Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think 20 min walking a day is not 'very active'

212 replies

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 15:51

I am reading a book called 'How not to die' by Michael Gregner. In it he talks about the 'Simple 7 steps' the American Heart Association says help cut your risk of Heart disease.

One is being 'very active'. This is defined as 22 minutes walking per day. I was pretty surprised by that. I walk more than that myself daily but don't consider myself very active, atall. I'm trying to get much healthier. Is that all I really need to aim for? Is there something I'm missing?

OP posts:
reqding · 11/03/2022 06:59

@GregBrawlsInDogJail

That's just not completely sedentary by my benchmark, yeah. But a surprising number of people are in fact totally sedentary, so it's better than that.
WFH has got me in this place where I rarely leave the house now. I don't walk and don't exercise. I keep telling myself I'll do something about it and then another week passes by.
Saltyquiche · 11/03/2022 06:54

Having read various studies about basic health gains through walking, 7000 is the minimum required for health benefits, with ever increasing health gains up to 14000 steps daily. However above 14000 there are fewer health gains

Rinatinabina · 08/03/2022 06:40

Maybe its this kind of thing,

www.verywellhealth.com/step-count-matters-one-study-finds-5202333#:~:text=Key%20Takeaways,death%20among%20middle%2Daged%20adults

I’m tubby as hell but I wouldn’t consider 7000 steps an active day yet it seems makes a difference. So 20 minutes would get me about 2000 steps (slow coach) I cover about 6000-7000 steps with general pottering around so if you are even less active than me 2000 steps, at just a stroll could actually make a difference to your health.

Dsisproblem · 08/03/2022 06:27

I think the thing is you actually don't need a large amount of activity to make a health difference. That's a positive message for many who feel they can't possibly get fit. Just getting out for a walk daily could improve many peoples health.

I think the biggest thing to improve health/live longer is to prioritise sleep. No screens before bed, dim lights, no food 3 hours before bed.

Listen to recent podcast on sleep from Dr Chatterjee. V interesting

cereallover · 08/03/2022 06:12

That's not much imo. I run just over 2 miles in the morning and have breakfast. Then walk 6 miles with ds in his pram. In total I think that takes me about 2.5 hours

PrincessNutella · 08/03/2022 03:34

I am American and I use the step tracker on my Iphone. I do a minimum of 5,000 steps a day (or else what, I don't know) it's just that over the past whatever years, if I ever walk less than that, then I feel as if I have to make it up so that I have an overall minimum of 5000 steps a day over the course of a month and a year of 5,000 steps. It definitely takes more than an hour a day, unless I go to the gym. So 20 minutes doesn't seem like much. But I can imagine how people wouldn't get around to it unless they made a conscious effort to do it.

Marchitectmummy · 08/03/2022 01:35

I also think the majority of people do not wall briskly for 20 minutes per day.

My school run, I would estimate 80 percent of parents drive to and from the school. And even then it's 6 years of a child being in education for which they are dropped off at school, say 2 children aversge 3 years apart that wiuld be 9 years of walking too and from school, out of ab adult life say of 40 years that would still leave 30 years not walking to school. For at least half of those they walk at a snails pace. Prior to school years again judging by our nursery from, most parents drove.

Dog walkers, most I see walk to the park, unleash the dog and stand talking while at most using one of those devices to launch a ball to exercise the dog.

I live in a very utban setting and yet barely see my neighbours walk beyond the tube station. I think the UK thinks it does more walking than it does, ambling yep let's pf that but walking at a pace nope not as many as people think.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/03/2022 00:00

@TheMoth

I'm a tall person. I never do as many steps as a short person. I did 21000 today though. That was a 10k run and family walk. Which means my kids probably did shit loads of steps.
Kids do something more akin to Dog Miles.

So do DPs, if mine is anything to go by. Grin

TheMoth · 06/03/2022 22:17

I'm a tall person. I never do as many steps as a short person. I did 21000 today though. That was a 10k run and family walk. Which means my kids probably did shit loads of steps.

MrsJBaptiste · 06/03/2022 19:12

I go to the gym 4-5 times a week and will make sure within that I run 15 miles a week then go on a walk on my days off the gym. I still wouldn't class myself as very active because I WFH and so only do 2,500 steps before I get to the gym.

Hearing someone say a 20 min walk a day is active is just ridiculous!

Fridafever · 06/03/2022 19:05

Yeah the step count claims are very weird sometimes. I remember someone saying their lowest ever day was something like 4k steps when they were in bed all day with flu. Then would not accept that a few trips to the loo could not possibly add up to that.

Chouetted · 06/03/2022 19:03

Most stepcounters vastly overestimate the number of steps though. I'm very skeptical of people who can rack up several miles by 1030am, without even leaving the house. Unless they genuinely live in a mansion.

lljkk · 06/03/2022 16:45

Most people struggle to go over the 5k steps a day.

Do we know that? I mean, where are the data?
This write up says different.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 05/03/2022 23:20

@TravellingFrom

Come on. Most people do NOT do 20 mins of walking a day. Most people struggle to go over the 5k steps a day.

What he is doing is encouraging people to move because the majority of people do not do as much walking/exercise as that.
You can argue as much as you want that it’s not a lot, it’s not being active etc… that’s not the point of his recommendation.

Just like the 5 a day is basically what you can hope most people will achieve. It doesn’t mean that 5 a day is enough or that eating 5 bananas a day is ok. It’s just what is achievable for most.

This always surprises me. Apart from during Covid, where I averaged 63 steps a day only because I was forcing myself to use the upstairs toilet (and then needed an hour rest because I couldn't get enough air into my lungs), I've usually done 5000 by about 10.30am at work and about 3000 at home if I haven't gone out - in terms of minutes, I do a minimum of the recommended week's per day (and that's with what I'd describe as a really quiet day at work).

I definitely still need to do actual exercise on top - walking to and from bus stops and then round site during the day, nipping outside for some daylight 2-3 times a day and then walking down to the next bus stop to avoid waiting with large numbers of schoolkids isn't enough, IMO.

I suppose my perspective is skewed because I don't go from sofa to car to desk to car to sofa each day. Maybe it would be different if I did.

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 23:00

@Ghislainedefeligonde

bigfat yes I agree it needs to be 20 min walking in one go, not just accumulating steps by walking to and from fridge/ bathroom/ office etc. A brisk 20 min walk has been shown to have huge benefits in reducing blood pressure, risk of diabetes etc. with greatest benefit being in the group currently doing less than this (which is likely the majority). If you are already fit and doing lots of exercise a 20 min walk on top of this won’t make as much impact compared to a sedentary person. But the fit and active group and not the ones being targetted with this type of message
I think even 10 min of brisk walking is good as that is what is targeted in the NHS Active 10 app.
OP posts:
FourTeaFallOut · 05/03/2022 21:39

Think I might have hit 150 sat watching the news this week. Not sure I'm getting a reduction in blood pressure though.

TheMoth · 05/03/2022 21:18

No. If it's not a gym night, I get home around 6,have tea and sit at the table working again! I usually stop at 9 and go to bed. By Friday, I'm asleep by 9.

Ghislainedefeligonde · 05/03/2022 20:53

bigfat yes I agree it needs to be 20 min walking in one go, not just accumulating steps by walking to and from fridge/ bathroom/ office etc. A brisk 20 min walk has been shown to have huge benefits in reducing blood pressure, risk of diabetes etc. with greatest benefit being in the group currently doing less than this (which is likely the majority).
If you are already fit and doing lots of exercise a 20 min walk on top of this won’t make as much impact compared to a sedentary person. But the fit and active group and not the ones being targetted with this type of message

Justdoingthisnow · 05/03/2022 20:18

I used to work in research and physical activity. The key thing is whether you get your heart rate up so 150 minutes a week of heart raising activity. For me walking wouldn't do that so I used to run or do HIT training (actually if it was vigorous you only need to do 75 minutes). However, you can meet the 150 minute target and still be sedentary which I definitely was/am with a desk job.

bigfatmeerkat · 05/03/2022 20:17

Surely it means 22 mins brisk walk in one session? Which is a big change from the sedentary lifestyle that's normalised in the US.

As a pp said, walking anywhere in US is just not normal. 10 min walk? Why not get a cab? 25 mins - who on earth would walk that? I once told a hotel driver I planned to walk the 45 mins back - he insisted on picking me up and driving me. He couldn't understand why anyone would walk that far.
Walking is underrated though, we should all walk more

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 20:15

@PortalooSunset

Yep I think the author has misquoted slightly, whether deliberate or not I don't know. But I agree with you I don't think I'd class it as very active.
Yes, I think he should have referred to it as 'brisk walking' rather than just walking. I've only just started the book so not sure at this stage if it was deliberate. He did say only 1 person out of a study of about 2000 passed all the 7 'simple steps' the AHA recommend.
OP posts:
bringonsummer2022 · 05/03/2022 20:06

I can't imagine walking for less than 20 minutes a day, actually I would find it really distressing. 20 minutes is a mile, which is only 2000 steps - I would do that just between car, work, desk, toilet, kitchen for drinks, up and down stairs - don't quite see how it's practically possible to do less unless you are disabled.
Like others I lived in the US and it's normal to drive from one side of the parking lot to another, and my housemates used to argue over who got the parking spot closest to the house.

PortalooSunset · 05/03/2022 20:00

Yep I think the author has misquoted slightly, whether deliberate or not I don't know. But I agree with you I don't think I'd class it as very active.

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 19:59

@lljkk

Re American Heart Association, I think they are defining 'very active' in this article, which cites this article.

And the point of last one is to divide activity levels into quintiles. The top 20% of people (presumably) did 22 or more minutes of moderate+ activity/day. These were older men referred for an exercise intervention, not random sampled people.

Probably the main people the AHA tries to help do very little exercise at point they start to try to improve their health.

Ah, so they are saying 'very active' is the average top amount of exercise people in their study did?
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 19:57

@TheFlyHalfsMum

It’s certainly not very active by any desirable outcome, but it may well be very active when measured against reality. 🤷🏻‍♀️

I did read something a while back suggesting, that the ubiquitous 10,000 steps has no basis in science, but doing just 4,500 steps a day was enough to ward off the worst of the negative consequences brought about by inactivity.

(And I don’t say this as a lazy person, my minutes of moderate or vigorous exercise for the last 6 days has been 544!)

Interesting, thank you.
OP posts: