Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

3 yo forty minutes of screaming and shouting and crying

115 replies

pandarific · 05/03/2022 11:04

Forty. Minutes. I have used my calm nice mum voice, I have explained why no, we cannot do what he wants to do. I have suggested other things. I had a baby crawling around too and a cold (from him).

Got: ‘I’m the leader, I say no, I’m in charge, not you, you are naughty, I say yes!!!’ Coupled with screeeeeeaming and crying.

I am so over it. So over it. He’s being such a nightmare at the moment.

At what age does this stop? My NCT group’s kids seem to be phasing out of the toddler tantrums, but mine is the only one who will keep going and going and going and -

Fully hate my life this morning. Please be nice to me.

OP posts:
stimpyyouidiot · 05/03/2022 14:24

@Hellolittlestar same here. Or 'I don't know'. I do the you pick or I'll pick for you thing though and that usually produces an answer.

Hellolittlestar · 05/03/2022 14:20

@Cuck00soup

^ Yes, you're in charge of the dinosaurs, and Mummy is in charge of you. Oh look there's a bird in the garden. Shall we go to the swings later or feed the ducks?^

I know you mean well with this advice, but it does not work on all kids. I get quite frustrated with all this unicorn happy parenting advice, because I want it to work too, but it never explains what to do if it doesn’t. If I give my 3 year old daughter a choice: “do you want A or B” she will say C or No.

parrotonmyshoulder · 05/03/2022 14:19

Harvey Karp’s book ‘The Happiest Toddler on the Block’ (cheesy title!) was really good when mine were that age. Helpful to understand why little kids behave like that, and some empathetic, kind strategies that really work.

Pumperthepumper · 05/03/2022 14:12

What did he want?

Phos · 05/03/2022 14:11

@TheFlyHalfsMum

That's the kind of thing my daughter would say in some situations. Lucky not this one for me. She sometimes asks to play the colours game now when she can feel herself going.

pandarific · 05/03/2022 14:10

@Squiffy01 I hear you, and I understand you. I worry about this too. Some of the advice here is good, some though well intentioned is just a bit obvious.

I think I forget sometimes with him that the BIG tantrums are usually because I haven’t understood him somehow. I just can’t stand being followed around and screamed at. My family was like that growing up, and I just can’t stand it. I swore never to have it happen in mine. Uuuuugh.

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 05/03/2022 14:09

Stop with the nicey nice voice. Speak in a more authoritative tone. I agree with stopping the reasoning. Say I have said no. When he starts just say no.

underneaththeash · 05/03/2022 14:05

Same as a PP different racks worked for different children. DS1 needed feeding. DS2 distraction and DD ignoring!
Sorry, not much help.

TheAbbotOfUnreason · 05/03/2022 14:04

Glad somebody else has pointed out that Biddulph was talking nonsense about testosterone increases before puberty.

Jazzyjeffery · 05/03/2022 14:02
  • almighty power struggles that should have said!
Jazzyjeffery · 05/03/2022 14:01

Ignore him till he calms down. As pp said, in some children continuing to talk fuels the rage. Try a cuddle by all means, but if that doesn't work completely disengage. When they've stopped, move on swiftly. No need to rake over it all. My ds is 10 and we still sometimes have alright power struggles. I still employ the same tactics now of offering a hug and if it's refused, walking away until he's calmed down. At his age we do talk about things afterwards but after the event when rational talk is possible. Some kids feed off the argument and have to have the last word. You sound like a brilliant parent op btw. Keep calm and carry on!!

HousePlantNeglect · 05/03/2022 14:01

Sympathies. I thought I was the worlds best mother with DS1 when he was two. All my friends kids having tantrums and my little darling playing nicely. My smugness lasted til he turned 3 and into, frankly, a monster for almost a year. Hideous, long, raging tantrums very frequently. It was awful.

During these times he hated any approach. Being touched, comforted, reasoned with, ignored, told off.

It has passed abs I’m sure it will for you. I wish you fortitude in the meantime!!!

stimpyyouidiot · 05/03/2022 13:52

@Snippysocks

Forty minutes?! If you've tried all the great suggestions on here and they've failed, go into another room, take a deep breath, go back in and a quick smack on a nappied bottom should do the trick. It's not the smack that does it (and shouldn't be a hard one done in anger), it's the shock if you never do it. When a toddler has got himself into this sort of rage he won't hear all the calm voices in the world. And yes - am anticipating a shoot down here, talks of violence etc but all my children still love me and ask me to have their children to stay so the occasional the short, sharp shock when they were little obviously didn't traumatise them or make them hate me. And they have all grown up to be kind and gentle people!
Shockseriously
Nocutenamesleft · 05/03/2022 13:51

@Nelliephant1

Boys do have a testosterone surge around the age of four and seven so it may be that it's kicking in a wee bit earlier for your wee boy. As with all things hormonal, there doesn't seem to be any rhyme nor reason for it and not a lot of rationality, he probably can't explain it either as it may be hormonal rather than anything else.

Have a look at the book Raising Boys by Steve Bidiulph. He's an Australian psychologist who is fab and his book is very light, easily read and full of things that the majority of people don't know about the physical and physiological development of boys.

Hang in there!

That’s incorrect. Boys don’t have a testosterone surge at that age. I work in endocrine!!

They have a surge around puberty. At 11-17. Then it starts to decline from around 19.

Not 4!!!!

sunflowerdaisyrose · 05/03/2022 13:50

My eldest child (now 7) still has tantrums, my six year old never has, remember they are all so different so don't worry you're doing something wrong.

Advice I was given was not to leave them/put them in any time out, they are taking comfort from you regardless of how it feels. Hugging mine when she doesn't want it makes it even worse and gets her hot and bothered.

I try not to keep repeating myself or a gaming with the tantrum but sometimes other things work. Distraction like saying 'oh wow, look at this!!' when looking out the window, finding a baby photo on the phone and saying how sweet and does she want to see it, talking about something nice coming up in a totally normal voice - that kind of thing. Otherwise repeating back to them what they are saying but as a question sometimes works -ie 'I'm the leader', 'you're the leader?'. 'Yes and i say I get it!' 'You say you get it?' Etc. Makes them stop and think sometimes and can de escalate.

It's horrible but staying a calm as far as you can is the best way to deescalate but it's really hard!

SmellyWellyWoo · 05/03/2022 13:48

My eldest was a royal pain in the arse for me (but an angel for every other bugger Hmm). I worked full time and honestly used to breathe a sigh of relief when I dropped him off at nursery in the morning. He got to four and suddenly just seemed to get easier. Can't remember how I got through it or what techniques I used (if any!). I suppose my point is- this too shall pass.

Nelliephant1 · 05/03/2022 13:46

@Cuck00soup

People really judge a 3 year old lying on the middle of a supermarket floor.

Nice people don't. Most of us have been there. I try to smile at the poor parent if I can.

No they don't!! People sympathise if anything and are just grateful it's either not them or they're kids have outgrown that stage!
stimpyyouidiot · 05/03/2022 13:44

No advice only solidarity here! My dd was notorious for being soooo argumentative and unreasonable and also followed me everywhere to prolong the pain. She's 4 now and while she occasionally loses her shit (mostly on a Friday when she's exhausted from school) she's thoroughly pleasant now.

Nelliephant1 · 05/03/2022 13:44

[quote BirdOnTheWire]@Nelliephant1 Steve Biddulph was a great help to me 20 years ago when there wasn't the collective wisdom of MN. My youngest now 24 was a professional tantrumer at 3.

he would be completely unable to control it but eventually it was like a switch flicked and he would collapse.[/quote]
Me too. I have three boys and I can't honestly say that they were ever problematic but Steve was doing a tour at the time, we went to listen to him and he was great, he's got a very entertaining way of putting things across.

I must have bought his book about six times as I kept lending it to parents of sons and I never got them back! 😄

Cuck00soup · 05/03/2022 13:43

People really judge a 3 year old lying on the middle of a supermarket floor.

Nice people don't. Most of us have been there. I try to smile at the poor parent if I can.

nameisnotimportant · 05/03/2022 13:41

This is totally normal for this age. I usually go with, it's okay to be angry but you do not scream and shout etc (I say this in quite a firm voice). I then say, I'm here ready when you need a cuddle. Then I get on doing things. Most of the time she's coming over to give me for cuddle after 5 mins. I've been consistent with this and the tantrums have reduced. My daughters now three and half and the other day she was arguing over a toy with her sibling. She came over and said mummy I'm starting to feel angry, I need a cuddle and there was no tantrum 🙌🏻. We have to be the calm when their brains and emotions are dis regulated. Which is easier said than done and I don't always get it right but being consistent has definitely worked.

katepilar · 05/03/2022 13:40

@Parfait

Sometimes it helped me to say "I wish I could do that for you, but I can't" And also to say "you cry, I can see you are upset" Paradoxically they often stopped!
Theres nothing paradoxical about that ;) Acknowledging someones emotions is a very poweful tool, both for children and adults.
BirdOnTheWire · 05/03/2022 13:40

@Nelliephant1 Steve Biddulph was a great help to me 20 years ago when there wasn't the collective wisdom of MN. My youngest now 24 was a professional tantrumer at 3.

he would be completely unable to control it but eventually it was like a switch flicked and he would collapse.

Nelliephant1 · 05/03/2022 13:34

Boys do have a testosterone surge around the age of four and seven so it may be that it's kicking in a wee bit earlier for your wee boy. As with all things hormonal, there doesn't seem to be any rhyme nor reason for it and not a lot of rationality, he probably can't explain it either as it may be hormonal rather than anything else.

Have a look at the book Raising Boys by Steve Bidiulph. He's an Australian psychologist who is fab and his book is very light, easily read and full of things that the majority of people don't know about the physical and physiological development of boys.

Hang in there!

katepilar · 05/03/2022 13:33

@Happylittlethoughts

You've explained, now minimise engagement with him. I find ant yo and fro conversation feeds fury in some little ones.
No, leaving a small child who is overwhelmed and overrun by their emotions is really bad. You are the parent who teaches them how to deal with emotions. Its not a powerfight.
Swipe left for the next trending thread