Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that Downs syndrome is a birth defect?

209 replies

seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 09:44

I'll start by saying that my dc3 has a birth defect (chromosomal) that means he is fairly disabled. It shares a lot of overlapping characteristics with DS (learning disabilities, cardiac problems, developmental delays etc) so I follow a lot of people on SM who have children with DS.
The WHO have included DS as a birth defect (alongside spina bifida, CHD) and there has been quite an uproar and "much disappointment at WHO". As a parent with a child with a birth defect I get the label hurts when it is written down like that, and my ds' disabilities are not his definition by any means. BUT, he still has a birth defect by definition, and no amount of flowery language is going to change his health problems and long term need for care.
I posted in AIBU for traffic, but it would be interesting to engage in discussion about why some people feel DS isn't a 'birth defect' but are fine with other birth diagnoses (for want of a better word) to be defects or disabilities?

OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 05/03/2022 10:29

@LowlyTheWorm

I don’t think using the term “downs” is considered offensive- it’s the calling people downs that is “My friends daughter is Downs” is offensive “My friends daughter has Downs” while a little odd isn’t offensive. Many people in the downs community call it that or DS etc. “Downs people” no “People with downs” fine What’s offensive about shortening a term?
There was a time when you were supposed to say 'people with disabilities' instead of 'disabled people'. Then it changed back to 'disabled people' because now the idea du jour is that they are disabled by society. I can understand someone having heard his and understood that you should no longer say 'people with...'. It's really hard to keep up with the right terminology.
Mickarooni · 05/03/2022 10:28

The term birth defect is very blunt and I do understand why some people find it hard.

Caspianberg · 05/03/2022 10:26

@seekinglondonlife - I guess because it’s one chromosomal thing that does have such varied outcomes. Some other are all pretty much incompatible with life ie 99.5% die at or before birth. But Ds really can have a positive life and outcome for many, so people don’t want it labelled as ‘bad’, as it isn’t for some.

Andouillette · 05/03/2022 10:26

Hmmm. This is a good example of public bodies (WHO in this instance) over simplifying things. 'Birth defect' is perhaps not accurate, it's congenital defect, meaning anything that happens from conception to birth but excluding birth injuries. It also maybe needs clarifying that the word defect refers to something that has gone wrong in the process between conception and birth, not that the child concerned is defective by definition. Because they aren't! It's all a bit odd because WHO generally refers to congenital anomalies, rather than defects which is a much better and more neutral way of putting it.

ClemFandangoo · 05/03/2022 10:24

@EarringsandLipstick

A birth defect is a structural change present at birth, that can affect any part of the body.

It doesn't mean an issue that arose during the birth as some PPs think.

So, yes, it's is correct to include Down syndrome.

That’s what I thought. Any defect present at birth.

As a PP said “Birth defect" means present at point of birth, so not acquired afterwards, and most are life long (can't be changed). Genetic variations can be included.

BoredZelda · 05/03/2022 10:24

I don’t like the words defect or abnormalities because of the connotations and wouldn’t want to hear it except when someone is talking about it in a medical sense. So much of the language of disability in a medical sense is outdated and offensive. When I give the medical definition of my daughter’s condition on here, posts have been deleted.

But mostly, it is one thing for a person to say “I (or my child) have a birth defect” and quite another to decide you are free to use that term for someone else. Language around disability is so personal, it is wrong to suggest any term is fine to use for everyone.

No, I think those issues are birth injuries.

I don’t think so. Injuries are something that is caused by birth trauma. Neither of those are.

seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 10:23

@MrsDeadpool spina bifida and cleft lip are definitely not injuries caused by birth, they both occur within 6-12 weeks post conception.

@MargotEmin I too am a big DS advocate. The posts I've been seeing though have really got me wondering though why it seems to be 'set apart' from other chromosomal/congenital conditions in a very positive light, even when those affected are badly affected.

OP posts:
x2boys · 05/03/2022 10:22

When people say that terminology is now out of date and offensive,who have they consulted with have they asked parents or carers what terminology they would prefer or the person themselves with the condition ( if they are able to give an opinion ) or do they just decide that it's offensive ,non of this helps my son .

WibbleWobbleWibble · 05/03/2022 10:21

My ds has autism and severe learning difficulties, I've never really considered it to be a birth defect but it is something he was born with so would be considered to be.
I hate the negativity of the term ..........who wants their child labeled as being DEFECTIVE from the moment they are born.........it's horrible!

MorningStarling · 05/03/2022 10:18

Yes, it's "Down's Syndrome" or more recently "Down Syndrom" - named after the man who first fully described it, John Langdon Down. Why it's named after him is a mystery to me, given that the original terms "mongoloid" and "mongolism" were created and used by him. Given that we don't tolerate commemorations of slavers, even if they also did important work for society, I don't understand why Down is remembered in this way given the century or more of use of the offensive terms he applied.

But yes, it's a birth defect, i.e. a defect in the baby at the point of birth. The term doesn't just mean things that happen during the birth itself.

KneadingKitty · 05/03/2022 10:17

It is a birth defect, but the problem is the connotations it gives. People tend to not like the term and find it offensive. Remember people used to leave babies with birth defects to die after they were born way back when.

x2boys · 05/03/2022 10:17

But all terms can be offensive ,my son is neither defected or abnormal ,fluffing around with terminology doesn't help him in anyway .

seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 10:16

@Mundra yes I totally agree that defect is a horrible word and an alternative would be better. However, should we then refer to cancerous cells as 'different cells' as 'cancer' is very loaded?
Why is it ok to call some conditions defects and not others?

OP posts:
user976327855 · 05/03/2022 10:15

@EarringsandLipstick

I think officially downs is a learning difficulty

The term 'downs' is not acceptable to use.

How?

It's named after John Langdon Down.

How is it offensive to miss out syndrome?

Mrsjayy · 05/03/2022 10:14

My disability wasn't acquired though it is congenital but definitely not acquired! As others have said a birth defect means noticed at birth , not everything about medical conditions need to be upbeat and positive.

SylvanianFrenemies · 05/03/2022 10:14

YANBU. I suspect most of the people complaining don't understand how disabling DS can be.

MargotEmin · 05/03/2022 10:14

I’d wonder whether ‘birth defect’ or ‘genetic defect’ was the more appropriate term.

It's typically referred to as a genetic abnormality

Bellringer · 05/03/2022 10:13

Defect is not a nice word, nor is abnormal.

Wafflefudge · 05/03/2022 10:12

@Mundra yes a few of us posted at the same time with similar thoughts.

MrsDeadpool · 05/03/2022 10:12

@Caspianberg

I wouldn’t really see cleft palate or spina bifta as a birth defect either, again already occurred in womb. So I guess it’s just peoples own definitions. To me ‘birth defect’ is simply something occurred at or during birth
No, I think those issues are birth injuries.
MargotEmin · 05/03/2022 10:12

I don’t think using the term “downs” is considered offensive- it’s the calling people downs that is
“My friends daughter is Downs” is offensive
“My friends daughter has Downs” while a little odd isn’t offensive. Many people in the downs community call it that or DS etc.
“Downs people” no
“People with downs” fine
What’s offensive about shortening a term?

This is absolutely correct, I think the PP is well intended but getting muddled.

I am a very active ally of the DS community (a sibling to be precise), I can't get worked up over people calling it a birth defect - I can understand why people might use that language, but it's just technically not quite right and isn't really used in any of the medical literature around DS. Trying to stick it on us now feels retrograde and clumsy.

seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 10:11

@lljkk I think you've hit the nail on the head there. Interestingly the people that I see shouting the loudest about this issue are the ones whose dc are quite severely affected, so they are on oxygen FT, have severe developmental delays and significant cardiac issues.
There's also something highly emotive about children with DS that I've never seen with any other birth condition. Do we as a society fetishize DS and put people with DS into a 'cute' and 'so loveable' box? Eg I've never seen anyone say they are so glad their dc has X condition, but many times I've heard parents say they are so glad their child has an extra chromosome.

OP posts:
bigbluebus · 05/03/2022 10:11

Although I've just looked up the definition and it says any defect present at birth regardless of cause - so on that basis both my DD and anyone with Downs Syndrome would be considered as having a birth defect.

Mundra · 05/03/2022 10:11

Ha, x-post! Or what @Wafflefudge and @MrsDeadpool said.

Caspianberg · 05/03/2022 10:11

I wouldn’t really see cleft palate or spina bifta as a birth defect either, again already occurred in womb.
So I guess it’s just peoples own definitions.
To me ‘birth defect’ is simply something occurred at or during birth