Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that Downs syndrome is a birth defect?

209 replies

seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 09:44

I'll start by saying that my dc3 has a birth defect (chromosomal) that means he is fairly disabled. It shares a lot of overlapping characteristics with DS (learning disabilities, cardiac problems, developmental delays etc) so I follow a lot of people on SM who have children with DS.
The WHO have included DS as a birth defect (alongside spina bifida, CHD) and there has been quite an uproar and "much disappointment at WHO". As a parent with a child with a birth defect I get the label hurts when it is written down like that, and my ds' disabilities are not his definition by any means. BUT, he still has a birth defect by definition, and no amount of flowery language is going to change his health problems and long term need for care.
I posted in AIBU for traffic, but it would be interesting to engage in discussion about why some people feel DS isn't a 'birth defect' but are fine with other birth diagnoses (for want of a better word) to be defects or disabilities?

OP posts:
RoastedFerret · 05/03/2022 12:20

I think the issue is defect. You're saying they're defective and I'm sure the parents and the people themselves very much disagree that they're defective in any way.

Would they though? I have a heart defect. It doesn't me that I'm defective. Unless you believe that a person is their disability I can't see how you could come to the conclusion that calling something a birth defect means that the person themselves are defective?

EarringsandLipstick · 05/03/2022 12:20

Oh and the use of ‘Down’s’ isn’t offensive if it’s simply a shortening of Down’s Syndrome, FFS

Well, it's incorrect - as per link shared. No need for FFS, when a simple google search would have confirmed it.

EarringsandLipstick · 05/03/2022 12:16

@x2boys

When people say that terminology is now out of date and offensive,who have they consulted with have they asked parents or carers what terminology they would prefer or the person themselves with the condition ( if they are able to give an opinion ) or do they just decide that it's offensive ,non of this helps my son .
Yes. See the links I shared, which is from the representative body, and is people-centred.
Gwenhwyfar · 05/03/2022 12:16

"You're saying they're defective and I'm sure the parents and the people themselves very much disagree that they're defective in any way."

Do they though?
Definition of defect: "an imperfection or abnormality that impairs quality, function, or utility"
Downs Syndrome does affect the person's health negatively doesn't it?

EarringsandLipstick · 05/03/2022 12:15

How?

It's named after John Langdon Down.

How is it offensive to miss out syndrome?

For you and the other posters unaware, here's a link: downsyndrome.ie/person-first-language-guidelines/

There are other international links that say the same.

About half way down the page, it's mentioned that using Downs as an abbreviation is no longer correct terminology. (DS can be used as an abbreviation). I've added the screenshot.

Similarly 'Downs' or Down's' with the apostrophe is incorrect. The person who identified the syndrome was not someone with DS. (So no apostrophe)

To say that Downs syndrome is a birth defect?
Gizacluethen · 05/03/2022 12:13

I think the issue is defect. You're saying they're defective and I'm sure the parents and the people themselves very much disagree that they're defective in any way.

I've read the blind community having a similar argument with an organisation, I think it was to do with wanting to be able to screen for blindness in embryos. Their argument is that it suggests parents should be able to abort blind babies and it's not nice to think that people feel that way about you. Being autistic I get it, obviously not fully, but certainly the idea that something is wrong with me, being called defective is much worse I think.
So yeah I get it.

Pennox · 05/03/2022 12:12

Even more technically, and accurately, it's a meiosis defect or failure as the extra chromosome 21 material is introduced during egg or sperm formation long before they ever come together to form an embryo and result in the birth of a baby.

MargotEmin · 05/03/2022 12:07

DS is being heavily politicised by anti abortionists, hence the 'don't screen me out' campaign against NIPT and Heidi Crowter's case to amend the abortion act. Just found out there's a preliminary hearing this Tuesday (8th) to determine whether she can appeal against the high court ruling.

Yes, just to clarify as one of the more vocal advocates on this thread I definitely do not endorse the anti abortion infiltration of the DS community.

Pennox · 05/03/2022 12:07

Its a genetic disorder or chromosomal abnormality that has been there since the moment of conception, or very soon after.

So technically it's a conception defect surely? Birth defect harks back to the days when people didn't understand genetics to me. And as its caused by extra genetic material its not even really a defect, which suggests a lack of something.

TwoShades1 · 05/03/2022 11:55

For some reason I would associate “birth defect” with something more like cleft palate or missing limb/s ie more physical things. I would have described DS as a congenital disorder or genetic disorder. But I don’t have a child with any of these issues so my knowledge of the correct terminology mat be incorrect or not appropriate.

Oblomov22 · 05/03/2022 11:52

I don't like it, that WHO are now referring to DS as a birth defect.

Pollyputthekettleon1975 · 05/03/2022 11:50

He's just my little boy at the end of the day.
He has his own personality, his own likes and dislikes. Blonde hair and blue eyes.
He's my little boy who just happens to have Down's Syndrome.
We don't even think of him as having Down's now. We just see him as himself.

HomeHomeInTheRange · 05/03/2022 11:46

I usually say ‘chromosomal condition’.

I have a child with what is described on his hospital notes as a ‘congenital abnormality’. It IS an abnormality, but I tend to say ‘mobility disability’ because that describes the effect on his life.

The4Seasons · 05/03/2022 11:45

I have a 10 year old DS with DS and yes, I often describe him as having Downs (I know the correct terminology is Down Syndrome, sorry if anyoneis offended).

I've never really thought about the term birth defect, it's never been used to describe my son. However whilst I'm not keen on the word defect it is used in a medical setting by medical professionals to describe abnormalities (also not a great word!) that occurred at conception, during gestation or during birth. There are lots of medical words I don't like (e.g. incompetent cervix) but they have a specific purpose that is universally understood. I would hope that the language changes to reflect the sensitivities of the audience.

Everydayimhuffling · 05/03/2022 11:45

This is interesting because I didn't know that was the definition of "birth defect". DS has a heart defect which I wouldn't usually call a birth defect because that makes me think of problems arising from the birth. I would usually say it's congenital. The word defect I have no problem with, but maybe that's because his is largely physical

Samcro · 05/03/2022 11:40

defect1
noun
/ˈdiːfɛkt,dɪˈfɛkt/
a shortcoming, imperfection, or lack.
"genetic defects"

so no imo it isn't and CP defiantly isn't
disabled people are not imperfect

Branleuse · 05/03/2022 11:40

@MrsLargeEmbodied

i think of defect as something that happens in the womb, ie exposure to radiation
I think of it more as a physical thing. Like a cleft palate, or a giant mole/birthmark. I dont think its the usual word for a disability, but its not exactly wrong either
DixonD · 05/03/2022 11:37

@LowlyTheWorm

I don’t think using the term “downs” is considered offensive- it’s the calling people downs that is “My friends daughter is Downs” is offensive “My friends daughter has Downs” while a little odd isn’t offensive. Many people in the downs community call it that or DS etc. “Downs people” no “People with downs” fine What’s offensive about shortening a term?
This.

Some people will find offence in ANYTHING.

Bickles · 05/03/2022 11:33

Trisomy 21 means there are 3 chromosome 21s. There should be 2. So yes it’s a birth defect.
I had to terminate a trisomy 21 pregnancy that was much wanted. Of course it’s a severe birth defect- you don’t get advised to terminate for nothing.

Pollyputthekettleon1975 · 05/03/2022 11:30

I always remember reading the report written by the educational psychologist, and the opening words being, "Tommy is Down's".
My heart sank before I could read any further.
I just remember thinking "No! Tommy is so much more than Down's".

Newyearnewme2022 · 05/03/2022 11:29

@ClemFandangoo
I consider a birth defect as something that happens at birth. My son had Down Syndrome pretty much from conception. It wasn’t picked up during any scans.
There are 3 types of Downs
Trisomy 21
Translocation
Mosaic
We were told that my son wouldn’t have many Downs ‘traits’ because Mosaic is considered the mildest form.
Unfortunately he also has autism at the more extreme end of the spectrum so has considerable learning disabilities and complex needs.
His official diagnosis are
Down Syndrome
Global developmental delay
ASD

hugr · 05/03/2022 11:29

@mam0918

Honestly, I hate this argument.

Let us call ourselves whatever WE choose - stop putting labels on us and telling us we are wrong.

Don't call someone who refers to themselves as Crippled 'differently abled'. Don't call someone who refers to themselves as Insane 'mentally unstable'. Don't call someone who refers to themselves as Handicapped 'Invalid'... Call them whatever they choose to call themselves.

There's no such thing as a one size fits all politically correct word, something will offend someone.

I have a 'birth defect' (not remotely offended by the term) and I am happy to refer to it as 'retardation' because it IS (I'm not scared of people too ignorant to understand the actual meaning of the word, a word is only offensive when used incorrectly) but people tell me I'm not allowed to call MYSELF retarded like they have any say in my fucking identity and how I live with MY condition.

Frankly, as my disability is in my brain and invisible it feels like people just want to wash over it and it makes THEM uncomfortable not me.

What I hate is when people tell me the correct term is 'invalid' which I have had a few times by patient liaisons of all people... I am perfectly fucking 'valid' just like anyone else thank you.

On an individual level this is fine but how do we refer to these groups of people as a collective? I can't use "retarded" in policy or professional documents, I have to use "intellectually or learning disabled" for example.
KindlyKanga · 05/03/2022 11:27

@Pegasussnail

I think the term defect is negative and we are (or should be) inclusive. So difference sounds more appropriate. That said - I agree that labels or a change in them does not take away from lifelong care and high support needs which we must be honest about. (Family member with DS and part of many forums on this)
I absolutely agree it's such a negative word to use.
Pollyputthekettleon1975 · 05/03/2022 11:26

It's there at conception, so I wouldn't say it's a birth defect.
An extra chromosome, or "Trisomy 21" as my child's paediatrician told me at birth. I didn't have a clue what he was saying as never heard that term before, until he yelled "Down's Syndrome! at me".

mam0918 · 05/03/2022 11:24

Honestly, I hate this argument.

Let us call ourselves whatever WE choose - stop putting labels on us and telling us we are wrong.

Don't call someone who refers to themselves as Crippled 'differently abled'. Don't call someone who refers to themselves as Insane 'mentally unstable'. Don't call someone who refers to themselves as Handicapped 'Invalid'... Call them whatever they choose to call themselves.

There's no such thing as a one size fits all politically correct word, something will offend someone.

I have a 'birth defect' (not remotely offended by the term) and I am happy to refer to it as 'retardation' because it IS (I'm not scared of people too ignorant to understand the actual meaning of the word, a word is only offensive when used incorrectly) but people tell me I'm not allowed to call MYSELF retarded like they have any say in my fucking identity and how I live with MY condition.

Frankly, as my disability is in my brain and invisible it feels like people just want to wash over it and it makes THEM uncomfortable not me.

What I hate is when people tell me the correct term is 'invalid' which I have had a few times by patient liaisons of all people... I am perfectly fucking 'valid' just like anyone else thank you.