Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think 20 min walking a day is not 'very active'

212 replies

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 15:51

I am reading a book called 'How not to die' by Michael Gregner. In it he talks about the 'Simple 7 steps' the American Heart Association says help cut your risk of Heart disease.

One is being 'very active'. This is defined as 22 minutes walking per day. I was pretty surprised by that. I walk more than that myself daily but don't consider myself very active, atall. I'm trying to get much healthier. Is that all I really need to aim for? Is there something I'm missing?

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 18:56

@pawpaws2022 - would you never walk up to the shop, or walk your DC to a club etc. in the evening? I'm not saying you should but surely not everyone who works sitting down does no walking in the evening?

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 18:53

@TravellingFrom

Btw for me the 20mins walking a day is the same sort if advice than saying use the stairs rather than the lift, park a bit further from the supermarket door and go down the bus one stop before yours.
I always find that advice annoying. As I always use the stairs etc. That's not why I'm overweight! Grin
OP posts:
RonCarlos · 05/03/2022 18:52

It's not 'very' active. It's definitely 'active' and better than nothing. A local fitness trainer around here recommends a half hour walk daily. I do 30-40 minutes after work. I don't have time to get to a gym and back and I don't like running.

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 18:51

@TravellingFrom

Come on. Most people do NOT do 20 mins of walking a day. Most people struggle to go over the 5k steps a day.

What he is doing is encouraging people to move because the majority of people do not do as much walking/exercise as that.
You can argue as much as you want that it’s not a lot, it’s not being active etc… that’s not the point of his recommendation.

Just like the 5 a day is basically what you can hope most people will achieve. It doesn’t mean that 5 a day is enough or that eating 5 bananas a day is ok. It’s just what is achievable for most.

Really? I find that surprising. Not saying you are not right.

He actually thinks it is far too little. My point is not that the American heart association are wrong to suggest it but are they right to class it 'very active'.

OP posts:
Sarahcoggles · 05/03/2022 18:48

@WombatChocolate

I agree with the PP that the thing that makes the biggest difference is starting to exercise. If someone goes from zero to 20 mins 5 times a week, the gain is bigger than those who already exercise get from boosting the length or the intensity of their exercise. There are diminishing returns after a certain point.

Those poo-pooing a brisk 30 minute walk which covers 2 miles as being nothing are probably those who exercise much more regularly and intensely. Great for them. They might be healthy and fit. Probably the thing that makes the biggest difference to them though is that first stretch of exercise too.

The majority are never going to do 2 hours a day in the gym. Those who do 2 hours or 3 hours in the gym shouldn’t be condescending about lesser amounts of exercise.

Isn’t the book about becoming MORE healthy and reducing your risks substantially, not about what being in absolute peak physical health involved and looks like. Most people have no desire to be elite athletes. Many people can improve their overall health by a few seemingly basic (but often hard to implement and stick to) changes.

Some people fool themselves. They think that ambling along with the dog whilst reading on their phone for 20 mins means they’ve exercised. That’s absolutely not the same as a brisk and purposeful walk which raise the heart rate.

According to the OP, the book says 22 minutes walking is very active. It isn’t. If 22 minutes per day is very active, what is an hour of walking a day? Because plenty of people do that if they have dogs and they don’t work. Are they elite athletes?!
UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 18:47

@Chouetted

It's not exactly nothing - it's a mile a day (or more) . And it's achievable.

I used to walk three miles a day, but frankly, taking an entire hour out of my day was too much. 20 minutes is far less likely to leave me chasing my tail for the rest of the day.

Oh, yes it is definitely something! It is doing activity and yes, would be achievable for many. I'm certain it is much better for your health than doing nothing! But would you think you were 'very active' if you walked a mile or just over a day? I'm not even saying people need to be 'very active'. 'Lightly active' or 'moderately active' could be fine and obviously depends on the person's circumstances
OP posts:
DespairingHomeowner · 05/03/2022 18:45

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

WombatChocolate · 05/03/2022 18:40

I agree with the PP that the thing that makes the biggest difference is starting to exercise. If someone goes from zero to 20 mins 5 times a week, the gain is bigger than those who already exercise get from boosting the length or the intensity of their exercise. There are diminishing returns after a certain point.

Those poo-pooing a brisk 30 minute walk which covers 2 miles as being nothing are probably those who exercise much more regularly and intensely. Great for them. They might be healthy and fit. Probably the thing that makes the biggest difference to them though is that first stretch of exercise too.

The majority are never going to do 2 hours a day in the gym. Those who do 2 hours or 3 hours in the gym shouldn’t be condescending about lesser amounts of exercise.

Isn’t the book about becoming MORE healthy and reducing your risks substantially, not about what being in absolute peak physical health involved and looks like. Most people have no desire to be elite athletes. Many people can improve their overall health by a few seemingly basic (but often hard to implement and stick to) changes.

Some people fool themselves. They think that ambling along with the dog whilst reading on their phone for 20 mins means they’ve exercised. That’s absolutely not the same as a brisk and purposeful walk which raise the heart rate.

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 18:39

I always find it strange the way on Teen Mom they just drop their young children off at school in a car. They don't even get out the car to see them in or for the teacher to see they have picked up their DC.

OP posts:
Saracen · 05/03/2022 18:39

@Fridafever

I believe the biggest bang for buck in terms of better health outcomes is quite a surprisingly small amount of activity versus nothing at all. It’s quite an important message to get out there because it’s very manageable and there are certainly people doing nothing because they’ve failed at being properly sporty/ active.

It’s obviously not very active in the commonly understood sense though.

Yes, I don't remember the details, but some research came out recently about that. Apparently there are really huge benefits to walking 20 min a day versus less. Above that, there are additional benefits of course, but this threshhold is really important.
Sarahcoggles · 05/03/2022 18:38

The people saying it’s better than nothing are missing the point. Of course it’s better than nothing, but that isn’t what the book is saying. The fact is that 22 minutes walking per day is not “very active”. It’s moderately active at best.

MrsPear · 05/03/2022 18:38

On average according to my phone which is only carried when out - my kids think I should get a Fitbit to include housework - alleges I average 5.1 miles a day which I’m surprised by.

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 18:37

@Walkingalot

Food for thought. I've always had a dog. Now mid 50's. I've walked my dog(s) every day for years and years. Sure, I've dabbled in other physical activities but none lasted, as they do. I have a resting heart rate of an athlete. It puzzled the hospital recently so much that they sent me for an ECG. I don't look fit, in fact I'm classed as obese! Size 14. I would add that I also walk everywhere I possibly can. So, walking regularly does help you keep fit. As for the American connection, I was stopped in America by Police - for walking. They questioned what I was doing, where I was going etc. I just said 'a walk'. They looked at me like I was crazy, lol.
Wow you must be very fit! I think you can be overweight and fit. It must definitely be harder in some places in the US to get a short walk in. Imagine just going for a walk being considered odd!
OP posts:
MrsPear · 05/03/2022 18:34

22 minutes a day?! That is only way to the school for me. So I do my required weekly exercise by Tuesday afternoon that’s easy.

Difficultcustomer · 05/03/2022 18:32

I think we need to benchmark against ourselves. I’m no where near as active as I could be. I’ve put on weight and less when even the little activity since wfh.

I would just about manage 20 minutes in one go. I have cerebral palsy, but should do more. What I mustn’t do is make an unrealistic goal to immediately walk 40 minutes briskly every day.

Maybe they should encourage people to walk 5minutes more a day every day or quicker so we build from wherever we are. Some of you are well beyond needing to add distance or intensity but those of us who need to don’t go mad with a resolution.

TheMoth · 05/03/2022 18:26

I don't walk 20 minutes a day. I drive for 45 minutes or so, then stand a lot. I do a lot of pacing around classrooms (and walking between them), but never 20 minutes consistently. I run 15k a week and do 2 gym classes, which keeps me slim.

pawpaws2022 · 05/03/2022 18:25

@Alwayswonderedwhy

I can't see how the average doesn't walk more than 20 mins a day just going about daily life. I wouldn't consider it active nevermind very active. More like the bare minimum.
I work 8.30 - 6 sat down, with no time to get up and move around So I guess anyone in similar jobs
TravellingFrom · 05/03/2022 18:23

Btw for me the 20mins walking a day is the same sort if advice than saying use the stairs rather than the lift, park a bit further from the supermarket door and go down the bus one stop before yours.

TravellingFrom · 05/03/2022 18:21

Come on.
Most people do NOT do 20 mins of walking a day. Most people struggle to go over the 5k steps a day.

What he is doing is encouraging people to move because the majority of people do not do as much walking/exercise as that.
You can argue as much as you want that it’s not a lot, it’s not being active etc… that’s not the point of his recommendation.

Just like the 5 a day is basically what you can hope most people will achieve. It doesn’t mean that 5 a day is enough or that eating 5 bananas a day is ok. It’s just what is achievable for most.

Chouetted · 05/03/2022 18:20

It's not exactly nothing - it's a mile a day (or more) . And it's achievable.

I used to walk three miles a day, but frankly, taking an entire hour out of my day was too much. 20 minutes is far less likely to leave me chasing my tail for the rest of the day.

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 18:19

@RoastedFerret

Apparently in the UK the average person does 90mins of moderate exercise a week. 25% do 30mins. Moderate would be fast walking. So as much as people want to say 'Americans' and shake their heads that's very active compared to the average British person.
90min of moderate exercise would be better than 140min of light exercise I would think.
OP posts:
Walkingalot · 05/03/2022 18:14

Food for thought. I've always had a dog. Now mid 50's. I've walked my dog(s) every day for years and years. Sure, I've dabbled in other physical activities but none lasted, as they do. I have a resting heart rate of an athlete. It puzzled the hospital recently so much that they sent me for an ECG. I don't look fit, in fact I'm classed as obese! Size 14. I would add that I also walk everywhere I possibly can. So, walking regularly does help you keep fit.
As for the American connection, I was stopped in America by Police - for walking. They questioned what I was doing, where I was going etc. I just said 'a walk'. They looked at me like I was crazy, lol.

Momicrone · 05/03/2022 18:10

I walk alot, 20 mins is nothing

notanothertakeaway · 05/03/2022 18:07

@Flippydip

I'd consider myself to be active if I walked for 20 mins a day. It's far more than I do currently, and I can't think of anyone I know who is that active.
@Flippydip You don't know anyone who walks 20 mins per day?

I find that surprising. Even 5 mins to bus stop, then 5 mins from bus to the office, and same at end of the work day, would be 20 mins

RoastedFerret · 05/03/2022 18:05

Apparently in the UK the average person does 90mins of moderate exercise a week. 25% do 30mins. Moderate would be fast walking. So as much as people want to say 'Americans' and shake their heads that's very active compared to the average British person.