Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that Downs syndrome is a birth defect?

209 replies

seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 09:44

I'll start by saying that my dc3 has a birth defect (chromosomal) that means he is fairly disabled. It shares a lot of overlapping characteristics with DS (learning disabilities, cardiac problems, developmental delays etc) so I follow a lot of people on SM who have children with DS.
The WHO have included DS as a birth defect (alongside spina bifida, CHD) and there has been quite an uproar and "much disappointment at WHO". As a parent with a child with a birth defect I get the label hurts when it is written down like that, and my ds' disabilities are not his definition by any means. BUT, he still has a birth defect by definition, and no amount of flowery language is going to change his health problems and long term need for care.
I posted in AIBU for traffic, but it would be interesting to engage in discussion about why some people feel DS isn't a 'birth defect' but are fine with other birth diagnoses (for want of a better word) to be defects or disabilities?

OP posts:
seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 15:48

Whoever said that DS has been politicized by anti abortionists seems to be correct. The 'case studies' are always very positive stories and in my groups of late one particular story is going around (that I suspect isn't true) is of a man with DS who has a son (no DS) who he raised and is now a doctor, so "they are capable of anything".
I only know one family with an adult child with DS, and they are really against the "cute and loving" narrative. The daughter is about 20 now, does not have any health issues and only has minor cognitive disabilities. She is likely to lead a fairly independent life with some support but hates when people infanticide her because she's 'cute'.

OP posts:
Mumoblue · 05/03/2022 15:24

It’s my understanding that people tend to use the term “abnormality” or “difference” now.

Which is fair enough. I have a psychical congenital abnormality which cannot be seen (wrong shape womb) and hearing a doctor say you have a “birth defect” is kind of tough. I don’t think trying to be sensitive in language is a bad thing.

elliejjtiny · 05/03/2022 15:20

Tbh although the term birth defect is a bit negative /rude thing to say about someone it's not something I would personally say is worth campaigning or making a fuss about. I am more cross at the way my ds had his dla taken from him and then given back 2 years later when I got the courage/energy/determination to apply again. Compared to the constant fighting for his education and health needs etc the terminology used is very low down on my list of things to be annoyed about.

nocheesegromit · 05/03/2022 15:05

@LangClegsInSpace

My question is more along the lines of why is DS a more emotive disability/difference/condition than other ones.

I think this is, at least in part, because the anti abortionists are politicising it - they are deliberately romanticising the condition.

Absolutely.

DS is a scale as I understand it, with degrees of seriousness. Not in the actual DS diagnosis, but the things that go with it, heart problems etc, as well as leaning and developmental issues.

Same for spina bifida, which can go unnoticed or be incredibly severe and life limiting.

Nobody who chooses to TFMR is doing so because of a small or inconsequential health issue with their baby.

Fairislefandango · 05/03/2022 15:02

It's factually inaccurate to call something a birth defect when it's actually a chromosomal difference which has been their from very early pregnancy and has nothing whatsoever to do with the birth process - am suprised WHO have termed it such, it's just misleading, surely a birth defect is by definition a defect caused by the birthing process ??

Why do you say it's factually inaccurate though? If the medical definition of birth defect is a defect present at birth, then why wouldn't a congenital disorder be considered a birth defect? There is nothing inherent in the phrase 'birth defect' which suggests causation. Rather like a 'childhood illness' is an illness experienced as a child, not an illness caused by the process of being/becoming a child.

TravellingFrom · 05/03/2022 14:40

@LangClegsInSpace

My question is more along the lines of why is DS a more emotive disability/difference/condition than other ones.

I think this is, at least in part, because the anti abortionists are politicising it - they are deliberately romanticising the condition.

Yes to that!

But also I think that romanticisation is more general than that.
Cute photos of children, always mentioning those adults with DS who are doing particularly well etc…
It is part if a wider movement to destigmatise people with disabilities and in particular with DS.

I’m sometimes wondering if that helps tbh. Because yes some people with DS/whatever other condition can do extremely well and handle their limitations in a fantastic way. But not everyone does. And those who don’t are just as worthy of appreciation/kindness/respect as those who do.

VelvetChairGirl · 05/03/2022 14:29

isnt a birth defect something like a club foot or a cleft pallet?

BiBabbles · 05/03/2022 14:26

I've not heard any conditions or disabilities referred to as a defect in a while. I think the WHO and similar might still use it in some writing to simplify language like congenital disorders / anomalies / malformations which are more neutral but is also language you kinda already need to know which creates its own barriers.

The only people I've known to use that language about my disabilities used it as part of their reasoning to be violent and I think the long history of that has led some to being more sensitive of such a potential warning sign especially if discussing children when disabled children are on a whole more likely to suffer abuse. Whether this is more common for DS compared to other similar conditions I don't know, but I think that's part of why some are wary about official support.

Call them whatever they choose to call themselves.

I agree with this and that there is no universal agreement on the right terms, though this seems to be about parents discussing their children's condition and how institutions should categorize these conditions so it's not quite the same.

My mother would call me defective, I call myself disabled (which I've also been told I shouldn't do largely either because others are worse or because the person assumed that meant I was giving up, either way it was more about the other person than me), though on an individual day I might call a particular part of my disability other names and I've never really followed the ever-changing categories for them.

My children are more likely to say X issues, so 'communication issues' or 'sensory issues' around the specific part that's the problem in the moment rather than use any diagnosis label or identify as disabled or similar which is an interesting shift.

Wingedharpy · 05/03/2022 14:20

Birth anomaly sounds better to me rather than birth defect.......but I know nothing.

Lilifer · 05/03/2022 14:18

It's factually inaccurate to call something a birth defect when it's actually a chromosomal difference which has been their from very early pregnancy and has nothing whatsoever to do with the birth process - am suprised WHO have termed it such, it's just misleading, surely a birth defect is by definition a defect caused by the birthing process ??

Midlifemusings · 05/03/2022 14:15

Defect is just a very negative word. Not surprising that most people don't want to refer to their child as defective. It may be technically correct based on formal definitions but if that isn't how someone sees or wants to refer to their child - all the more power to them. The children are going to have enough struggles without being looked at by their parents as a defect or defective. And they would prefer that others not see or talk about their children that way either.

LangClegsInSpace · 05/03/2022 14:14

My question is more along the lines of why is DS a more emotive disability/difference/condition than other ones.

I think this is, at least in part, because the anti abortionists are politicising it - they are deliberately romanticising the condition.

whiteworldgettingwhiter · 05/03/2022 14:13

Down Syndrome is used in the rest of the world; Down's Syndrome is used in the UK.

whiteworldgettingwhiter · 05/03/2022 14:11

It's a chromosomal disorder that manifests itself in many ways, including cardiac issues, learning disabilities and certain physical characteristics.

Not a birth defect.

PrincessNutella · 05/03/2022 13:25

Down Syndrome is a genetic disability or a genetic condition.
I agree that it's not technically correct to call Down Syndrome a birth defect. And defect is a harsh word. But people with disabilities aren't living in bodies that are simply different, are they? They are fully human and equal in every way. But being blind doesn't make you hear twice as well, Disabled people have to work harder to get through the day and that is to be respected.

gogohm · 05/03/2022 13:20

I think of a defect as something that needs fixing, and crucially can be fixed. Learning disabilities, chromosomal and genetic disorders, neural pathway disorders etc cannot be fixed, that are human differences and cause varying degrees of being differently able. Some are life limiting, others are not but they aren't defects in my understanding of the word. I have sn autistic dd, she's not defective l, well perhaps in manners sometimes Grin

Wafflefudge · 05/03/2022 13:15

I have found found post on Facebook now and can see that most people are reacting to the term defect as suspected.
They are also responding to the wording of the post which refers to preventing birth defects and then listing Down Syndrome. The WHO have since edited the post.

gluenotsoup · 05/03/2022 13:12

I think some issues around this are being clouded by the terms defect, differences and disabilities. For what it’s worth I don’t like the term defect, my dd has one of the worlds most rare and complex syndromes and is severely affected with profound and multiple physical and learning disabilities. She is different in every way, but not defective. The terms here can be varied in what individuals find upsetting or acceptable, but the bottom line for me is that unfortunately there is still a huge lack of understanding and tolerance from a big part of society, and that’s why I feel strongly that we do need to be aware of powerful words can be in basically educating people about other people. Whatever words we use won’t make my daughters syndrome any easier to live with both me and her, life is beyond hard. But it might help a bit if I don’t have to also worry that some people stare and see her as a bit of a freak. She isn’t- she’s just different. Disabled- yes. Defective-no. Some people just can’t see beyond it.

EarringsandLipstick · 05/03/2022 13:05

That's interesting @Legomania

Strange that UK is an outlier in this. On the site you mention I see they support World Down Syndrome Day so the accepted international norm, in the English language, is Down Syndrome.

I didn't see any use of 'Down's' on the website.

5128gap · 05/03/2022 12:51

I think it should be up to people who actually have DS to decide on the terminology used.

seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 12:48

WHO are not calling people with DS a defect, on World National Birth defect day they simply listed a few of the most common birth defects, with DS being one of them.
I need to clarify that I absolutely advocate for anyone's choice/decision in pregnancy, and when someone is alive I most certainly believe they should be given whatever intervention that is in their best interest.
My question is more along the lines of why is DS a more emotive disability/difference/condition than other ones.

OP posts:
Legomania · 05/03/2022 12:38

@EarringsandLipstick

Oh and the use of ‘Down’s’ isn’t offensive if it’s simply a shortening of Down’s Syndrome, FFS

Well, it's incorrect - as per link shared. No need for FFS, when a simple google search would have confirmed it.

Except that's for Ireland (and I know the US also use Down Syndrome).

In the UK the equivalent charity is called the Down's Syndrome Association.

BluesCluesToo · 05/03/2022 12:30

@Grapewrath

Grapewrath that's the thing, it seems as if DS is presented as something lovely and endearing to have, in a way that other chromosomal abnormalities aren't. Is it the stereotype that everyone with DS is very loving perhaps? (I have to admit that all of the babies that I follow with DS are exceptionally cute grin) There was a documentary about Iceland having nobody with DS within their population (they seem to terminate all known conditions) and many were saying they were villains for wanting to eradicate DS. Why should we advocate for DS and not other conditions where the person can lead a full life too?).

I just think that parents should be able to choose whether to carry a pregnancy to full term when there is a disability regardless of what it is. If people with children who have Down Syndrome want to advocate for their individual child then absolutely but who the fuck is anyone to take away options for others?
I will advocate for my son til can’t anymore but make no mistake disability is exhausting, life changing and can be soul destroying. I hate that people romanticise it and the ‘ill love my baby no matter what’
Yes you will. Of course you will, but you may lose everything else in the process. Who is anyone to tel another human they must make that sacrifice

Completely agree
Proudboomer · 05/03/2022 12:23

[quote seekinglondonlife]@Proudboomer I'm in the same boat, but do you not agree that by linguistic definition it is a defect? My ds's heart/brain is defective according to the definition. I obviously think he is amazing though.[/quote]
No I don’t see it as a defect. It is just a difference in genetics’. Who decides what is normal anyway?

Grapewrath · 05/03/2022 12:23

Grapewrath that's the thing, it seems as if DS is presented as something lovely and endearing to have, in a way that other chromosomal abnormalities aren't. Is it the stereotype that everyone with DS is very loving perhaps? (I have to admit that all of the babies that I follow with DS are exceptionally cute grin)
There was a documentary about Iceland having nobody with DS within their population (they seem to terminate all known conditions) and many were saying they were villains for wanting to eradicate DS. Why should we advocate for DS and not other conditions where the person can lead a full life too?).

I just think that parents should be able to choose whether to carry a pregnancy to full term when there is a disability regardless of what it is. If people with children who have Down Syndrome want to advocate for their individual child then absolutely but who the fuck is anyone to take away options for others?
I will advocate for my son til can’t anymore but make no mistake disability is exhausting, life changing and can be soul destroying. I hate that people romanticise it and the ‘ill love my baby no matter what’
Yes you will. Of course you will, but you may lose everything else in the process. Who is anyone to tel another human they must make that sacrifice