Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that Downs syndrome is a birth defect?

209 replies

seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 09:44

I'll start by saying that my dc3 has a birth defect (chromosomal) that means he is fairly disabled. It shares a lot of overlapping characteristics with DS (learning disabilities, cardiac problems, developmental delays etc) so I follow a lot of people on SM who have children with DS.
The WHO have included DS as a birth defect (alongside spina bifida, CHD) and there has been quite an uproar and "much disappointment at WHO". As a parent with a child with a birth defect I get the label hurts when it is written down like that, and my ds' disabilities are not his definition by any means. BUT, he still has a birth defect by definition, and no amount of flowery language is going to change his health problems and long term need for care.
I posted in AIBU for traffic, but it would be interesting to engage in discussion about why some people feel DS isn't a 'birth defect' but are fine with other birth diagnoses (for want of a better word) to be defects or disabilities?

OP posts:
godmum56 · 05/03/2022 10:48

@x2boys
"I personally hate difference ,it really minimizes my son's disabilities ,he is very much disabled ."

I agree, as a retired therapist, I hated the term "differently able and was glad it got canned. It seemed to be both rude and dismissive of people's reall struggles.

x2boys · 05/03/2022 10:45

@Branleuse

I think theres a concerted effort in disability activism to reframe most disabilities and difficulties as a difference rather than terms like defect, disability etc which are more loaded with negativity. Its to do with the social model of disability which frames the issue as a problem with society not the person. I think it could be considered a defect to have an extra chromosome that disables rather than helps, but I can see why people are not keen on describing it that way too
I personally hate difference ,it really minimizes my son's disabilities ,he is very much disabled .
TYbakedpotato · 05/03/2022 10:45

I think 'birth defect' is one of those medical terms that feels more negative than it's supposed to be - like a 'geriatric pregnancy'.

I suspect it's so emotive, because generally speaking, you want to avoid anything with a defect, and it therefore implies that given a choice, people wouldn't choose to have a child with DS. The language makes it into an implied personal attack/judgement.

x2boys · 05/03/2022 10:42

[quote seekinglondonlife]@Grapewrath that's the thing, it seems as if DS is presented as something lovely and endearing to have, in a way that other chromosomal abnormalities aren't. Is it the stereotype that everyone with DS is very loving perhaps? (I have to admit that all of the babies that I follow with DS are exceptionally cute Grin)
There was a documentary about Iceland having nobody with DS within their population (they seem to terminate all known conditions) and many were saying they were villains for wanting to eradicate DS. Why should we advocate for DS and not other conditions where the person can lead a full life too?).[/quote]
Babies with Down syndrome will one day be adults with Down syndrome , unfortunately like other children with Disabilities ,they can become less " cute" as they get older it becomes harder as a parent or carer as your child gets older as often people are less understanding of behaviour then a cute little toddler .

Branleuse · 05/03/2022 10:42

I think theres a concerted effort in disability activism to reframe most disabilities and difficulties as a difference rather than terms like defect, disability etc which are more loaded with negativity. Its to do with the social model of disability which frames the issue as a problem with society not the person.
I think it could be considered a defect to have an extra chromosome that disables rather than helps, but I can see why people are not keen on describing it that way too

Yellowsubhubabubbub · 05/03/2022 10:40

It’s probably the word “ defect” that you ,as a loving parent , are taking against.
Sad

godmum56 · 05/03/2022 10:39

I think it depends of what the term is going to be used for. Is it to be used for a world wide health coding system or are they wanting to control how everybody talks about a particular disability?

EdenFlower · 05/03/2022 10:38

A birth defect is not the same as a birth injury. You can't class a negligent doctor breaking a baby's arm, or a poor mite starved of oxygen because they waited too long and caused brain damage as birth defects- they were a perfectly healthy babies in the womb.

seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 10:36

@Grapewrath that's the thing, it seems as if DS is presented as something lovely and endearing to have, in a way that other chromosomal abnormalities aren't. Is it the stereotype that everyone with DS is very loving perhaps? (I have to admit that all of the babies that I follow with DS are exceptionally cute Grin)
There was a documentary about Iceland having nobody with DS within their population (they seem to terminate all known conditions) and many were saying they were villains for wanting to eradicate DS. Why should we advocate for DS and not other conditions where the person can lead a full life too?).

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 05/03/2022 10:36

I have a dd who's official disability is:

Congenital amputation defect of the left arm below elbow.

In real terms it's she was born missing her left arm between the elbow and wrist.
It is a defect she was born with. Not quite sure it is a birth defect as it wasn't caused by the birth, but I think that is splitting hairs.

Yes, writing defect about my darling daughter feels harsh. She is amazing as she is.
But it is a defect. It's a difference from the normal which in a perfect world would never happen.

Calling it "a birth difference" is less harsh, but actually I like it less. Difference isn't a good thing. You wouldn't say "my child's birth difference is the mop of beautiful curly hair".
And being excepted by the norm, not being seen as different is important.

Wafflefudge · 05/03/2022 10:35

@seekinglondonlife I think perhaps you feel that parents of children with Down Syndrome are objecting to being grouped with other birth defects but I think it's the terminology itself they dislike. Obviously I don't know that for sure as havent seen the discussions you are referring too but that would be my instinct. The dictionary definition in every day language of defective is broken or faulty so surely its understandable that people might not want their child labelled in that way.

Fairislefandango · 05/03/2022 10:35

Perhaps you can give us an agreed / shared definition of ‘birth defect’@seekinglondonlife- and only then people can meaningfully engage.

Wikipedia says (citing a government document which cites WHO document):

Abirth defect, also known as acongenital disorder, is a condition present atbirthregardless of its cause.[3]Birth defects may result indisabilitiesthat may bephysical,intellectual, ordevelopmental.[3]

A birth defect doesn't mean a condition caused at birth.

Mrsjayy · 05/03/2022 10:35

Maybe apparent at birth is a better descriptor? And then we wouldn't have the umbrella term and we could just use "condition " names. I mean the I do have a defect and I'm fine with that but I can't speak for everyone, putting a constant positive spin on disability is abelism imo.

x2boys · 05/03/2022 10:33

[quote Caspianberg]@seekinglondonlife - I guess because it’s one chromosomal thing that does have such varied outcomes. Some other are all pretty much incompatible with life ie 99.5% die at or before birth. But Ds really can have a positive life and outcome for many, so people don’t want it labelled as ‘bad’, as it isn’t for some.[/quote]
There are thousands of chromosome abnormalities ,lots if people have a chromosome ,deletion , duplication, translocation etc ,many people won't know as it doesn't affect them or only affects them mildly ,my son has a chromosome deletion we only found out as he has severe autism and learning disabilities ,and he had blood tests to see if there were any underlying reasons ,unless it affects your family ,most people are not aware of rare chromosome disorders/ abnormalities

gluenotsoup · 05/03/2022 10:32

Defect or abnormality might be sort of accurate, but they imply an inferiority, a lessening if the person as being wrong, broken, substandard. Most birth differences, be it a cleft palate, heart issues, limb differences through to severe and lifelong genetic or chromosomal syndromes, are just that - differences in the way our bodies and brains look and work. All people, regardless of differences should be valued equally, and the terminology and language used in this situation is fundamental to this, and educating people to this end. We remove negative terminology in many areas where equality is to the forefront, and this should be no different.

KneadingKitty · 05/03/2022 10:32

I think some of the positivity towards DS is because of the perception that people with DS are always happy. People use this to gloss over the condition.

110APiccadilly · 05/03/2022 10:32

I too would have thought birth defect was something that was a result of what happened at birth, not necessarily any condition you're born with, but if spina bifida etc are then I suppose so are chromosomal differences. It doesn't seem like a very precise definition then though. But perhaps it doesn't need to be.

Certainly no one's ever referred to my friend's little boy who was born with a heart condition as having a birth defect, but I assume by this definition he would have, even though it was detected before birth?

TulipCat · 05/03/2022 10:32

I am in no way an expert on terminology, but to me a birth defect is a small abnormality that a baby is born with like an extra toe or a pointed ear, as opposed to a condition that affects their life to a much greater extent.

GingersHaveSoulsToo · 05/03/2022 10:32

Just to complicate things, my DD was medically classed as born with a congenital heart defect, however it was more correctly a change in the heart structure that should have happened when she started breathing didn't happen. The consultant explained that it was defined as congenital even though before she was born she didn't have it and it wasn't a birth injury.

My DD's heart was definitely defective. She was never 'defective' though.

MrsDeadpool · 05/03/2022 10:31

[quote seekinglondonlife]@MrsDeadpool spina bifida and cleft lip are definitely not injuries caused by birth, they both occur within 6-12 weeks post conception.

@MargotEmin I too am a big DS advocate. The posts I've been seeing though have really got me wondering though why it seems to be 'set apart' from other chromosomal/congenital conditions in a very positive light, even when those affected are badly affected.[/quote]
Sorry, you misunderstand me. I meant that injuries received during birth aren’t birth defects.

I am well versed in chromosomal disorders and spina bifida.

Gwenhwyfar · 05/03/2022 10:31

"Do we as a society fetishize DS and put people with DS into a 'cute' and 'so loveable' box? Eg I've never seen anyone say they are so glad their dc has X condition, but many times I've heard parents say they are so glad their child has an extra chromosome."

I think you have these arguments about autism as well. Some people see it as a positive rather than a negative even though it has traditionally been considered a disorder.

EdenFlower · 05/03/2022 10:31

Of course it is a birth defect! You are born with it!

seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 10:31

@Caspianberg, so many chromosomal conditions have a spectrum, it certainly isn't exclusive to DS. Even the "incompatible with life" ones can have varied outcomes. Babies with Edwards syndrome for example can live for years.

OP posts:
LadyPropane · 05/03/2022 10:29

I didn't realise that the term "birth defect" was used in any sort of official capacity.

I sort of get it during pregnancy in some circumstances, but surely once the person is born and living their life, it seems very harsh and unpleasant to say they are defective. I would feel like I was insulting someone if I told them they had a birth defect.

Grapewrath · 05/03/2022 10:29

Not sure really. I would imagine s birth defect is something that happened at birth, not in formation.
DS is disabled and is referred to as having a congenital abnormality. I’m not arsed what people call it personally, it doesn’t change anything.
I think Down syndrome is viewed differently for some reason, like people campaigning to not have screening so it isn’t eliminated. I love my DS but if I could have chosen for him not to have a disability I would.