Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that Downs syndrome is a birth defect?

209 replies

seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 09:44

I'll start by saying that my dc3 has a birth defect (chromosomal) that means he is fairly disabled. It shares a lot of overlapping characteristics with DS (learning disabilities, cardiac problems, developmental delays etc) so I follow a lot of people on SM who have children with DS.
The WHO have included DS as a birth defect (alongside spina bifida, CHD) and there has been quite an uproar and "much disappointment at WHO". As a parent with a child with a birth defect I get the label hurts when it is written down like that, and my ds' disabilities are not his definition by any means. BUT, he still has a birth defect by definition, and no amount of flowery language is going to change his health problems and long term need for care.
I posted in AIBU for traffic, but it would be interesting to engage in discussion about why some people feel DS isn't a 'birth defect' but are fine with other birth diagnoses (for want of a better word) to be defects or disabilities?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fifi0102 · 11/05/2022 23:37

We tend to use the term chromosomal abnormality in LD services. They do tend to portray Downs Syndrome as cute babies and toddlers in the press and not the later time period.

A lot of 40 year olds with downs syndrome develop dementia ,I've nursed them and its so heartbreaking seeing a young person in a nursing home with people in their 80s and 90s . I never realised until I started nursing how common dementia and downs syndrome is. The heartbreaking thing is mainstream services can't cope and there isn't enough specialist services.

LangClegsInSpace · 11/05/2022 23:19

Interesting timing for this two month old AIBU thread to be resurrected.

Only yesterday the US Ambassador (actually the Chargé d'Affaires who is filling in between appointments) hosted a great big party to celebrate the passing of Liam Fox's Down Syndrome Act. Which is a bit weird.

twitter.com/RoseUnwin/status/1524329504117776385

I've written about this Act and the group behind it (National Down Syndrome Policy Group) here:

www.mumsnet.com/talk/feminism/4289660-Late-term-abortion-high-court?page=35&reply=117028063

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4539125-more-institutional-capture-pro-lifers-this-time

This isn't really to do with DS (the Act does nothing) it's to do with abortion rights.

Blue4YOU · 11/05/2022 21:43

I have a daughter who is severely disabled. I refer to her as having congenital defects in a medical scenario and the most wonderful and life-enhancing little girl I’ve ever known in my personal conversation.
I suppose I think of “defect” in a medical setting much like “disabled”; a description not a judgment.
Ive had people ask me in hospital waiting rooms “what’s wrong with her?” And I reply she has an unknown condition that she was born with.
The worst question (I’ve been asked numerous times by random persons in public and in hospital waiting rooms) “did you know there was something wrong with her during pregnancy “ - the obvious inference being that I should have known better than to actually let her live.
Sorry I’ve not read the full thread but there’s a real need to distinguish between medical terminology used in those settings (which arguably should be changed too) and “real life”.

WonderingWanda · 11/05/2022 21:01

Shtfday I agree that the world defect has a lot of negative connotations and dislike it also. Could do with being changed in the same way we no longer used handicapped.

WonderingWanda · 11/05/2022 20:58

If you read the definition of birth defect it is any structural change present at birth so chromasomal differences are actually a structural change in the DNA whether it's a deletion, addition or duplication, as as well as more obvious structural changes like a cleft palate or heart defect for example.

Something like cerebral palsey which is caused by lack of oxygen at birth would be a birth injury where part of the braim dies at birth but it was structurally sound before that.

Alwayshoovering · 11/05/2022 20:38

I'm with you on this OP. It is a birth defect in the sense that a child is born with a physical and mental impairment, rather then it being something that develops as they get older.

gluenotsoup · 11/05/2022 20:01

Good post @Shtfday

Shtfday · 11/05/2022 13:13

not read the full thread - but what does it matter to you if the DS community don't see DS as a birth defect.

It is the word defect that I take issue with, defective is just a very negative oppressive term.
If you get a new TV and it is defective you return it to the shops. why do we need such a negative word about human beings. Human beings that are more than just one thing, have value and worth and do not need to have the term defective used to describe them.

I am Deaf from Birth and some may label that as defective/broken/needing in fixing. But I am a full and equal human who can contribute and participate in society. I do not need fixing and I am not less than others who hear. Lack of access to information is a barrier that I face daily. but this is a problem with our society and how it is not inclusive to all and not me that is the problem.

In the Deaf community we have a term called Deaf Gain. that encompasses all the benefits we have due to deafness. I know that belonging to a minority community we are often oppressed but the community means that we are not alone and the DS and the Autistic communities like the Deaf community have barriers (often barriers created by man), individuals may have additional challenges such as health complications linked to or separate to the Deaf/Autistic/DS but Health challenges can happen to anyone at anytime and are not just members of those communities that are impacted.

littledrummergirl · 06/03/2022 16:45

I agree OP, it’s a birth defect and a disability. It can be very severe too. For some reason society likes to pretend that all people with DS are as functional as the “high functioning” people who are visible in everyday life. They don’t like to think about people with severe DS who may be so profoundly disabled that they can’t walk or talk and barely leave the house.

Nope, my sibling would fall into this group- they are still not defective. They are 100% uniquely themselves.
The human race is made up of individuals, all with their own differences and similarities. Rather than ignoring this in an attempt to group people into a homogeneous mass that can be labelled and differing anyone who falls outside of what can be narrow definitions, we should be embracing those differences and learning from them.

Fairislefandango · 06/03/2022 08:59

Birth defect is a medical term with an actual meaning. You can't just pretend it means birth injury because you'd prefer it to.

^This. It is quite right that people should be able to refer to themselves, their children etc and whatever health conditions they have however they wish (different people prefer different terms, as is apparent on this thread alone), and to ask other people to also refer to them personally that way. But you can't unilaterally decide to change the meanings of scientific and medical terminology.

autienotnaughty · 06/03/2022 07:50

My ds is autistic I would never use the term birth defect and think disabled is factually inaccurate so tend to stick to he is autistic or sometimes neuro diverse. Incase anyone doesn't know most autistic people prefer 'is autistic' to 'has autism'

One of the things I struggle with is the fact that disabled people are seen in society as lesser than people who are not disabled. So a child is born with a disability and people are sad because that that child is disabled'. But then there are some conditions ie life limiting ones, or ones with significant pain/suffering where it is sad that a person has that condition as no one wants another person to suffer but that doesn't apply to all conditions .

My asd son is amazing and I wouldn't change him at all (I'd definitely make society move inclusive though) so it saddens and angers me when people see having an autistic child as less good than having a non autistic child (this has been said to me). I feel in society we have a quite rigid view of normal and wish the world could be more open to difference and embrace it rather than condemn it.

autienotnaughty · 06/03/2022 07:28

@EarringsandLipstick thank you it's not a term I use but I wasn't aware it was offensive.

autienotnaughty · 06/03/2022 07:26

Surely the definition of birth defect is that something was defective at birth (or for arguments sake during pregnancy) that caused long term issue. Either way it's an awful terminology to describe anyone as defective it's certainly not one I would use to describe anyone. But anyway DS would not fit in that category as it's chromosomal. I also dislike the term learning difficulties for people who are neuro diverse. They don't have difficulty learning they learn and develop differently. And disability is such a massive umbrella term which can lead to ablest misconceptions about what disabled people should look like/behave like.

WhatNoRaisins · 06/03/2022 06:56

Birth defect is a medical term with an actual meaning. You can't just pretend it means birth injury because you'd prefer it to.

GreMay1 · 06/03/2022 06:04

@gogohm

I would personally use congenital or chromosomal to describe ds.

I describe DD's autism as congenital too as she was noticeably different from birth

There's a lot of confusion because each person has a preference of what term they "like". I think the correct terminology MUST be used to avoid confusion.
GreMay1 · 06/03/2022 05:52

@x2boys

I also think people can get to tied up in terminology ,changes all the time when I was a child ,children like my son would have been described as mentally handicapped,,,what's acceptable terminology now ,might not be in years to come ,non if which helps the actual person with the disability imo.
Very true
Bumpitybumper · 06/03/2022 05:43

@Obira
I agree OP, it’s a birth defect and a disability. It can be very severe too. For some reason society likes to pretend that all people with DS are as functional as the “high functioning” people who are visible in everyday life. They don’t like to think about people with severe DS who may be so profoundly disabled that they can’t walk or talk and barely leave the house
I agree, the obsession with cute, smiley babies/toddlers/young children and more capable (usually youngish) adults works to almost gloss over those who are more severely impacted by DS or those that clearly have more limited lives because they have DS. I cynically wonder why this is the case? It feels almost like groups are trying to hoodwink society (and dare I say prospective parents) about what the realities of Down Syndrome can be like?

This can be even more stalk as those with DS age and they lose their 'cuteness' and differences can become more apparent. Being a 'higher functioning' person with DS can be hard as they can be more aware of the gap between them and their peers/siblings that don't have DS. They are aware that they can't drive, live completely independently or raise a family in the same way as other people. The syndrome limits them and frustration and anger can arise. They also face ageing parents (the vast majority of people with DS live with their parents or rely heavily on them for support) and scary health related risks like early onset dementia.

All of the above is my experience of knowing middle aged people with Down Syndrome. Not cute, not smiley, not easy but worthwhile and much loved people. In a bid to not erase DS I think the movement need to be careful that they don't infact erase those that represent the less palatable side of the syndrome!

MangyInseam · 06/03/2022 04:05

@Lilifer

It's factually inaccurate to call something a birth defect when it's actually a chromosomal difference which has been their from very early pregnancy and has nothing whatsoever to do with the birth process - am suprised WHO have termed it such, it's just misleading, surely a birth defect is by definition a defect caused by the birthing process ??
No, it's something that's present at birth rather than acquired later. My BIL had club feet, a birth defect, even in the womb, not caused by the birth, and not somehow acquired later.
MangyInseam · 06/03/2022 04:03

I think you are right op. It's not a defect in the personhood of the child.
But it's a defect in the process of gamete production in the parent.

I'm not convinced the current approach of being more and more restrictive about language is actually helpful to the people it's supposed to protect. Obviously we don't want to go around telling people they are defective, but it does no one any good to pussyfoot around the actual causes of something like Downs. It's not just a difference like brown or blue eyes, it represents an error in cell division which, if it had happened somewhat differently, could have been incompatible with life.

The important thing is that we don't fail to value all kinds of different people. Which we do, quite often, and I think arguing about this kind of thing is a way of distracting from that much more difficult problem.

TheOriginalEmu · 06/03/2022 02:38

[quote seekinglondonlife]@Caspianberg lots of issues are from conception or fairly early on. Things like spina bifida, cleft lip and palate, CHD. Even many chromosomal disorders. None of them are defects of the birth process.
I don't intend this to be a goady thread BTW, more interested in why DS has a lot of emotion tied into that other birth defects/abnormalities don't.[/quote]
I’m not sure it’s that DS has more emotion tied to it, as much as it’s more common than a lot of other genetic disabilities and as such has a larger community around it so the voice is louder.
I think birth defect is an unpleasant way of describing any condition. Language around these things isn’t meant to make it seem less of an issue, but to make people with these conditions feel less like some kind of freak. I have a child with DS and one with ASD and I wouldn’t like either to be described as having a defect. Condition, disability, syndrome. There are lots of words that are much better imo.

Bizawit · 06/03/2022 02:26

*you’re not your!

Bizawit · 06/03/2022 02:21

[quote seekinglondonlife]@Bizawit for me, my ds' condition is a defect in the sense that his chromosomes have defected away from what is the standard/normal amount that there should be. It doesn't mean he is a defect though. He is not wholly defined by this defect, but it does have a major impact on him.[/quote]
Your conflating the meaning of “to defect” (a verb) and “a defect” noun in your explanation there. “Defect” the noun (eg birth defect) means “a fault or problem in something or someone that spoils that thing or person and causes it not to work correctly”.

HoppingPavlova · 06/03/2022 01:24

Proudboomer- Who decides what is normal anyway?

When it’s a fact that it deviates from standard anatomy/physiology in structure or function. It’s not subjective.

Obira · 05/03/2022 23:52

I agree OP, it’s a birth defect and a disability. It can be very severe too. For some reason society likes to pretend that all people with DS are as functional as the “high functioning” people who are visible in everyday life. They don’t like to think about people with severe DS who may be so profoundly disabled that they can’t walk or talk and barely leave the house.

seekinglondonlife · 05/03/2022 23:39

@Bizawit for me, my ds' condition is a defect in the sense that his chromosomes have defected away from what is the standard/normal amount that there should be. It doesn't mean he is a defect though. He is not wholly defined by this defect, but it does have a major impact on him.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread