Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think 20 min walking a day is not 'very active'

212 replies

UndertheCedartree · 05/03/2022 15:51

I am reading a book called 'How not to die' by Michael Gregner. In it he talks about the 'Simple 7 steps' the American Heart Association says help cut your risk of Heart disease.

One is being 'very active'. This is defined as 22 minutes walking per day. I was pretty surprised by that. I walk more than that myself daily but don't consider myself very active, atall. I'm trying to get much healthier. Is that all I really need to aim for? Is there something I'm missing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Scarlettpixie · 13/03/2022 15:18

Dr Gregor recommends as much walking as you can. He has a treadmill desk. I had a quick google and found this:

But how much is enough? Dr. Greger believes health authorities ‘have fallen into the same trap as the nutrition authorities, recommending what they think may be achievable, rather than simply informing us what the science says, and letting us make up our own mind’.

Official US guidelines say adults should get at least 150 minutes a week of moderate aerobic exercise (that’s just 20 minutes a day).

“Dr. Greger says: “It is true that walking 150 minutes a week is better than walking 60 minutes a week.

“Following the current recommendations for 150 minutes appears to reduce your overall mortality rate by seven percent, compared to being sedentary.

“Walking for only 60 minutes a week only drops your mortality rate about three percent. But, walking 300 minutes a week drops overall mortality by 14percent.

“So, walking twice as long – 40 minutes a day, compared to the recommended 20 – yields twice the benefit. And, an hour-long walk each day may reduce mortality by 24 percent.”

TheHumanExperience · 13/03/2022 14:46

20 minute brisk walk where you are 'deep' breathing has huge health related benefits.

elp30 · 13/03/2022 01:56

I should also add that those distances I mentioned, are each way, not all together.

That means a minimum of 4-6 miles round-trip journeys.

elp30 · 13/03/2022 01:34

I'm in Texas and the "school run" is far where I live.

The elementary school (ages 5-10) and the high school (ages 14-18) begin at 7:35am and from my home is 2.1 miles away and 3 miles. That's 40 minutes and over an hour to get to school in the morning or afternoon return at 2:35pm.

The middle school (ages 11-13) begins later at 9:05am and it's 2.5 miles from my home. Again around 45 minutes but the day ends at 4:45pm. In the winter, the kids are walking home in the dark.

Luckily for me, there are established yellow school bus routes for my children's schools. But other areas are not so lucky and have to arrange their own transport even with long distances.

Someone, I think the OP @UndertheCedartree mentioned that she found it odd that parents in an American program dropped their kids off at school in the car. This may be why. Plus, in my city, the fourth largest in the nation, has massive commuting times to the city so many kids are dropped off very early (our working day begins at 8am traditionally) and long distances away from schools is why many people do this. My children had after-school activities at school that ended an hour or two after the school day and if there's an after-school activity, there are no school buses home and families must find arrangements to get the kids to their homes and that includes driving.
That doesn't include off-campus after-school activities.

That is why many people are always driving and walking, even 20 minutes a day, can be hard for many Americans on a typical day.

pixie5121 · 13/03/2022 00:43

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Procrastination4 · 13/03/2022 00:36

Just because you don’t consider it to be “active” doesn’t mean there aren’t health benefits, though. And I guess he’s talking about right across the age spectrum, so, for someone in their 80’s to be doing a twenty minute walk every single day would be active, surely. For kids that would be positively sedentary as the majority of them do huge amounts of running every day in the school yard from my daily observations of them (teacher). So it’s relative, I guess. And besides, it’s probably more beneficial to do 20 mins of walking daily throughout your entire adult life rather than run 5-10 k pretty regularly in your twenties and thirties and give it up for a more sedentary lifestyle in your 60’s and 70’s.

Saltyquiche · 13/03/2022 00:17

So between 3-7 miles a day? I'm curious how there can possibly be no health benefit below 3 miles - do you have the studies?

^^

In answer to your question, studies showed some minor gains at low walking levels. 7k to 14k was shown to be the sweet spot. If you Google walking studies you’ll come across quite a lot of research

Thatswhyimacat · 12/03/2022 20:55

I've done 150 minutes of activity so far today and it's my rest day, so it's all walking. On a normal day I will do about 100-120 minutes of walking and 50-60 minutes dedicated exercise. When calculating my TDEE I'm classed as moderately active.

UndertheCedartree · 12/03/2022 20:53

@tinkywinkyshandbag

I like to walk my dogs twice a day for at least 40 minutes per walk, I do have quite a physically active job but I still think I could do more. I'm struggling at the moment because of plantar fasciitis which is making it difficult for me to walk, and I really hate it. I really want to be more active - and my dogs are getting fatter too!!
Plantar fascitis is so painful! Are you doing exercises for it?
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 12/03/2022 20:52

@soulinablackberrypie

Nearly every job I've ever had has involved about a half-hour walk each way. My current job is about a 50 minute walk each way. I don't really think of that as exercise because it's something I need to do to get from A to B (I haven't got a car). But I miss it on days when I'm not working - I get fidgety and will usually get out for a walk of some sort during the day, unless I go for a run instead. I'm not super-fit (I can run, but not fast) and am visibly somewhat overweight - I should imagine I'd be pretty unfit by now if I didn't walk at all.

I can well believe people in America think 20 minutes is a long walk, as it sounds like it's just not the cultural norm there (except maybe in New York City and a few other more "alternative" towns?) I have very occasionally met someone in the UK who had no idea about walking. When my DS was a baby, I used to walk to a local coffee morning once a week with him in a pushchair - it took about 10 minutes. Another woman who lived in the same road as me went to the same thing and usually drove. One week her car was in for repairs and she walked - and arrived embarrassingly early because she'd allowed 45 minutes for the short walk!

45 minutes wow! I do know many avid car drivers who if their car is in the garage they feel unable to go anywhere - it is really strange!
OP posts:
tinkywinkyshandbag · 12/03/2022 20:50

I like to walk my dogs twice a day for at least 40 minutes per walk, I do have quite a physically active job but I still think I could do more. I'm struggling at the moment because of plantar fasciitis which is making it difficult for me to walk, and I really hate it. I really want to be more active - and my dogs are getting fatter too!!

UndertheCedartree · 12/03/2022 20:48

@thecatsthecats - I agree with you, especially on a warm day much nicer to walk. My DC's Social Worker was worried about us walking to school - it is only a 20 min walk!

OP posts:
SnipSnipMrBurgess · 11/03/2022 21:52

I hate walking with a passion, I really do. I don't find it enjoyable.

20 mins would be torture to me.

LondonQueen · 11/03/2022 21:07

Americans walk a lot less than we do, I think it's 60 minutes a day exercise is considered very active here.

soulinablackberrypie · 11/03/2022 21:03

Nearly every job I've ever had has involved about a half-hour walk each way. My current job is about a 50 minute walk each way. I don't really think of that as exercise because it's something I need to do to get from A to B (I haven't got a car). But I miss it on days when I'm not working - I get fidgety and will usually get out for a walk of some sort during the day, unless I go for a run instead. I'm not super-fit (I can run, but not fast) and am visibly somewhat overweight - I should imagine I'd be pretty unfit by now if I didn't walk at all.

I can well believe people in America think 20 minutes is a long walk, as it sounds like it's just not the cultural norm there (except maybe in New York City and a few other more "alternative" towns?) I have very occasionally met someone in the UK who had no idea about walking. When my DS was a baby, I used to walk to a local coffee morning once a week with him in a pushchair - it took about 10 minutes. Another woman who lived in the same road as me went to the same thing and usually drove. One week her car was in for repairs and she walked - and arrived embarrassingly early because she'd allowed 45 minutes for the short walk!

UndertheCedartree · 11/03/2022 15:25

@Dsisproblem

I think the thing is you actually don't need a large amount of activity to make a health difference. That's a positive message for many who feel they can't possibly get fit. Just getting out for a walk daily could improve many peoples health.

I think the biggest thing to improve health/live longer is to prioritise sleep. No screens before bed, dim lights, no food 3 hours before bed.

Listen to recent podcast on sleep from Dr Chatterjee. V interesting

I agree, that even a small amount of exercise can really improve a person's health. I am not for a minute criticising the idea that doing a small manageable amount of exercise is a good goal.

And yes sleep is so interesting. It has such a big effect in so many areas! I'm reading a book on it at the moment. I'll look out the podcast.

OP posts:
TheOrigRights · 11/03/2022 14:47

I walk so fast my Garmin automatically detects it as an "activity" so I end up with all these daft little walks to the corner shop or a walk from a car part to the store/cinema/sports centre.

I should probably work out how to turn that function off as it looks pretty wanky when it automatically uploads to my strava.

Rno3gfr · 11/03/2022 14:23

I don’t drive so I walk a few miles each day out of necessity because we live at least a 20-40 minute walk from everything. It doesn’t bother me as I’m used to it and I’d never be able to get anywhere if I didn’t walk. I also walk pretty fast as I’m bored of how long it takes just to get to the shop, etc,. That said, I actually consider myself a bit unfit as, although I’m a healthy weight, I don’t exactly do any strenuous activity to get my heart going.

20 minutes of walking a day is laughable to be considered ‘active’. It just shows how sedentary we’ve all become.

Disclaimer: I’m no saint, I would probably drive everywhere and be sedentary if I could

SartresSoul · 11/03/2022 14:01

The average American adult walks 4K steps a day so that’s probably why. Such a vast country I suppose they don’t have the opportunity to walk in the same way we do. I walk on average 16k steps a day and I’d consider that ‘very active, some days 22k.

balalake · 11/03/2022 13:59

The organisation the OP refers to is in the United States. Where 22 minutes walking is probably unheard of for many people, never mind the lazy able-bodied people there are in the UK.

thecatsthecats · 11/03/2022 13:40

@Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin

Hmm maybe the fact he is American is the key point here....l was in the USA years ago and asked how far a particular landmark was from the hotel. They said oh it is a long way you need a cab. Started walking and was there in 15 mins! Not sure if the average American would walk that. Disclaimer l love America and its people so no offence intended at all! And even a short walk can give me a nice little boost so think it is good for mental health too.
Dunno, I've met many Brits who are similar.

MIL - you can't walk to THAT hotel after the party (it was 30m walk after midnight, walking together, ILs got a taxi to their house a 10m walk away)
Colleague given a lift to my house - 5m walk, and to work - 20m walk
Friend's husband didn't want his three year old to walk a one mile round trip on a pleasant day.

Very frustrating because I find short trips make me travel sick, so hate it when I'm forced into them.

UndertheCedartree · 11/03/2022 13:31

@Marchitectmummy

I also think the majority of people do not wall briskly for 20 minutes per day.

My school run, I would estimate 80 percent of parents drive to and from the school. And even then it's 6 years of a child being in education for which they are dropped off at school, say 2 children aversge 3 years apart that wiuld be 9 years of walking too and from school, out of ab adult life say of 40 years that would still leave 30 years not walking to school. For at least half of those they walk at a snails pace. Prior to school years again judging by our nursery from, most parents drove.

Dog walkers, most I see walk to the park, unleash the dog and stand talking while at most using one of those devices to launch a ball to exercise the dog.

I live in a very utban setting and yet barely see my neighbours walk beyond the tube station. I think the UK thinks it does more walking than it does, ambling yep let's pf that but walking at a pace nope not as many as people think.

This is where the Active 10 app is good as it tells you how much brisk walking you do. I only brisk walk on the way back from dropping my DD off or on the way to pick her up as when she is with me she faffs around and walks slowly! So I do 20 min brisk walking 6 days a week (as she does gymnastics at school on a Saturday) plus I pick her up 3 days a week.But she is Y5 so not sure what I'll do when she goes to school alone - good point!!
OP posts:
SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 11/03/2022 13:23

Tbf, with the way modern life is, I'm not surprised.

Most days I only really 'walk' around my house. I commute to work by car which is parked outside my house and get dropped off by the entrance to the building, then back again. Even if I get the bus, it's a 5 min walk to the bus stop.
I don't go for a walk on my lunch break because for about half the year (if not, more) it's either freezing, raining or really windy.

I do go the gym though three times a week.

ghostmouse · 11/03/2022 13:12

I’ve gone from walking 30 mins a day to nothing for health reasons but I’ve been told by cardio that ihave to start by doing 10 minutes gentle walking a day.

No 22 minutes is not a lot but to someone who is suffering from health probs or who is completely sedentary it’s something to work towards

Chouetted · 11/03/2022 13:08

@Saltyquiche

Having read various studies about basic health gains through walking, 7000 is the minimum required for health benefits, with ever increasing health gains up to 14000 steps daily. However above 14000 there are fewer health gains
So between 3-7 miles a day? I'm curious how there can possibly be no health benefit below 3 miles - do you have the studies?
Swipe left for the next trending thread