be set to only use in person
So PIN number only - no tap and no online purchases

CMOTDibbler · 05/03/2022 16:33

My dad used to get a lot of scam phone calls, and got really worried about it. So I made him a laminated flow chart to have on the wall with a few reminders at the top, and things to say - so a reminder to say 'Sorry I can't hear very well, please send me this information in a letter' to anyone claiming to be from BT/HMRC/British Gas. Not to make any payments over the phone or to pay anyone in cash. Not to buy anything at the door or let anyone do any work, and never leave the door open to get them a drink/donation etc (after mums handbag was stolen in a distraction burglary like this).
Then it had the flow chart of they say 'we need to know who you are' or 'you owe us' and so on.

It gave him confidence to just put the phone down on people, and an agreement to phone me if he was worried that he'd done the wrong thing in saying no

gogohm · 05/03/2022 16:31

You need power of attorney for financial affairs, they I suggest a card that cannot go overdrawn, you can transfer in weekly. But she needs to consent

Landedonfeet · 05/03/2022 16:29

I think you think you need to think about her moving closer to you
Fairly swiftly

Landedonfeet · 05/03/2022 16:29

Completely short term solution
And when I say short term
I mean less than a week
Enough time for her to get replacements

cuno · 05/03/2022 16:28

Well you can't take her cards off her! Is there a silver surfers club or simular locally, they usually teach about these things in a way that's easy for non-techy older people to understand ime, my brother used to run one. Support her with getting a flag put on her bank account so there are extra measures in place. It doesn't sound like there are any issues beyond her being a bit older on things like Facebook and not very knowledgeable about scams, so there isn't a lot you can do to stop her.

Hunderland · 05/03/2022 16:26

My DM the same. Rang me saying they knew everything about her account - turns out she'd told them what they needed to know.

My aunt lost a fortune to scammers so I'll be so upset if DM is taken in too.

feministqueen · 05/03/2022 16:22

I think you need to respect that she is a grown woman but also make her understand that the world is a fast moving and deceitful place.

You need to drum into her that she should never ever under any circumstances give her personal info out regards her bank over the phone. Likewise with computer security or any request to buy vouchers. She must not do it. If it is to cost her money in any way at all that she isn't aware of in advance then she should say no and call you for advice

I've said to my mum that noone will ever Cal asking for money and if they do they will write to you to tell you that you owe. When you get the letter send it to me.

SofiaAmes · 05/03/2022 16:21

It's a huge problem and these scammers are good. I finally have my elderly mother trained to call, text or email me anytime she gets a call from anyone asking her for something. I have also added myself on to her bank accounts so that a notification is sent to me every time there is a withdrawal.