Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think 20 min walking a day is not 'very active'

212 replies

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 15:51

I am reading a book called 'How not to die' by Michael Gregner. In it he talks about the 'Simple 7 steps' the American Heart Association says help cut your risk of Heart disease.

One is being 'very active'. This is defined as 22 minutes walking per day. I was pretty surprised by that. I walk more than that myself daily but don't consider myself very active, atall. I'm trying to get much healthier. Is that all I really need to aim for? Is there something I'm missing?

OP posts:
AlwaysLatte · 05/03/2022 19:54

I would say that was sedentary!

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 19:54

@gingerhills

I used to work with Americans - lots of them. And many commented that I would say, 'It's just a short walk from here,' meaning 10-15 mins, 20 max, when to them a 'short walk' was 2 minutes.
A short drive to them is often a long drive for us!
OP posts:
Saltyquiche · 05/03/2022 19:50

I’d become unfit and overweight and untoned if I only walked 20 minutes a day

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 19:50

[quote PortalooSunset]@UndertheCedartree I'm confused by your assertion that it doesn't mean 'brisk walking' and only walking? A quick Google of the AHA guidelines will tell you that moderate activity does in fact mean brisk walking.. Mind, they also say at least 30 minutes 5 days a week so I guess the writer has altered things slightly. <a class="break-all" href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.heart.org/idc/groups/heart-public/%40wcm/%40fc/documents/downloadable/ucm_448770.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjCzaLI0a_2AhXCiVwKHWbZC4cQFnoECCAQBQ&usg=AOvVaw2KIgK6LuWdgXzR4996BjE2" rel="nofollow" target="_blank"> Link to AHA guide[/quote]
Thank you for that! He does just say walking in the book and I did try and find it on the AHA site - obviously not very well! A brisk walk at least would seem of more benefit! I still wouldn't class that as 'very active' but maybe 'moderately active'.

OP posts:
PortalooSunset · 05/03/2022 19:48

Ahem. I posted a link to the AHA guidelines. Says brisk walk for 30 minutes is moderate activity?

RonCarlos · 05/03/2022 19:46

Brisk walk, not stroll. I think it is to form a habit, i.e. if you do nothing else then at least do this. I guess her theory is that by walking 30 mins a day minimum, you might also feel inspired to also do a couple of classes.

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 19:43

@RonCarlos

It's not 'very' active. It's definitely 'active' and better than nothing. A local fitness trainer around here recommends a half hour walk daily. I do 30-40 minutes after work. I don't have time to get to a gym and back and I don't like running.
Agreed. But do they recommend a stroll or a brisk walk?
OP posts:
lljkk · 05/03/2022 19:41

Re American Heart Association, I think they are defining 'very active' in this article, which cites this article.

And the point of last one is to divide activity levels into quintiles. The top 20% of people (presumably) did 22 or more minutes of moderate+ activity/day. These were older men referred for an exercise intervention, not random sampled people.

Probably the main people the AHA tries to help do very little exercise at point they start to try to improve their health.

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 19:41

@Sarahcoggles - just to be clear it is the American heart association that says this not the author - he disagrees. But that is my thought - what do you call it when someone is doing 20 min brisk execise or 30 min or an hour if a light 20 min walk is very active. Is a 10 min stroll 'moderately active'?

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 19:35

@WombatChocolate

I agree with the PP that the thing that makes the biggest difference is starting to exercise. If someone goes from zero to 20 mins 5 times a week, the gain is bigger than those who already exercise get from boosting the length or the intensity of their exercise. There are diminishing returns after a certain point.

Those poo-pooing a brisk 30 minute walk which covers 2 miles as being nothing are probably those who exercise much more regularly and intensely. Great for them. They might be healthy and fit. Probably the thing that makes the biggest difference to them though is that first stretch of exercise too.

The majority are never going to do 2 hours a day in the gym. Those who do 2 hours or 3 hours in the gym shouldn’t be condescending about lesser amounts of exercise.

Isn’t the book about becoming MORE healthy and reducing your risks substantially, not about what being in absolute peak physical health involved and looks like. Most people have no desire to be elite athletes. Many people can improve their overall health by a few seemingly basic (but often hard to implement and stick to) changes.

Some people fool themselves. They think that ambling along with the dog whilst reading on their phone for 20 mins means they’ve exercised. That’s absolutely not the same as a brisk and purposeful walk which raise the heart rate.

I hope I haven't come across that way. I think even 5 minutes a day compared to nothing is great and might be all someone can do. And yes, it would make sense that doing something rather than nothing is the biggest gain. What is 'best' for us ultimately is going to be individual. And no I don't want to be an elite athlete either, and I don't think it is great in terms of of health anyway. And yes, I agree the point is to raise the heart rate which was why I was surprised 'walking' rather than 'brisk.walking' made you 'very active'.

The book itself as far as I can tell so far is about getting extremely healthy, not just about a few first steps. Which is why he doesn't agree with 20 min walk per day being 'very active' or the thing to ultimately aim for.

OP posts:
TheFlyHalfsMum · 05/03/2022 19:31

It’s certainly not very active by any desirable outcome, but it may well be very active when measured against reality. 🤷🏻‍♀️

I did read something a while back suggesting, that the ubiquitous 10,000 steps has no basis in science, but doing just 4,500 steps a day was enough to ward off the worst of the negative consequences brought about by inactivity.

(And I don’t say this as a lazy person, my minutes of moderate or vigorous exercise for the last 6 days has been 544!)

Difficultcustomer · 05/03/2022 19:25

It does depend a bit where in America you mean. Also as with most of the world health outcome depends on poverty even in same town or city. I have relatives in cities in America who don’t walk and there isn’t a pavement. They go to the gym a lot. An aunt I. A town that walks a lot, wide pavements (sidewalks) but mainly spring and autumn as otherwise very hot or cold.

gingerhills · 05/03/2022 19:21

I used to work with Americans - lots of them. And many commented that I would say, 'It's just a short walk from here,' meaning 10-15 mins, 20 max, when to them a 'short walk' was 2 minutes.

LiveintheNow · 05/03/2022 19:13

@Walkingalot

As for the American connection, I was stopped in America by Police - for walking. They questioned what I was doing, where I was going etc. I just said 'a walk'. They looked at me like I was crazy, lol.

That is just like 'The pedestrian' short story by Ray Bradbury. No one walks any more, they are all home watching TV.

pawpaws2022 · 05/03/2022 19:12

[quote UndertheCedartree]@pawpaws2022 - would you never walk up to the shop, or walk your DC to a club etc. in the evening? I'm not saying you should but surely not everyone who works sitting down does no walking in the evening?[/quote]
No DC. And not usually. Finish work at 6, cook tea, shower, cleaning. I shop online ATM as CEV so don't tend to go to shops

TisTheSeasonToBe · 05/03/2022 19:10

For the majority of people 20 mins brisk walking a day would be a huge increase on their current activity levels in many areas.
To me it wouldnt be very active tho.

Walkingalot · 05/03/2022 19:07

I used to use a fitbit to measure my walking. I'd walk my DS to school, with the dog and then go for a walk. Later on I'd walk into town to shop (not every day) and then I'd go and pick up my son, with the dog. I think I run up over 10,000 steps daily, easily. Week-ends weren't a cop out as I'd use that opportunity to go further with the dog, even if it meant a car ride to somewhere more interesting but then I'd do a 2 hr walk at least. Of course you have the winter/summer variances but overall, if you keep that up year in, year out - you're going to be reasonably fit. I think steady and consistent wins the day.

dizzydizzydizzy · 05/03/2022 19:05

Well I think it's quite a low bar, but as PPs have said, compared With nothing, it is v good.

I am very fit and run and swim for longer than that several times a week.

Shopgirl1 · 05/03/2022 19:04

It’s better than nothing I suppose, but wouldn’t be enough for me to feel fit - but I’m just used to more, I’m a runner, I have 15,000 steps a day minimum, more on run days, and couldn’t do that in 20 minutes. It’s definitely better than nothing and especially if in addition to walking around generally, so a deliberate brisk extra 20 minute walk.

PriamFarrl · 05/03/2022 19:02

@RoastedFerret

Apparently in the UK the average person does 90mins of moderate exercise a week. 25% do 30mins. Moderate would be fast walking. So as much as people want to say 'Americans' and shake their heads that's very active compared to the average British person.
I think the thing that people are saying ‘Americans’ at is the idea of walking for just 20 minutes counting as exercise rather than just getting somewhere.
DelilahBucket · 05/03/2022 19:01

Depends on a lot of factors. If you normally sit on your backside every day then yes, a 22 minute walk will be more beneficial than current lifestyle choices. However I think it is important to define what kind of walk that means. I know so many people who think "oh I went for a 45 minute walk today so I can have a slice of cake" when that walk was a snail pace meander. On the other hand, a fast pace with hills for 22 minutes a day will really help and it won't put strain on joints.

PortalooSunset · 05/03/2022 19:00

I struggle to do 20 minutes a day tbh. I work 8.5 hours with an hour commute. Spent 4 hours doing heavy digging in the garden today though and am planning on doing a 10k run tomorrow.

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 19:00

@Difficultcustomer

I think we need to benchmark against ourselves. I’m no where near as active as I could be. I’ve put on weight and less when even the little activity since wfh.

I would just about manage 20 minutes in one go. I have cerebral palsy, but should do more. What I mustn’t do is make an unrealistic goal to immediately walk 40 minutes briskly every day.

Maybe they should encourage people to walk 5minutes more a day every day or quicker so we build from wherever we are. Some of you are well beyond needing to add distance or intensity but those of us who need to don’t go mad with a resolution.

Oh, I completely agree, you need to build up gradually. I'm doing C25k which is great for that. I would think we should start being 'lightly active' before building to 'moderately active' or 'very active'.
OP posts:
PortalooSunset · 05/03/2022 18:58

@UndertheCedartree I'm confused by your assertion that it doesn't mean 'brisk walking' and only walking? A quick Google of the AHA guidelines will tell you that moderate activity does in fact mean brisk walking.. Mind, they also say at least 30 minutes 5 days a week so I guess the writer has altered things slightly. <a class="break-all" href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.heart.org/idc/groups/heart-public/%40wcm/%40fc/documents/downloadable/ucm_448770.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjCzaLI0a_2AhXCiVwKHWbZC4cQFnoECCAQBQ&usg=AOvVaw2KIgK6LuWdgXzR4996BjE2" rel="nofollow" target="_blank"> Link to AHA guide

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 18:57

@TheMoth

I don't walk 20 minutes a day. I drive for 45 minutes or so, then stand a lot. I do a lot of pacing around classrooms (and walking between them), but never 20 minutes consistently. I run 15k a week and do 2 gym classes, which keeps me slim.
I think that trump's the walking! But don't you do any walking in the evening after work?
OP posts: