Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that Downs syndrome is a birth defect?

209 replies

seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 09:44

I'll start by saying that my dc3 has a birth defect (chromosomal) that means he is fairly disabled. It shares a lot of overlapping characteristics with DS (learning disabilities, cardiac problems, developmental delays etc) so I follow a lot of people on SM who have children with DS.
The WHO have included DS as a birth defect (alongside spina bifida, CHD) and there has been quite an uproar and "much disappointment at WHO". As a parent with a child with a birth defect I get the label hurts when it is written down like that, and my ds' disabilities are not his definition by any means. BUT, he still has a birth defect by definition, and no amount of flowery language is going to change his health problems and long term need for care.
I posted in AIBU for traffic, but it would be interesting to engage in discussion about why some people feel DS isn't a 'birth defect' but are fine with other birth diagnoses (for want of a better word) to be defects or disabilities?

OP posts:
Bizawit · 05/03/2022 21:10

[quote seekinglondonlife]@MrsDeadpool spina bifida and cleft lip are definitely not injuries caused by birth, they both occur within 6-12 weeks post conception.

@MargotEmin I too am a big DS advocate. The posts I've been seeing though have really got me wondering though why it seems to be 'set apart' from other chromosomal/congenital conditions in a very positive light, even when those affected are badly affected.[/quote]
Fgs. It’s because DS is one of the most common chromosomal abnormalities. There is a strong community who are working to reduce stigma and emphasise living positively with DS. For those saying it is obviously a “defect” what exactly do you mean? It’s a chromosomal difference. Describing it as “defective” is a value judgment , not a matter of fact.

iolaus · 05/03/2022 20:47

If I was asked to list birth defects I don't think I'd have listed a chromosonal disorder - but several of the associated conditions I would, as many of them are also born with heart defects

I think I think of 'birth defects' as more a structural condition - as opposed to chromosonal or even cerebral palsy, caused by asphixia at birth,

Not all birth defects are a major issue though - for example my daughter was born with unilateral renal agenesis (she only has one kidney) doesn;t affect her at all

x2boys · 05/03/2022 20:37

As I said up theeaad people get tied up knots regarding disability language my son's chromosome disorder doesn't have a name it comes under the rare chromosome disorder category to be technical he has a deletion on the short arm of chromosome 16 wether I call it a disorder or an abnormality or any other term it's the underlying cause of his complex disabilities but it doesn't define him he's still my adored child that's the way I see it anyway 🤷

Branleuse · 05/03/2022 19:35

@Pollyputthekettleon1975

He's just my little boy at the end of the day. He has his own personality, his own likes and dislikes. Blonde hair and blue eyes. He's my little boy who just happens to have Down's Syndrome. We don't even think of him as having Down's now. We just see him as himself.
Well of course, hes your kid. Hes more than having down syndrome. Hes more than being little. Hes more than just a boy. Hes more than his blondeness.

For some reason we dont have to justify all the other descriptive words. Theyre ok

lljkk · 05/03/2022 19:22

congenital anomalies will just be the next 'birth defect' phrase before it gets stigmatised

Difficultcustomer · 05/03/2022 19:08

I have spastic cerebral palsy. It is often associated with trauma at birth but can be a birth defect. In everyday life I’m more interested in the manner People use words- birth defect, disability, spastic can be factual descriptions, ignorantly or curiously or hate speech. I can tell the difference. I’m sure a lot of disabled people or their carers can as well.

Whatever terms WHO uses From a WHO paper I’m more interested in whether governments or organisations are following up

Through the resolution on birth defects of the Sixty-third World Health Assembly (2010), Member States agreed to promote primary prevention and improve the health of children with congenital anomalies by:

developing and strengthening registration and surveillance systems;
developing expertise and building capacity for the prevention of birth defects and care of children affected;
raising awareness on the importance of newborn screening programmes and their role in identifying infants born with congenital birth defects;
supporting families who have children with birth defects and associated disabilities; and
strengthening research on major birth defects and promoting international cooperation in combatting them.

helpfulperson · 05/03/2022 18:42

The challenge with the WHO is that even amongst English speaking nations what is acceptable in on country is unacceptable in another so there are conflicts in language. And then we add in all the many other languages and translations.

User69734 · 05/03/2022 18:37

A birth defect is something present at birth, not something that occurred at or after the birth. The main categories of birth defect are:
Chromosomal abnormality
Genetic eg congenital metabolic disorder
Intrauterine damage due to infection, teratogen etc

Embracelife · 05/03/2022 18:34

That pahe also lists conditions like cystic fibrosis etc
Of course they ard genetic all of theses or congenital
But to continue to refer to people with such conditions as defective is not acceptable today

Embracelife · 05/03/2022 18:32

www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/birth-defects#:~:text=Congenital%20anomalies%20can%20be%20defined,infancy%2C%20such%20as%20hearing%20defects.

Embracelife · 05/03/2022 18:32

They should really stick to "congenital anomalies"
Birth defect harks back to previous centuries views of anyone with a difference as defective
Whether physical or mental difference
Hence the locking people away in institutions

Disability action groups need to get onto the Who

littledrummergirl · 05/03/2022 18:26

My sibling has downs syndrome and is definitely not defective.

They live with a chromosome difference, which means that like 100% of the human race they are unique.

lljkk · 05/03/2022 18:19

I think it should be up to people who actually have DS to decide on the terminology used.

What if they can't agree... or in some cases, understand.

Does that mean a different label rather than an umbrella phrase? Like call each ethnicity by its name, fine, but then how would you write this sentence without saying ethnic minority:

"Some people are prejudice against ethnic minorities."

What umbrella term could be used? "Brown":? "non-white" -- I mean, who would need to agree (agreement to confirmed how, and how frequently?) and how could it be phrased simply?

So same with birth defects. Fine don't use language that upsets people, but then how do you distinguish "genetic difference" (like green vs. blue eyes) from problem difference (extra chromosomes) without using a word that denotes "problem"

MischievousBiscuits · 05/03/2022 17:17

DS had Patau Syndrome and it was considered a defect I think. Its a trisomy too, just on a different chromosome

Fairislefandango · 05/03/2022 17:04

I don't see why 'abnormality' is better than 'defect' tbh. Surely saying something is 'abnormal' can be perceived to be at least as offensive?

Essentially a 'defect' means a problem or something wrong - in this case with a function or a body part. We all get problems or things wrong with us at some point. Whenever that defect occurs, or whether it is fixable or not, having it doesn't mean there's something wrong with us as a person. It's not a moral judgement.

BluesCluesToo · 05/03/2022 16:53

@5128gap

I think it should be up to people who actually have DS to decide on the terminology used.
Although I agree with this in principle, unfortunately some wouldn't be able to. There are high functioning people with DS of course, but some are at the more severe end, are non verbal and need care.
lakeswimmer · 05/03/2022 16:25

My DC has a chromosome disorder, that's how I would describe it and a phrase medical professionals have used with us. I have never used the term birth defect, never even considered it.

DC's chromosome disorder wasn't uncovered until age 12 when they had genetic testing although it was obvious before then there was something going on. It was nothing to do with their birth though.

BobbyeinArkansas · 05/03/2022 16:23

Yes it’s a birth defect. We had all sorts of tests done during pregnancy for birth defects and Downs was one of them.

WhiteJellycat · 05/03/2022 16:17

DS is a genetic duplication. It's from conception and not related to birth. I have boys with genetic issue,ASD, dyspraxia, language disorders. I dont have spare breath to think about things like mislableing etc. It wont change the outcomes if you call it a gift or call it a disorder.

seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 16:14

That's what I'm wondering, why is the use of the word defect seemingly acceptable for some conditions and abhorrent for others?

OP posts:
nocheesegromit · 05/03/2022 16:12

@ThatsNotMyGolem

"Defect" is a disgusting term when applied to people.
It depends on how it's being applied, I think. Spina bifida is a neural tube defect, that's the medical term. It's physical, and causes catastrophic damage. It's a defect during the growth of the developing baby.
Mrsjayy · 05/03/2022 16:08

Why is defect disgusting?

mam0918 · 05/03/2022 16:08
  • cant reform it
mam0918 · 05/03/2022 16:07

@Fairislefandango

It's factually inaccurate to call something a birth defect when it's actually a chromosomal difference which has been their from very early pregnancy and has nothing whatsoever to do with the birth process - am suprised WHO have termed it such, it's just misleading, surely a birth defect is by definition a defect caused by the birthing process ??

Why do you say it's factually inaccurate though? If the medical definition of birth defect is a defect present at birth, then why wouldn't a congenital disorder be considered a birth defect? There is nothing inherent in the phrase 'birth defect' which suggests causation. Rather like a 'childhood illness' is an illness experienced as a child, not an illness caused by the process of being/becoming a child.

This.

de·fect (dē'fekt)
An imperfection, anomaly, malformation, dysfunction, or absence.

I have a birth defect.
It's an internal malformation that causes dysfunction.
It formed in the formation of me genetically.
It was present from birth.
It is incurable (you can 'reform' it).

It is not visible or 'fixable' and I have no idea where posters are getting the concept that it only exists if you can see it or fix it like a cleft pallet or birthmark.

I have other medical issues that are 'defects' without any malformation but rather a loss of function such as my failing kidneys.

My kidneys are NOT birth defects, they worked fine at birth but due to illness they are now dysfunctional.

Birth defect simply refers to it being something that was defective in 'from the outset.

As for it being 'negative' if we functioned completely correctly we wouldn't be 'disabled' or any other term you wack on it.

There is no 'nice' work to say something that basically means broken, it's all just semantics.

ThatsNotMyGolem · 05/03/2022 16:02

"Defect" is a disgusting term when applied to people.